Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 3

CNR MHMT01002011202212 Jun 2026
Fort, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal
Mumbai · Maharashtra (MH)
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 3 · 12 Jun 2026 · CNR MHMT010020112022

Order Details: Copy of Judgment
Pdf Text: 1 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
Presented on : 04.10.2022
Decided on : 12.06.2026
Duration : 3Y 8M 8D
Exh.
BEFORE THE MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI
(Presided over by Monica I. Arland, Chairman)
Motor Accident Claims Petition No.1302 of 2022
1. Mr. Afroz Abdul Gaffar Ansari
Aged : 52 years,
Father of the deceased
2. Mrs. Anjum Ara w/o Afroz Ansari
Aged : 46 years,
Mother of the deceased
3. Hiba Afroz Ansari
Aged : 19 years
Unmarried sister of deceased
All applicants presently residing at :
Room No.1203, 12th floor,
KSA Royal Building,
1/2 Sankli Street,
Mumbai-400 008.
Permanent address :
Room No.47, Ground Floor,
House No.116/118,
Gol Darwaza Chawl,
Sukhlaji Street,
Mumbai-400 008. ... Applicants
-Versus-
Darayas Sam Jijina
Aged 24 years,
Address :
Flat No.17, 1st floor,
Ahura Apartment,
-- 1 of 22 --
2 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
Gun Powder Road,
Opp. Military Canteen Mazgaon,
Mumbai-400 010. … Opp. Party No.1
(Owner of offending vehicle)
Mohammed Amir Javed Shaikh
Aged 24 years,
Address :
Room No.7, Sindhi Street,
Near Podar Hospital,
Dr. Annie Besant Road,
Worli, Mumbai-400 018. … Opp. Party No.2
(Driver of offending vehicle)
Moksh Bhaven Shah
Aged : 24 years,
Address :
Room No.5, 2nd Floor,
Rakhangi Mahal, Dr. Annie Besant Road,
Near Worli Post Office,
Mumbai-400 018. … Opp. Party No.3
(Co-Passenger of the offending vehicle)
(Deleted as per order dated 24.2.2026)
- And -
The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.
Having its registered office at :
New India Assurance Building,
87 M.G. Road, Fort,
Mumbai-400 001. … Insurer
(Insurer of vehicle No.MH-01-AQ-9009)
Petition for compensation amount Rs.1,00,000/-
-------------------------------
Mr. Abdul Mannan Ansari - Advocate for the Applicants.
Opposite party No.1 and 2 - Exparte
Opposite party No.3 - Deleted
Mr. S. Meshram - Advocate for the Insurer.
-------------------------
-- 2 of 22 --
3 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
JUDGMENT
(Delivered on this 12th June 2026)
1. This petition has been filed by the applicants
under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act for grant of
compensation of Rs.1,00,000/- along with interest from
the opposite parties and Insurer.
2. According to the applicants, the applicant no.1
is the father, the applicant no.2 is the mother of the
deceased and the applicant no.3 is the unmarried sister of
the deceased.
3. According to the applicants, on 29.05.2022 at
around 1:00 a.m., the deceased had gone to visit his
relatives and while coming back from Bandra he was
driving the Scooter bearing No.MH-01-DF-8398 with care
and caution and his cousin sister namely Ms. Naba Shaikh
was the occupant as pillion rider. At that time the offending
Car No.MH-01-AQ-9009 while overtaking a Dumper which
was behind the scooter, dashed the scooter. Due to the
impact the deceased and the pillion rider both fell down on
the road. The pillion rider sustained serious injuries.
However, the rider/deceased came under the wheels of the
Car. He was taken to Raheja Hospital. However, he
succumbed to the accidental injuries before admission in
the Hospital.
4. The Police Station, Mahim registered an offence
-- 3 of 22 --
4 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
against the driver and owner of the offending vehicle vide
F.I.R. No.0702/2022 for the offences punishable under
Section 279, 338, 323, 506(2), 304(2), read with section 34
of the Indian Penal Code and Section 184 and 185 of the
Motor Vehicles Act.
5. At the time of accident, the deceased was aged
about 23 years. He was working as a Trainee in Delivery
Department of the Clover Infotech Private Ltd. and was
earning Rs.20,000/- p.m. According to the applicants, the
offending Skoda Car No.MH-01-AQ-9009 is owned by
opposite party No.1, driven by Opposite party No.2 and
insured with the Insurer at the time of the accident.
Therefore, the applicants have filed the present petition
and claimed compensation of Rs.1,00,000/- from the
Opposite parties and Insurer along with interest.
6. The Opposite party No.1, 2 and 3 though duly
served with notices vide Exh.9, 10 and 15 but failed to
appear. Hence, by order dated 11.03.2025 vide Exh.1, the
matter was proceeded ex-parte as against the opposite
party No.1, 2 and 3.
7. Later on the Opposite party No.3 appeared
through counsel and filed written statement at Ex.21.
However, Opposite party No.3 came to be deleted vide
order dated 24.2.2026.
8. The Insurer has filed written statement vide
-- 4 of 22 --
5 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
Exh.14 and resisted the claim of the applicants. It is
contended that the offending vehicle was not involved in
the accident and the driver of the offending Car was not
rash and negligent in driving his vehicle. It is also
contended that the accident occurred due to rash and
negligent driving by the deceased and pleaded that
contributory negligence be taken into consideration.
Hence, prayed for dismissal of the petition.
9. My learned predecessor framed Issues vide
Ex.17 on 11.03.2025. I reproduce the same. I record my
finding thereon for the reasons given below.
Sr.
No.
Issues Findings
1. Do the applicants prove that on
29/05/2022, at about 03:45 a.m.,
vehicular accident occurred on
Mahim Causeway road, South flank,
near Koli Statue, Mahim (W),
Mumbai, due to rash and negligent
driving on the part of driver of Motor
Car bearing No.MH-01-AQ-9009
Mr. Moiz Afroz Ansari died due to
injuries sustained in said accident?
Affirmative
2. Does the Insurer prove the defences
raised and particularly that accident
occurred due to contributory
negligence of the deceased who was
driving Motor Scooter bearing
No.MH-01-DF-8393 at the time of
accident?
Negative
3. Are the applicants entitled to
compensation ? If yes, to what extent
and from whom?
Yes, to the
extent of
Rs.41,75,118/-
jointly and
severally from
-- 5 of 22 --
6 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
Opposite
parties and
Insurer
4. What order? As per final
order
R E A S O N S
As to Issue No.1:-
10. In order to prove the contentions made in the
petition, the applicants have examined applicant no.1
(AW1) vide Exh.29 who proved the documents Exh.32 to
Exh.51. The applicants have also examined Ms. Elizabeth
Paul (AW2) vide Ex.53 who proved documents Ex.54 to
Ex.56.
11. The Insurer has not examined any witness to
prove its defence.
12. Perused the record. Heard learned counsel
Shri. Abdul Mannan Ansari for the applicant and learned
counsel Shri S. Meshram for the Insurer. Perused the
written notes of arguments filed by the applicant vide
Exh.59.
13. It is argued by the learned counsel for the
applicants that the deceased died in an accident which has
taken place due to dash by the driver of the offending Car
No.MH-01-AQ-9009 on 29.05.2022 and there is no
negligence on the part of the deceased. It is also argued
that deceased died before admission in the hospital.
-- 6 of 22 --
7 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
14. It is further argued that Police Station, Mahim
registered an offence against the driver and owner of the
offending vehicle vide F.I.R. No.0702/2022 for the offences
punishable under Section 279, 338, 323, 506(2), 304(2),
read with section 34 of the Indian Penal Code and Section
184 and 185 of the Motor Vehicles Act.
15. It is also argued that the Insurer has failed to
examine any eye witness as well as driver of the offending
vehicle to rebut the applicants testimony or to prove any
contributory negligence.
16. Per contra, it is argued by the Learned Counsel
for the Insurer that the applicants are the parents of the
deceased who was aged about 24 years. In support of the
contentions, the learned counsel for the Insurer has
referred and relied on following citation :
 Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. V/s. Meena Variyal &
Ors. 2007 ACJ 1284 S.C..
 New India Assurance Co. Ltd. V/s. Alpa Rajesh Shah
& Ors. 2014 ACJ 1747 H.C. (Bom.)
17. Afroz Abdul Gaffar Ansari (AW1) has testified
vide Exh.29 and he reiterated about the incident. According
to him, on 29.05.2022 at around 1:00 a.m., the deceased
had gone to visit his relatives and while coming back from
Bandra he was driving the Scooter bearing No.MH-01-DF-
8398 with care and caution and his cousin sister namely
-- 7 of 22 --
8 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
Ms. Naba Shaikh was the occupant as pillion rider. At that
time the offending Car No.MH-01-AQ-9009 while
overtaking a Dumper which was behind the scooter, dashed
the scooter. Due to the impact the deceased and the pillion
rider both fell down on the road. The pillion rider sustained
serious injuries. However, the rider/deceased came under
the wheels of the Car. He was taken to Raheja Hospital.
However, he succumbed to the accidental injuries before
admission in the Hospital.
18. He also testified that Police station Mahim
registered an offence against the driver and owner of the
offending vehicle vide F.I.R. No.0702/2022 for the offences
punishable under Section 279, 338, 323, 506(2), 304(2),
read with section 34 of the Indian Penal Code and Section
184 and 185 of the Motor Vehicles Act. It is his evidence
that the accident occurred due to negligence on the part of
driver of the offending vehicle. He testified that the owner
and driver of the offending vehicle were drunk at the time
of the accident. He proved the FIR Exh.32, Spot
panchnama Exh.33, inquest panchnama Ex.34, document
of S.L. Raheja Hospital Ex.35, Cause of death certificate
Ex.36, Autopsy report Ex.37, Death Certificate Ex.38,
Charge sheet Ex.39, FSL report of the owner Ex.40, FSL
report of the driver Ex.41.
19. During the course of cross examination, he
admitted that he had not witnessed the accident personally
and therefore cannot tell as to because of whose fault the
-- 8 of 22 --
9 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
accident took place.
20. At the outset, it is to be seen as to whether the
deceased died in the accident, which took place on
29.05.2022 at about 1:00 a.m., due to rash and negligent
driving of the driver of the Skoda Car No.MH-01-AQ-9009.
In this respect, the police papers are required to be
scrutinized. On perusal of the FIR (Exh.32), it discloses
that the offence was registered against the owner and
driver of the Skoda Car No.MH-01-AG-9009 vide F.I.R.
No.0702/2022 for the offences punishable under Section
279, 338, 323, 506(2), 304(2), read with section 34 of the
Indian Penal Code and Section 184 and 185 of the Motor
Vehicles Act. The Spot Panchnama vide Exh.33 discloses
that the Police visited the spot of accident and prepared the
Spot Panchanama in presence of panchas namely, Salman
Amer Khan and Fahad Munawar Lokhandwala. The
Inquest Panchnama (Ex.34) is also conducted on 29.5.2022
in presence of Rahil Mobin Shaikh and Salman Amir Khan.
The chargesheet (Ex.39) discloses that it was filed against
Mohd. Amir Shaikh, Dryas Sam Jijani and Moksha Shah
and they are facing trial before the Metropolitan
Magistrate, Bandra, Mumbai under section 279, 304(2),
338, 323, 506(2) read with sections 34, 114 of the Indian
Penal Code and section 184, 185 of the Motor Vehicles Act.
21. The Cause of Death Certificate (Ex.36) and Post
Mortem Report (Ex.37) disclose that the Cause of death of
the deceased is “Shock due to Polytrauma (unnatural)”.
-- 9 of 22 --
10 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
The death certificate (Ex.38) shows the date of death of
deceased as 29.05.2022.
22. On going through the documents filed on
record, evidence adduced and the submissions of
applicants, it appears that the accident took place on
29.05.2022 at about 03:00 a.m. on Mahim Causeway Road,
Mahim (West), Mahim due to rash and negligent driving of
the driver of the offending Car No.MH-01-AQ-9009
wherein the deceased sustained injuries and succumbed to
the accidental injuries before admission in the hospital.
Therefore, I hold that the accident took place due to rash
and negligent driving of Car No.MH-01-AQ-9009 owned
by Opposite party No.1 and driven by Opposite party No.2.
Hence, I answer Issue No.1 in affirmative.
As to Issue No.2 :-
23. The Insurance company has contended that the
accident occurred due to contributory negligence of the
rider of the Scooter. However, except for taking such a plea
in the written statement no evidence whatsoever has been
adduced in support thereof.
24. It is pertinent to note that neither the driver nor
the owner of the offending car has entered the witness box.
The Insurance company has also not examined any
independent witness to establish any negligence on the part
of the scooter rider. No material has been brought on
-- 10 of 22 --
11 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
record to demonstrate that the scooter rider violated any
traffic rule or contributed to the occurrence of the accident.
25. On the contrary the FIR, spot panchnama and
charge sheet placed on record vide Ex.32, Ex.33 and Ex.37
reveal that the criminal case was registered against the
driver and the owner of the offending Car. The
Investigating agency upon completion of investigation has
filed the charge sheet against them. The contents of the
charge sheet do not attribute any negligence or fault to the
rider of the scooter i.e. the deceased. There is not even a
whisper in the police papers regarding any contributory
negligence on the part of the scooter rider, the deceased.
26. It is well settled that though the contents of the
FIR and charge sheet are not conclusive proof of
negligence, they are relevant piece of evidence from the
Opposite side. In the case in hand the police papers
consistently indicate rash and negligent driving of the
offending Car and there is absolutely no evidence to the
contrary.
27. The burden of proving contributory negligence
squarely lies upon the parties alleging it. Mere pleading is
not proof in the absence of any oral or documentary
evidence establishing negligence on the part of the scooter
rider, the defence of contributory negligence remains a bald
assertion and cannot be accepted.
-- 11 of 22 --
12 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
28. Therefore, I hold that the accident occurred
solely due to rash and negligent driving of the offending car
by its driver. The Insurance company has failed to prove
contributory negligence on the part of the scooter rider.
Accordingly, the Issue No.2 is answered in negative.
As to Issue No.3 and 4 :-
29.
“The principle of torts “Restitution in integrum”
signifies that a person entitled to damages and
compensation pursuant to an accident, should, as nearly as
possible, get such sum of money which would put him in
the same position as he would have been, if he had not
sustained the injury in the civil wrong. The accident occur
on account of rash and negligent act. Though there is no
intention to cause the injury, the wrong doer is under an
obligation to pay damages to the victim or his dependents.
The idea of paying damages is to put the dependents
financially in the same condition, had the victim not
suffered injury and lived his natural span of life.”
30. According to the applicants, due to the sudden
and unexpected accidental death of the deceased who was
aged about 23 years, they have suffered mental, physical
and monitory loss and therefore, applicants have claimed
compensation of Rs.1,00,000/- from the Opposite party
No.1, 2 and the Insurer. As per the applicants, at the time of
accident the deceased was working as a Trainee in Delivery
Department of the Clover Infotech Private Ltd. and was
earning Rs.20,000/- p.m.
-- 12 of 22 --
13 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
31. It is argued by the learned counsel for the
applicants that at the time of the accident the deceased was
24 years old, working with Clover Infotech Pvt. Ltd. and
earning Rs.20,000/- p.m. during the training period. It is
further argued that the deceased had bright future and
would have earned Rs.60,000/- to Rs.70,000/- p.m. It is
also argued that the applicants have spent Rs.50,000/-
towards funeral expenses.
32. Per contra it is argued by the learned counsel
for the Insurer that the deceased was working as Trainee
and was earning Rs.20,000/- p.m. However, the deceased
was on Probation.
33. Afroz (AW1) vide Ex.29 deposed that at the time
of the accident the deceased was aged about 24 years. He
was working with Clover Infotech Pvt. Ltd. as a Trainee and
was earning Rs.20,000/- p.m. He further deposed that
after the completion of training period of 12 months, the
deceased was entitled to receive a salary of Rs.25,000/-
p.m. He proved receipts of payments made to S.L. Raheja
Hospital Ex.42, bills for the last rites of his deceased son
Ex.43, Aadhaar card of the deceased Ex.44, PAN card of the
deceased Ex.45, driving licence of the deceased Ex.46,
mark sheet of the deceased issued by University of Mumbai
Ex.47, result copy of the University Ex.48, driving licence
of the driver of the offending vehicle Ex.49, RC book of the
vehicle No.MH-01-AQ-9009 Ex.50 and copy of Policy
Ex.51.
-- 13 of 22 --
14 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
34. He was cross examined at length from the side
of the Insurer. He denied that he has stated false that his
deceased son had pursued MBA. He also denied that his
deceased son was working in a private firm wherein he was
receiving salary of Rs.20,000/- p.m. so also after the
completion of probation he was to be given Rs.25,000/-.
He was confronted about the number of children apart
from the deceased wherein he answered that he has one
daughter. He also answered in respect of his occupation
that he is doing the Jari work. He denied that he was never
dependent upon the income of his deceased son.
35. Ms. Elizabeth Paul (AW2) is examined vide
Ex.53. She deposed that he is working as a Senior Vice
President – Human Resources with Clover Infotech Pvt.
Ltd. Company. She deposed that deceased was working as
a Trainee for a period of 12 months and the company
offered him an annual CTC of Rs.2,40,000/- initially for
the training period. She deposed that the company had
made agreement with the deceased wherein the deceased
had agreed to provide his services initially for the period of
12 months and thereafter for the period of 30 months to the
company. She further deposed that the deceased was a hard
working employee who joined their company on 25.2.2022
on a salary of Rs.20,000/- per month until the deceased
expired on 29.05.2022 in a motor vehicular accident. She
filed and proved the offer letter issued to the deceased on
25.02.2022 Ex.54 and the trainee appointment letter of the
deceased Ex.55 and an agreement between the company
-- 14 of 22 --
15 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
and the deceased Ex.56.
36. She was cross examined at length from the side
of the Insurer. She was confronted about the nature of the
work of their company and the work assigned to deceased
wherein she replied that it is an IT company providing
service for BFSI (Banking and Insurance) and the deceased
had joined as a Trainee for JAVA technology. She admitted
that at the time of death Moiz was on probation.
37. She was confronted about the take home salary
of the deceased during his probation wherein he replied
that Basic, HRA, Special Allowance, Statutory bonus, ESIC
and PF. However, witness volunteered that during the
probation the employee is entitled for all the benefits.
38. She was further confronted about the benefit
given to the deceased wherein he replied that Basic, HRA,
Special allowance, statutory bonus and other benefits
which were mentioned in salary structure at page no.268.
She was also confronted about having any documentary
evidence to show the details which are mentioned in the
salary structure wherein he replied in affirmative. However
volunteered that presently she do not have the documents.
39. She denied that the deceased was entitled only
for Basic, HRA and special allowances and rest of the
things mentioned in the salary structure were to be given
after his confirmation. She admitted that the training
-- 15 of 22 --
16 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
agreement was subject to certain conditions, which also
includes his performance and non-disclosure of company’s
affairs to anyone and various conditions. She also admitted
that if there would have been any breach concerning the
contents mentioned in clause-9 of the agreement, the
deceased was subject to termination. She further admitted
that as per the agreement the deceased was supposed to be
posted at any part in India. She denied that as per the
termination clause, if the employee refuses to join the place
of posting assigned to him or her by the company, the
termination could take place. She admitted that any breach
of the clause of termination mentioned in the agreement,
the deceased could have been terminated.
40. She also admitted that as per the training
appointment letter, it was the prerogative of the company
to transfer the post of the employee.
41. The Aadhaar Card and PAN Card of the
deceased vide Ex.44 and Ex.45 are filed and proved by the
applicant no.1 Afroz (AW1). On perusal of the same, it can
be seen that the birth of the deceased is mentioned as
24.11.1998. Therefore considering the Aadhaar Card and
PAN Card being the authentic documents, it can be safely
held that the date of birth of deceased is 24.11.1998 and the
deceased died on 29.05.2022, it means, at the time of the
accident the age of the deceased was 23 years, 6 months
and 5 days old. Therefore, for determination of
compensation, the age of the deceased can be taken into
-- 16 of 22 --
17 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
consideration within the group of 21 to 25 years.
42. In support of the contention of the occupation
and income the applicants have examined Ms. Elizabeth
(AW2) the employer of the deceased who has proved the
offer letter vide Ex.54, trainee appointment letter vide
Ex.55 which was duly acknowledged and signed by the
deceased so also the agreement between the deceased and
the company entered upon vide Ex.56 i.e. between the
deceased and M/s. Clover Infotech.
43. The said documents reveal that on the date of
accident the deceased was working as a Trainee and was
receiving stipend/salary of Rs.20,000/- p.m. i.e.
Rs.2,40,000/- p.a. The evidence of Ms. Elizabeth (AW2)
further shows that the employment of the deceased was not
casual or temporary in nature. The deceased had already
been selected and appointed by the company and was
undergoing a structured trainee program. The training and
employment agreement provides a defined salary
progression after successful completion of various stages of
training. As per the said agreement at Ex.56, the salary
payable to the deceased was to increase to Rs.21,700/- to
Rs.24,000/- p.m. during the period of 13 to 24 months,
Rs.23,400/- p.m. to Rs.28,750/- p.m. during the period
from 25 – 36 months and Rs.25,000/- to Rs.35,000/- p.m.
during the period of 37 to 42 months.
44. Thus, the evidence on record establishes that
-- 17 of 22 --
18 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
the deceased had a settled career path with assured
prospectus of advancement and increase in remuneration.
The salary progression was not based upon mere
conjectures or speculative expectations but was supported
by documentary evidence proved through the employer.
45. In view of the ratio laid down by Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the Case of National Insurance V/s.
Pranay Sethi while determining the loss of dependency.
The deceased was in regular employment and have a
demonstrable avenue of future advancement. Therefore,
addition towards future prospects cannot be denied merely
because he was undergoing training on the date of accident.
46. Accordingly, the actual income of the deceased
can be assessed to Rs.20,000/- p.m. (Rs.2,40,000/- p.a.).
Having regard to the age of the deceased that he was aged
about 24 years at the time of accident and the principles
governing future prospects, an addition of 40% towards
future prospects is held to be just and proper.
47. Thus, in view of ratio laid down in Smt. Sarla
Verma & Ors. -Vs- Delhi Transport Corporation & anr. (AIR
2009 Supreme Court 3104), the actual multiplier for the age
between 21 to 25 years comes as 18. Hence, the loss of
dependency comes to Rs.40,32,000/- [Rs.20,000/- p.m. x
12 months + 40% future prospects less 1/3rd personal
expenses x 18 multiplier].
-- 18 of 22 --
19 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
48. Moreover, as per the ratio of National Insurance
Co. Ltd.
Vs Pranay Sethi and others, [2017 ACJ 2700 (SC)]
applicants are entitled to Rs.18,000/- towards funeral
expenses, Rs.18,000/- towards loss to estate. The applicant
No.1 and 2 being parents are entitled to Rs.96,000/-
(Rs.48,000/- x 2) towards filial consortium.
49. The applicants are also entitled for the expenses
incurred towards treatment at S.L. Raheja Hospital proved
vide Ex.42 amounting to Rs.9,617.93 rounded to Rs.9,618/-
and the ambulance charges of Rs.1,500/- proved vide page
no.260 of Ex.43.
50. Thus, the total amount of compensation comes
to Rs.41,75,118/-.
51. I have gone through the ruling cited and relied
upon by the learned counsel for the Insurer. They are not
helpful to the present case as the facts and circumstances of
the case cited supra is different from the case in hand.
52. It is already held that the offending Car No.MH-
01-AQ-9009 is owned by the opposite party on the date of
accident and was insured with the insurer. The applicants
have filed the copy of insurance policy vide Exh.51 which
discloses that the offending Car was insured with the
Insurer for the period from 13.9.2021 to 12.9.2022. The
accident took place on 29.05.2022 wherein the Car
No.MH-01-AQ-9009 is involved. It means at the time of
-- 19 of 22 --
20 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
accident, the vehicle was duly insured with the Insurer.
Therefore, the insurer is liable to indemnify the Opposite
party.
53. The applicants have claimed interest @ 12% per
annum. The claim being in petition under Motor Vehicles
Act, the interest can be granted on compensation amount.
It is the general principle that in the petition under Motor
Vehicles Act, the interest should be granted equal to the
rate of interest on fixed deposits of nationalized banks. As
the Tribunal has to assess just and fair compensation,
therefore, I think it proper to grant interest @ 7.5% per
annum on the amount of compensation. Therefore, in my
opinion, the interest @ 7.5% p.a. should be granted on
compensation amount from the date of petition. Hence, I
answer Issue No.3 accordingly and pass the following
order.
-: O R D E R :-
1. The petition is hereby allowed with costs against
the opposite parties and the Insurer.
2. Opposite parties and the Insurer shall jointly and
severally pay Rs.41,75,118/- (Rupees Forty One
Lakhs Seventy Five Thousand One Hundred
Eighteen only) towards compensation to
applicants along with interest @ 7.5% per annum
from the date of application till its full realization.
3. Amount of Rs.50,000/-, if any, granted towards
-- 20 of 22 --
21 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
no fault liability to the applicant shall be adjusted
from the above said amount of compensation.
4. Apportionment order is as under :
 Rs.7,00,000/- each be invested in FDRs of
nationalised bank in the name of applicants
for the period of 5 years with standing
instruction to the bank to renew said fixed
deposit after its maturity for every 5 years,
till further order of this Tribunal. The
applicants are at liberty to withdraw
quarterly interest on the said FDRs.
 Balance amount along with accrued interest
be equally paid to the applicants by
NEFT/RTGS directly in their bank account,
against proper identification and by
following the necessary office procedure,
subject to payment of deficit Court fees, if
any.
5. The Opposite parties and Insurer are directed to
deposit the FDR amounts in the account of the
Tribunal given below :
Account Name MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL,
MUMBAI
Account No. IFSC MICR
00000040777482356 SBIN0030002 400002273
and the balance amount directly in the account of
the applicant give below :
-- 21 of 22 --
22 M.A.C.P. No.1302/2022
Sr.
No.
Name of the applicant Account No. Bank Name and
IFSC
1. Mr. Afroz Abdul Gaffar
Ansari
41710033502 State Bank of
India
SBIN0000547
2. Mrs. Anjum Ara Afroz
Ansari
68005968244 Bank of
Maharashtra
MAHB0000067
3. Hiba Afroz Ansari 04170100021086 Bank of Baroda
BARB0SIRPMR
by NEFT/RTGS as per apportionment order and
submit the compliance report of the same to the
official email address of this Tribunal.
6. The applicants are hereby directed to deposit
deficit court fees if any within 15 days from the
date of award.
7. Award be drawn up accordingly.
[M. I. Arland]
CHAIRMAN
Date: 12.06.2026 MACT, Mumbai
*sb
-- 22 of 22 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.