Order 1

Order Details: Copy of Judgment
Pdf Text: ,l-lh- nkok Øekad 769@2018 --1-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 12-03-2026
MHCC010037002018 nk[ky fnukad % 17-03-2018
uksan.kh fnukad % 19-03-2018
fudky fnukad % 12-03-2026
dkyko/kh % 07&o- 11&e- 26&fn-
uxj fnok.kh U;k;ky; eqacbZ ;sFkhy] U;k;ky; Øekad 09
¼ lqfuy ek- ikVhy] uxj fnok.kh U;k;k/kh’k ½
,l-lh-nkok Øekad 769@2018
¼U;k;fu.kZ;kpk fnukad % 12@03@2026½ fu’kk.kh & 30
Jh- lw;Zdkar vkdkjke ukxi]
o; % 54 o”kZs] O;olk; % uksdjh]
iRrk% 2@209] nqljk etyk] fl)hfouk;d
fcfYMax] Hkxoarjko ijGdj ekxZ] ijG xko] ijG]
eqacbZ&400 012- -------- oknh
fo:)
egkjk"V x`gfuekZ.k o {ks=fodkj izkf/kdj.k ¼EgkMk½]
x`g fuekZ.k Hkou] dykuxj] okanzs ¼iwoZ½]
eqacbZ&400 051- ---- izfroknh
odhy Jh- ,l-ds-fils] oknhdjhrk
odhy Jh- [kksczkxMs] izfroknh djhrk& foukdSfQ;r
U;k;fu.kZ;
¼ fnukad 12-03-2026 jksth ikjhr ½
izLrqrpk nkok fnukad 05-03-2018 jksthph izfroknhauh oknhl
ikBfoysyh uksVhl csdk;ns'khj vlY;kps rlsp oknh gk fnukad
03-10-2001 jksthP;k rkck i=kuqlkj nkok feGdrhpk dk;ns'khj
HkkMsd:@rkcsnkj vlY;kps gDdKkiu dj.;kr ;kos o lnfudkaoj
csdk;ns'khj rkck dj.kkÚ;k O;DrhaP;k ;knhrwu oknhps uko deh
-- 1 of 10 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 769@2018 --2-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 12-03-2026
dj.;kckcr izfroknhauk funsZ'k nsrkuk izfroknhauh nkok feGdrhrwu oknhl
csn[ky d: u;s ok R;kP;k dCtsofgokVhl gjdr vMFkGk d: u;s v'kk
fujarj eukbZlkBh nk[ky dj.;kr vkyk vkgs-
2- oknhpss dFku FkksMD;kr [kkyhyizek.ks %&
Hkxoarjko ijGdj ekxZ] ijG foyst] ijG ;sFkhy ^fl)hfouk;d
fcfYMax* ;k bekjrhP;k nqlÚ;k etY;kojhy [kksyh Øekad 2@209 gh
feGdr nkO;kpk fo"k; vlwu R;kl ;kiq<s lks;hlkBh ^nkok feGdr* vls
lacks/kys vkgs- e;r fouk;d l[kkjke lkoar o dksaMhjke x.kw
lkGoh ;kaP;k rkC;krhy nkok feGdr 1995 lkyh R;kauh :i;s
2]14]000@& brdh jDde oknhdMwu fLodk:u oknhP;k rkC;kr fnyh-
lnj lkoar o lkGoh ;kauh oknhP;k ukos R;kckcr [kksVh o cukoV
dkxni=s fygqu fnyh vlwu nkok feGdrhps dk;ns'khj gLrkarj dj.;kps
vk'oklu oknhl fnys gksrs- R;kuqlkj] nkok feGdr oknhP;k rkC;kr vlwu
fnukad 24-07-2000 jksthP;k i=kuqlkj nkok feGdrhrhy oknhpk rkck
csdk;ns'khj vlY;kps izfroknhauh oknhl dGfoys- R;kuarj] oknhus
izfroknhaP;k dk;kZy;kr iznku vkns'kkn~okjs (Pay Order) :i;s
2]00]300@& brdh jDde tek dsyh vlwu R;kckcr fnukad
03-10-2001 jksth oknhl ikorh nsrkuk nkok feGdr oknhP;k ukos oxZ
>kY;kps dGfoys- R;kuarj] oknhus fu;feri.ks nkok feGdrhP;k HkkM~;kph
rlsp brj lsokdjkaph jDde tek dsyh vlwu izfroknh dk;kZy;kus nkok
feGdrhckcr csdk;ns'khj rkck vlysY;k O;DrhaP;k ;knhrwu oknhps uko
v|ki deh dsys ukgh- vls vlrk EgkMk vf/kfu;ekP;k dye 95 v¼3½
uqlkj izfroknhauh oknhl uksVhl ikBforkuk nkok feGdrhpk [kqyk rkck 7
fnolkar ns.;kph ekx.kh dsyh- lnj uksVhl csdk;ns'khj vlwu oknh gk nkok
feGdrhpk dk;ns'khj rkcsnkj vlY;kus R;kuqlkj dks.krhgh dk;Zokgh
-- 2 of 10 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 769@2018 --3-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 12-03-2026
dj.;kpk izfroknhauk vf/kdkj ukgh- lcc] fnukad 05-03-2018 jksthph
izfroknhauh oknhl ikBfoysyh uksVhl csdk;ns'khj vlY;kps rlsp oknh gk
fnukad 03-10-2001 jksthP;k rkck i=kuqlkj nkok feGdrhpk dk;ns'khj
HkkMsd:@rkcsnkj vlY;kps gDdKkiu dj.;kr ;kos o lnfudkapk
csdk;ns'khj rkck dj.kkÚ;k O;DrhaP;k ;knhrwu oknhps uko deh
dj.;kckcr izfroknhauk funsZ'k nsrkuk izfroknhauh nkok feGdrhrwu oknhl
csn[ky d: u;s v'kk fujarj eukbZph oknhus fouarh dsyh vkgs-
3- izfroknhauk nkO;kps leUl feGkY;kuarj rs ofdykekQZr gtj
>kys ijarq] R;kauh dSfQ;r nk[ky dsyh ukgh- R;keqGs] lnj nkok
R;kaP;kfo:) foukdSfQ;r pkyyk-
4- oknhus vkiY;k dFkukiq"B~;FkZ Lor%ph lk{k fu'kk.kh 5 oj
Äsryh vlwu fnukad 24-07-2000 jksthps i= fu'kk.kh 7 oj] fnukad
03-10-2001 jksthps i= rlsp rkck fnY;klaca/khps i= ,d=kr fu'kk.kh 8
oj] fnukad 03-10-2001 rs 04-05-2017 ;k dkyko/khr oknhus tek
dsysY;k fofo/k jdekalaca/khP;k ikoR;k ,d=kr fu'kk.kh 09 oj] lu
1995 rs 2000 ;k dkyko/khr lnj bekjrhP;k lsokdjkiksVh tek
dsysY;k jdekackcrP;k ikoR;k ,d=kr fu'kk.kh 10 oj] lu 1995 iklwu
iq<hy dkyko/khr nkok feGdrhrhy vkiY;k okLrO;kckcr nk[ky dsysyh
dkxni=s fu'kk.kh 12 rs 21 oj] fnukad 05-03-2018 jksthph uksVhl o
R;kl fnukad 14-03-2018 jksth fnysY;k Eg.k.;kph izr vuqØes fu'kk.kh
22 o 23 oj] fnukad 23-03-2021 jksthph HkkMs ikorh rlsp R;kojhy
naM ¼isuYVh½ tek dsY;kph fnukad 05-03-2021 o 19-03-2021
jksthP;k ikoR;k ,d=kr fu'kk.kh 24 oj nk[ky dsY;k vkgsr-
-- 3 of 10 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 769@2018 --4-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 12-03-2026
5- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr oknhrQsZ ofdykauh fu'kk.kh 29 oj fnysyk
ys[kh ;qfDrokn okpyk- rlsp oknhrQsZ odhy o izfroknhrQsZ ofdykapk
rksaMh ;qfDrokn ,sdyk- oknhus fu'kk.kh 5 ojhy ljriklknjE;ku nkO;ke/;s
uewn ckch lkaxrkuk mijksYysf[kr dkxni=kackcr lkaxhrys vlwu izfroknh
EgkMk dk;kZy;kus nkO;kl dSfQ;r fnyh ulyh rjh oknhP;k dFkukackcr
rlsp dk;ns'khj eqn~;koj oknhpk myVrikl ?ksryk vlwu izfroknhrQsZ
dk;Zdkjh vfHk;ark ,Q@nf{k.k foHkkx] Jh- ifjf{kr Hkq;kj ;kauh fu'kk.kh
26 oj iqjf'kl nk[ky dsyh vkgs-
6- oknhus nkO;kdkeh fnukad 05-03-2018 jksth izfroknhauh nkok
feGdrhlaca/kh EgkMk vf/kfu;ekP;k dye 95 v¼3½ uqlkj fnysyh uksVhl
csdk;ns'khj vlY;kP;k gDdKkiukph fouarh djrkuk fnukad
05-03-2018 jksthP;k lnj uksVhlvk/kkjs nkok feGdrhrwu vkiY;kyk
csn[ky d: u;s ok nkOkk feGdrhrhy vkiY;k dCtsofgokVhl gjdr
vMFkGk d: u;s v'kh izfroknhfo:) fujarj eukbZph fouarh dsyh vkgs-
ijarq] fu'kk.kh 26 oj izfroknh dk;kZy;kr dk;Zjr mijksYysf[kr
vf/kdkÚ;kus iqjf'kl nsrkuk 'in the above matter as per internal resolution
of the office, this plaintiff was regularized, however, due to the
appointment of the committee by the government for remission of the
regularization of total 323 occupants, I am withdrawing notice given to
the plaintiff under Section 95 A (3) of MHADA Act. And the decision of
the committee will be binding upon the plaintiff. I am making this
pursis to file on record in this matter.' vls dGfoys vkgs-
7- ifj.kker% fnukad 05-03-2018 jksthph fu'kk.kh 22 ojhy
uksVhl izfroknh dk;kZy;kus ekxs ?ksrY;kus rh uksVhl csdk;ns'khj
vlY;kckcr oknhus dsysyh gDdKkiukph fouarh fu"QG (Infructuous)
-- 4 of 10 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 769@2018 --5-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 12-03-2026
>kyh vlwu fnukad 05-03-2018 jksthP;k lnj uksVhlvk/kkjs izfroknhuh
nkok feGdrhrwu vkiY;kyk csn[ky d: u;s ok nkOkk feGdrhrhy
vkiY;k dCtsofgokVhl gjdr vMFkGk d: u;s v'kk fujarj eukbZph
oknhus dsysyh fouarhns[khy ;k ?kMhyk fu"QG >kY;kps Li"V gksrs-
8- ;kf'kok;] oknhus oj uewn dsY;kizek.ks nkok feGdrhpk rks
dk;ns'khj HkkMsd:@rkcsnkj vlY;kps gDdKkiu dj.;kr ;kos o EgkMkP;k
ekydhP;k bekjrhe/;s vukf/kdkjkus jkgkr vlysY;k O;DrhaP;k ;knhrwu
vkiys uko deh dj.;kckcr izfroknhl funsZ'k ns.;kr ;kosr v'kh fouarh
dsyh vkgs-
9- nkO;kP;k ifjPNsn 4&v o c e/;s nkok feGdr e;r
fouk;d l[kkjke lkoar o dksaMhjke x.kw lkGoh ;kaP;k rkC;kr gksrh o
R;kauk vkiyh Qlo.kwd dj.;kP;k gsrwus [kksV~;k o cukoV dkxni=kavk/kkjs
nkok feGdrhpk rkck nsrkuk vkiY;kdMwu R;kiksVh 1995 lkyh :i;s
2]14]000@& brdh jDde ?ksrY;kps uewn dsys vkgs- R;klaca/kh] oknhus
nkO;ke/;s uewn ckch fu'kk.kh 5 ojhy ljriklknjE;ku lkaxhrY;k vlY;k
rjh myVriklknjE;ku fouk;d l[kkjke lkoar ;kP;kdMwu vki.k nkok
feGdr [kjsnh dsyh vlwu R;kckcr fouk;d lkoar o vkiY;k njE;ku
dks.krkgh ys[kh djkj >kyk ulY;kps lkaxhrys-
10- myVriklknjE;ku iq<s oknhus 2001 lkyh vki.k EgkMkdMwu
nkok feGdr [kjsnh dsY;kps lkaxrkuk fouk;d lkoar gk nkok feGdrhpk
ekyd uOgrk ijarq] rks EgkMk'kh lacaf/kr dkes djhr gksrk vls lkaxhrys-
rlsp] oknhus myVriklknjE;ku iq<s dksaMhjke x.kw lkGoh gk nkok
-- 5 of 10 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 769@2018 --6-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 12-03-2026
feGdrhpk ekyd uOgrk rlsp nkok feGdrhlaca/kh dksaMhjke lkGoh o
vkiY;knjE;ku dks.krsgh dkxni= fygqu Bso.;kr vkys ulY;kps lkaxhrys-
11- myVriklknjE;ku oknhus lkaxhrysY;k ojhy ckch fopkjkr
Äsrk nkok ifjPNsn 4&v o c e/;s lnj lkoar o lkGoh ;kauh [kksV~;k
vkf.k cukoV dkxni=kavk/kkjs 1995 lkyh nkok feGdr vkiY;kyk foØh
dsY;kps ok nkok feGdrhpk rkck vkiY;kyk fnY;kps oknhus dFku dsys
vlys rjh R;kfoijhr ckch myVriklknjE;ku lkaxhrY;kus fouk;d lkoar
o dksaMhjke lkGoh ;kaP;k'kh nkok feGdrhckcr oknhpk :i;s
2]14]000@& jdeslaca/kh 1995 lkyh O;ogkj >kY;kps o lkoar o
lkGoh ;kauh oknhP;k ukos [kksVh o cukoV dkxni=s fygqu fnY;kps oknhps
dFku fLodkjkgZ o fo'oklkgZ ukgh-
12- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] oknhrQsZ fu'kk.kh 7 ojhy fnukad
24-07-2000 jksthP;k izfroknh dk;kZy;kus ikBfoysY;k i=kpk vk/kkj
oknhus ?ksryk vlwu R;ke/;s ^lnj ;kstuk QDr v'kk ?kql[kksjkalkBh ykxw
gksbZy T;kaph dkgh nykykdMwu Qlo.kwd gksowu xkGs forj.k >kys gksrs o
R;kapsdMs eaMGkps cksxl forj.k vkns'kgh ns.;kr vkys gksrs o T;k
Äql[kksjkauh v|kor HkkMs o lsok vkdkj Hkjys vkgs fdaok Hkj.;kph r;kjh
vkgs* vlk etdwj uewn vkgs- myVriklknjE;ku oknhus lkaxhrysY;k ojhy
ckch fopkjkr ?ksrk] fouk;d lkoar o dksaMhjke lkGoh ;kaP;kckcrps
oknhps dFku fLodkjkgZ o fo'oklkgZ ulY;kus eqyr% fu'kk.kh 7 ojhy
fnukad 24-07-2000 jksthps i= oknhP;k enrhl ;srs gk oknhrQsZ
ofdykapk ;qfDrokn fLodkjkgZ ukgh-
-- 6 of 10 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 769@2018 --7-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 12-03-2026
13- ojhy ckc fopkjkr ?ksrk] oknhus fnukad 01-10-2001 jksth
izfroknhP;k dk;kZy;kr :i;s 1]92]000@& o fnukad 13-10-2001
jksth :i;s 8]300@& brdh jDde nkok feGdrhckcr tek dsyh vlwu
R;kl vuql:u nkok feGdrhpk rkck izfroknh dk;kZy;kdMwu ns.;kr
vkY;kps oknhps dFku vkgs- ijarq] oknhus myVriklknjE;ku ojhyizek.ks
nksUgh jdek iznku vkns'kkn~okjs (Pay Order) tek dsY;kps lkaxrkuk
EgkMkP;k mieq[; vf/kdkÚ;kus vkiY;kyk R;kckcr rksaMh lwpuk fnyh gksrh
vls lkaxhrys- ifj.kker% :i;s 2]00]300@& brdh jDde nkok
feGdrhiksVh izfroknhaP;k dk;kZy;kr mijksYysf[kr fu'kk.kh 7 ojhy
uksVhlvk/kkjs ikjhr dj.;kr vkysY;k vkns'kkn~okjs oknhus tek dsyh vls
Eg.krk ;s.kkj ukgh-
14- ;kmij] fu'kk.kh 26 ojhy iqjf'kle/;s EgkMkdMhy
lnfudkackcr >kysY;k rFkkdFkhr Qlo.kwdhP;k O;ogkjklaca/kh 'kklukus
lferh fu;qDr dsyh vlwu R;k lferhpk fu.kZ; oknhoj ca/kudkjd jkfgy
vls uewn dj.;kr vkY;kph ckc fopkjkr ?ksrk v|ki nkok feGdrhckcr
izfroknh EgkMkus vafre fu.kZ; ?ksryk ulY;kps fnlwu ;srs-
15- lcc] fuOoG izfroknh dk;kZy;kus oj uewn dsY;kizek.ks
oknhdMwu jDde fLodkjY;kps oknhps dFku fopkjkr ?ksrys rjh R;kvk/kkjs
oknh gk nkok feGdrhlaca/kh vukf/kdkjkus rkck ?ksrysY;k
O;DrhaP;k ;knhrwu vkiys uko izfroknh dk;kZy;kus deh djkos vlk
vkKkFkhZ eukbZpk vkns'k feG.;kl ik= ukgh-
16- ;kf'kok;] fu'kk.kh 26 ojhy iqjf'kln~okjs fnukad
05-03-2018 jksthph uksVhl izfroknh dk;kZy;kus ekxs ?ksrY;kus R;k
-- 7 of 10 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 769@2018 --8-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 12-03-2026
uksVhlvk/kkjs oknhl nkok feGdrhrwu csn[ky dj.;kph ok oknhdMwu
vukf/kdkjkus nkok feGdrhpk rkck ?ksryk tk.;kph 'kD;rk vkgs gs oknhps
dFku ns[khy ojhy ifjfLFkrhr fLodkjkgZ ukgh- ;kmij] fu'kk.kh 26 ojhy
iqjf'kle/;s uewn dsY;kizek.ks 'kklukP;k lacaf/kr lferhpk fu.kZ; oknhoj
ca/kudkjd jkg.kkj vlwu R;kuqlkj izfroknh EgkMk dk;kZy;kdMwu Hkfo";kr
t:j rh dk;Zokgh dsyh tkbZy ;kckcr okn vl.;kps dkj.k ukgh-
R;keqGs] oknhus nkO;kdkeh dsysY;k fouaR;kuqlkj nkn feG.;kl oknh gk ;k
?kMhyk ik= ukgh-
17- oknhus ojhyizek.ks gDdKkuikP;k nksu rlsp vkKkFkhZ eukbZph
o fujarj eukbZph izR;sdh ,d fouarh dsyh vlwu nkok ifjPNsn 17 e/;s
U;k;ky;kP;k vf/kdkjkdjhrk o U;k;ky;hu eqnzkadkdjhrk nkO;kph
vkdkj.kh :i;s 1000@& dsY;kps oknhps dFku vkgs- nkO;klkscr
oknhus ,dw.k :i;s 400@& fdaerhpk U;k;ky;hu eqnzkad fnY;kps
fnlwu ;srs- ijarq] ojhy ifjfLFkrhr oknhus gDdKkiu] vkKkFkhZ o fujarj
eukbZP;k dsysY;k fouaR;k ikgrk U;k;ky;kP;k vf/kdkjkdjhrk o
U;k;ky;hu eqnzkadkdjhrk nkO;kph vkdkj.kh izR;sdh :i;s 1000@& v'kh
,dw.k :i;s 4000@& brdh dj.ks vko';d vlwu R;koj ;s.kkjk :i;s
800@& fdaerhpk U;k;ky;hu eqnzkad ns.ks vko';d gksrs ijarq] oj uewn
dsY;kizek.ks oknhus :i;s 400@& fdaerhpk U;k;ky;hu eqnzkad fnyk
vlwu moZjhr :i;s 400@& fdaerhpk U;k;ky;hu eqnzkad oknhus
ns.;kckcr vafre vkns'kke/;s funsZ'k ns.ks xjtsps vkgs-
18- lcc] oj uewn dkj.kkLro lacaf/kr uksVhlckcr gDdKkiukph
o fujarj eukbZph oknhph fouarh fu"QG (Infructuous) >kyh vlwu vU;
fouaR;kackcr izfroknhfo:)ps vkiys dFku fl) dj.;kl oknh vi;'kh
-- 8 of 10 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 769@2018 --9-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 12-03-2026
Bjyk vlY;kus lnj nkok QsVkG.;kl ik= vkgs- R;keqGs] eh
[kkyhyizek.ks vkns'k ikjhr djhr vkgs %&
%% vkns’k %%
v- ,l-lh-nkok Øekad 769@2018 QsVkG.;kr ;sr vkgs-
c- oknhus gDdKkiu o vkKkFkhZ eukbZP;k fouarhckcr U;k;ky;kP;k
vf/kdkjkdjhrk o U;k;ky;hu eqækadkdjhrk nkO;kph vkdkj.kh
izR;sdh :i;s 1000@& ,dw.k :i;s 4000@& brdh d:u R;koj
deh iM.kkjk :i;s 400@& brdk U;k;ky;hu eqækad fnukad
30-03-2026 i;Zar n~;kok- oknh gk eqnrhr moZjhr
U;k;ky;hu eqækad ns.;kl pqdY;kl] Fkdhr tehu eglqy Eg.kqu
lnj eqækadkP;k jdesph olqyh dj.;kdjhrk ftYgkf/kdkjh] c`gUeqacbZ
;kauk dGfo.;kr ;kos-
fnukad % 12-03-2026
¼ lqfuy ek- ikVhy ½
uxj fnok.kh U;k;k/kh’k] c`gUeqacbZ
U;k;ky; Øekad 09
Jqrys[kukph rkjh[k % 12-03-2026
fyI;arj.kkph rkjh[k % 12-03-2026
Lok{kjhph rkjh[k % 12-03-2026
-- 9 of 10 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 769@2018 --10-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 12-03-2026
“CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL
SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.”
Upload Date Upload Time Name of the Stenographer
12.03.2026 5.50 a.m. Mrs. Poonam Y. Pawar,
Stenographer (Grade-I)
Name of the Judge (With C.R. No.) H.H.J. SHRI. S. M. PATIL
(COURT ROOM NO.09)
Date of Pronouncement of
JUDGEMENT /ORDER
12.03.2026
JUDGEMENT /ORDER signed by
P.O. on
12.03.2026
JUDGEMENT /ORDER uploaded on 12.03.2026
-- 10 of 10 --