Final Order 1

Order Details: Copy  of Judgment
Pdf Text: 1 C.C.No.2703/PW/2018
Exh.09
MHMM190098822018
IN THE COURT OF JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE FIRST CLASS,
44TH COURT, ANDHERI, MUMBAI.
(PRESIDED OVER BY SUJITKUMAR C. TAYDE)
(Date of Judgment: 12th August, 2024)
Case No.2703/PW/2018
CNR No.MHMM190098822018
FIR/Crime No.138/2018
Police Station: Versova, Mumbai.
COMPLAINANT The State of Maharashtra
through the Station Incharge of
Versova Police Station, Mumbai.
REPRESENTED BY Learned A.P.P. Smt. Seema Mokal
ACCUSED 1] Ravindra Sakharam Patil,
Age – 52 Yrs., Occ – Labour,
2] Mukesh Sakhram Patil,
Age – 40 Yrs., Occ. Labour,
3] Madhuri Mukesh Patil,
Age – 32 Yrs., Occu. Labour,
4] Minakshi Ravindra Patil,
Age – 44 Yrs., Occu. Labour,
(Sujitkumar C. Tayde),
JMFC,44th Court, Andheri, Mumbai.
-- 1 of 10 --
2 C.C.No.2703/PW/2018
Exh.09
Accused No.1 to 4 are
R/o. Patil House, Shiv Galli,
D'Souza Wadi, Versova,
Andheri (W), Mumbai.
5] Naresh @ Narendra Janardan
Bhanji,
Age – 49 Yrs., Occu. Labour,
R/o. Bhanji House, Shiv Galli,
Versova, Andheri (W),
Mumbai.
REPRESENTED BY Learned Advocate Shri Vikaschandra
Dubey
Part 'B'
(Para 44(ii) off Chapter VI of Criminal Manual)
Date of offence 29/03/2018
Date of FIR 30/03/2018
Date of chargesheet 04/10/2018
Date of framing of charges 01/10/2018
Date of commencement of
evidence
21/06/2024
Date of which judgment is
reserved
12/08/2024
Date of the judgment 12/08/2024
(Sujitkumar C. Tayde),
JMFC,44th Court, Andheri, Mumbai.
-- 2 of 10 --
3 C.C.No.2703/PW/2018
Exh.09
Accused Details
Rank of
the
accused
Name of
Accused
Date of
Arrest
Date of
Release on
Bail
Offences
charged
with
Whether
acquitted or
convicted
Sentence
imposed
Period of
Detention
Undergone
during
Trial for
purpose of
Section
428 of
Cr.P.C.
1 Ravindra
Sakhara
m Patil
30/03/2
018
30/03/20
18
141, 142,
143, 147,
148, 323,
324, 504,
506 r/w.
149 of the
Indian
Penal
Code.
Acquitted No No
2 Mukesh
Sakhram
Patil
do do do do No No
3 Madhuri
Mukesh
Patil
do do do do do do
4 Minakshi
Ravindra
Patil
do do do do do do
5 Naresh
@
Narendr
a
Janarda
n Bhanji
20/06/2
018
20/06/20
18
do do do do
(Sujitkumar C. Tayde),
JMFC,44th Court, Andheri, Mumbai.
-- 3 of 10 --
4 C.C.No.2703/PW/2018
Exh.09
Part 'C'
LIST OF PROSECUTION/DEFENCE/COURT WITNESSES
A. Prosecution:
RANK NAME NATURE OF EVIDENCE (EYE
WITNESS, POLICE WITNESS,
EXPERT WITNESS, MEDICAL
WITNESS, PANCH WITNESS,
OTHER WITNESS)
PW 1 Informant – Rajashree
Krushna Bhoba
Exh.No.06
PW 2 Witness – Siddhart Krishna
Bhoba
Exh.No.08
B. Defence witnesses, if any.
RANK NAME NATURE OF EVIDENCE (EYE
WITNESS, POLICE WITNESS,
EXPERT WITNESS, MEDICAL
WITNESS, PANCH WITNESS,
OTHER WITNESS)
Nil Nil Nil
C. Court witnesses, if any.
RANK NAME NATURE OF EVIDENCE (EYE
WITNESS, POLICE WITNESS,
EXPERT WITNESS, MEDICAL
WITNESS, PANCH WITNESS,
OTHER WITNESS)
Nil Nil Nil
LIST OF PROSECUTION EXHIBITS
Sr.
No.
Nature of Exhibit Exhibit No.
1 FIR 07
(Sujitkumar C. Tayde),
JMFC,44th Court, Andheri, Mumbai.
-- 4 of 10 --
5 C.C.No.2703/PW/2018
Exh.09
U;k ; fu .kZ ;
¼fnukad 12@08@2024 jksth ikfjr½
vkjksih daaz 1 rs 5 Hkkjrh; naM lafgrsps dye 141] 142]
143] 147] 148] 323] 324] 504] 506 lg 149 vUo;s e/;s uewn
vlysY;k f'k{kkik= xqUg;kP;k laijh{ksyk lkeksjs tkr vkgsr-
vfHk;ksx i{kkps dFku FkksMD;kr [kkyhyizek.ks %
2- fnukad 29@03@2018 jksth 22-30 oktsP;k lqekjkl Hkksck
gkmlP;k leksj xYyhe/;s] f'koxYyh] va/ksjh if'pe] eqacbZ] ;sFks vkjksih
daz-3 ek/kqjh ikVhy fgP;k eqykl fQ;kZnh jktJh d`”.kk Hkksck fgus pkirhpk
rqdMk [kk.;klkBh fnyk ;kdkj.kko#u vkjksih ek/kqjhus fQ;kZnh o frP;k
eqyhl f'kohxkG d#u gkrkus ekjgk.k dsyh o c?kqu ?ks.;kph /kedh fnyh-
rlsp fQ;kZnhus vkjksihl frP;k eqyhl dk ekjrk v'kh fopkj.kk dsyh
vlrk loZ vkjksihauh csdk;ns'khj teko teoqu fQ;kZnhP;k eqykl ckacqus
ekjgk.k d#u R;kP;k MksD;kl nq[kkir dsyh- rlsp fQ;kZnhph cfg.k
Hkkjrh ikVhy fg R;kaP;k enrhlkBh vkyh vlrk vkjksih ek/kqjh fgus frP;k
mtO;k gkrkP;k djaxGhyk pkok ?ksoqu nq[kkir dsyh- ifj.kkeh fQ;kZnhus
ojhy vkjksihafo#/n iksyhl LVs'ku olksZok ;sFks rdzkj nk[ky dsyh- ;k
rdzkjhP;k vuq”kaxkus vkjksihfo#n~/k Hkk- na- fo- dye 141] 142] 143]
147] 148] 323] 324] 504] 506 lg 149 vUo;s xqUgk dza-
138@2018 uksanfo.;kr vkyk-
3- ;k xqUg;kps riklh vf/kdkjh Jh-,- ih- tk/ko
¼lgk¸;d&iksyhl fujh{kd½ ;kauh lnjP;k xqUg;kP;k riklknjE;ku
lk{khnkjakps tckc uksanfoys- ?kVukLFkG iapukek r;kj dsyk- vkjksihauk vVd
(Sujitkumar C. Tayde),
JMFC,44th Court, Andheri, Mumbai.
-- 5 of 10 --
6 C.C.No.2703/PW/2018
Exh.09
dsyh- R;kauk lnj xqUg;kr vkjksihafo#n~/k xqUgkn'kZd iqjkok feGwu vkY;kus
vkjksihafo#n~/k U;k;ky;kr nks”kkjksi i= nk[ky dsys-
4- vkjksihafo#n~/k Hkk-na-fo- dye 141] 142] 143] 147]
148] 323] 324] 504] 506 lg 149 vUo;s nks"kkjksi Bsoyk-
vkjksihauk lnj nks”kkjksi okpwu o letkowu lkafxryk- vkjksihauh xqUgk dcqy
dsyk ukgh o izdj.k iq<s pkyfo.;kph ekx.kh dsyh-
5- vkjksihafo#/n xqUgkn'kZd iqjkok u vkY;kus R;kaps QkStnkjh
izfdz;k lafgrk dye 313 ps vUo;ss fuosnu uksnafo.;kr vkys ukgh-
6- izzLrqr [kVyk fudkyh dk<.;klkBh [kkyhy eqn~ns ekÖ;k
fopkjkFkZ mifLFkr >kys- R;kojhy fu"d"kZ eh iq<hyizek.ks uksanfor vkgs %
dz- eqn~ns fu”d”kZ
1 vfHk;ksx i{k gs fln~/k djrks dk; dh]
fnukad 29@03@2018 jksth lqekjs 22-
30 oktrkps lqekjkl Hkksck gkmlP;k leksj
xYyhe/;s] f'koxYyh] va/ksjh if'pe]
eqacbZ loZ vkjksihauh gsrqiqoZd LobZPNsus
XkSjdk;n;kph eaMGh r;kj d#u fQ;kZnhyk
nq[kkir dsyh R;k vuq”kaxkus Hkkjrh; naM
lafgrsP;k dye 141] 142] 143] 147
vkf.k 148 uqlkjPkk xqUgk dsyk\
udkjkFkhZ
2 vfHk;ksx i{k gs fln~/k djrks dk; dh]
ojhy osGh] fno'kh o fBdk.kh loZ
vkjksihauh gsrqiqoZd LobZPNsus XkSjdk;n;kph
udkjkFkhZ
(Sujitkumar C. Tayde),
JMFC,44th Court, Andheri, Mumbai.
-- 6 of 10 --
7 C.C.No.2703/PW/2018
Exh.09
eaMGh r;kj d#u fQ;kZnhyk ekjgk.k
d#u nq[kkir dsyh vkf.k R;k vuq”kaxkus
Hkkjrh; naM lafgrsP;k dye 323 lg
149 uqlkjPkk xqUgk dsyk\
3 vfHk;ksx i{k gs fln~/k djrks dk; dh]
ojhy osGh] fno'kh o fBdk.kh loZ
vkjksihauh gsrqiqoZd LobZPNsus XkSjdk;n;kph
eaMGh r;kj d#u fQ;kZnhyk ckacqus
ekjgk.k d#u xaHkhj t[keh dsys vkf.k
R;k vuq”kaxkus Hkkjrh; naM lafgrsP;k dye
324 lg 149 uqlkjPkk xqUgk dsyk\
udkjkFkhZ
4 vfHk;ksx i{k gs fln~/k djrks dk; dh]
ojhy osGh] fno'kh o fBdk.kh loZ
vkjksihauh gsrqiqoZd LobZPNsus XkSjdk;n;kph
eaMGh r;kj d#u fQ;kZnhyk viekukLin
f'kohxkG dsyh o fryk jkx ;sbZy vkf.k
frP;kdMqu lkoZtfud 'kkarrspk Hkax gksbZy
v'kkizdkjps d`R; dsys vkf.k R;k
vuq”kaxkus Hkkjrh; naM lafgrsP;k dye
504 lg 149 uqlkjPkk xqUgk dsyk\
udkjkFkhZ
5 vfHk;ksx i{k gs fln~/k djrks dk; dh]
ojhy osGh] fno'kh o fBdk.kh loZ
vkjksihauh gsrqiqoZd LobZPNsus XkSjdk;n;kph
eaMGh r;kj d#u fQ;kZnhyk ftos Bkj
ekj.;kph /kedh fnyh vkf.k R;k vuq”kaxkus
Hkkjrh; naM lafgrsP;k dye 506 lg
149 uqlkjPkk xqUgk dsyk\
udkjkFkhZ
(Sujitkumar C. Tayde),
JMFC,44th Court, Andheri, Mumbai.
-- 7 of 10 --
8 C.C.No.2703/PW/2018
Exh.09
6 dk; vkns'k \ vafre vkns'kkuqlkj
loZ vkjksihaph funksZ”k
eqDrrk dj.;kr ;sr
vkgs-
dkj.kfeekalk
eqn~ns dz- 1 rs 5 P;k vuq"kaxkus%
7- ojhy loZ iz'u ijLijka'kh fuxMhr vlwu lkekbZd iqjkok
miyC/k vlY;keqGs ;k loZ iz'ukauk ,df=rfjR;k mRrj ns.ks ;ksX; Bjrs-
8- mHk;i{kkpk ;qDrhokn ,sdyk-
9- vkjksihfo#n~/kpk nks”kkjksi fln~/k dj.;klkBh vfHk;ksx i{kk}kjs
[kkyhy lk{khnkjkauk rikl.;kr vkys-
vuqdzeka
d
lk{khnkjkps uko fu'kk.kh dz-
1 fQ;kZnh & jktJh d`”.kk Hkksck 6
2 lk{khnkj & fl/nkFkZ d`”.kk Hkksck 8
10- izLrqr izdj.k xsY;k lgk o”kkZiklwu izyafcr vkgs- ;k fn?kZ
dkyko/khr vfHk;ksx i{kkyk iqjs'kh la/kh nsowulqn~/kk ojhy lk{khnkjka
O;frfjDr dks.kR;kgh lk{khnkjkauk ;k izdj.kkr rikl.;kr vkys ukgh- v'kk
ifjfLFkrhe/;s miyC/k iqjkO;kuqlkj fn?kZdkyhu izyafcr izdj.k vfoyacfjR;k
fudkyh dk<.ks vko';d Bjrs-
(Sujitkumar C. Tayde),
JMFC,44th Court, Andheri, Mumbai.
-- 8 of 10 --
9 C.C.No.2703/PW/2018
Exh.09
11- fQ;kZnh & jktJh d`”.kk Hkksck o lk{knkj fl/nkFkZ d`”.kk
Hkksck ;kauh R;kaP;k lk{k iqjkO;ke/;s vls dFku dsys dh vkjksih o
R;kaP;ke/;s eqykao#u HkkMa.k >kys gksrs o R;k HkkaM.kkr rs [kkyh iMys o
R;kauk nq[kkir >kyh o fQ;kZnhuss vkjksihafo#/n iksyhl LVs'kyk rdzkj
nk[ky dsyh- fQ;kZnhus nks”kkjksi 'kkfcrhdfjrk vfHk;ksxi{kkl enr dsyh
ukgh- ifj.kkeh ljdkjh ofdykauh fQ;kZnh o lk{knkjkyk fQrqj ?kksf”kr
d#u R;kaph myV rikl.kh ?ksryh- ijarq ;k egRokP;k lk{knkjkauh
vkjksihafo#/n dks.krkgh iqjkok uksnafoyk ukgh- egRokph ckc Eg.kts
fQ;kZnh o lk{knkjkus 'kiFksoj vls dFku dsys dh vkjksih o R;kPa;ke/;s
U;k;ky;kckgsj rMtksM >kyh vkgs vkf.k R;kauk gk [kVyk iq<s pkyok;pk
ukgh-
12- izLrqr izdj.kkr vfHk;ksx i{kkus lacaf/kr riklh vf/kdkjh o
fQ;kZnhps oS|dh; ifj{k.k dj.kkjs lacaf/kr oS|dh; vf/kdkjh ;kauklqn~/kk ;k
izdj.kkr rikl.;kr vkys ukgh- ;k egRokP;k iqjkO;k vHkkoh oj
mYysf[kr nks”kkjksi uk'kkfcr Bjrks- lnj ckacq fQ;kZnhyk o lk{knkjkyk
R;kaP;k iqjkO;knjE;ku iznf'kZr dj.;kr vkyk ukgh- R;keqGs lnj ckacq
vkjksiahauh fQ;kZnhyk ekj.;klkBh mi;ksxkr vk.kyk gh ckc fl/n gksr ukgh-
laf{kIri.ks lcG iqjkO;k vHkkoh loZ vkjksih funkZs”k lqVdk gks.;kl ik=
Bjrkr- ifj.kkeh iz'u dz-1 o 5 ps fu”d”kZ udkjkFkhZ uksano.;kr ;sr vkgsr-
;k vuq”kaxkus [kkyhy vkns'k ikfjr dj.;kr ;sr vkgs-
vkns'k
1 vkjksih daz- 1 jfoanz l[kkjke ikVhy] vkjksih daz-2 eqds'k
l[kkjke ikVhy] vkjksih daz-3 ek/kqjh eqds'k ikVhy] vkjksih
(Sujitkumar C. Tayde),
JMFC,44th Court, Andheri, Mumbai.
-- 9 of 10 --
10 C.C.No.2703/PW/2018
Exh.09
daz-4 feuk{kh jfoanz ikVhy o vkjksih daz-5 ujs'k mQZ ujsnaz
tuknZu Hkkuth ;kaph Hkk- n- fo- dye 141] 142] 143]
147] 148] 323] 324] 504] 506 lg 149 vUo;s
naMuh; vijk/kkrwu QkStnkjh izfdz;k lafgrsP;k dye 248
¼1½ vUo;s funksZ"k eqDrrk dj.;kr ;srs-
2 vkjksih daz 1 rs 5 ;kapk oS;fDrd tkreqpydk ca/ki= o
tekurhps ca/ki= jn~n dj.;kar ;kos-
3 vkjksih daz 1 rs 5 ;kauh QkStnkjh O;ogkj lafgrsP;k dye
437&v vUo;ss izR;sdh jDde #i;s 5]000@& v{kjh #i;s
ikp gtkj QDr pk oS;fDrd tkreqpydk ca/ki= n;kok-
4 [kqY;k U;k;ky;kr U;k;fu.kZ; tkghj-
¼lqftrdqekj pa- rk;Ms½
U;k; naMkf/kdkjh izFke oxZ]
fn- 12@08@2024 44 os U;k;ky;] va/ksjh] eaqcbZ-
(Sujitkumar C. Tayde),
JMFC,44th Court, Andheri, Mumbai.
-- 10 of 10 --