Full Order Text
Interim Order 1 · 21 Aug 2026 · CNR MHMT010021512023
Order Details: Order on Exh. Pdf Text: 1 MHMT010021512023 BEFORE THE MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL FOR GREATER MUMBAI, AT MUMBAI M.A.C.P. No. 1250 of 2023 Rama Yellapa Gollar ... Applicant Versus Mrs. Leonine Sunil Karlekar and New India Assurance Co. Ltd. ... Opposite Party ... Insurer ORDER BELOW EXHIBIT 18 1. This is an application preferred by the insurer, New India Assurance Co. Ltd., for setting aside the order dated 05.01.2026 by which the claim petition was directed to proceed against it without a written statement, for condonation of delay, and for taking its written statement on record. 2. I have read Exhibit 18, the written statement tendered along with it, the endorsement/say of the applicant, the pleadings, and the material roznama and prior orders. I have also heard the learned advocates to the extent reflected by the record. The application must be decided against the background of the insurer's prolonged default, but also in light of the stage of the claim and the -- 1 of 9 -- 2 requirement that compensation proceedings be decided effectively on their merits. 3. The applicant instituted this claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, seeking compensation for serious injuries allegedly sustained in the motor accident dated 12.06.2023 involving motor car No. MH-01-BF-0036. The insurer admits the factum of insurance in its proposed defence, while disputing negligence and quantum. 4. The chronology is material. Notice to the insurer was served on 20.11.2023. The insurer entered appearance through its advocate on 11.03.2024, filed its address memo, and sought time to file its reply/written statement. Nevertheless, no written statement was filed on the subsequent dates. On 10.09.2025 the time was expressly filed her written statement, but the insurer remained absent. Ultimately, on 05.01.2026, after nearly twenty-two months from its appearance, the Tribunal ordered that the proceeding would continue against the insurer without its written statement. 5. Exhibit 18 was presented on 23.03.2026. The insurer states that 05.01.2026 was the first working day after the Christmas vacation; its advocate had travelled to his native place in Sindhudurg and, owing to delayed train service, could not reach Mumbai in time. It asserts that the default was neither deliberate nor intentional; that the claim is -- 2 of 9 -- 3 substantial; and that denial of an opportunity to contest negligence and quantum would cause serious prejudice. A written statement was tendered with the application. 6. The applicant's advocate has endorsed 'No Objection' upon Exhibit 18. The roznama further records that the applicant's say was filed. Thus, the application is not opposed. An absence of opposition, however, does not automatically erase procedural default; the Tribunal must still be satisfied that its discretion is exercised judicially and without defeating the object of timely disposal. 7. The questions that arise are: (i) whether the Tribunal possesses discretion to recall the order closing the insurer's right to file its written statement; and (ii) if so, whether the facts justify exercise of that discretion and on what terms. 8. Section 169(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 authorises the Claims Tribunal, subject to the applicable rules, to follow such summary procedure as it thinks fit. The object is to secure a just, expeditious and effective adjudication of claims. The Tribunal is not a Civil Court in the strict sense for every procedural purpose, though the salutary principles of the Code of Civil Procedure may guide it where consistent with the Act and the rules. A procedural direction closing a party's right to plead is therefore capable of recall in an appropriate case in exercise of the Tribunal's incidental power to regulate its own proceedings and prevent failure of justice. -- 3 of 9 -- 4 9. In New India Assurance Co. Ltd. v. R. Srinivasan, (2000) 3 SCC 242, the Hon'ble Supreme Court recognised that a statutory Tribunal possesses inherent or incidental power to recall an order in appropriate circumstances so that abuse of process is prevented and justice is advanced. The principle supports recall of a procedural order when sufficient grounds exist; it does not create an unrestricted licence to revive rights lost through indifference. 10. In Kailash v. Nanhku, (2005) 4 SCC 480, the Hon'ble Supreme Court held, in the context of Order VIII Rule 1 CPC, that the prescription of time for filing a written statement is procedural and directory in non-commercial proceedings. At the same time, extension beyond the prescribed period is not routine: it must be supported by reasons, granted only in exceptional circumstances, and may be balanced by costs. Salem Advocate Bar Association, T.N. v. Union of India, (2005) 6 SCC 344, similarly explains that the time schedule is intended to curb delay, yet the Court retains narrowly controlled power to extend time where the ends of justice so demand. 11. R.N. Jadi & Brothers v. Subhashchandra, (2007) 6 SCC 420, reiterates that procedure is a handmaid of justice, but cautions that judicial discretion must not encourage lethargy or render the time prescription meaningless. More recently, Desh Raj v. Balkishan (Dead) through proposed legal representative, (2020) 2 SCC 708, reaffirmed that the outer limit under Order VIII Rule 1 is directory for ordinary -- 4 of 9 -- 5 civil suits, while distinguishing the mandatory regime applicable to commercial disputes. The present motor accident claim is plainly not a commercial dispute governed by the amended mandatory 120-day bar. 12. The converse caution is equally important. In Atcom Technologies Ltd. v. Y.A. Chunawala & Co., (2018) 6 SCC 639, the Hon'ble Supreme Court declined to condone an extraordinary and inadequately explained delay, emphasising that the power to accept a belated written statement cannot be exercised mechanically. The party seeking indulgence must display bona fides, and the Court must consider the length of delay, the explanation, prejudice, and the stage of trial. 13. Applying these principles, the insurer's explanation is not satisfactory for the entire period. The asserted train delay can explain the advocate's absence on 05.01.2026, but it does not explain why no written statement was filed from 11.03.2024 onward despite repeated opportunities and an express extension on 10.09.2025. The insurer is an institutional litigant, represented by counsel, and was expected to exercise reasonable diligence. Its default cannot be treated as a mere technical lapse or excused without consequence. 14. Yet, four countervailing circumstances carry substantial weight. First, Exhibit 18 was moved on 23.03.2026, about seventy-seven days after the closing -- 5 of 9 -- 6 order, and not after commencement or completion of evidence. Secondly, the written statement was tendered with the application; the insurer is therefore ready to plead rather than merely seeking another open-ended adjournment. Thirdly, its defence concerning negligence, contributory negligence and quantum concerns matters material to a proper adjudication of the claim, though every such contention remains subject to proof and the statutory limits upon an insurer's defence. Fourthly, the applicant has expressly stated that there is no objection. 15. The owner has already filed her written statement. Issues have not yet been framed and the applicant's evidence has not commenced. Taking the insurer's written statement on record at this stage will therefore not require reopening of evidence or undoing a completed procedural step. The prejudice caused by delay is compensable by costs and by imposing strict, self-operative conditions. Conversely, permanently excluding the written statement may constrain a full adjudication and could generate avoidable appellate proceedings. 16. Motor accident compensation law is welfare- oriented, but welfare adjudication does not mean that the Tribunal should decide without relevant pleadings where they can be received without irremediable prejudice. The applicant remains entitled to a speedy decision and must not bear the expense or inconvenience caused by the insurer's default. Substantial justice in the present -- 6 of 9 -- 7 circumstances is served by one final opportunity, coupled with realistic costs and a prohibition against any further time. 17. In view of the exceptional combination of the early procedural stage, contemporaneous tender of the written statement, material nature of the proposed defence, and the applicant's no-objection, the discretion ought to be exercised in favour of recall. This conclusion should not be understood as approving the insurer's inaction between March 2024 and January 2026. That inaction is the reason for imposing costs of Rs.10,000/- and making compliance a condition precedent. 18. The application accordingly deserves to be partly allowed on strict terms. Hence, the following order: ORDER (i) Application at Exhibit 18 is partly allowed, subject to the conditions stated below. (ii) The order dated 05.01.2026 directing the claim application to proceed against the insurer without its written statement is set aside. (iii) The delay in filing the insurer's written statement is condoned, subject to the insurer paying costs of Rs.10,000/- (Rupees Ten Thousand only) to the applicant within -- 7 of 9 -- 8 fourteen days from the date of this order and filing on record proof of such payment. (iv) Subject to compliance with clause (iii), the written statement tendered by the insurer along with Exhibit 18 shall be taken on record and assigned an exhibit number. No further or fresh opportunity to file another written statement shall be granted; any amendment shall require a separate application and shall be considered on its own merits. (v) If the costs are not paid and proof is not filed within the stipulated period, this conditional order shall stand recalled automatically, Exhibit 18 shall stand rejected, and the order dated 05.01.2026 shall revive without any further reference to the Tribunal. (vi) The applicant may file a rejoinder/additional pleading, if legally advised, within fourteen days after service/acceptance of the insurer's written statement. This liberty shall not be used to delay framing of issues. (vii) The contentions in the proposed written statement are not accepted on merits by this order. All questions concerning negligence, contributory negligence, quantum, -- 8 of 9 -- 9 statutory defences and liability are expressly kept open for determination upon evidence and in accordance with law. (viii) Upon compliance, the matter shall proceed forthwith to framing of issues. No adjournment shall be granted to the insurer for any step already required by this order, save for a cause beyond its control recorded in writing. Pronounced on: 21 August 2026. (Shashikant Eknathrao Bangar), Member, C.R. No. 3, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Greater Mumbai -- 9 of 9 --
