Final Order 1

Order Details: Copy  of Judgment
Pdf Text: 1 [kVyk dz- 3069@ihMCY;w@2018 U;k;fu.kZ;
izkIr fnukad % 15@11@2018-
uksan.kh fnukad % 16@11@2018-
fudky fnukad % 20@06@2023
dkyko/kh % 04 o"ksZ] 07 efgus]
04 fnol-
fu'kk.kh %
egkuxj naMkf/kdkjh ;kaps U;k;ky;kr
66 os U;k;ky;] va/ksjh] eqacbZ
¼fiBklu vf/kdkjh Jh-fot; fpa-xobZ½
¼U;k;fu.kZ; dye 355 Qsks- iz- la- vUo;s½
¼v½ [kVyk Øaekd %& 3069@ihMCY;w@2018
¼c½ vijk/k ?kMY;kph rkjh[k %& 23@04@2018
¼d½ fQ;kZnhps uko ¼vfHk;ksxi{k½ %& egkjk"Vª ljdkj]
}kjk & ofj"B iksyhl fufj{kd]
iobZ iksyhl Bk.ks-
¼xqUgk uksan Ø-&237@2018½-
¼M½ vkjksihps uko jkts'k y{e.k ejkBs
o;%& 56 o"ksZ] /aknk%& uksdjh-
jk- ch@2] lgkj lkslk;Vh] lgkj jksM]
ikjlhokMk] va/ksjh ¼iqoZ½] eqacbZ-
i½ dks.kR;k Lo:ikpk xqUgk vkgs \ %& Hkk-n-fo- lafgrk dye 354] 354 ¼v½
¼1½ vUo;s
¼Q½ vkjksihyk xqUgk dcqy vkgs dk\ %& vkjksihyk xqUgk dcqy ukgh-
¼c½ vafre vkns'k %& vkjksihph funksZ”k eqDrrk dj.;kr ;srs-
¼Hk½ vkns'kkpk fnukad %& 20@06@2023
nks"kkjksi %& Hkk-n-fo- lafgrk dye 354] 354 ¼v½ ¼1½ vUo;s
vfHk;ksxi{kkrQsZ %& Jherh- vkQzhu [kku] lgk- ljdkjh vfHk;ksDrk
vkjksihrQsZ %& Jh-lqt; ukes fo/khK
-- 1 of 7 --
2 [kVyk dz- 3069@ihMCY;w@2018 U;k;fu.kZ;
U;k ; fu .kZ ;
¼fn- 20@06@2023 jksth ikfjr½
izLrqrpk [kVyk vkjksihfo:/n~ Hkk-n-fo- lafgrk dye 354] 354 ¼v½
¼1½izek.ksP;k vijk/kklkBh pkyfo.;kr vkysyk vkgs- vfHk;ksxi{kkph gdhdr
FkksMD;kr v’kh vkgs dh] fQ;kZnh lk;jk tCckj vUlkjh gh iksn~nkj baVjuW'kuy
'kkGsP;k cloj okgd Eg.kqu uksdjh djrs- fnukad 23@04@2018 jksth 12-30
oktrk iksn~nkj 'kkGsleksj rh 'kkGsP;k eqykauk cle/;s clfo.;klkBh ?ksoqu tkr gksrh-
R;kosGh iksn~nkj 'kkGssP;k clP;k VªkUliksVZ'kups eWustj jkts'k ejkBs ;kauh ^^tYnh
tYnh cl es ysds tkvks] tYnh tYnh cPpks dks fcBkvks** vls cksyqu frP;k dacjsyk
gkr ykoqu /kDdk fnyk- rlsp nksu efgU;kiqohZgh R;kus lnjpk izdkj frP;klkscr dsyk
gksrk Eg.kqu fQ;kZnhus R;kP;kfo:/n fQ;kZn@ rdzkj nk[ky dsyh-
2- ojhy etdwjkP;k fQ;kZnho:u iobZ iksyhl Bk.ks ;sFks vkjksihfo:/n
xqUgk uksan gksowu riklkvarh vUos"ku vf/kdk&;kus U;k;ky;kr nks"kkjksii= ikBfoys-
vkjksihfo:/n fu’kk.kh dz-4 oj jpysys Hkk-n-fo- lafgrk dye 354] 354 ¼v½ ¼1½
izek.ksps vijk/k R;kl okpwu nk[kfoys vlrk R;kus fu’kk.kh dz-5 dMhy fuosnuk}kjs rs
ukdcwy d:u laifj{ksph ekx.kh dsyh- vijk/k ’kkfcrsdkeh vfHk;ksxi{kkus lgk
lk{khnkjkaph lk{k uksanfoyh- vkjksihus [kksVh dsl dsY;kpk cpko ?ksrysyk vkgs-
3- izLrwr [kVY;kP;k U;k;fu.kZ;kdkeh ek>s fopkjkFkZ iq<hy eqn~ns mifLFkr
gksrkr- R;kojhy ek>s fu"d"kZ dkj.kfeekalslg eh iq<hyizek.ks fnys vkgsr-
v-dz- eqn~ns fu"d"kZ
1- vkjksihus ueqn fno’kh] osGh o fBdk.kh LobPNsus]
fQ;kZnhP;k dacjsyk gkr ykoqu] L=heukl yTtk mRiUu
gksbZy vls d`R; dsys dk;\
udkjkFkhZ-
2- vafre vkns'k dk;\ vkjksihph funksZ”k
eqDrrk dj.;kr
;srs-
dk j .k fe eka lk
4- nks"kkjksi 'kkchrslkBh vfHk;ksx i{kkus lgk lk{khnkj riklys- fQ;kZnh
lk{khnkj dz-1 lk;jk tCCkkj vUlkjh ¼fu-Ø-7½] lk{khnkj dz-2 jkepanz /keZnso lakxksydj
-- 2 of 7 --
3 [kVyk dz- 3069@ihMCY;w@2018 U;k;fu.kZ;
¼fu-Ø-10½] lk{khnkj dz-3 js'ek lqjs'k lk[kjs ¼fu-Ø-12½] lk{khnkj dz-4 'kksHkk ,dukFk
lksudkacGs ¼fu-Ø-13½] riklh vf/kdkjh lk{khnkj dz-5 lat; ek:rh ykM ¼fu-Ø-16½
vkf.k iksyhl vf/kdkjh lk{khnkj dz-6 fiz;kadk rkR;klks ikVhy ¼fu-Ø-17½ ;kaph lk{k
uksanfo.;kr vkyh- vkjksihpk QkS-iz-la dye 313 izek.kspk tckc fu'kk.kh dz-18 oj
uksanfo.;kr vkyk- mHk; cktwapk ;qfDrokn ,sdyk- v’kk izkIr ifjfLFkrhr
vfHkys[kkojhy iqjkO;ko:u ek>s ojhy eqn~n;kaojhy fu”d”kZ iq<hy izek.ks %
eqnns Ø-1 ckcr%&
5- izLrwr [kVY;ke/;s vkjksihus fQ;kZnhP;k dacjsyk gkr ykoqu] L=heukl yTtk
mRiUu gksbZy vls d`R; dsys gh ckc vfHk;ksxi{kkus lcG iqjkO;kfu’kh fu%la’kf;ri.ks
'kkfcr dj.ks vko’;d vkgs- fon~oku ’kkldh; vfHk;ksDrk ;kauh vlk ;qfDrokn
dsyk dh] vkjksihl dBksj 'kklu dj.;kr ;kos ;kmyV] vkjksihps fon~oku fof/kK ;kauh
vlk ;qfDrokn dsyk dh] vfHkys[kkoj vkjksihaps nks"kkjksi 'kkfcr gksrhy brir lcG
iqjkok u vkY;kus vkjksiahph funksZ"k eqDrrk dj.;kar ;koh-
6- lk;jk tCCkkj vUlkjh ¼lk{khnkj dz-1½ fgus frP;k ljriklkr vls
lkafxrys fd] rh vkjksihyk vksG[krs- fnukad 23@04@2018 jksth rh iksn~nkj
'kkGsP;k cle/;s dkekoj vlrkuka] rh cle/kqu eqykauk mrjor gksrh- nksu eqys
vkre/;s jkfgys- rso<;kr vkjksih Eg.kkyk fd] cl leksj ?;k- R;kosGsl vkjksihus
frP;k dacjsyk gkr ykoqu /kDdk fnY;keqGs rh eqykaoj iMyh- nql&;k fno'kh rh
eqykauk cle/kqu mrjor vlrkuka] vkjksihus frP;k dacjsyk gkr ykoyk vkf.k /kDdk
fnyk] R;keqGs rh iMyh- lnj ?kVuk frus lqijok;>j lk;yh fgyk lkafxryh-
frP;klkscr ns[khy vkjksih vlkp okxyk gksrk- uarj frus lnj ?kVusph ekfgrh lqjt
ljkauk lkafxryh- R;kauh lnj ?kVuk ofj"Bkauk lkaxsu vls lkafxrys- frl&;k fno'kh
rh eqykauk cle/;s p<or vlrkuka] vkjksihus frP;k dacjsyk gkr ykoyk vkf.k
R;keqGs frus R;kP;kfo:/n iksyhl Bk.;kr rdzkj nk[ky dsyh-
7- jkepanz /keZnso lakxksydj ¼lk{khnkj dz-2½ gk ?kVukLFkGkojP;k
iapukE;kojhy lk{khnkj vkgs- R;kus R;kP;k ljriklkr vls lkafxrys fd] fnukad
23@04@2018 jksth iobZ iksyhlkauh R;kyk iksn~nkj 'kkGsP;k csleasV ;sFks iapukek
-- 3 of 7 --
4 [kVyk dz- 3069@ihMCY;w@2018 U;k;fu.kZ;
dj.;kdfjrk cksykfoys gksrs- frFks fou;Hkaxkph ?kVuk ?kMyh gksrh- iksyhl vf/kdkjh
fiz;adk ikVhy fgus 'kksHkk dkacGsyk ?kVusckcr fopkjys o frP;kdMqu xkMhpk uacj ?
ksryk- iksyhlkauh iapukek dsyk vkf.k R;kph lgh ?ksryh- myVriklknjE;ku]
vfHk;ksxi{kkP;k dFkukP;k myV dks.krkgh etdqj vfHkys[kkoj vkyk ukgh- R;keqGs
riklknjE;ku] riklh vf/kdkjh ;kauh ?kVukLFkGkoj tkoqu] ?kVukLFkGkpk iapukek dsyk
gksrk- fg ckc fufoZokni.ks fl/n gksrs-
8- js'ek lqjs'k lk[kjs ¼lk{khnkj dz-3½ gh fQ;kZnh lk-dz-1 lk;jk
fgP;klkscr iksn~nkj 'kkGsr dkekoj gksrh- frus frP;k ljriklkr vls lkafxrys fd] rh
fQ;kZnhyk vksG[krs- rh iksn~nkj 'kkGsr cl dsvj Vsdj Eg.kqu dke djhr gksrh-
lk;jkpk rhu osGk fou;Hkax >kyk gksrk Eg.kqu fQ;kZn ns.;kdfjrk rh iobZ iksyhl
Bk.;kr fQ;kZnhlkscr xsyh gksrh-
9- 'kksHkk ,dukFk lksudkacGs ¼lk{khnkj dz-4½ fgus frP;k ljriklkr vls
lkafxrys fd] rh lk;jk vUlkjh vkf.k vkjksihyk vksG[krs- ?kVuk ,d o"kkZiqoh 'kkGsr
nqikjh 12-30 oktrk ?kMyh- vkjksihus frP;k dacjsyk gkr ykoqu] ysdja yodj
iVkiV p<ok vls lkafxrys- uarj lk;jk vkf.k rh cl ?ksoqu xsys- nql&;k osGsl
lnjph ?kVuk >kyh vkf.k lnjph ckc lqjt ljkauk lkafxryh vkf.k uarj frus
lk;jkyk rdzkj ns.;kl lkafxrys- 'kksHkk lksudkacGs fgus ljriklknjE;ku] vfHk;ksx
i{kkP;k dFkukps leFkZu dsys vlys rjhgh] frus ?kVuk izR;{k ikfgyh gksrh vls frps
Eg.k.ks ukgh- R;keqGs frpk rksaMh iqjkok vfHk;ksxi{kkP;k cktqus xzkg; /kjrk ;s.kkj ukgh-
10- riklh vf/kdkjh lat; ykM ¼lk{khnkj dz-5½ ;kuh R;kaP;k ljriklkr
vls lkafxrys fd] ?kVuk fnukad 23@04@2018 jksth ?kMyh vkf.k ,Q-vk;-vkj
fnukad 26@04@2018 jksth efgyk iksyhl fujh{kd fiz;kadk ikVhy ;kauh uksanfoyk
gksrk- ?kVukLFkGkpk iapukek ikVhy ;kauh dsyk gksrk- ofj”BkaP;k vkns'kko:u lnj
xqUg;kpk rikl R;kapsdMs vkyk- riklknjE;ku] R;kauh lk;yh vuar xksLkkoh]
'kksHkk ,dukFk lksudkacGs] lqjt lqHkk”k mRrsdj vkf.k js'ek lqjs'k lkcGs ;k pkj
lk{khnkjkaps tckc uksanfoys- riklknjEkku R;kauh fQ;kZnhyk QkS-iz-la dye 164 izek.ks
tckc uksanfo.;klkBh U;k;ky;kr ikBfoys gksrs- myV riklknjE;ku]R;kus Li"Vi.ks
dcqy dsys vkgs fd] ?kVukLFkGkoj 'kkGsP;k vkokjkr loZ= lh-lh-fVOgh dWEksjs
-- 4 of 7 --
5 [kVyk dz- 3069@ihMCY;w@2018 U;k;fu.kZ;
ykoysys vlqu] fQ;kZnhus lkafxrY;kizek.ks dks.krhgh ?kVuk R;kfno'khP;k QqVste/;s
fnlqu vkyh ukgh-
11- fiz;kadk ikVhy ¼lk{khnkj dz-6½ ;kauh R;kaP;k ljriklkr vls lkafxrys
fd] fnukad 26@04@2018 jksth rh Bk.ks veaynkj Eg.kqu ldkGh 8-00 rs jk=h 8-
00 i;Zar drZO;koj gtj gksrh- fQ;kZnh lk;jk vUlkjh gh iksyhl Bk.;kr vkyh
vkf.k fryk rdzkj nk[ky djko;kph vkgs vls lkafxrys- frus ?kVusph gdhdr
lkafxryh- R;kuh Lor% frpk tckc uksanfoyk- lnj lk{khnkj ;kauh fQ;kZnhpk tckc
uksanfoyk] ;kf'kok; dks.krkgh egRokpk iqjkok vfHkys[kkoj vkyk ukgh-
12- vfHkys[kkojhy miyC/k iqjkO;ko:u vls fnlqu ;srs fd] fQ;kZnh lk;jk
vkf.k lk{khnkj dz-3 o 4 g;k iksn~nkj 'kkGsrhy cle/;s okgd@enruhl Eg.kqu
dkekyk gksR;k- lk{khnkj dz-3 o 4 ;kapk rksaMh iqjkok vfHk;ksx i{kkP;k dFkuk'kh
lqlaxr vlyk rjhgh] rs nksUgh lk{khnkj ?kVusps izR;{kn'kh lk{khnkj ukghr- rlsp
riklh vf/kdkjh ;kauh R;kaP;k myVriklkr Li"Vi.ks ekU; dsys vkgs fd] fQ;kZnhus
lkafxrY;kizek.ks dks.krhgh ?kVuk R;kosGP;k lh-lh-fV-Ogh QqVste/;s fnlqu vkyh
uOgrh-
13- v'kk ifjfLFkrhr fQ;kZnhP;k lkax.;kizek.ks vkjksihus R;kosGh frpk
fou;Hkax dsyk gksrk fdaok ukgh ;kph [kkrjtek dj.;klkBh nksUgh odhykaP;k le{k
vfHkys[kkoj nk[ky vlysyk isuM~kbZOge/khy ^^vkVhZdy v** QqVst U;k;ky;krhy
lax.kdkoj cf?krys- R;kr ,dq.k ikp rs lgk lh-lh-fV-Ogh- dWesjWrhy pyfp= cf?
krys- R;ko:u vls fnlqu ;srs fd] ?kVusP;k fno'kh fQ;kZnhus lkafxrY;kizek.ks
dks.krhgh ?kVuk ?kMyh uOgrh-
14- ;kf'kok; iquZriklknjE;ku] fQ;kZnhus Lor% U;k;ky;kleksj QkS-iz-la
164 izek.ks uksanfoysY;k tckckojhy lgh vksG[k.;kl udkj fnyk- rlsp
myVriklknjE;ku] loZ lk{khnkjkauh iksn~nkj 'kkGsps iz'kklu rlsp /kMd dkexkj
;qfu;ups lnL;kae/khy okn vlY;kdkj.kkauh 'kkGk iz'kklukus toGikl ckoUu
deZpk&;kuka rlsp fQ;kZnhyk dkeko:u dk<qu VkdY;kps ekU; dsys vkgs- v'kk
ifjfLFkrhr] vkjksihus ?ksrysyk cpko fo'oluh; okVrks- fQ;kZnhus lkafxrY;kizek.ks
dks.krhgh ?kVuk ^^vkVhZdy v** ojhy isuM~kbZOg e/khy pyfp=kr fnlr ukgh-
-- 5 of 7 --
6 [kVyk dz- 3069@ihMCY;w@2018 U;k;fu.kZ;
15- vfHk;ksx i{k vkjksihfo:/n vkjksi fl/n dj.;kl vleFkZ Bjyk vkgs-
R;keqGs vfHk;ksxi{kkP;k gdhdrhizek.ks vkjksihus dks.krkgh xqUgk dsyk vls Eg.krk
;s.kkj ukgh- R;keqGs vkjksihus fQ;kZnhP;k dacjsyk gkr ykoqu] L=heukl yTtk mRiUu
gksbZy vls d`R; dsys vls Eg.krk ;s.kkj ukgh- ;k loZ ckchapk fopkj d:u eh eqn~nk
dz- 1 ps mRrj udkjkFkhZ nsr vkgs-
eqnn~k Ø- 2 ckcr
16- ojhy foospukizek.ks vfHk;ksxi{kkus vkjksihfo:/npk nks"kkjksi ’kkfcr
gksbZy brir iqjkok fnyk ulY;kps Li"V >kY;kus vkjksihph funksZ"k eqDrrk dj.ks
vko’;d vkgss- nks"kkjksii= jdkuk dz-10 e/;s dks.kR;kgh eqn~nsekykpk mYys[k
ulY;kus R;kckcr vkns’k ikfjr dj.;kph vko’;drk ukgh- ;k loZ ckchapk fopkj
d:u eh eqn~nk dz-2 dkeh iq<hyizek.ks vkns’k ikfjr djr vkgs-
vkns'k
1- vkjksih jkts'k y{e.k ejkBs ;kph Hkk-n-fo- lafgrk dye 354] 354
¼v½ ¼1½ izek.ksP;k naMuh; vijk/kkrwu Qskstnkjh izfØ;k lafgrsP;k dye
248 ¼1½ vUo;s funskZ"k eqDrrk dj.;kr ;srss-
2- vkjksihph oS;fDrd tkreqpydk ca/ki= o tekurhps ca/ki= folftZr
dj.;kar ;srkr-
3- vkjksihus Qskstnkjh O;ogkj lafgrsP;k dye 437&v vUo;s
jDde :i;s 10]000@& ¼v{kjh :i;s ngk gtkj QDr½ pk oS;fDrd
tkreqpydk ca/ki= n;kok-
4- [kqY;k U;k;ky;kr U;k;fu.kZ; tkghj-
fn- 20@06@2023 ¼fot; fpa- xobZ½
egkuxj naMkf/kdkjh]
66os U;k;ky;] va/ksjh] eqacbZ-
Jqrys[ku fnukad- %& 20@06@2023
izfrys[ku fnukad- %& 20@06@2023
Lok{kjh fnukad- %& 22@06@2023
-- 6 of 7 --
7 [kVyk dz- 3069@ihMCY;w@2018 U;k;fu.kZ;
-- 7 of 7 --