Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 06 Oct 2026 · CNR MHMT010023372026
Order Details: Order on Exh. Pdf Text: Page 1 of 17 MHMT010023372026 BEFORE THE MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL FOR GREATER MUMBAI, AT MUMBAI MISC. APPLICATION NO.596 OF 2026 IN M.A.C.T. APPLICATION NO.1991 OF 1995 Najma Begum Mohammed Saheed Ahmed Pathan & Ors. …Applicants Versus Parveen Tarique A. Siddique & Anr. …Opposite Parties And The United India Insurance Co. Ltd. …Insurer Appearance : Shri. T. J. Mendon – Advocate for the applicant. 1. This Miscellaneous Application is taken out by the applicants seeking recall/release and disbursement of the compensation amount deposited by the insurer pursuant to the judgment and order dated 06.02.2023 passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Judicature at Bombay in First Appeal No.1766 of 2002 arising out of the judgment and award dated 31.07.2001 passed by this Tribunal in M.A.C.T. Application No.1991 of 1995. The applicants have further prayed that, Applicant No.1 – Smt. Najma Begum Mohammed Saheed -- 1 of 17 -- Page 2 of 17 Ahmed Pathan – having died during pendency of the proceedings, her share be released/disbursed amongst her surviving legal heirs, namely Applicant Nos.2 to 7. 2. I have carefully perused the Miscellaneous Application, affidavit filed in its support, judgment and award dated 31.07.2001 passed by this Tribunal, authenticated copy of the judgment dated 06.02.2023 passed by the Hon'ble Bombay High Court in First Appeal No.1766 of 2002, death certificate of Applicant No.1, identity credentials produced by Applicant Nos.2 to 7, their bank-account particulars and the reports submitted by the office/Registrar. The entire record has been considered before passing the present order. I. Background of the proceedings 3. The original claim arose out of an unfortunate motor vehicular accident dated 23.04.1995 in which Mohammed Saheed Ahmed Mustaq Ali lost his life. The deceased was travelling in Motor Lorry No.MRL-6762 and the accident occurred on the Bombay-Ahmedabad Highway near Manor involving Motor Truck No.GJ-7-U-7004. 4. His widow and children instituted M.A.C.T. Application No.1991 of 1995 seeking compensation on account of his accidental death. -- 2 of 17 -- Page 3 of 17 5. By judgment and award dated 31.07.2001, this Tribunal partly allowed the claim petition. The liability arising out of the two vehicles was apportioned and the respective owners and insurers were directed to satisfy the award in the manner recorded therein. 6. Being dissatisfied with the quantum of compensation, the original claimants preferred First Appeal No.1766 of 2002 before the Hon'ble High Court of Judicature at Bombay seeking enhancement. II. Judgment of the Hon'ble High Court 7. The First Appeal was finally decided by the Hon'ble Bombay High Court on 06.02.2023. Upon reassessment of the compensation, the Hon'ble High Court determined the total compensation at 9,65,500/- and, after deducting the ₹ amount already awarded by the Tribunal, held the claimants entitled to an enhanced compensation of 4,55,180/- ₹ . 8. The Hon'ble High Court further made specific directions regarding interest. In substance, the enhanced amount included the compensation awarded under the conventional head of consortium and the remaining component of -- 3 of 17 -- Page 4 of 17 1,15,180/-. The Hon'ble High Court directed payment of ₹ interest at 7.5% per annum on the component specified in its judgment from 01.01.2018 till realization and interest at 7.5% per annum on the remaining amount of 1,15,180/- ₹ from the date of filing of the claim petition till realization. 9. Significantly, clause (iii) of the operative order passed by the Hon'ble High Court expressly permits the claimants to withdraw the enhanced amount together with accrued interest thereon. Thus, so far as the entitlement to withdrawal of the amount deposited pursuant to the appellate judgment is concerned, the issue stands concluded by the judgment of the Hon'ble High Court. III. Deposit by the insurer and verification of appellate proceedings 10. The office report dated 03.10.2026 records that United India Insurance Company Ltd. has deposited an amount of 8,75,095/- by NEFT on 26.03.2025 ₹ in the Tribunal. 11. There appears to be some discrepancy in the amount mentioned at different places in the Miscellaneous Application and the amount reflected in the office record. The judicial order for disbursement cannot proceed merely on the amount stated in the application when the Tribunal's accounts disclose the actual deposit. -- 4 of 17 -- Page 5 of 17 12. Therefore, for purposes of the present order, the amount actually lying to the credit of M.A.C.T. Application No.1991 of 1995/Misc. Application No.596 of 2026, together with interest, if any, earned thereon while lying in deposit/investment, shall be treated as the amount available for disbursement, subject to reconciliation by the Accounts Section. 13. The office/Registrar has further reported that the judgment dated 06.02.2023 in First Appeal No.1766 of 2002, as uploaded on the official website of the Hon'ble High Court, corresponds with the authenticated copy tendered by the applicants. The report further records that no subsequent order of the Hon'ble High Court has been found uploaded and that no order from the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter has been received by this Tribunal till the date of the report. 14. Consequently, on the material presently before the Tribunal, there is no judicial order staying, varying or prohibiting implementation of the appellate judgment dated 06.02.2023. IV. Death of Applicant No.1 -- 5 of 17 -- Page 6 of 17 15. During the pendency of the appellate proceedings, original Applicant No.1 – Smt. Najma Begum Mohammed Saheed Ahmed Pathan, widow of the deceased – expired. 16. The death certificate produced on record shows that Najma Begum died on 07.12.2017. The certificate is stated to have been issued by the competent authority under the Registration of Births and Deaths Act and the applicable Rules. 17. Applicant No.3, Shahnavaz Mohammed Saheed Ahmed Pathan, has filed an affidavit stating that Applicant No.1 died leaving behind Applicant Nos.2 to 7 as her surviving legal heirs and that she did not leave behind any other legal heir. It is further affirmed that if any other person subsequently asserts a claim as legal heir of deceased Applicant No.1, the applicants would bear the consequences thereof. 18. Applicant Nos.2 to 7 are the children of the deceased victim as well as of deceased Applicant No.1. They were already parties to the original claim petition and were appellants before the Hon'ble High Court. Their identity documents have also been produced before the Tribunal. V. Legal position -- 6 of 17 -- Page 7 of 17 19. The Motor Vehicles Act is a beneficial and welfare- oriented legislation. Compensation awarded under it is intended to reach the victims or their legal representatives expeditiously rather than remain indefinitely locked in judicial deposit after the entitlement has attained finality. 20. In Gujarat State Road Transport Corporation v. Ramanbhai Prabhatbhai, (1987) 3 SCC 234, the Hon'ble Supreme Court explained that the expression "legal representative" in motor accident compensation jurisprudence is required to receive a broad and beneficial construction. It is not confined narrowly to particular categories of heirs. The underlying object is to ensure that persons legally representing the estate and persons suffering on account of the death are not deprived of the remedy provided under the Motor Vehicles Act. 21. The principle was subsequently reiterated in N. Jayasree & Ors. v. Cholamandalam MS General Insurance Co. Ltd., (2022) 14 SCC 712, wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court emphasized the beneficial character of the Motor Vehicles Act and the wider meaning to be attributed to the expression "legal representative". 22. In the present case, Applicant Nos.2 to 7 stand on an -- 7 of 17 -- Page 8 of 17 even stronger footing. They are not strangers seeking entry into the proceedings for the first time. They are the children of the deceased victim and deceased Applicant No.1; they were original claimants and appellants themselves. Their identity and status emerge from the original proceedings and the appellate judgment. VI. Principles governing release of compensation 23. The object of retaining compensation in fixed deposit is protection and not deprivation. 24. In General Manager, Kerala State Road Transport Corporation v. Susamma Thomas, (1994) 2 SCC 176, the Hon'ble Supreme Court laid down safeguards regarding investment of compensation particularly where beneficiaries are minors, illiterate or otherwise susceptible to exploitation. 25. However, those safeguards were subsequently explained by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in A.V. Padma & Ors. v. R. Venugopal & Ors., (2012) 3 SCC 378. The Hon'ble Supreme Court noticed that Tribunals had sometimes converted protective guidelines into an inflexible rule and mechanically directed long-term investment even where adult and literate claimants genuinely required and were entitled to receive the compensation. -- 8 of 17 -- Page 9 of 17 26. The Supreme Court clarified that the guidelines in Susamma Thomas were intended to safeguard the interests of vulnerable claimants and were not intended to prevent competent adult claimants from obtaining the fruits of an award. The Tribunal must therefore exercise judicial discretion according to the facts of each case instead of mechanically continuing the amount in fixed deposits. 27. Applicant Nos.2 to 7 are now adults. Indeed, the identity documents placed on record indicate that considerable time has elapsed since the institution of the original claim in the year 1995. There is therefore no apparent justification for indefinitely withholding the compensation otherwise payable to them, provided their identity and individual bank accounts are duly verified. VII. Effect of the High Court's withdrawal direction 28. There is an additional and decisive consideration in the present matter. The Hon'ble High Court has expressly permitted the claimants to withdraw the enhanced compensation together with accrued interest. 29. Once such a direction has been issued by the appellate Court and the insurer has deposited the amount in -- 9 of 17 -- Page 10 of 17 compliance therewith, the Tribunal, while administering the deposit, must give effect to the appellate decree/order. The Tribunal cannot reopen the computation of compensation or impose conditions which would substantially defeat the permission to withdraw granted by the Hon'ble High Court, except such procedural safeguards as are reasonably necessary to ensure payment to the genuine beneficiaries. 30. The present proceedings are therefore essentially proceedings for implementation and disbursement rather than fresh adjudication of compensation. VIII. Apportionment consequent upon death of Applicant No.1 31. The next question concerns the amount/share attributable to deceased Applicant No.1. 32. Applicant No.1 was the widow of the victim and Applicant Nos.2 to 7 are stated to be her surviving children/legal heirs. Her death does not cause the monetary entitlement forming part of her estate to lapse. Subject to the applicable law of succession and absence of any rival claimant, the amount forming part of her estate devolves upon her lawful heirs. -- 10 of 17 -- Page 11 of 17 33. At the same time, a Motor Accident Claims Tribunal deciding a disbursement application should exercise appropriate caution before conclusively adjudicating complicated questions of succession which may properly belong to a competent civil/succession Court. In the present case, however, no rival claimant is presently before the Tribunal; Applicant Nos.2 to 7 were themselves parties throughout the claim proceedings; and an affidavit has been tendered asserting that there is no other surviving legal heir. 34. In these circumstances, it would be neither just nor consistent with the beneficial object of the Motor Vehicles Act to indefinitely withhold the amount merely on a hypothetical possibility of some future rival claim. 35. The interest of justice can adequately be protected by obtaining a joint indemnity/undertaking from Applicant Nos.2 to 7 that, should any person hereafter establish a superior or competing entitlement to the share of deceased Applicant No.1, they shall remain liable to restore/reimburse such amount in accordance with orders of the competent Court. IX. Identity and banking safeguards -- 11 of 17 -- Page 12 of 17 36. The applicants have produced identity credentials. Before actual electronic transfer, however, the Accounts Section shall verify the identity of each recipient and match the name, bank-account number and IFSC particulars with the documents tendered on record. 37. Compensation shall ordinarily be remitted directly to the individual bank account of the concerned beneficiary through RTGS/NEFT or such other electronic mode adopted by the Tribunal. Payment through an advocate, agent or third-party account shall not be made unless specifically permitted by a judicial order. 38. Such verification is procedural and protective. It does not amount to reopening the substantive entitlement already determined by the award and the appellate judgment. X. Conclusion 39. Having considered the application, affidavit, original award, appellate judgment, death certificate, identity credentials and office reports, I am satisfied that the amount deposited pursuant to the judgment dated 06.02.2023 should no longer be retained merely for want of a formal disbursement order. -- 12 of 17 -- Page 13 of 17 40. Applicant Nos.2 to 7 are adults and were themselves original claimants/appellants. The record presently placed before the Tribunal does not disclose any rival claimant or any subsisting stay against the appellate judgment. The High Court itself has expressly permitted withdrawal of the enhanced amount with accrued interest. 41. Consequently, subject to reconciliation of the deposit, verification of identity and bank particulars and execution of an appropriate indemnity in respect of the share devolving from deceased Applicant No.1, the Miscellaneous Application deserves to be allowed. 42. Hence, I proceed to pass the following order: O R D E R 1. Miscellaneous Application No.596 of 2026 is allowed in the following terms. 2. The Accounts Officer shall verify and reconcile the entire amount deposited by United India Insurance Company Ltd. pursuant to the judgment dated 06.02.2023 passed by the Hon'ble Bombay High Court in First Appeal No.1766 of 2002, including the -- 13 of 17 -- Page 14 of 17 NEFT deposit of 8,75,095/- dated 26.03.2025 ₹ , and shall ascertain the total amount presently lying to the credit of M.A.C.T. Application No.1991 of 1995, inclusive of interest accrued on deposit/investment, if any. 3. The amount so ascertained shall be dealt with strictly in accordance with the judgment and order dated 06.02.2023 of the Hon'ble Bombay High Court and the apportionment flowing therefrom. 4. The share independently payable to each of Applicant Nos.2 to 7 under the award/appellate judgment shall be released to the respective applicant after due verification of his/her identity credentials, PAN, bank-account particulars and IFSC details. 5. Since original Applicant No.1, Smt. Najma Begum Mohammed Saheed Ahmed Pathan, died on 07.12.2017, the amount, if any, representing her individual share and forming part of her estate shall, in the absence of any rival claim presently on record, be distributed amongst Applicant Nos.2 to 7 in accordance with their lawful succession entitlement, subject to compliance with paragraph 6 below. 6. Before release of the share attributable to deceased Applicant No.1, Applicant Nos.2 to 7 shall furnish a joint indemnity-cum-undertaking to the satisfaction of the Registrar that: (a) they are the surviving legal heirs entitled to receive the said -- 14 of 17 -- Page 15 of 17 amount; (b) to their knowledge, no other person has a subsisting superior claim thereto; (c) if any other person subsequently establishes a lawful entitlement to the whole or any part of the said amount, they shall abide by the order of the competent Court and refund/reimburse the amount to the extent lawfully required; and (d) the particulars and documents furnished by them are true and genuine. 7. Upon such verification and compliance, the amount payable to Applicant Nos.2 to 7 shall be transferred directly to their respective verified individual bank accounts through RTGS/NEFT/electronic transfer, without insisting upon continuation of the amount in long-term fixed deposits merely as a matter of routine. 8. No amount shall be transferred to the bank account of an advocate, agent, intermediary or third person. 9. If any discrepancy is noticed between the names appearing in the original proceedings, the High Court judgment and the identity/bank documents—particularly variations in spelling or aliases—the Registrar shall verify the same from the supporting identity documents and affidavit and, if satisfied regarding identity, record such verification before authorising payment. A merely clerical variation in spelling shall not by itself -- 15 of 17 -- Page 16 of 17 defeat disbursement to an otherwise duly identified beneficiary. 10. If, during such verification and before actual remittance, any rival claim, prohibitory order, stay order or subsequent order of the Hon'ble High Court/Hon'ble Supreme Court is received or brought to the notice of the Tribunal, disbursement of the disputed component alone shall be withheld and the matter shall immediately be placed before the Tribunal for further orders. 11. The authenticated copy of the judgment dated 06.02.2023 produced by the applicants, having been reported by the office to correspond with the judgment available on the official website of the Hon'ble High Court, may be acted upon for the purpose of the present disbursement, subject to the verification already recorded by the office. 12. The Accounts Section shall prepare a claimant-wise calculation/disbursement statement, showing: (i) principal amount available for disbursement; (ii) interest, if any, accrued while the amount remained deposited/invested with the Tribunal; (iii) individual amount payable to Applicant Nos.2 to 7; (iv) amount representing the share of deceased Applicant No.1 and its distribution; and (v) the final amount electronically remitted to each beneficiary. The said statement shall form part of the record. -- 16 of 17 -- Page 17 of 17 13. After successful electronic transfer, proof of remittance/UTR particulars shall be retained on the record. 14. Subject to completion of the aforesaid formalities and successful disbursement of the entire amount lying to the credit of the proceedings, Miscellaneous Application No.596 of 2026 shall stand disposed of. 15. No order as to costs. Pronounced in open Tribunal. Date: 06/10/2026 Place: Mumbai (Shashikant Eknathrao Bangar) Member, C.R. No.3 Motor Accident Claims Tribunal Greater Mumbai -- 17 of 17 --
