Final Order 1

Order Details: Copy  of Judgment
Pdf Text: 1 C.C.No.786/PW/2019
Exh.
MHMM190032942019
IN THE COURT OF JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE FIRST CLASS,
44TH COURT, ANDHERI, MUMBAI.
(PRESIDED OVER BY SUJITKUMAR C. TAYDE)
(Date of Judgment: 13th August, 2024)
Case No.786/PW/2019
CNR No.MHMM190032942019
FIR/Crime No.321/2017
Police Station: Versova, Mumbai.
COMPLAINANT The State of Maharashtra
through the Station Incharge of
Versova Police Station, Mumbai.
REPRESENTED BY Learned A.P.P. Smt. Seema Mokal
ACCUSED 1] Yogesh Balasaheb Shivekar,
Age – 32 Yrs., Occu. Business,
2] Dinesh Balasaheb Shivekar,
Age – 27 Yrs., Occu. Nil,
3] Santosh @ Vipul Ramashankar
Singh
Age – 32 Yrs., Occu. Nil,
All Accused R/o. Sagar Kutir Sangh,
Sat Bangala, Andheri (W),
Mumbai.
REPRESENTED BY Learned Advocate Shri D.D.Kerkar
(lqftrdqekj pa- rk;Ms),
U;k; naMkf/kdkjh izFke oxZ]
44os U;k;ky;] va/ksjh] eaqcbZ-
-- 1 of 11 --
2 C.C.No.786/PW/2019
Exh.
Part 'B'
(Para 44(ii) off Chapter VI of Criminal Manual)
Date of offence 09/09/2017
Date of FIR 10/09/2017
Date of chargesheet 27/02/2019
Date of framing of charges 06/03/2021
Date of commencement of
evidence
25/10/2021
Date of which judgment is
reserved
13/08/2024
Date of the judgment 13/08/2024
Accused Details
Rank of
the
accused
Name of
Accused
Date of
Arrest
Date of
Release on
Bail
Offences
charged
with
Whether
acquitted or
convicted
Sentence
imposed
Period of
Detention
Undergone
during
Trial for
purpose of
Section
428 of
Cr.P.C.
1 Yogesh
Balasahe
b
Shivekar
11/09/20
17
11/09/201
7
324, 323
r/w. 34 of
the Indian
Penal Code
Acquitted No No
2 Yogesh
Balasahe
b
Shivekar
do do do do do do
3 Santosh
@ Vipul
Ramasha
nkar
Singh
do do do do do do
(lqftrdqekj pa- rk;Ms),
U;k; naMkf/kdkjh izFke oxZ]
44os U;k;ky;] va/ksjh] eaqcbZ-
-- 2 of 11 --
3 C.C.No.786/PW/2019
Exh.
Part 'C'
LIST OF PROSECUTION/DEFENCE/COURT WITNESSES
A. Prosecution:
RANK NAME NATURE OF EVIDENCE (EYE
WITNESS, POLICE WITNESS,
EXPERT WITNESS, MEDICAL
WITNESS, PANCH WITNESS,
OTHER WITNESS)
PW 1 Informant – Pinky Jitendra
Shivekar
Exh.No.03
PW 2 Witness – Sachin Subhash
Aherkar
Exh.No.05
PW 3 Panch – Natwarlal
Chimanlal Solanki
Exh.No.06
PW 4 Witness – Jitendra Vikas
Shivekar
Exh.No.7
B. Defence witnesses, if any.
RANK NAME NATURE OF EVIDENCE (EYE
WITNESS, POLICE WITNESS,
EXPERT WITNESS, MEDICAL
WITNESS, PANCH WITNESS,
OTHER WITNESS)
Nil Nil Nil
C. Court witnesses, if any.
RANK NAME NATURE OF EVIDENCE (EYE
WITNESS, POLICE WITNESS,
EXPERT WITNESS, MEDICAL
WITNESS, PANCH WITNESS,
OTHER WITNESS)
Nil Nil Nil
(lqftrdqekj pa- rk;Ms),
U;k; naMkf/kdkjh izFke oxZ]
44os U;k;ky;] va/ksjh] eaqcbZ-
-- 3 of 11 --
4 C.C.No.786/PW/2019
Exh.
LIST OF PROSECUTION EXHIBITS
Sr.
No.
Nature of Exhibit Exhibit No.
1 FIR 04
U;k ; fu .kZ ;
¼fnukad 13@08@2024 jksth ikfjr½
vkjksih daz-1 rs 3 Hkkjrh; naM lafgrsps dye 324] 323
lg dye 34 vUo;s e/;s uewn vlysY;k f'k{kkik= xqUg;kP;k laijh{ksyk
lkeksjk tkr vkgsr-
vfHk;ksx i{kkps dFku FkksMD;kr [kkyhyizek.ks %
2- fQ;kZnh fiadh f'kosdj fgpk pqyr Hkkm lfpu vkgsjdj ;kps
vkjksih fnus'k f'kosdj ;kps lkscr eS=hps laca/k gksrs- fnus'k f'kosdjph
iRuh fiz;adk gh lfpu f'kosdjP;k ekekph eqyxh vlY;keGs rks frP;k
lkscr cksyr gksrk vkf.k ;k xks”Vhpk jkx eukr /k#u vkjksih fnus'k gk
lfpu lkscr usgeh HkkaM.k djk;pk- fnukad 09-09-2017 jksth 22-30
oktrkP;k lqekjkl fiad vikVZesaV leksj] ts- ih- jksM] lkrcaxyk] olksZok]
va/ksjh if'pe] eqacbZ] ;sFks ojhy loZ vkjksihauh fQ;kZnh fiadh ftrsanz
f'kosdj fgpk pqyr Hkkm ukes lfpu vkgsjdj ;kauh ckacqus o gkrkus ekjgk.k
d#u nq[kkir iksgkspfoyh- ifj.kkeh fQ;kZnhus vkjksihfo#/n iksyhl LVs'ku
olksZok ;sFks rdzkj nk[ky dsyh- ;k rdzkjhP;k vuq”kaxkus vkjksihafo#n~/k Hkk-
(lqftrdqekj pa- rk;Ms),
U;k; naMkf/kdkjh izFke oxZ]
44os U;k;ky;] va/ksjh] eaqcbZ-
-- 4 of 11 --
5 C.C.No.786/PW/2019
Exh.
na- fo- dye 324] 323 lg dye 34 vUo;s xqUgk dza-321@2017
uksanfo.;kr vkyk-
3- ;k xqUg;kps riklh vf/kdkjh Jh-x.ks'k vfgjs ¼iksyhl&mi&
fujh{kd½ ;kauh lnjP;k xqUg;kP;k riklknjE;ku lk{khnkjakps tckc uksanfoys-
?kVukLFkG iapukek r;kj dsyk- vkjksihyk vVd dsyh- R;kauk lnj
xqUg;kr vkjksihfo#n~/k xqUgkn'kZd iqjkok feGwu vkY;kus vkjksihfo#n~/k
U;k;ky;kr nks”kkjksi i= nk[ky dsys-
4- vkjksihfo#n~/k Hkk-na-fo- dye 324] 323 lg 34 vUo;s
nks"kkjksi Bsoyk- vkjksihyk lnj nks”kkjksi okpwu o letkowu lkafxryk-
vkjksihus xqUgk dcqy dsyk ukgh o izdj.k iq<s pkyfo.;kph ekx.kh dsyh-
5- vkjksihfo#/n xqUgkn'kZd iqjkok vk<Gqu vkY;kus QkStnkjh
izfdz;k lafgrk dye 313 ps vUo;ss vkjksihps fuosnu uksnafo.;kr
vkys- ;k fuosnukr vkjksihauh R;kauk tk.khoiqoZd xksoY;kpk cpko mifLFkr
dsyk-
6- izzLrqr [kVyk fudkyh dk<.;klkBh [kkyhy eqn~ns ekÖ;k
fopkjkFkZ mifLFkr >kys- R;kojhy fu"d"kZ eh iq<hyizek.ks uksanfor vkgs %
dz- eqn~ns fu”d”kZ
1 vfHk;ksx i{k gs fln~/k djrks dk; dh]
fnukad 09@09@2017 jksth lqekjs 22-
udkjkFkhZ
(lqftrdqekj pa- rk;Ms),
U;k; naMkf/kdkjh izFke oxZ]
44os U;k;ky;] va/ksjh] eaqcbZ-
-- 5 of 11 --
6 C.C.No.786/PW/2019
Exh.
30 oktrkP;k lqekjkl fiad vikVZesaV
leksj] ts- ih- jksM] lkrcaxyk] olksZok]
va/ksjh if'pe] eqacbZ] ;sFks loZ vkjksihauh
lax.kerd#u gsrqiqoZd fQ;kZnhP;k Hkkokyk
ckacqus ekjgk.k d#u xaHkhj t[keh dsys
vkf.k R;k vuq”kaxkus Hkkjrh; naM lafgrsP;k
dye 324 lg 34 uqlkjPkk xqUgk dsyk\
2 vfHk;ksx i{k gs fln~/k djrks dk; dh]
ojhy osGh] fno'kh o fBdk.kh ;sFks loZ
vkjksihauh lax.kerd#u gsrqiqoZd
fQ;kZnhP;k Hkkokyk gkrkus ekjgk.k d#u
nq[kkir dsyh vkf.k R;k vuq”kaxkus
Hkkjrh; naM lafgrsP;k dye 323 lg
34 uqlkjPkk xqUgk dsyk\
udkjkFkhZ
3 dk; vkns'k \ vafre vkns'kkuqlkj
loZ vkjksihaph funksZ”k
eqDrrk dj.;kr ;sr
vkgs-
dkj.kfeekalk
eqn~ns dz- 1 o 2 P;k vuq"kaxkus%
7- ojhy loZ iz'u ijLijka'kh fuxMhr vlwu lkekbZd iqjkok
miyC/k vlY;keqGs ;k loZ iz'ukauk ,df=rfjR;k mRrj ns.ks ;ksX; Bjrs-
8- mHk;i{kkpk ;qDrhokn ,sdyk-
(lqftrdqekj pa- rk;Ms),
U;k; naMkf/kdkjh izFke oxZ]
44os U;k;ky;] va/ksjh] eaqcbZ-
-- 6 of 11 --
7 C.C.No.786/PW/2019
Exh.
9- vkjksihafo#n~/kpk nks”kkjksi fln~/k dj.;klkBh vfHk;ksx i{kk}kjs
[kkyhy lk{khnkjkauk rikl.;kr vkys-
vuqdzeka
d
lk{khnkjkps uko fu'kk.kh dz-
1 fQ;kZnh & fiadh ftrsnz f'kosdj
¼lk{knkj daz-1½
3
2 lk{knkj & lfpu lqHkk”k vkgsjdj
¼lk{knkj daz-2½
5
3 iap lk{knkj & uVojyky fpeuyky
lksyadh ¼lk{knkj daz-3½
6
4 lk{knkj & ftrsanz fodkl f'kosdj
¼lk{knkj daz-4½
7
10- izLrqr izdj.k xsY;k ikp o”kkZiklwu iqjkO;klkBh izyafcr
vkgs- ;k fn?kZ dkyko/khr vfHk;ksx i{kkyk iqjs'kh la/kh nsowulqn~/kk ojhy
lk{khnkjk O;frfjDr dks.kR;kgh lk{khnkjkauk ;k izdj.kkr rikl.;kr vkys
ukgh- v'kk ifjfLFkrhe/;s miyC/k iqjkO;kuqlkj fn?kZdkyhu izyafcr izdj.k
vfoyacfjR;k fudkyh dk<.ks vko';d Bjrs-
11- izLrqr izdj.kkr vkjksiahafo#/n Hkkjrh; naM lafgrkps dye
324 uqlkj ?kMysY;k xqUg;kpk nks”kkjksi dj.;kr vkyk vkgs- ;k vuq”kaxkus
vfHk;ksxi{kkyk [kkyhy egRokps ?kVd la'k;kP;k pkSdVhckgsj fl/n dj.ks
vko';d vkgs-
(lqftrdqekj pa- rk;Ms),
U;k; naMkf/kdkjh izFke oxZ]
44os U;k;ky;] va/ksjh] eaqcbZ-
-- 7 of 11 --
8 C.C.No.786/PW/2019
Exh.
1 vkjksihus LosPNsus fQ;kZnh fdaok lk{knkjkyk iksgkspfoysyh 'kkfjjhd
nq[kkir(
2 Lknj nq[kkir vkjksihus tk.khoiqoZd iksgkspfo.ks(
3 vkjksihus nq[kkir iksgkspforkuk mi;ksxkr vk.kysys gR;kj gs ?kkrd
Lo#ikps vl.ks-
ojhy egRokps ?kVd y{kkr ?ksmu miyC/k iqjkO;kps foospu dj.ks
dzeizkIr Bjrs-
12- fQ;kZnh & fiadh ftrsanz f'kosdj ¼lk{knkj daz-1½ fgus frP;k
lk{k iqjkO;ke/;s vls dFku dsys dh ?kVusP;k fno'kh jk=h 9-30 oktrk
ohl iapohl eqykauh lfpu vkgsjdj ;kyk jkWMus ekjys o rh HkkaM.k
lksMfo.;klkBh rsFks xsyh vlrk iksyhl rsFks vkys vkf.k R;kauh lfpuyk
dqij gkWLihVyyk usys- ;k fBdk.kh mYys[kuh; ckc Eg.kts
rFkkdFkhr ?kVuk gh fQ;kZnhus nk[ky dsysY;k izFke [kcj vgokykuqlkj
fnukad 09@09@2017 jksth 22-30 oktrk ?kMyh o ?kVusP;k osGh
iksyhllq/nk R;k fBdk.kh vkys gksrs- ijarq ;k ?kVuslac/khpk izFke [kcj
vgokyek= fnukad 10@09@2017 jksth 4-40 oktrk uksnafo.;kr vkyk-
;k foyackus uksnafo.;kr vkysY;k izFke [kcj vgokykps Li”Vhdj.k
vfHk;ksxi{kkrQsZ lek/kkudkjdfjR;k ns.;kr vkys ukgh-
13- fQ;kZnhP;k iqjkO;kyk ikBhack ns.;klkBh ;k izdj.kkr
vfHk;ksxi{kkrQsZ fQ;kZnhps irh ftrsanz f'kosdj & ¼lk{knkj daz-4½ ;kauk
rikl.;kr vkys iajrq R;kauh rFkkdFkhr ?kVuscn~n~y R;kauk dkgh ekfgr
ulY;kps dFku d#u iksyhlkauh R;kaps c;ku u uksnafoY;kps iqjkO;kr dFku
(lqftrdqekj pa- rk;Ms),
U;k; naMkf/kdkjh izFke oxZ]
44os U;k;ky;] va/ksjh] eaqcbZ-
-- 8 of 11 --
9 C.C.No.786/PW/2019
Exh.
dsys- R;kpizek.ks ?kVukLFkG iaplk{knkj uVojyky lksyadh ¼lk{knkj daz-3½
;kaus lq/nk ?kVukLFkGiapukek 'kkchrhdfjrk vfHk;ksxi{kkyk ikBhack fnyk
ukgh-
14- ;k izdj.kkrhy t[keh lk{knkj lfpu lqHkk”k vkgsjdj ¼lk{knkj
daz-2½ ;kauh v'kh lk{k fnyh dh ?kVusP;k fno'kh ohl iapohl yksd
R;kP;k ?kjkckgsj vkys o R;k yksdkae/;s vkjksihapk lekos'k gksrk- ;k
lk{knkjkP;kiqjkO;kuqlkj R;k yksdkauh R;kyk ekjgk.k dsyh o R;keqGs rks
cs'kq/n >kyk- ijarq ;k lk{knkjkus iksyhlkale{k fnysY;k c;kuke/;s ek= gh
ckc ueqn ulY;kps ekU; dsys- rlsp fQ;kZnh fiadh f'kosdj fgus tjh
frP;k iqjkO;ke/;s ?kVusP;k fno'kh ohl iapohl yksdkalkscr vkysY;k
vkjksihauh lfpu vkgsjdj ¼lk{knkj daz-2½ ;kyk jkWMus ekjY;kps dFku dsys
vlys rjh gh egRokph ckc frP;k iksyhl c;kuke/;s ueqn ulY;kps ekU;
dsys vkgs- v'kkizdkjs ;k nksUagh izR;{kn'khZ vkf.k egRokP;k lk{knkjkauh
U;k;ky;kle{k fnysyh lk{k vkf.k iksyhlkauh uksnafoysys R;kps c;ku
;ke/;s dekyhph rQkor o folaxrh vkgs- vfHk;ksxi{kkrQsZ ;kizdj.kkr
laca/khr rikl vf/kdkjh ;kauk rikl.;kr vkys ukgh- R;keqGs gh rQkor
o folaxrh dk;e jgkrs vkf.k ;kpk Qk;nk vkjksihaP;k i{kkr tkrks-
15- ;k izdj.kkr lk{knkj lfpuyk >kysyh nq[kkir fl/n
dj.;klkBh laca/khr oS|dh; vf/kdkjh ;kauk rikl.;kr vkys ukgh-
fQ;kZnhus vkjksihauh lfpuyk jkWMus ekjgk.k dsY;kpk iqjkok uksnafoyk- ijarq
rFkkdFkhr jkWMlq/nk ;k izdj.kkr tIr n'kZfoysyk ukgh- fdacgquk
nks”kkjksii=ke/;s ykdMh ckacq tIr n'kZfoys vkgsr- egRokph ckc Eg.kts
(lqftrdqekj pa- rk;Ms),
U;k; naMkf/kdkjh izFke oxZ]
44os U;k;ky;] va/ksjh] eaqcbZ-
-- 9 of 11 --
10 C.C.No.786/PW/2019
Exh.
fQ;kZnh fdaok lk{knkj lfpu ;kauh ykdMh ckacqP;k lgk¸;kus vkjksihauh
ekjgk.k dsY;kpk iqjkok uksnafoyk ukgh- v'kkifjfLFkrhe/;s ;kizdj.kkr tIr
n'kZfoysY;k ykdMh ckacqcn~n~y iz'ufpUg fuekZ.k gksrs- laf{kIri.ks lnj
xqUg;kpk rikl gk lnks”k vlY;kps fun'kZukl ;srs-
16- fQ;kZnh fiadh f'kosdj fgus vkjksih fnus'kph iRuh o lfpu
vkgsjdj ¼lk{knkj dz-2½ ;kps izselac/k vlY;kps myVrikl.khr ekU; dsys
vkgs- R;kpizek.ks fQ;kZnhus fnysY;k izFke [kcj vgokyke/;s vkjksih
fnus'k o lfpu ;kaP;ke/;s ojhy izselac/kkeqGs ?kVusP;kiqohZiklqu okn
vlY;kps dFku dsys vkgs- egRokph ckc Eg.ktss rFkkdFkhr xaHkhj ?kVuspk
izFke [kcj vgoky foyackus nk[ky dj.;kr vkY;kps fl/n >kys vkgs-
v'kkifjfLFkrhe/;s vkjksihauk ;k izdj.kkr iqoZ oSeU;L;krqu tk.khoiqoZd
xksoY;kP;k la'k;kyk oko feGrks o ;k la'k;kpk Qk;nk vkjksihaP;k i{kkr
tkrks- ,darjhr izdj.kkrhy miyC/k lk{khiqjkO;kps foospu dsys vlrk
vlk fu”d”kZ fu?krks dh oj mYysf[kr vkjksihauah Hkkjrh; naM lafgrk dye
324] 323 lg dye 34 vUo;s xqUgk dsyk gh ckc fl/n gksr ukgh-
laf{kIri.ks lcG iqjkO;k vHkkoh vkjksih funkZs”k lqVdk gks.;kl ik= Bjrkr-
ifj.kkeh iz'u dz-1 o 2 ps fu”d”kZ udkjkFkhZ uksano.;kr ;sr vkgsr- ;k
vuq”kaxkus [kkyhy vkns'k ikfjr dj.;kr ;sr vkgs-
vkns'k
1 vkjksih daz- 1 ;ksxs'k ckGklkgsc f'kosdj] vkjksih daz-2 fnus'k
ckGklkgsc f'kosdj vkfk.k vkjksih daz-3 larks”k mQZ foiwy
jek'kadj flax ;kaph Hkk- na- fo- dye 324] 323 lg 34
vUo;s naMuh; vijk/kkrwu QkStnkjh izfdz;k lafgrsP;k dye
248 ¼1½ vUo;s funksZ"k eqDrrk dj.;kr ;srs-
(lqftrdqekj pa- rk;Ms),
U;k; naMkf/kdkjh izFke oxZ]
44os U;k;ky;] va/ksjh] eaqcbZ-
-- 10 of 11 --
11 C.C.No.786/PW/2019
Exh.
2 vkjksih daz- 1 rs 3 ;kapk oS;fDrd tkreqpydk ca/ki= o
tekurhps ca/ki= jn~n dj.;kar ;kos-
3 vkjksih daz- 1 rs 3 ;kauh QkStnkjh O;ogkj lafgrsP;k dye
437&v vUo;ss izR;sdh jDde #i;s 5]000@& v{kjh #i;s
ikp gtkj QDr pk oS;fDrd tkreqpydk ca/ki= n;kok-
4 nks”kkjksii=ke/;s tIr n'kZfoysY;k ckacqP;k dkB;k eqY;ghu
vlY;keqGs ;k U;k;fu.kZ;kP;k vihy dkyko/khuarj u”V
dj.;kr ;kO;k-
5 [kqY;k U;k;ky;kr U;k;fu.kZ; tkghj-
¼lqftrdqekj pa- rk;Ms½
U;k; naMkf/kdkjh izFke oxZ]
fn- 13@08@2024 44 os U;k;ky;] va/ksjh] eaqcbZ-
(lqftrdqekj pa- rk;Ms),
U;k; naMkf/kdkjh izFke oxZ]
44os U;k;ky;] va/ksjh] eaqcbZ-
-- 11 of 11 --