Skip to main content
Court Order

Order 1

CNR MHMT01001694202419 Aug 2026
Fort, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal
Mumbai · Maharashtra (MH)
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Order 1 · 19 Aug 2026 · CNR MHMT010016942024

Order Details: Order on Exh.
Pdf Text: 1 of 13
MHMT010016942024
BEFORE THE MOTOR ACCIDENTS CLAIMS TRIBUNAL
FOR GREATER MUMBAI AT MUMBAI
MISC. APPLICATION NO. 300 OF 2024
1. Smt. Sunita Rahul Hiwale
2.Kum. Aaryan Rahul Hiwale
3.Kum. Aades Rahul Hiwale ... Applicants
Versus
1. Jayshree Logistics Pvt. Ltd.
2. ICICI Lombard General Insurance
Co. Ltd.
... Opponent No. 1
... Insurer / Opponent
No. 2
ORDER BELOW EXHIBIT 13
(Application for amendment of the cause-title and
connected particulars)
1. The applicants, seeks leave to amend the cause-title
and the connected particulars in the original application for
condonation of delay. The application is supported by the
affidavit at Exhibit 14 and the documents produced with
the list at Exhibit 16. The opponents were afforded an
opportunity to file their replies. No reply opposing Exhibit
13 is found on record. The application is nevertheless
required to be tested on its own merits, particularly because
one proposed correction touches the computation of delay
under Section 166(3) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 ("the
Act").
-- 1 of 13 --
2 of 13
A. Record considered
2. The material presently relevant consists of: (i) the
original delay-condonation application presented on 26
June 2024; (ii) its supporting affidavit; (iii) Exhibit 13
dated 18 June 2026; (iv) the affidavit at Exhibit 14; (v) the
application at Exhibit 13 and list of documents at Exhibit
16; and (vi) the documents produced therewith, namely the
Aadhaar cards of the next friend and the minor applicant,
the school-leaving certificate of the minor applicant and the
driving licence of his deceased father. Each has been
perused for the limited purpose of the proposed
amendment.
3. The original cause-title describes the native address
as Village Kolhapur, Post Mahora, Taluka Jalna,
Maharashtra - 431206. Exhibit 13 asserts that the correct
native address is Village Kolhapur, Post Mahora, Taluka
Jafrabad, District Jalna, Maharashtra - 431206. It further
seeks incorporation of the Mumbai address as Chawl No.
13, Room No. 1, Mahatma Phule Nagar, near Narayan Guru
High School, Chembur, Mumbai - 400071. The Aadhaar
documents of the next friend and minor support the
Chembur address. The school-leaving certificate records the
minor's birthplace as Kolhapur, Taluka Jafrabad, District
Jalna, and thus independently lends support to the native-
place correction. The driving licence also indicates the
Mahatma Phule Nagar/P. L. Lokhande Marg, Chembur
locality, although the room number and PIN differ.
-- 2 of 13 --
3 of 13
Amendment may therefore be permitted in terms of the
Aadhaar and school record, leaving proof and legal effect to
the appropriate stage.
4. The original pleading states that the accident
occurred on 22 October 2022 and that the proceeding was
instituted on 26 June 2024. The pleading also refers to a
delay of "one year, two months and four days". That period
does not represent the entire interval between the accident
and institution; it is, however, the arithmetical period
beyond six months from the accident. Six months from 22
October 2022 expired on 22 April 2023, and the interval
from 22 April 2023 to 26 June 2024 is one year, two
months and four days. The proposed correction thus
clarifies the computation without changing either
foundational date.
4-A. There is an additional discrepancy which cannot be
ignored. The delay application appears to mention
registration of the FIR on 29 October 2022, whereas the
supporting affidavit contains the facially inconsistent date
22 October 2021, which precedes the pleaded accident by
one year. Exhibit 13 does not set out a precise proposed
replacement FIR date or annex a certified FIR in its
supporting list. Leave granted by this order cannot therefore
be used to choose between those dates. Any correction of
the FIR date must be sought by a separate, specific
application supported by the certified FIR/police record and
after notice to the opponents.
-- 3 of 13 --
4 of 13
B. Questions for determination
5. (i) Whether the proposed amendments are necessary
for determining the real controversy and can be allowed
without prejudice to the opponents; and (ii) whether
permission to correct the delay particulars would amount to
deciding, at this interlocutory stage, the applicability or
condonability of Section 166(3) of the Act.
C. Governing principles concerning amendment
6. Section 169(1) of the Act permits a Claims Tribunal,
subject to the rules, to follow such summary procedure as it
thinks fit. A motor accident claim is a welfare proceeding
aimed at determining just compensation; procedural rules
are its handmaid and not its master. While the Code of Civil
Procedure, 1908 does not apply with all its technical rigour,
the settled principles underlying Order VI Rule 17 furnish
sound guidance when a pleading requires correction.
7. In Jai Jai Ram Manohar Lal v. National Building
Material Supply, Gurgaon, (1969) 1 SCC 869, the Supreme
Court held that rules of procedure are intended to advance
justice and that a bona fide mistake should ordinarily be
permitted to be corrected where the other side can be
protected. Ganesh Trading Co. v. Moji Ram, (1978) 2 SCC
91, explains that amendments necessary to determine the
real controversy should be allowed unless they substitute a
wholly new and inconsistent cause or cause irremediable
prejudice.
-- 4 of 13 --
5 of 13
8. Revajeetu Builders & Developers v. Narayanaswamy
& Sons, (2009) 10 SCC 84, collects the controlling
considerations: whether the amendment is imperative for
proper adjudication; whether it is bona fide; whether
refusal would lead to multiplicity; whether it fundamentally
changes the nature of the case; and whether prejudice can
be compensated or otherwise cured. Life Insurance
Corporation of India v. Sanjeev Builders Pvt. Ltd., (2022)
16 SCC 1, reiterates that all amendments necessary for
determining the real question in controversy should
ordinarily be allowed, provided injustice or prejudice not
capable of compensation is not caused to the opposite
party.
9. The proposed address correction neither changes the
parties nor introduces a new accident, vehicle, policy,
injury, or claim. It facilitates service and proper
identification. The delay correction is also explanatory: the
accident date and presentation date remain unaltered. Any
opponent may meet the amended assertion by an additional
reply. Accordingly, no accrued substantive defence is
extinguished merely by granting leave to amend.
D. Section 166(3), the DAR framework, and the present
binding direction
10. The applicant's assertion that the accident preceded
the amended limitation provision is factually incorrect:
Section 166(3), inserted by Act 32 of 2019, was brought
into force with effect from 1 April 2022, whereas the
-- 5 of 13 --
6 of 13
pleaded accident is dated 22 October 2022. The provision
states that no application for compensation shall be
entertained unless made within six months of the
occurrence of the accident. The original application was
presented on 26 June 2024. Thus, on the face of the
pleaded dates, the question under Section 166(3) does
arise.
11. At the same time, Section 166(4), in its amended
form, requires the Claims Tribunal to treat an accident
report forwarded under Section 159 as an application for
compensation. In Jai Prakash v. National Insurance Co. Ltd.,
(2010) 2 SCC 607, and Gohar Mohammed v. Uttar Pradesh
State Road Transport Corporation, 2022 SCC OnLine SC
1798, the Supreme Court strengthened the statutory police-
report/DAR mechanism so that a victim is not deprived of
compensation merely because of procedural default or want
of legal assistance. These authorities do not, by themselves,
finally answer the constitutional and interpretive
controversy surrounding Section 166(3), but they
illuminate the beneficial statutory scheme and the
significance of the date on which the accident
information/report reached the competent Tribunal.
11-A. The Madras High Court in Malaravan v.
Praveen Travels Pvt. Ltd., 2023 SCC OnLine Mad 5467,
construed Sections 159 and 166(4) with Rule 150-A and
Annexure XIII of the Central Motor Vehicles Rules. It held,
in substance, that where an FIR/report concerning a post-1
-- 6 of 13 --
7 of 13
April 2022 accident was registered and accessible within six
months, the claimant's later petition operates as a reminder
to process the statutory report, rather than an independent
proceeding liable to rejection at the threshold. The Orissa
High Court in Manager (Legal), Shriram General Insurance
Co. Ltd. v. Subash Pradhan, W.P. (C) No. 24028 of 2024,
decided on 6 January 2025, reviewed the legislative history
and the decisions of several High Courts while reiterating
the prospective operation of Section 166(3). These
authorities are persuasive; their factual predicates must be
verified from the police and Tribunal record in the present
case.
12. More importantly, the Supreme Court, in ICICI
Lombard General Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Ayiti Navaneetha &
Ors., SLP (C) Nos. 8412-8413 of 2023 with Bhagirathi Dash
v. Union of India & Anr., W.P. (C) No. 166 of 2024 and
connected matters, by order dated 4 November 2025,
directed that during pendency of the batch, Tribunals and
High Courts shall not dismiss claim petitions as barred by
limitation prescribed under Section 166(3). By the
subsequent order dated 17 February 2026 in Bhagirathi
Dash, the Supreme Court directed that the interim
arrangement/order dated 4 November 2025 shall continue
until further orders. The said direction binds this Tribunal
under Article 141 of the Constitution and must be
scrupulously followed.
-- 7 of 13 --
8 of 13
13. Consequently, the present application need not and
ought not be used as a vehicle for finally pronouncing upon
the constitutionality of Section 166(3), the availability of
Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963, or the Tribunal's
inherent/statutory power to condone. Nor can the claim be
rejected on limitation at this stage. The correct course is to
permit accurate pleading of the foundational dates and the
period stated by the applicant, preserve every contention of
the insurer and owner, and direct registration/progression
of the substantive claim in conformity with the prevailing
Supreme Court orders.
E. Minor claimant and justice-oriented procedure
14. The claimant no.2 was born on 18 March 2010 as
consistently shown in the Aadhaar card and school-leaving
certificate, and was therefore 12 years old on the pleaded
accident date and 14 years old when the proceeding was
instituted. The cause-title's description of his age as about
13 years is plainly approximate. To prevent recurring error
as the proceeding continues, the amended cause-title may
state "minor, date of birth 18 March 2010" instead of a
changing numerical age. The claimant no.3 was born on 18
September 2013 as shown in the Aadhaar document and
was therefore a minor both on the accident date and on the
date of institution. The proceeding is prosecuted through
their mother and next friend. This circumstance does not
authorise the Tribunal to rewrite Section 166(3); it does
reinforce the need to avoid non-suiting a child for curable
-- 8 of 13 --
9 of 13
errors of an adult representative. Nagappa v. Gurudayal
Singh, (2003) 2 SCC 274 and Kajal v. Jagdish Chand,
(2020) 4 SCC 413 support a realistic, justice-oriented
approach, without prejudging negligence, injury, disability,
quantum, territorial jurisdiction or liability.
F. Findings
15. Exhibit 13 is bona fide and necessary to place
accurate identifying particulars and an intelligible
computation before the Tribunal. The proposed correction
does not alter the cause of action or withdraw an admission
concerning the date of accident or the date of institution.
Any possible prejudice is fully cured by supplying the
amended copy and permitting consequential replies. The
amendment shall therefore be allowed, but subject to
safeguards: (a) the dates 22 October 2022 and 26 June
2024 shall not be changed except by a separate, specifically
pleaded and supported application; (b) the statement of
one year, two months and four days shall be treated only as
the applicant's calculation of the period beyond six months
and not as a judicial finding that such delay is condonable;
and (c) all objections on limitation, jurisdiction, proof of
address, maintainability and merits remain open.
16. The amendment will ordinarily relate back for
purposes of the corrected cause-title because it merely
clarifies identity/address. However, it shall not be
construed as retrospectively creating a DAR, altering the
date of institution, validating any otherwise unavailable
-- 9 of 13 --
10 of 13
remedy, or defeating any defence. Registration and further
proceedings shall remain subject to the final decision and
further directions of the Supreme Court in Bhagirathi Dash
and the connected batch.
ORDER
1. Application at Exhibit 13 is allowed, subject to the
conditions stated below.
2. The applicants are permitted to amend the cause-title
by recording the native address as: "Village Kolhapur, Post
Mahora, Taluka Jafrabad, District Jalna, Maharashtra -
431206" and the Mumbai address, in accordance with the
Aadhaar and school records produced, as: "Chawl No. 13,
Room No. 1, Mahatma Phule Nagar, P. L. Lokhande Marg,
near Narayan Guru High School, Chembur, Mumbai -
400071." The applicant may be described as "minor, date of
birth 18 March 2010" in place of a changing approximate
age.
3. The applicants are permitted to clarify that, on the
pleaded accident date of 22 October 2022 and the
presentation date of 26 June 2024, the period beyond six
months is stated to be one year, two months and four days.
This is an arithmetical pleading only and shall not be
treated as a finding on limitation or condonation.
4. No amendment shall be made to the accident date,
FIR date, presentation date, identity of the vehicle, parties,
policy particulars, nature of the claim, or material facts of
-- 10 of 13 --
11 of 13
the accident under cover of this order. In particular, the
inconsistent FIR dates in the original application and
affidavit shall not be corrected except upon a separate,
specific application supported by certified police material.
5. The amendment shall be carried out in red ink / by
filing a consolidated amended copy, as permissible under
the applicable practice, within seven days. A clean amended
copy shall be supplied to both opponents.
6. The opponents may file an additional reply confined
to the amendments within fifteen days from service of the
amended copy. Their earlier and additional objections,
including under Section 166(3) of the Act, are expressly
kept open.
7. No order as to costs.
Dated: 19th August 2026 (Shashikant Eknathrao Bangar)
Mumbai Member, C.R. No. 3,
Motor Accident Claims Tribunal,
Greater Mumbai,
-- 11 of 13 --
12 of 13
AUTHORITIES REFERRED
Decision Proposition used
Jai Jai Ram Manohar Lal v. National
Building Material Supply, Gurgaon,
(1969) 1 SCC 869
Bona fide
amendments and
correction of
misdescription;
procedure serves
justice.
Ganesh Trading Co. v. Moji Ram, (1978)
2 SCC 91
Amendment
necessary to
determine the real
controversy;
prejudice/new cause
test.
Nagappa v. Gurudayal Singh, (2003) 2
SCC 274
Duty to award just
compensation;
technical limits in
the claim do not
control the statutory
duty.
Revajeetu Builders & Developers v.
Narayanaswamy & Sons, (2009) 10 SCC
84
Structured factors
governing
amendment.
Jai Prakash v. National Insurance Co.
Ltd., (2010) 2 SCC 607
Police/Tribunal
coordination and
victim-protective
claims procedure.
Kajal v. Jagdish Chand, (2020) 4 SCC
413
Full and realistic
compensation for an
injured minor.
Life Insurance Corporation of India v.
Sanjeev Builders Pvt. Ltd., (2022) 16 SCC
1
Contemporary
restatement of
amendment
principles.
Gohar Mohammed v. Uttar Pradesh State
Road Transport Corporation, 2022 SCC
OnLine SC 1798
Mandatory accident-
report/DAR
procedure and
treatment of the
-- 12 of 13 --
13 of 13
Decision Proposition used
report as claim
petition.
Malaravan v. Praveen Travels Pvt. Ltd.,
2023 SCC OnLine Mad 5467
Post-amendment
FIR/report
framework; a later
claim may operate
as a reminder to
process the statutory
report.
Manager (Legal), Shriram General
Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Subash Pradhan,
W.P. (C) No. 24028/2024 (Orissa High
Court, 06.01.2025)
Legislative history
and prospective
operation of Section
166(3).
ICICI Lombard General Insurance Co. Ltd.
v. Ayiti Navaneetha & Ors., SLP (C) Nos.
8412-8413/2023 with Bhagirathi Dash v.
Union of India & Anr., W.P. (C) No.
166/2024, order dated 04.11.2025
Pending the
constitutional batch,
no claim petition is
to be dismissed as
barred by Section
166(3).
Bhagirathi Dash v. Union of India & Anr.,
W.P. (C) No. 166/2024 and connected
matters, order dated 17.02.2026
The interim
arrangement/order
dated 04.11.2025
continues until
further orders.
-- 13 of 13 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.