Order Details: Order on Exh. Pdf Text: Page 1 of 23 MHMT010010612026 BEFORE THE MOTOR ACCIDENT CLAIMS TRIBUNAL, MUMBAI MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATION NO. 335 OF 2026 IN M.A.C. APPLICATION NO. 2935 OF 1996 1. Smt. Rukmini…
Read Full Order →Rukmini Deepak Alias Dilip Kachare and OrsVsBalasaheb P Ghule and The United India Ins Co Ltd +1 more
TrustJury record updated 10 Oct 2026
Case Overview
- Registration Number
- 335/2026
- Registration Date
- 02 Jul 2026
Advocates
1For Petitioner
For Respondent
Not available
Parties
3Acts & Sections
1Case Timeline
23 Jul 2026
2 recordsCourt ProceedingApplicant Absent Adv. for App. Present 1. Miscellaneous Application No.335 of 2026 is allowed in the following terms. 2. It is declared that surviving…
Read full proceedingHide details
Applicant Absent Adv. for App. Present 1. Miscellaneous Application No.335 of 2026 is allowed in the following terms. 2. It is declared that surviving…
Business: Applicant Absent
Adv. for App. Present
1. Miscellaneous Application No.335 of 2026 is allowed in the following terms.
2. It is declared that surviving Applicants Nos.1 to 4 are entitled to receive the compensation amount deposited and/or payable pursuant to the judgment dated 2 July 2025 passed by the Honourable High Court of Judicature at Bombay in First Appeal No.105 of 2007, arising out of M.A.C. Application No.2935 of 1996.
3. In continuation of and consistently with the earlier orders passed in the claim proceedings, particularly the order deleting the name of deceased Applicant No.5 and the order dated 11 December 2025 in Miscellaneous Application No.496 of 2025, the total net distributable amount shall be divided equally among surviving Applicants Nos.1 to 4.
4. Each surviving Applicant shall be entitled to one-fourth share in the net amount comprising
(i) compensation payable under the modified award
(ii) interest payable thereon in accordance with the judgment dated 2 July 2025
(iii) interest accrued on deposits or investments relating to the claim and
(iv) the share previously attributable to deceased Applicant No.5, subject to adjustment of amounts already lawfully paid or withdrawn.
5. The Accounts Section shall verify the precise amount deposited by Opponent No.2 The United India Insurance Company Limited on 27 April 2026 through NEFT. The discrepancy, if any, between the amount stated in the application and the amount appearing in the office report shall be reconciled from the NEFT credit advice, bank statement, challan, deposit register and the Tribunals accounts ledger.
6. Within fifteen working days from the date of this order, the Accounts Section shall prepare a comprehensive calculation sheet showing
a all deposits made by the Insurance Company
b the interest calculation in accordance with the final judgment
c amounts already released to or withdrawn by each of the original Applicants
d all amounts presently lying in deposit or investment
e accrued interest on such deposits
f the net balance available and
g the exact one-fourth share payable to each surviving Applicant.
7. The calculation sheet shall be signed by the Accounts Officer and verified by the Registrar Assistant Registrar concerned. A copy thereof shall be furnished to the Applicants or their learned Advocate.
8. The office shall ascertain the deficit court fee, if any, payable upon the enhanced compensation in terms of the judgment of the Honourable High Court. In case any deficit is payable, a written requisition containing the calculation shall be issued. Upon payment thereof, disbursement shall not be delayed.
9. Any fixed deposit or investment standing in the names of the original Applicants or in the name of the Tribunal and referable to this claim shall, upon maturity or premature encashment in accordance with banking rules, be credited along with accrued interest to the claim account and included in the net distributable amount.
10. The amount payable to each Applicant shall be transferred by RTGS or NEFT directly to an account standing in the name of the concerned Applicant. Payment by account payee cheque may be permitted only if electronic transfer is not feasible for a recorded reason.
11. Before payment, each Applicant shall furnish
i recent passport size photographs
ii self-attested Aadhaar card
iii self-attested PAN card
iv proof of present address
v cancelled cheque or bank passbook showing the Applicants name, account number, branch and IFSC
vi an undertaking that the right to receive compensation has not been assigned, transferred or encumbered and
vii a receipt and satisfaction voucher after credit of the amount.
12. The office shall verify the original KYC documents and return them immediately after retaining self-attested copies. The bank account particulars shall be independently verified from the cancelled cheque, passbook or bank certificate.
13. The share of original Applicant No.3, described in the original proceedings as Sheetal Deepak alias Dilip Kachare, shall be disbursed in her present married name, namely Smt. Shital Bhimrav Narute, or in the substantially corresponding spelling recorded in her verified bank account, upon her filing
a an affidavit cum declaration affirming that both names refer to one and the same person
b her marriage related name change document, if readily available
c Aadhaar and PAN credentials and
d bank account particulars in her present name.
14. Minor transliterational variations in the spelling of Sheetal Shital, Bhimrao or Bhimrav,Kachare or Kachre or Narute Narule shall not, by themselves, constitute a ground to refuse payment, provided the identity is otherwise satisfactorily established.
15. Since all four Applicants are majors and there is no material indicating legal incapacity or vulnerability necessitating protection by compulsory investment, no portion of their respective shares shall be directed to be retained in a long term fixed deposit.
16. The Applicants shall nevertheless be at liberty to invest the whole or any part of the amount according to their own financial requirements and prudence.
17. No part of the compensation shall be paid or transferred into the account of the Advocate, clerk, agent, representative, tout, moneylender or any person other than the concerned Applicant.
18. The Tribunal and the disbursing bank shall comply with the applicable provisions of the Income-tax Act, 1961. No tax shall be deducted from the principal compensation. Any deduction from the interest component shall be made only if and to the extent legally mandatory, after applying the relevant threshold claimant wise and financial year wise.
19. Disbursement under this order shall be without prejudice to the liberty granted to Opponent No.2 Insurance Company by the Honourable High Court to recover the amount from the available assets of the deceased owner in accordance with law.
20. In case the calculation reveals that the Insurance Company has not deposited the entire amount payable under the modified award, inclusive of interest up to the legally relevant date, the present disbursement shall be treated as part satisfaction only. The Applicants shall be at liberty to initiate or continue appropriate execution proceedings for recovery of the shortfall.
21. The office shall not record full satisfaction of the award unless the Accounts Officer certifies that the entire principal, interest and other amount payable under the final judgment have been deposited and appropriately accounted for.
22. After successful electronic transfer, the Accounts Section shall place on record the transaction confirmation, beneficiary details and payment certificate.
23. Subject to completion of verification, payment of deficit court fee, if any, and furnishing of KYC and bank documents, the disbursement shall be completed expeditiously and preferably within thirty days from the date on which all compliances are fulfilled.
24. Miscellaneous Application No.335 of 2026 stands disposed of accordingly.
25. There shall be no order as to costs.
Nature Of Disposal: ALLOWED OTHERWISE
Disposal Date: 23-07-202622 Jul 2026
1 recordCourt ProceedingApplicant Absent Adv for Applicant Present Court is busy in preparation of Judgement in MACP 1301/2019, recording in evidence in MACP 837/2023,…
Next purpose: ORDER ON EXH._____READYRead full proceedingHide details
Applicant Absent Adv for Applicant Present Court is busy in preparation of Judgement in MACP 1301/2019, recording in evidence in MACP 837/2023,…
Business: Applicant Absent Adv for Applicant Present Court is busy in preparation of Judgement in MACP 1301/2019, recording in evidence in MACP 837/2023, Exe.131/2024, order passed in MACP 2027/2025 Next Purpose: ORDER ON EXH._____READY
14 Jul 2026
1 recordCourt ProceedingApplicant Absent Adv. for App. Present Report received from A. O. and Writ Department Exh. 6 Application for deleting Applicant no. 5 filed by App. Adv.…
Next purpose: AMEND PLAINTRead full proceedingHide details
Applicant Absent Adv. for App. Present Report received from A. O. and Writ Department Exh. 6 Application for deleting Applicant no. 5 filed by App. Adv.…
Business: Applicant Absent Adv. for App. Present Report received from A. O. and Writ Department Exh. 6 Application for deleting Applicant no. 5 filed by App. Adv. Order- Perused the application and copy of death certificate and order dated 11.12.2025 passed in M. A. 496/2025 . Considering that App. No. 5 has died. Her name is permitted to be deleted.Necessary amendment be carried out. Order- Perused the Application and copies of death certificate of original Applicant and D. H. No. 5 and order dt 11.12.2025 passed in M.A. 496/2025. Considering that the original applicant no. 5 Indirabai G. Kachare has died on 9.10.2025 her name is permitted to be deleted since her legal Representative are already on record as original Applicants D. H. no. 4 Necessary amendment be carried out in Miscellaneous Application and copy be supplied. Amendment carried out on EXh. 1 Next Purpose: AMEND PLAINT
04 Jul 2026
1 recordCourt ProceedingApplicant absent Adv for applicant present Exh. 1 Application for Misc. Exh. 2 Affidavit Exh. 3 Pursis Exh. 4 Memo of Address Exh. 5 List of document…
Next purpose: REPORTRead full proceedingHide details
Applicant absent Adv for applicant present Exh. 1 Application for Misc. Exh. 2 Affidavit Exh. 3 Pursis Exh. 4 Memo of Address Exh. 5 List of document…
Business: Applicant absent Adv for applicant present Exh. 1 Application for Misc. Exh. 2 Affidavit Exh. 3 Pursis Exh. 4 Memo of Address Exh. 5 List of document Order passed below Exh.1 Report of A.O. MACT regarding deposit of awarded compensation and report of writ section regarding pendency of writ/litigation be called. Next Purpose: REPORT
Additional Case Details
Additional Case Details
Filing Number: 1320/2026 Filing Date: 07-05-2026 First Hearing Date: 04th July 2026 Decision Date: 23rd July 2026 Court Number And Judge: 3-H. H. Member
TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.
