Full Order Text
Interim Order 2 · 24 Aug 2026 · CNR MHMT010031422025
Order Details: Order on Exh. Pdf Text: 1 MHMT010031422025 BEFORE THE MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL FOR GREATER MUMBAI AT MUMBAI M.A.C.P. No.2271 of 2025 Shekh Amad Shekh Rahim …Applicant Versus Dayashankar Kanhaiyalal Gupta …Opposite Party And Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. …Insurer ORDER BELOW EXHIBIT 20 1. This application is preferred by Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. seeking its discharge/deletion from the present claim petition on the ground that the policy issued by it in respect of Motor Car No. MH-03-EF-9602 is only a Standalone Own Damage Policy, carrying no third-party liability coverage, whereas third-party liability in respect of the vehicle was, on the date of the accident, covered by Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. Background 2. The applicant has filed the present claim petition under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 seeking compensation for injuries allegedly sustained in an accident dated 23.11.2025 near Navghar Bridge, Mulund (East), Mumbai. -- 1 of 13 -- 2 3. According to the applicant, Motor Car No. MH-03-EF-9602, owned by Opposite Party Dayashankar Kanhaiyalal Gupta, was driven rashly and negligently, crossed the divider and collided with Motor Car No. MH-02-FG-6128 in which the applicant was travelling. 4. While instituting the petition, the applicant joined Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. as insurer of Motor Car No. MH-03-EF-9602. Case of Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. 5. The applicant-insurer contends that it has issued Policy No. 3405/00614426/000/00 in respect of the offending vehicle for the period 30.01.2025 to 29.01.2026. 6. It is, however, specifically contended that the said policy is a Chola Standalone Own Damage Policy for Private Car and does not cover any third-party liability arising out of death, bodily injury or property damage caused by use of the insured vehicle. 7. Cholamandalam has produced the policy schedule in support of this contention. 8. It has further produced a copy of the bundled policy issued by Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd., bearing Policy No. OG-24- 9910-1825-00166368, issued in favour of the same owner, Dayashankar Kanhaiyalal Gupta, in respect of the same vehicle. -- 2 of 13 -- 3 9. According to Cholamandalam, although the own-damage component of the Bajaj Allianz bundled policy was for the first year, namely from 30.01.2024 to 29.01.2025, the Motor Liability/Third-Party component continued from 30.01.2024 to 29.01.2027. 10. Since the accident occurred on 23.11.2025, Cholamandalam submits that the third-party liability, if any, fell within the subsisting motor liability period of the Bajaj Allianz policy and not under its standalone own-damage policy. Stand of the applicant 11. The application is opposed on behalf of the injured applicant. The substance of the objection is that the claim ought not to be rendered defective by immediately discharging Cholamandalam without first bringing the correct third-party insurer, Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd., on record. 12. The applicant therefore seeks an opportunity to amend the claim petition and implead Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. before Cholamandalam is deleted/discharged. Points for consideration 13. The following questions arise: (i) Whether the policy issued by Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. covered third-party liability on 23.11.2025? -- 3 of 13 -- 4 (ii) Whether the record prima facie discloses subsisting third-party insurance with Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. on the date of accident? (iii) What consequential order is necessary to secure complete and effective adjudication of the claim? Nature of the Cholamandalam policy 14. I have carefully perused the policy produced by Cholamandalam. 15. Its description itself is "Chola Standalone Own Damage Policy for Private Car." The period stated therein is 30.01.2025 to 29.01.2026. 16. More importantly, the schedule separately records the details of the motor third-party insurance policy covering the vehicle and expressly stipulates, in substance, that the coverage under the Cholamandalam policy is only for own damage of the insured vehicle and that no other liability, including third-party liability for personal injury/property damage, is payable thereunder. 17. Thus, the policy document itself makes a clear distinction between: (a) contractual coverage for physical/own damage to the insured vehicle provided by Cholamandalam; and -- 4 of 13 -- 5 (b) compulsory third-party liability insurance provided under another policy. 18. A claim by an injured third party under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act is not a claim for repair or own damage to the insured vehicle. The statutory liability in such proceedings arises from the third-party risk contemplated by Chapter XI of the Motor Vehicles Act. 19. Consequently, an insurer who has issued only a standalone own-damage policy cannot be fastened with statutory third-party liability merely because its own-damage policy happened to be operational on the date of accident. Bajaj Allianz policy 20. The documentary material assumes further significance because Cholamandalam has itself placed on record the policy issued by Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. 21. The policy bears No. OG-24-9910-1825-00166368 and names Dayashankar Kanhaiyalal Gupta as the insured. 22. The policy relates to the offending vehicle and records: Policy issued: 30.01.2024; Own Damage Period: 30.01.2024 to 29.01.2025; Motor Liability Period: 30.01.2024 to 29.01.2027. 23. The accident in the present proceedings admittedly pertains to 23.11.2025. -- 5 of 13 -- 6 24. Thus, prima facie, the accident occurred after expiry of the one- year own-damage component of the Bajaj Allianz bundled policy but well within its three-year motor-third-party liability period. 25. The Bajaj Allianz policy schedule also reflects collection of premium under the liability component including basic third-party liability. The documentary position therefore prima facie supports the contention of Cholamandalam that Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd., and not Cholamandalam, was the insurer carrying the statutory third-party risk on the date of accident. 26. These observations are, of course, confined to the question of proper parties at the present interlocutory stage. Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd., once impleaded and served, must have full opportunity to admit or dispute the policy, its applicability, coverage and liability in accordance with law. Nothing herein shall amount to a final adjudication fastening liability upon the proposed insurer without hearing it. Object of compulsory third-party insurance 27. Chapter XI of the Motor Vehicles Act embodies a legislative policy intended to ensure availability of an identifiable and financially responsible person to satisfy awards made in favour of victims of motor accidents. 28. The distinction between an own-damage cover and statutory third-party cover cannot therefore be ignored. The contractual -- 6 of 13 -- 7 own-damage insurer cannot be substituted for the insurer which had undertaken the compulsory statutory third-party risk. 29. At the same time, motor accident compensation law is beneficial legislation. A genuine claimant should not ordinarily be non-suited merely because, while presenting the claim petition, the wrong insurer was described or arrayed, particularly where the correct insurance policy has subsequently surfaced on the record. Power to bring the proper insurer on record 30. The Claims Tribunal is required under Section 168 of the Motor Vehicles Act to hold an inquiry and determine just compensation and specify the person or persons by whom compensation is payable. 31. Procedural rules in motor accident claims are intended to advance the adjudication of substantive rights and not to defeat them by technicality. 32. The principles underlying Order I Rule 10(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure permit addition of a necessary or proper party at any stage where such presence is necessary to enable the adjudicating forum to effectually and completely adjudicate upon the controversy and avoid multiplicity of proceedings. 33. In Ramesh Hirachand Kundanmal v. Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay, (1992) 2 SCC 524, the Hon'ble Supreme Court explained that the power under Order I Rule 10(2) is of wide -- 7 of 13 -- 8 amplitude and exists to remedy defects of parties. A necessary party is one without whom an effective order cannot appropriately be made, while a proper party is one whose presence facilitates complete and final adjudication. 34. In Mumbai International Airport Pvt. Ltd. v. Regency Convention Centre & Hotels Pvt. Ltd., (2010) 7 SCC 417, the Hon'ble Supreme Court reiterated that although ordinarily the plaintiff is dominus litis, the Court retains judicial discretion under Order I Rule 10(2) to add a necessary or proper party in order to secure effective and complete adjudication. 35. These procedural principles assume particular significance in proceedings under the Motor Vehicles Act, where the identity of the insurer carrying third-party risk directly concerns the determination under Section 168 as to the person by whom the compensation, if awarded, is payable. Whether Cholamandalam should continue as a party 36. Once the policy documents presently before the Tribunal show that Cholamandalam's policy is restricted to standalone own damage and expressly excludes third-party liability, no useful purpose would ultimately be served by continuing it as the statutory third-party insurer in the claim. 37. Continued joinder of a person against whom, on the admitted/documentary nature of the policy, the particular statutory -- 8 of 13 -- 9 liability claimed does not arise would unnecessarily enlarge the proceeding and obscure the real controversy. 38. Nevertheless, immediate unconditional deletion of Cholamandalam before the correct third-party insurer is brought on record may create an avoidable procedural vacuum and may prejudice the injured applicant because the claim was initially instituted on the understanding that Cholamandalam was the relevant insurer. 39. The more just and procedurally appropriate course is therefore to permit the discharge of Cholamandalam while simultaneously directing consequential correction of the array of parties by bringing Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. on record. 40. Such a course neither imposes any liability upon Bajaj Allianz without hearing it nor continues proceedings unnecessarily against Cholamandalam. It merely ensures that the real question of statutory insurance liability is adjudicated in the presence of the insurer whose policy prima facie covered the third-party risk on the date of accident. No final finding against Bajaj Allianz at this stage 41. It requires emphasis that the present order does not constitute a declaration that Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. is finally liable to satisfy any award. -- 9 of 13 -- 10 42. Upon impleadment, the said insurer shall be entitled to file its written statement and raise every defence available to it under the Motor Vehicles Act and otherwise in law. 43. Similarly, questions regarding validity of the policy, identity of the vehicle, compliance with policy conditions, driving licence, negligence, involvement of the vehicle and ultimate liability remain open for adjudication after evidence. 44. The present inquiry is confined to determining whether Cholamandalam, whose contract is shown to be a standalone own- damage policy, should continue as the third-party insurer and whether the prima facie third-party insurer ought to be brought before the Tribunal. Conclusion 45. From the material presently available, I find that: (i) Motor Car No. MH-03-EF-9602 was owned by Opposite Party Dayashankar Kanhaiyalal Gupta; (ii) Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. issued a standalone own-damage policy for the period 30.01.2025 to 29.01.2026; (iii) the said policy expressly does not undertake third-party liability for personal injury/property damage; (iv) Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. issued Policy No. OG- 24-9910-1825-00166368 in respect of the vehicle; -- 10 of 13 -- 11 (v) the motor-third-party liability period under the Bajaj Allianz policy is shown as 30.01.2024 to 29.01.2027; (vi) the accident dated 23.11.2025 falls within that period; (vii) Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. is therefore, prima facie, a necessary/proper party for effective adjudication of the insurance liability; and (viii) Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. ought not ultimately to remain arrayed as the insurer liable for the third- party claim merely because its standalone own-damage policy was in force. 46. Exhibit 20 therefore deserves to be allowed, subject to consequential directions safeguarding complete adjudication of the claim. ORDER 1. Application at Exhibit 20 is allowed in the following terms. 2. It is declared, for the limited purpose of the present interlocutory application and subject to any legally permissible contrary material, that Policy No. 3405/00614426/000/00 issued by Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. is a Standalone Own Damage Policy and does not provide third-party liability coverage in respect of the claim arising from the accident dated 23.11.2025. 3. The applicant/claimant is permitted and directed to carry out necessary amendment in the claim petition and array Bajaj Allianz -- 11 of 13 -- 12 General Insurance Co. Ltd., the issuer of Policy No. OG-24-9910- 1825-00166368, as the insurer of Motor Car No. MH-03-EF-9602 for third-party liability, within two weeks from the date of this order. 4. Upon carrying out such amendment, fresh amended copy of the claim petition shall be supplied and notice shall be issued to Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. in accordance with law. 5. Upon the amendment being carried out and Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. being brought on record, Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd. shall stand discharged/deleted from the claim petition as the insurer in respect of the third-party claim, unless before such deletion any legally sustainable circumstance requiring its continued presence is brought to the notice of the Tribunal. 6. Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd., upon appearance, shall be afforded reasonable opportunity to file its written statement and to raise all defences available to it in accordance with the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 and law. 7. No finding in this order shall be construed as a final adjudication of the liability of Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. All questions concerning the validity, applicability and terms of its policy and ultimate liability are expressly kept open for adjudication after hearing the said insurer. -- 12 of 13 -- 13 8. The amendment shall relate to the pending claim proceedings and shall not, by itself, affect the applicant's substantive claim arising from the accident dated 23.11.2025. 9. Considering that the initial impleadment appears to have arisen from confusion regarding concurrent/sequential own-damage and third-party components of the policies, the prayer of Cholamandalam for compensatory costs is rejected. 10. Parties shall bear their own costs of this application. Mumbai. Date : 24/08/2026 (Shashikant Eknathrao Bangar), Member, C.R. No.3, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Greater Mumbai. -- 13 of 13 --
