Final Order 1

Order Details: Copy  of Judgment
Pdf Text: -- 1 --
nk[ky rkjh[k % 05-07-2018
uksan.kh rkjh[k % 05-07-2018
fudky rkjh[k % 20-06-2019
dkyko/kh % 00 o"ksZ 11 efgus 15 fnol
fu'kk.kh Øekad %&
egkuxj naMkf/kdkjh] 44 os U;k;ky;] va/ksjh] eqacbZ
;kaps U;k;ky;kr
¼fiBklu vf/kdkjh % la- ck- fMxs½
U;k-iz-Øekad 1796@ih- MCY;w-@2018
lh-,u~-vkj~-ua- ,e~-,p~-,e~-,e~-19 007117 2018
egkjk”Vª 'kklu
n~okjk ¼ olksZok iksyhl Bk.ks] va/ksjh] eqacbZ-
xqUgk Øekad 83@2017½ --- vfHk;kstu i{k
fo#/n
1- lyhe lqyrkuvyh fojkuh
o; %& 32 o”ksZ O;olk; %& dkgh ukgh
--- vkjksih
2- vkeuk lqyrkuvyh fojkuh
o; %& 57 o”ksZ O;olk; %& dkgh ukgh
nks?ks jk- %& ,p~-ch-@17] vkxk[kku ckx]
;kjhjksM] olksZok] va/ksjh ¼i½] eqacbZ-
nks"kkjksi % Hkkjrh; naM fo/kku dye 498¼v½]
406 lg 34 vUo;s-
---------
vfHk;kstui{kkrQsZ ofdy & ljdkjh vfHk;ksDrk Jh- xkslkoh
vkjksihrQsZ ofdy & Jh- jkds'k ekyi
--2@&
-- 1 of 8 --
-- 2 --
U;k ; fu .kZ ;
¼?kksf"kr fnukad %20-06-2019½
vkjksih fo#n~/k Hkkjrh; naM fo/kku ps dye 498¼v½] 406
lg 34 vUo;s vfHk;ksx pkyfo.;kr ;sr vlwu izdj.kkph FkksMD;kr
gdhdr [kkyhyizek.ks vkgs-
2- ;krhy fQ;kZnh ukes lkS- 'kkghu lyhe fojkuh o vkjksih
lyhe lqyrkuvyh fojkuh ;kapk fookg fnukad 31-03-2016 jksth LiksVlZ
Dyc dkWEYisDl va/ksjh] eqacbZ ;sFks eqfLye fjrhfjoktkizek.ks ikj iMyk-
yXuke/;s fQ;kZnh ;kauk R;kaps vkbZ&oMhykauh lksU;kps nkfxus] usdysl fjax
o iSls fnys gksrs- yXukuarj fQ;kZnh g;k R;kaps irhlkscr vkxk[kku
ckx] ,p-ch-17] ;kjhjksM] olksZok] va/ksjh if'pe ;sFks jkgko;kl xsY;k-
R;kaps ?kjkr lyhe o R;kaph vkbZ Jherh vkeuk vls fQ;kZnh lkscr jkgr
gksrs- yXukuarj ,d efgU;ki;Zar loZ fBd pkyys gksrs- ijarw R;kaurj
fQ;kZnh ;kaps irh@vkjksih dzekad 1 gs fQ;kZnhl] lklqyk uhV c?kr ukgh]
frP;kdMs y{k nsr ukgh] fryk osGsoj tso.k nsr ukgh vls Eg.kwu HkkaM.k
djhr vlr- fQ;kZnh g;k R;kaps uohu yXu vlY;keqGs ;k loZ xks”VhadMs
nqyZ{k djhr vlr o R;kaps irh ts dkgh cksyrhy rs lgu djhr vlr-
fQ;kZnhauh lu 2016 e/s; R;kaps yXukps jthLVªs'ku dj.;kdjhrk lkafxrys
vlrk R;kaP;k irhus@vkjksih dzekad 1 ;kus fQ;knhl f'kohxkG d#u
gkrkus ekjgk.k dsyh gksrh- R;kuarj fQ;kZnh ;kaps irh o lklw@ vkjksih
dzekad 1 o 2 ;kauh fQ;kZnhl frP;k ekgs#u vtqu dkgh lkeku vk.kys
ukgh rj fQ;kZnh ;kauk dk;eps ekgsjh jkgkos ykxsy vls lkafxrys-
3- R;kuarj jetku miokl vlrkuk fQ;kZnhph lklw@ vkjksih
--3@&
-- 2 of 8 --
-- 3 --
dzekad 2 fQ;kZnhP;k irhl@vkjksih dzekad 1 ;kal lkaxr vlr dh R;kus
fQ;kZnhyk lksMwu n;kos o R;kaP;k tkrhe/khy nql&;k eqyhlkscr yXu
djkos- R;kuarj fQ;kZnhps irhus R;k ?kjh ulrkuk R;kph eS=h.k >ksgjk fgpk
ok<fnol lktjk dsyk o R;kckcr fQ;kZnhus fopkj.kk dsyh vlrk R;kus
fryk f'kohxkG dsyh- fQ;kZnhps irhl uohu O;olk; djko;kpk vlY;kus
R;kus fQ;kZnhdMs nkfxus cWadsr xgk.k Bso.;klkBh ekfxrys vlrk] fQ;kZnhus
R;kl udkj fnY;kus vkjksih dzekad 1 ;kauh fryk ekjgk.k dsyh o
fQ;kZnhl frP;k oMhykadMwu O;olk; pkyq dj.;klkBh iSls
vk.k.;klkBh /kedkoq ykxys- fQ;kZnhps eksBs fnj lqyseku fQ;kZnhps lklqyk
?kjh ?ksoqu xsys vlrk] rqÖ;keqGs vkbZ ?kj lksMwu xsyh o rq fryk ?ksoqu ;s
vls Eg.kwu R;kaps irh@vkjksih dzekad 1 tcjnLrh d# ykxys o HkkaM.k
dsys- lnjosGh fQ;kZnh ;kaps lklqus@vkjksih dzekad 2 ;kauh fQ;kZnhP;k
vkbZyk Qksu d#u fQ;kZnh ;kauk R;kaps ?kjh ?ksoqu tk.;kl lkafxrys- o R;k
fnolkiklwu fQ;kZnh g;k R;kaP;k vkbZps ?kjh jkgr vkgsr-
4- fnukad 05@03@2017 jksth fQ;kZnhps irh@vkjksih dzekad 1
;kauh fQ;kZnhl jljkt gkWVsy] foysikysZ] eqacbZ ;sFks cksykoys o R;kyk ?
kVLQksV ikfgts vls lkafxrys- R;koj fQ;kZnhus R;kal ?kVLQksV ns.kkj ukgh
vls lkafxrys vlrk vkjksih dzaekd 1 us fryk c?kqu ?ks.;kph /kedh fnyh-
lnjckcr fQ;kZnhus fM-,u~-uxj iksfyl Bk.ks ;sFks vn[kyik= rdzkj dzekad
943@2017 vUo;s uksan ?ks.;kr vkyh vkgs- R;keqGs fQ;kZnh ;kauh R;kaps
yXu >kysiklqu R;kaps irh o lklq ;kauh osGksosGh fdjdksG dkj.kkao#u
f'kohxkG d#u gkrkus ekjgk.k d#u c?kqu ?ks.;kph /kedh fnyh- rlsp
fQ;kZnh ;kapk ekulhd o 'kkfjjhd NG dsyk- R;keqGs fnukad 17-03-
2017 jksth fQ;kZnhus iksyhl Bk.ks olksZok ;sFks vkjksihfo#/n fQ;kZn
--4@&
-- 3 of 8 --
-- 4 --
fu'kk.kh dz-06 fnyh-
5- iksyhl Bk.ks vaeynkj ;kauh fQ;kZnuqlkj xqUgk dzekad
83@2017 Hkkjrh; naM fo/kkups dye 498¼v½] 406 lg 34 vUo;s
xqUgk nk[ky dsyk o izdj.k lgk- iksyhl fujh{kd Jh- ekuflax ikVhy
;kauk rikldkeh lqiwnZ dj.;kr vkys-
6- rikl vf/kdk&;kauh ?kVukLFkGkyk HksV nsowu ?kVukLFkGkpk
iapukek dsyk] lk{khnkjkaph rikl fVIi.kh ?ksryh o riklkvarh vkjksihfo#/n
fnukad 05-07-2018 jksth Hkkjrh; naM fo/kkups dye 498¼v½] 406
lg 34 uqlkj nks”kkjksii= lknj dsys-
7- QkStnkjh izfdz;k lafgrsP;k dye 207 ph iwrZrk dj.;kr
vkyh- vkjksihyk nks”k fu'kk.kh dz02 Hkkjrh; naM fo/kku ps dye
498¼v½] 406 lg 34 e/khy etdwj okpwu o letkowu lkafxryk
vlrk vkjksihus vkjksi ukdkjys- R;kckcr vkjksihpk Lora= tckc fu'kk.kh
dz03 vUo;s uksanfo.;kr vkyk-
8- vfHk;kstu i{kkus [kcjh lk{khnkj dz-1 Jherh 'kkghu lyhe
fojkuh] fQ;kZnh ;kaph fu'kk.kh dz-05 vUo;s lk{k uksanfoyh- vkjksihfo#n~/k
iqjkok miyC/k ulY;kus QkStnkjh izfdz;k lafgrsP;k dye 313 ¼1½ ¼c½
uqlkj vkjksihpk tckc uksanfo.;kr vkyk ukgh- vkjksihus 'kiFksoj lk{k
fnyh ukgh-
9- miyC/k ys[kh o rksaMh iqjkO;kP;k fopkjkvarh [kkyhy eqn~ns
fuekZ.k >kys- R;kojhy fu”d”kZ iq<hyizek.ks ns.;kr ;sr vkgs-
--5@&
-- 4 of 8 --
-- 5 --
v-dz- okniz'u fu”d”kZ
1- lu 2016 rs fnukad 17@03@017 ;k
dkyko/khr] ,p~-ch-17] vkxk[kku ckx]
;kjhjksM] olkZsok] va/ksjh ¼i½] eqacbZ ;k
fBdk.kh vkjksih dz- 1 o 2 ;kauh
laxuerkus o gsrwiqjLdj [kcjh ;kauh yXukr
gqaMk o lksU;kps nkfxus deh vk.kys Eg.kwu
R;kaPkk 'kkjhjhd o ekufld NG dsY;kph
ckc vfHk;kstu i{k fln~/k djrs dk;\
udkjkFkhZ
2- mijksDr LFkGh] dkGh vkjksih dz-1 o 2
;kauh laxuerkus o gsrwiqjLdj [kcjh ;kaP;k
ekydhps L=h/ku o brj oLrq Lor%P;k
Qk;n;klkBh okijY;kph ckc vfHk;kstu
i{k fln~/k djrs dk;\ udkjkFkhZ
3- vafre vkns'k dk; \ vkjksihyk funksZ'k eqDr
dkj.kehekalk
eqn~ns dz- 1 rs 3 ckcr %
10- [kcjh lk{khnkj Jherh- 'kkghu lyhe fojkuh ;kauh lk{khr
lkafxrys dh] vkjksih dzekad 1 gs R;kaps irh vkgsr o vkjksih dzekad 2
g;k R;kaP;k lklq vkgsr- R;kapk fookg fnukad 31 ekpZ 2016 jksth
eqfLye /kekZizek.ks ikj iMyk- yXukuarj R;k vkjksihalkscr eqqacbZ ;sFks ,d=
dqVaqckr jkgw ykxY;k- R;kauh iq<s lk{khr lkafxrys dh] R;kauh fQ;kZn
fu'kk.kh dz-06 fnyh gksrh- R;koj R;kaph Lok{kjh vkgs- R;kauh iq<s lk{khr
lkafxrys dh] lnjP;k fQ;kZne/khy etdwj R;kauk vkBor ukgh- R;kauh iq<s
lk{khr lkafxrys dh] R;kapk o vkjksihapk U;k;ky;kP;k ckgsj lesV >kyk
vkgs o R;kauk vkjksihafo#/n lk{k n;ko;kph ukgh o vkjksihauk funksZ”k eqDr
--6@&
-- 5 of 8 --
-- 6 --
dj.;kl R;kaph dkghgh gjdr ukgh-
11- vfHk;kstu i{kkus R;kauk mRrj lwpd iz'u fopkjys vlrk
R;kauh dcqy dsys dh] R;kauk vkjksihauh #i;s 7-5 yk[kkpk fMekaM Mªk¶V
fnyk vkgs- R;kauh iq<s lkafxrys dh] R;kauh iqjlhl nk[ky dsyh vlwu
R;kauk vkjksihafo#/n [kVyk pkyok;pk ukgh- R;keqGs vfHk;kstu i{kkpk
iqjkok can dj.;kr vkyk-
12- vfHk;kstu i{kkus o vkjksihP;k ofdykauh ;qDrhokn dsyk dh]
[kVY;kpk fudky xq.koRrsoj ns.;kr ;kok-
13- Hkkjrh; naM fo/kku ps dye 498¼d½ pk nks”k fl/n
dj.;kdjhrk vfHk;kstu i{kkus [kkyhy ckch fl/n dj.ks vko';d gksrs-
1- vkjksih vU;k;xzLFk O;Drhpk irh vlyk ikfgts-
2- vkjksihus iS'kkdjhrk vU;k;xzLFk O;Drhpk
'kkjhjhd o ekufld NG dsysyk vlyk ikfgts-
3- vkjksihP;k NGkeqGs vU;k;xzLFk O;DrhP;k
ftforkl /kksdk fuekZ.k >kyk vlyk ikfgts-
14- mijksDr iqjkO;kP;k voyksduko#u Li”V gksrs dh] [kcjh
lk{khnkj Jherh- 'kkghu lyhe fojkuh ;kauh vkjksiha fo#n~/k lk{k fnysyh
ukgh- R;kauh lk{khr lkafxrys dh]R;kapk fookg fnukad 31 ekpZ 2016 jksth
eqfLye /kekZizek.ks ikj iMyk- yXukuarj R;k vkjksihalkscr eqqacbZ ;sFks ,d=
dqVaqckr jkgw ykxY;k- R;kauh iq<s lk{khr lkafxrys dh] R;kauh fQ;kZn
fu'kk.kh dz-06 fnyh gksrh- R;koj R;kaph Lok{kjh vkgs- R;kauh iq<s lk{khr
--7@&
-- 6 of 8 --
-- 7 --
lkafxrys dh] lnjP;k fQ;kZne/khy etdwj R;kauk vkBor ukgh- R;kauh iq<s
lk{khr lkafxrys dh] R;kapk o vkjksihapk U;k;ky;kP;k ckgsj lesV >kyk
vkgs o R;kauk vkjksihafo#/n lk{k n;ko;kph ukgh o vkjksihauk funksZ”k eqDr
dj.;kl R;kaph dkghgh gjdr ukgh- vfHk;kstu i{kkus R;kauk mRrj lwpd
iz'u fopkjys vlrk R;kauh lkafxrys dh] R;kauk vkjksihauh #i;s 7-5
yk[kkpk fMekaM Mªk¶V fnyk vkgs- R;kauh iq<s lkafxrys dh] R;kauh iqjlhl
nk[ky dsyh vlwu R;kauk vkjksihafo#/n [kVyk pkyok;pk ukgh- Lor%
[kcjhusp iqjlhl@le>ksrk nk[ky d:u tknk rksaMh iqjkok ns.ks ukgh o
lk{khnkj rikl.ks ukgh vls lkafxrys- R;keqGs vfHk;kstu i{kkus brj
lk{khnkj riklysys ukgh- vfHkys[kkojhy brj dkxni=s 'kkfcr gksow 'kdys
ukghr R;keqGs vkjksih dz- 1 o 2 ;kaP;k fo:/n iqjs'kh lk{k vfHkys[kkoj
miyC/k ukgh- R;keqGs Hkkjrh; iqjkok vf/kfu;e ps dye 3 vUo;s
vkjksihauh laxuerkus o gsrwiqjLdj [kcjh ;kapk 'kkjhjhd o ekufld NG
dsY;kps] [kcjh ;kaP;k ekydhps L=h/ku o brj oLrqapk vkjksihauh Lor%P;k
Qk;n;klkBh okij dsY;kps rlsp R;kapk vU;k;kus fo'okl?kkr d#u
Qlo.kwd dsY;kph ckc vfHk;kstu i{k fln~/k dj.;kl vi;'kh >kys-
lcc eqn~ns dz-01 rs 03 oj udkjkRed fu”d”kZ uksano.;kr ;sr vkgs o
eqn~nk dz-4 oj [kkyhyizek.ks vafre vkns'k ikjhr dj.;kr ;sr vkgs-
vafre vkns'k
1- vkjksih dz-1½ lyhu lqyrkuvyh fojkuh] 2½- Jherh
vkeuk lqyrkuvyh fojkuh ;kaph QkStnkjh izfdz;k
lafgrsP;k dye 248¼1½ vUo;s Hkkjrh; naM fo/kku ps
dye 498 ¼v½ 406 lg 34 P;k vfHk;ksxkrwu funksZ”k
eqDrrk dj.;kr ;srs-
--8@&
-- 7 of 8 --
-- 8 --
2- vkjksihauh QkStnkjh izfdz;k lafgrsP;k dye 437¼v½
uqlkj #i;s 5]000@& izR;sdh ps ca/ki= o tkehu lknj
djkos- tkehu ulY;kl l/;kpk tkehu lgk efgU;kadfjrk
oS/k jkghy-
U;k;fu.kZ; [kqY;k U;k;ky;kr lax.kdkoj lax.khd`r d#u ?kksf”kr
dj.;kr vkys-
lgh@&
¼la- ck- fMxs½
egkuxj U;k; naMkf/kdkjh
fnukad % 20-06-2019 44os U;k;ky;] va/ksjh] eqacbZ
fofugk-
--@&
-- 8 of 8 --