Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 09 Oct 2023 · CNR MHMT010018322023
Order Details: Order on Exh. Pdf Text: COMMON ORDER BELOW EXH.1 in Misc. Application No.338, 339 & 340 of 2023 in MACP Nos.1034/2016, 816/2016 and 817/2016 The applicants have filed these applications for transferring respective MACP Nos.1034/2016, 816/2016 and 817/2016 from Court No.2 to any other Court. 2. Applicants contended that due to pandemic COVID- 19, aforesaid matters were prolonged. Thereafter the applicants had proceeded with the matters by examining their witnesses. Despite continuous followup and persuasion the witnesses from the hospital could not remain present. The applicants and their advocates were present in Tribunal on 09/08/2023 but on that day they were wrongly shown as absent. On the same day, applicants’ evidence was closed. The concerned Court failed to consider that on earlier date i.e. 02/08/2023 the applicants had already prayed for issuing witness summons but due to absence of witnesses, applicants could not examine the witnesses on 09/08/2023. Fair opportunity of hearing needs to be granted to the applicants. 3. On 13/09/2023, Ld. Advocate for applicants had applied and prayed for setting aside order of closing of evidence. It was also rejected. The concerned Tribunal failed to secure the presence of witnesses. According to applicants they would suffer great prejudice if matter is proceeded before Court No.2. 4. Heard Ld. Advocates of applicants and insurer. Vide order on Exh.1 itself, dated today, the driver and opposite party are proceeded ex-parte as according to both the Ld. Advocates those parties are ex-parte in the original motor accident claim petitions. So, in these applications, -- 1 of 3 -- notice to them is dispensed with. Ld. Advocate for applicants argued as per application. Ld. Advocate for insurer submitted that she has already filed written notes of argument in the original motor accident claim petitions, the applicants had unnecessarily prolonged the matter, the applicants were given sufficient opportunity and the present application is having no merits. 5. All these applications are supported by affidavit. Certified copy of witness summons issued on behalf of applicants in original MACP matters are also on record. Certified copies of applications filed by applicants for setting aside order of closing evidence is also on record. It was decided by the concerned Tribunal by passing order as “Being devoid of merits, rejected”. Thus, there appears to be a substance in submission of Ld. Advocate for applicants. On this factual background, there is also substance in submission on behalf of applicants that because of not getting sufficient opportunity, applicants would be deprived to prove loss of income, other relevant losses and would not get just compensation. 6. The general power of transfer and withdrawal of the matters from one Court to another is provided as per Section 24 of the CPC. In that connection, sub rule-2 of Rule 275 of The Maharashtra Motor Vehicle Rules, 1989 provides that “for the purposes other than those specified in sub rule (1), the Claims Tribunal may exercise all or any of the powers of the Civil Court as may be, necessary in any case for discharging its functions under the Act and made thereunder rules”. Further the last four lines of Sub Rule (B)(1) of Rule 276 of The Maharashtra Motor Vehicle Rules, -- 2 of 3 -- 1989, provides that “ in so far as the Act and these rules makes no provision or make insufficient provision, the relevant provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure,1908, shall, so far as may be, applied to the proceedings before the Claims Tribunal.” Accordingly, this Tribunal has power to withdraw and transfer the matter from one Tribunal to another. 7. Considering the substance in the present applications, the applicants should get sufficient opportunity of hearing and just compensation, all the aforesaid 3 matters are required to be allowed by invoking the aforesaid powers in Rule 275 & 276 of The Maharashtra Motor Vehicle Rules, 1989. So, following order is passed. : ORDER 1. MACP No.1034/2016, 816/2016 and 817/2016 are hereby withdrawn from Court No.2 and transferred to Court No.3 for trial and disposal according to law from the stage it is transferred. 2. Court No.3 is directed to entertain and dispose of according to law, the applications, if any, filed by the applicants for examining the witnesses. 3. Original copy of this order is kept in Misc. Application No.338/2023 while its xerox copies are kept in Misc. Application Nos.339 & 340 of 2023. 4. Accordingly, Misc. Application No.338, 339 and 340 of 2023 are disposed of. [N K Brahme] Date : 09/10/2023 CHAIRMAN GDE MACT, MUMBAI -- 3 of 3 --
