Full Order Text
Order 2 · 24 Feb 2026 · CNR MHMT010020112022
Order Details: Order on Exh. Pdf Text: MACP NO.1302 OF 2022 ORDER BELOW EXH.27 Perused the application and say. 2. Heard the Ld. Counsel for the Opposite Party No.3 so also the applicant and the insurer. 3. It is the contention of the Opposite Party No.3 that the applicant has filed the claim petition for grant of compensation due to injuries sustained by the applicant in an accident which took place on 29.05.2022 wherein the FIR is registered by Mahim police station vide CR.702/2022 under Sections 279, 304 (A), 338, 323, 506(2), 114 and 34 of the Indian Penal Code read with Sections 184 and 185 of the Motor Vehicles Act. 4. It is also contended that the Opposite Party No.1 is the owner of the offending vehicle bearing registration No.MH-01- AQ-9009 which was driven by the Opposite Party No.2 on the day of alleged accident. However, the said vehicle is insured with New India Assurance Co. Ltd. 5. It is further contended that the Opposite Party No.3 was rear seat passenger in the offending vehicle and neither he was the owner nor the driver or the insurer of the offending vehicle. Moreover, the Opposite Party No.3 had no control, supervision, dominion or authority over the offending vehicle and no role has been attributed by him for his negligence, rashness or any breach of duty. : 2 : -- 1 of 4 -- 6. It is contended that under Section 166 of M. V. Act, the liability can be fastened only upon the driver for negligence, the owner for vicarious liability and the insurer which has statutory liability or contractual liability. Furthermore, a mere occupant or passenger in the rear seat in the offending vehicle cannot fasten any liability upon a person for payment of compensation towards the negligence. 7. It is contended that the Opposite Party No.3 is discharged from the Sessions Case No.684/2022 on the grounds that there was no sufficient evidence to proceed against the Opposite Party No.3. Moreover, no right or any relief arises against the Opposite Party No.3, therefore, prayed for deletion of Opposite Party No.3 from the array of parties. 8. In support of the contention, the Ld. Counsel for Opposite Party No.3 relied upon the following rulings: • Sushma Vs. Nitin Ganapati Rangole • Kasturi Vs. Iyyamperumal and others (2005) 6 SCC 733 9. Per contra, the applicant filed the say and strongly opposed the application filed by the Opposite Party No.3 stating therein that the Opposite Party No.3 is a necessary party as he was the co-passenger at the time of the alleged accident and therefore, police made him the accused in the case. 10. It is submitted that the Opposite Party No.3 despite of having licence, allowed his friend i.e. Opposite Party No.2 to drive the vehicle after consuming alcohol. Furthermore, if the Opposite Party No.3 has been discharged by the Ld. Sessions Court, the : 3 : -- 2 of 4 -- same does not give right to the Opposite Party No..3 for deleting his name from the MACP application. Hence, prayed for rejection of the application. 11. The Ld. Counsel for the insurer also filed the application and strongly opposed the same and stated that Opposite Party No.3 is an eyewitness and passenger and his contribution to the accident can be ascertained only after a detailed evidence and framing of issues in the matter. Therefore, prayed that till such time, the Opposite Party No.3 may be continued as a party in the MACP application. 12. On perusal of the record and the documents filed by the applicant in the matter, it can be seen that the Police Station Mahim has registered the FIR No.702 on 29.05.2022 under Sections 279, 304 (A), 338, 323, 506(2), 114 and 34 of the Indian Penal Code read with Sections 184 and 185 of the Motor Vehicles Act, against one Mohd. Ameer Javed Shaikh and Darayas Sam Jijina. On going through the Chargesheet, it can be seen that it was filed against Mohd. Ameer Javed Shaikh, Darayas Sam Jijina and Shri. Moksh Shah. 13. On perusal of claim petition, it can be seen that the applicant has made all 3 of them a party to the clam petition. On further perusal of the police documents, it can be seen that the Opposite Party No.3 was one of the occupant in the offending vehicle on the alleged day of accident. However, the said vehicle was driven by Mohd. Ameer Javed Shaikh and the offending vehicle was owned by Darayas Jijina. The police : 4 : -- 3 of 4 -- papers further depicts that the Opposite Party No.3 was the occupant in the offending vehicle. 14. Here in the present matter, the applicant has filed the application under Section 166 of the M. V. Act for the compensation for the injury sustained by him in the alleged accident. However, the Opposite Party No.3 was the rear seat occupant in the offending vehicle at the relevant time of the accident. As the Opposite Party No.3 is neither the owner, nor the driver so also the insurer, therefore, the negligence on the part of the driver of the vehicle involved in the accident can not be vicariously attached to the passengers so as to reduce the compensation awarded to the applicant. 15. In view of the same , I am of the opinion that the application filed by the Opposite Party No.3 for deletion in the present matter is deserves to be allowed. Hence, the following order. ORDER 1. The application is hereby allowed. 2. The Opposite Party No.3 be deleted. (M. I. Arland) Chairman, Date : 24.02.2026 MACT, Mumbai GDE -- 4 of 4 --
