Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 26 Jun 2024 · CNR MHMT010013532024
Order Details: Order on Exh. Pdf Text: COMMON ORDER BELOW EX.1 & Ex.4 IN M.A. No.251 of 2024 AND M.A. No.247 OF 2024 IN MACP No.494 OF 2010 Applicants have filed these application for directing Accounts Officer to recall the entire amount, its disbursement in their favour, discharging next friend of then minor applicant no.2 and disbursement of share of applicant no.3, who is died on 5.12.2021. 2. In application Ex.1 in M.A. No.251/2024 it is the contention of applicant that the Insurer filed an appeal against the judgment and award passed by this Tribunal of Rs.67,31,400/- bearing F.A. No.1232/2022. The Hon’ble High court disposed off said appeal on 21.3.2024. The applicants have not received any appeal memo of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. As per the order dated 21.3.2024 the Hon’ble High Court is pleased to allow the Insurer/Appellant to withdraw a sum of Rs.1,45,000/- with proportionate interest out of deposited amount and permitted applicant to withdraw remaining amount. 3. In application Ex.4, applicants contended that applicant No.3, mother of deceased died on 5.12.2021 at their native place. Her legal representative is Keshar Ramchandra Jadhav aged about 54 years. He has no objection for disbursement of her share in favour of applicant No.1 and 2 in equal proportion. The legal heir also filed his affidavit in support of this application. Moreover, he personally appeared in the court and affirmed the contents of application Ex.4 and affidavit filed in support of Ex.5 and prayed to disburse share of his mother in between applicant no.1 and 2 equally. 4. In M.A. No.247/2024, applicant contended that applicant No.2 Aditya Vaisham Jadhav who was minor at the time of application attained the age of majority. At present he is -- 1 of 4 -- : 2 : 21 years old. Initially original application came to be filed through next friend. His date of birth is 29.8.2002. As he attained the age of majority therefore, he prayed for discharging his next friend and allowing him to withdraw his share out of award amount as per order of Hon’ble Parent High court dated 21.3.2024. His next friend i.e. mother also filed her affidavit in support of this application vide Ex.2 and that of applicant No.2 at Ex.3. He also placed on record verified copy of his birth certificate indicating his date of birth as 29.8.2002. Same contains in his Aadhar card and PAN card. 5. On perusal of death certificate it appears that Sitabai Ramchandra Jadhav died on 5.12.2021 at Malan Bauddhawadi, Taluka Guhagar, Dist. Ratnagiri. On perusal of judgment of Hon’ble Parent High Court in F.A. No.1232/2022 it appears that the appeal preferred by Insurance company is partly allowed. Insurer is permitted to withdraw Rs.1,45,000/- with proportionate interest out of deposited amount, the claimants are permitted to withdraw balance amount with proportionate interest. Moreover, the parties are permitted to withdraw the statutory amount alongwith accrued interest as per rule. 6. On perusal of report of accounts officer it appears that the insurance company has deposited Rs.1,12,30,834/- with this Tribunal on 2.4.2019 which has been invested in State Bank of India. Moreover, as per order passed in M.A. No.246/2021 dated 16.7.2021 an amount of Rs.15,00,000/- has been recalled. A sum of Rs.10,00,000/- paid to Veena Jadhav, applicant No.1 and Rs.5,00,000/- paid to Sitabai Jadhav on 6.10.2021. The balance amount has been reinvested in respective bank. -- 2 of 4 -- : 3 : 7. As per report of writ section no any order has been received from the Hon’ble Apex Court in this matter. 8. Considering the material placed on record it can be easily gathered that the appeal filed by Insurance company has been decided by the Hon’ble Parent High Court. The Insurance company is allowed to withdraw sum of Rs.1,45,000/- alongwith proportionate interest thereon and claimants are permitted to withdraw the balance amount with proportionate interest. It appears that the Tribunal by its judgment and award, awarded compensation of Rs.15,00,000/- with accrued interest to applicant No.2 minor son, Rs.10,00,000/- to applicant No.3 mother of deceased, now no more. Moreover, 50% amount of remaining compensation directed to be paid to the applicant No.1 and the remaining 50% directed to be deposited in fixed deposit for the period of 10 years. 9. Now the Hon’ble Parent High court permitted them to withdraw said amount with proportionate interest. Already Rs.5,00,000/- has been paid to applicant No.3 now deceased. Remaining amount of her share with accrued interest claimed to be disbursed in favour of applicant No.1 and 2 in equal proportion to which the sole legal heir have no objection. He expressed his intention into the court itself. Moreover, there is nothing on record to show that any appeal has been preferred against the order of the Hon’ble Parent High court before the Hon’ble Apex Court by the Insurance company. Applicant No.1 filed her affidavit dated 25.6.2024 contending that no any intimation of appeal memo of the Hon’ble Supreme Court has been received. 10. Moreover, as then minor applicant No.2 attained the age of majority he is also entitled to receive his share -- 3 of 4 -- : 4 : of compensation out of deposited compensation amount alongwith accrued interest. Therefore, there is no impediment in disbursing said amount in favour of applicant by obtaining their undertaking that they should redeposit the amount if any adverse order received from the Hon’ble Apex Court in future. Hence, these applications deserve to be allowed. In the result, I proceed to pass following order : ORDER 1) Applications Ex.1 and Ex.4 in M.A. No.251/2024 and application Ex.1 in M.A. No.247/2024 are hereby allowed. 2) Next friend of then minor applicant No.2 is hereby discharged. 3) Applicant No.1 and 2 are entitled to receive the share of deceased applicant No.3 alongwith accrued interest in equal proportion as awarded. 4) Accounts officer is hereby directed to recall the invested amount and after deducting Rs.1,45,000/- with proportionate interest from it as per order of the Hon’ble High Court remaining amount be disbursed in favour of applicant No.1 and 2 as apportioned in award alongwith proportionate interest after obtaining undertaking from them that they should deposit the same, if any adverse order received from the Hon’ble Apex Court in future. 5) Insurance company is at liberty to withdraw sum as ordered by the Hon’ble High Court. 6) True copy of this order be kept in M.A. No.247/2024. sd/- (R.V. Jagtap) I/c Member, C.R. No.2 Date : 26.06.2024 MACT, MUMBAI sb* -- 4 of 4 --
