Final Order 1

Order Details: Copy  of Judgment
Pdf Text: 1 C.C. NO.695/PS/2019-Judgment
CNR No.MHMM19-001850-2019
izdj.k nk[ky % fn-31@01@2019
izdj.k uksan.kh % fn-31@01@2019
izdj.k fudky % fn-18@11@2022
dkyko/kh % 03o- 09e- 17 fn-
egkuxj naMkf/kdkjh ;kaps 63os U;k;ky;kr
¼fiBklhu vf/kdkjh Jherh ,l- ,- vkj- lS¸;n½
[kVyk dz-695@ih-,l@2019
fu’kk.kh dz-20
egkjk”Vª ‘kklu
lgkj iksfyl LVs’ku ---vfHk;ksx i{k
fo#n~/k
Hkjr rqdkjke dne
o; % 53 o”ksZ
jkg.kkj % y{eh fuokl] ijsjkokMh]
?kkVdksij if’pe] eqacbZ- ---vkjksih
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
vfHk;ksx i{kkrQsZ % Jh- ‘kgk
vjksihrQsZ fo/khK % Jh- ,l-,l- ?kkjxs
&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&
fudkyi=
¼fudky fnukad 18@11@2022½
1- vkjksihfo#n~/k Hkkjrh; naM lafgrsps dye 279 o 338 vUo;s
[kVyk pkyfo.;kr vkyk-
2- vfHk;ksx i{kkps dFku FkksMD;kr [kkyhyizek.ks vkgs %
fnukad 04@01@2018 jksth 14-05 oktrkps lqekjkl eqdqan
uxj] cl LVkWi] nklh ckj vWUM jsLVkWjaV leksj] va/ksjh iqoZ] eqacbZ ;sFks vkjksihus
R;kP;k rkC;krhy csLV cl dz-,e-,p-&01&,y-&9852 Hkj/kko osxkus
fu”dkGthi.ks iq<hy csLV clyk vksOgjVsd dj.;kP;k iz;Rukr iq<a FkkacysY;k
clyk ?kklyh- R;keqGs rdzkjnkjyk iq<hy clpk /kDdk ykxwu R;kyk xaHkhj
-- 1 of 6 --
2 C.C. NO.695/PS/2019-Judgment
CNR No.MHMM19-001850-2019
nq[kkir gks.;kl dkj.khHkwu >kyk- lcc] rdzkjnkjkus vkjksihfo#n~/k rdzkj ¼fu-
10½ nk[ky dsyh-
3- rdzkjnkjkus fnysY;k rdzkjhP;k vk/kkjkoj lgkj iksyhl LVs'ku ;sFks
xqUgk dz-07@2018 uksanfo.;kr vkyk- ?kVusph pkSd'kh iksfyl mifujh{kd
Jherh ukbZd ;kauh dsyh- R;kauh ?kVukLFkG iapukek ¼fu-16½ cuoyk- rdzkjnkjps
oS|dh; izek.ki= izkIr dsys- lk{khnkjkaps tckc uksanfoys- riklkvarh
vkjksihfo#/n iqjkok feGwu vkY;kus nks”kkjksii= nk[ky dsys-
4- vkjksihfo#n~/k ¼fu-3½ vUo;s nks”kkjksi fuf'pr dsys- vkjksihus xqUgk
dcwy dsyk ukgh o [kVyk pkyfo.;kph ekx.kh dsyh- vkjskihfo#n~/k xqUgkn'kZd
iqjkok vkY;kus R;kps QkStnkjh izfdz;k lafgrk dye 313 ps ¼fu-18½ vUo;s
fuosnu uksanfo.;kr vkys-
5- [kkyhy eqn~ns ;k izdj.kkP;k fu”d”kkZizr tk.;kdjhrk ek>s fopkjkFkZ
mifLFkr >kys- rjh eqn~n;kaps fu”d”kZ eh [kkyhy dkj.kfeekalk }kjs nsr vkgs %
v-dz- eqn~ns fu”d”kZ
1 vfHk;ksx i{kkus fl/n dsys dk dh] vkjksihus R;kps
rkC;krhy csLV cl dz-,e-,p-&01&,y-&9852
Hkj/kko osxkus ftohrkl /kksdk fuekZ.k gksbZy v’kk fjrhus
pkyoyh\ ukgh
2 vfHk;ksx i{kkus fl/n~ dsys dk dh] vkjksihus R;kps
rkC;krhy csLV cl dz-,e-,p-&01&,y-&9852
Hkj/kko osxkus ftohrkl /kksdk fuekZ.k gksbZy v’kk
fjrhus pkyowu rdzkjnkjyk xaHkhj t[keh dsys \
ukgh
3 dk; vkns'k\ vafre
vkns'kkizek.ks
-- 2 of 6 --
3 C.C. NO.695/PS/2019-Judgment
CNR No.MHMM19-001850-2019
dk j .k fe eka lk
6- eqn~nk dz-1 o 2 ckcr%
rdzkjnkj ¼lk{khnkj dz-1½ us ¼fu-9½ dMs lk{k fnyh dh] fnukad
04@01@2018 jksth nqikjh 02-00 oktrkps lqekjkl ejksG ikbZiykbZu cl
LFkkudko#u cl dz-186 vkyh- R;kus cle/;s p<.;klkBh ifgY;k ik;jhoj
ik; Bsoyk- vkjksih clpk pkyd gksrk- R;kus cl u Fkkacork yxspp cl pkyw
dsyh- R;kus iq<P;k clyk vksOgjVsd dj.;kpk iz;Ru dsyk- R;keqGs R;kyk
iq<P;k clpk /kDdk ykxyk] rks clP;k ik;jhoj iMyk- clP;k okgdkus csy
oktowu cl Fkkacoyh o R;kyk vkre/;s ?ksrys- R;kyk fj{kse/;s clowu
nok[kkU;kr ikBowu fnys- iksfyl nok[kkU;kr vkys- R;kph rdzkj fu’kk.kh ¼fu-
10½ uksanowu ?ksryh-
7- rqG’khjke ek#rh xykaMs ¼lk{khnkj dz-2½ us ¼fu-12½ dMs lk{k
fnyh dh] ?kVusP;k osGsl rks ejksG Msikse/;s okgdkps dke djr gksrk-
R;kfno’kh rks cl dz-186 e/;s okgd Eg.kwu gksrk- vkjksih R;k clpk pkyd
gksrk- cl ejksG rs va/ksjh pkyyh gksrh- rdzkjnkj /kkor vkyk o cl idMyh
R;keqGs rdzkjnkj iMyk- rks rdzkjnkjyk nok[kkU;kr ?ksmu xsyk- rdzkjnkj Lor%
/kkor vkY;kus [kkyh iMyk- iksfylkauh R;kpk tckc uksanoyk gksrk ijarq]
R;krhy etdqj R;kyk ekfgrh ukgh-
8- rikfld vaeynkj lgk;d iksfyl fujh{kd Jherh ukbZd ¼lk{khnkj
dz-3½ ;kauh ¼fu-15½ dMs lk{k fnyh dh] fnukad 05@01@2018 jksth dqij
nok[kkU;krqu vi?kkrkph [kcj vkyh- nok[kkU;kr tkowu rdzkjnkjpk tckc
uksanoyk- riklke/;s ?kVukLFkG iapukek ¼fu-16½ cufoyk- lk{khnkjkaps tckc
uksanoys- rdzkjnkjps oS|dh; izek.ki= izkIr dsys- riklkvarh vkjksihfo#n~/k
nks”kkjksi i= nk[ky dsys-
9- rikfld vaeynkj ¼lk{khnkj dz-3½ ?kVuspk izR;{kn’khZ lk{khnkj
ukgh- rikfld vaeynkjkus ?kVusuarj iqjkos xksGk d#u nks”kkjksii= nk[ky dsys
-- 3 of 6 --
4 C.C. NO.695/PS/2019-Judgment
CNR No.MHMM19-001850-2019
vkgs- lnj lk{khnkj gk vkSipkfjd lk{khnkj vlwu R;kpk iqjkok vkjksihfo#n~/kpk
xqUgk fln~/k dj.;klkBh mi;qDr Bjr ukgh-
10- clpk okgd rqG’khjke lk{khnkj dz-2 ?kVuspk izR;{kn’khZ lk{khnkj
vkgs- R;kus R;kP;k lk{khiqjkO;kr vls lkafxrys dh] rdzkjnkj /kkor vkyk-
R;kus cl idMyh o rks [kkyh iMyk- ;k O;frjhDr vfHk;ksx i{kkus ?kVuspk
dks.krkgh izR;{kn’khZ lk{khnkj riklyk ukgh-
11- vkjksihfo#n~/k Hkkjrh; naM lafgrsps dye 279 o 338 vUo;s
xqUgk ‘kkfcr gks.ksdkeh vfHk;ksx i{kkus [kkyhy ?kVd fln~/k dsys vkgsr dk; gs
ikg.ks t#jhps vkgs-
vkjksihfo#n~/k Hkkjrh; naM lafgrsps dye 279 ;k dyekps ?kVd [kkyhyizek.ks%
1- vkjksih okgu gkdrks vxj lokjh djrks-
2- v’kh d`rh lkoZtfud jLR;koj djrks-
3- d`rh csnjdkji.kkph o g;x;hph vlrs-
4- R;keqGs ekuoh thforkl /kksdk vlrks-
5- vxj nq[kkir] vxj uqdlku gks.;kpk laHko vlrks-
vkjksihfo#n~/k Hkkjrh; naM lafgrsps dye 338 ;k dyekps ?kVd [kkyhyizek.ks%
1- vkjksih csnjdkji.ks o g;x;hus d`R; djrks-
2- lnjgq d`R;keqGs ekuoh ftohr fdaok brjkaph O;fDrxr
lqjf{krrk /kksD;kr ;srs-
3- lnjgq d`R;keqGs dks.kR;kgh O;fDrhl xaHkhj nq[kkir iksgksprs-
12- oj ueqn dsY;kizek.ks vkjksihfo#n~/k T;k dyeka[kkyh fuosnu
uksanfo.;kr vkys R;k loZ dyekae/;s vfHk;ksx i{kkus ‘kkfcr dj.;kpk ,d
eqn~nk ,dlkj[kkp vkgs vkf.k rks Eg.kts vkjksihps g;x;hps vkf.k
fu”dkGthi.kkps d`R;- fu”dkGthi.kkps vkf.k g;x;hi.kkps d`R; gs
loZlkekU;i.ks lkj[ksp okVr vlys rjhgh R;ke/;s fdafprlk Qjd
-- 4 of 6 --
5 C.C. NO.695/PS/2019-Judgment
CNR No.MHMM19-001850-2019
vkgs- ,[kknh O;fDr T;kosGh letqu&metqu vkf.k dkgh va’kh eqn~nkegwu
vFkok dks.krhgh xjt ulrkuk ,[kkns vls d`R; djrs dh T;keqGs foijhr ?kMq
‘kdrs o ;kph tk.kho vlrkukgh /kksdk iRdjrs R;kosGh gh g;x; Bjrs-
loZlkekU;i.ks ,[kkn;k O;Drhus ,[kkns d`R; djrkuk ,[kknk /kksj.kh ek.kql
tks ;ksX; rh dkGth o vo/kku Bsowu rs d`R; djsy- r’kh dkGth u ?ksrk
,[kkns d`R; dj.ks Eg.kts fu”dkGthi.kk Bjrks- vFkkZrp g;x;hps d`R; gs vls
d`R; vlrs dh ts d`R; ,d /kksj.kh ek.kql loZlkekU;i.ks dj.kkj ukgh vkf.k
fu”dkGthi.kkps d`R; gs vls d`R; vlrs dh rs d`R; ,[kkn;k /kksj.kh ek.klkus
dj.ks t#jhps vlrs rFkkfi rks rs djr ukgh-
13- oj ueqn iqjkO;ko#u vkrk gs ikg.ks xjtsps vkgs dh] vkjksihps
d`R; gs fu”dkGthi.kk o g;x;hps gksrs dk \ vkf.k R;kP;k ;k d`R;keqGs
lnjph ?kVuk ?kMyh dk \ vkf.k iq<s lnjph ckc vfHk;ksx i{kkus fnysY;k
ys[kh vkf.k rksaMh iqjkO;ko#u ‘kkfcr gksrs dk \
14- R;keqGs oj ueqn iqjkO;ko#u ?kVusP;kosGh vkjksih R;kP;k
rkC;krhy okgu jLR;kph ifjfLFkrh vFkok jLR;kojhy jgnkjh ;kpk fopkj u
djrk osxkus pkyfor gksrk vkf.k R;keqGs ?kVuk ?kMyh vlsgh Eg.krk ;s.kkj
ukgh- okgu pkyd dks.kR;k izdkjs g;x;hus o vfopkjkus R;kps okgu pkyfor
gksrk gs vfHk;ksx i{kkus fln~/k dsys ukgh- ;k O;frjhDr jLR;kojhy rkRdkyhu
ifjfLFkrh vFkok vkjksihus useds dks.kR;k vVh ‘krhZapk Hkax dsyk o R;kps d`R;
d’kkizdkjs fu”dkGthi.kkps o g;x;hps gksrs vlk dks.krkgh iqjkok vfHk;ksx
i{kkus fnysyk ukgh-
15- v’kk ifjfLFkrhr vfHk;ksx i{k fln~/k dj.;kl v;’kLoh Bjyk
vkgs dh] vkjksihus R;kps rkC;krhy cl g;x;hus] fu”dkGthi.ks] ekuoh
ftforkl /kksdk fuekZ.k gksbZy v’kk in~/krhus pkyfoyh rlsp xkMh osxkr
okgrqdhP;k fu;ekadMs nqyZ{k d#u o jLR;kpk vankt o brj ifjfLFkrh y{kkr u
?ksrk pkyfoyh- ^^Eg.kqu ek>k eqn~nk dz-1 o 2 pk fu”d”kZ udkjkFkhZ vkgs-**
-- 5 of 6 --
6 C.C. NO.695/PS/2019-Judgment
CNR No.MHMM19-001850-2019
16- eqn~nk dz-3 ckcr %
vfHk;ksx i{kkrQsZ rikl.;kr vkysY;k lk{khnkjkaP;k tckckr
vkjksihfo#n~/kpk nks”kkjksi fln~/k dj.;klkBhpk vko’;d o Bksl iqjkok vkysyk
ukgh- R;keqGs iqjkO;kvHkkoh vkjksihfo#n~/kpk dks.krkgh nks”kkjksi fln~/k gksow
‘kdyk ukgh- v’kk izdkjs vkjksihfo#n~/kpk [kVyk fln~/k >kyk ulY;keqGs
eqn~nk dz-3 djhrk ek>k vafre vkns'k [kkyhyizek.ks vkgs %
vkns'k
¼1½ vkjksihph Hkkjrh; naM lafgrsps dye 279 o 338 e/kwu QkStnkjh
izfdz;k lafgrk dye 248¼1½ izek.ks funksZ”k eqDrrk dj.;kr ;sr vkgs-
¼2½ R;kpk tkfeu dnck jn~n dj.;kr ;sr vkgs-
¼3½ vkjksihus QkStnkjh izfdz;k lafgrk dye 437&v izek.ks jDde :i;s
15]000@& oS;fDrd ca/ki= n;kos-
fBdk.k % eqacbZ Jherh ,l- ,- vkj- lS¸;n
fnukad % 18@11@2022 egkuxj naMkf/kdkjh]
63 os U;k;ky;] va/ksjh] eqacbZ-
-- 6 of 6 --