Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 23 Nov 2024 · CNR MHMM190314212024
Order Details: Order below Ex-1 Pdf Text: 1 C. C. No. 4401636/N/2024 in C.R. No.538/2024 of Versova police station ORDER BELOW APPLICATION FOR RETURN OF PROPERTY : 1. The present application came to be filed under section 503 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita wherein the applicant Mrs. Archana Singh prayed for return of property i.e. Gold necklace and earring set weighing 180 grams value Rs.9,00,000/ and three gold chains weighing 15 grams value of Rs.1,00,000/, which were seized in C.R No.538/2024 under seizure panchanama by Versova Police Station. 2. Say of I.O. and learned APP were called. 3. Having gone through the record, it appears that there is no any material document placed on record which can establish the fact that the seized property was in possession of the applicant at the relevant time. Moreover, the applicant has not filed any relevant document to establish his ownership regarding the said seized property. The applicant filed her photograph which shows that a woman wears some ornaments. But in my opinion, this photograph cannot be considered to establish the defacto and dejure possession and ownership of the ornaments in question. Thus, the said document is not sufficient to prove the ownership and possession of the said ornaments at this stage. Apart from this, the chargesheet in the instant case is yet to be filed. The investigation is in progress. The seizure panchanama has not been filed on record. In such circumstances, unless and until all the relevant documents are produced and the accused is heard, the interim custody of the said valuable property cannot be given to the applicant. -- 1 of 2 -- 2 4. The learned advocate for the applicant placed reliance on the following citation: 1 Judgment delivered by Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Ramprakash Sharma Vs State of Haryana 2 Judgment delivered by Hon'ble Gauhati High Court in Criminal Writ Petition No.284/2022 5. I have gone through the above citations. With due respect to the ratio laid down therein, this Court is of humble opinion that the facts and circumstances of the case mentioned therein are different than that of the facts and circumstances of the present case on hand. Moreover, the applicant has not filed any valid document to establish his ownership in respect of the said seized property. Thus, considering the nature of the case, I pass the following order: ORDER The application is rejected. Sd/ ( Sujitkumar C. Tayde ) Judicial Magistrate First Class, Date : 23.11.2024 44th Court, Andheri, Mumbai. spj -- 2 of 2 --
