Final Order 1

Order Details: Copy  of Judgment
Pdf Text: 1 C.C.No.428/PW/2018
Exh.09
MHMM190013722018
IN THE COURT OF JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE,
ANDHERI, MUMBAI.
(PRESIDED OVER BY SUJITKUMAR C. TAYDE)
(Date of Judgment: 25th July, 2024)
Case No.428/PW/2018
CNR No.MHMM190013722018
FIR/Crime No.151/2017
Police Station: Versova, Mumbai.
COMPLAINANT The State of Maharashtra
through the Station Incharge of
Versova Police Station, Mumbai.
REPRESENTED BY Learned A.P.P. Smt. Seema Mokal
ACCUSED 1] Anurag Ashokkumar Asthana,
Age – 35 Yrs., Occ. Nil,
2] Arpit Sunilkumar Garg,
Age – 31Yrs., Occu. Nil,
3] Ashok Rambahal Asthana,
Age – 64 Yrs., Occu. Nil,
All R/o.102, New Ekta Co. Operative
Housing Society,
V. N. Sawant Road,
Amboli, Andheri (W), Mumbai.
REPRESENTED BY Learned Advocate Shri Kamlesh
Tripathi
(Sujitkumar C. Tayde),
JMFC, Andheri, Mumbai.
-- 1 of 9 --
2 C.C.No.428/PW/2018
Exh.09
Part 'B'
(Para 44(ii) off Chapter VI of Criminal Manual)
Date of offence 14/05/2017
Date of FIR 17/05/2017
Date of chargesheet 06/02/2018
Date of framing of charges 15/11/2021
Date of commencement of
evidence
06/08/2022
Date of which judgment is
reserved
25/07/2024
Date of the judgment 25/07/2024
Accused Details
Rank of
the
accused
Name of
Accused
Date of
Arrest
Date of
Release on
Bail
Offences
charged
with
Whether
acquitted
or
convicted
Sentence
imposed
Period of
Detention
Undergone
during
Trial for
purpose of
Section
428 of
Cr.P.C.
1 Anurag
Ashokku
mar
Asthana
23/07/2
014
23/07/2014 452, 323,
427 r/w.
34 of the
Indian
Penal
Code
Acquitted No No
2 Arpit
Sunilku
mar
Garg
do do do do do do
3 Ashok
Rambah
al
Asthana
do do do do do do
(Sujitkumar C. Tayde),
JMFC, Andheri, Mumbai.
-- 2 of 9 --
3 C.C.No.428/PW/2018
Exh.09
Part 'C'
LIST OF PROSECUTION/DEFENCE/COURT WITNESSES
A. Prosecution:
RANK NAME NATURE OF EVIDENCE (EYE
WITNESS, POLICE WITNESS,
EXPERT WITNESS, MEDICAL
WITNESS, PANCH WITNESS,
OTHER WITNESS)
PW 1 Witness Nazim Hasan
Kadir
Exh.No.4
PW 2 Investigating Officer –
Rohit Vitthal Bhise
Exh.No.5
B. Defence witnesses, if any.
RANK NAME NATURE OF EVIDENCE (EYE
WITNESS, POLICE WITNESS,
EXPERT WITNESS, MEDICAL
WITNESS, PANCH WITNESS,
OTHER WITNESS)
Nil Nil Nil
C. Court witnesses, if any.
RANK NAME NATURE OF EVIDENCE (EYE
WITNESS, POLICE WITNESS,
EXPERT WITNESS, MEDICAL
WITNESS, PANCH WITNESS,
OTHER WITNESS)
Nil Nil Nil
(Sujitkumar C. Tayde),
JMFC, Andheri, Mumbai.
-- 3 of 9 --
4 C.C.No.428/PW/2018
Exh.09
LIST OF PROSECUTION EXHIBITS
Sr.
No.
Nature of Exhibit Exhibit No.
Nil Nil Nil
U;k ; fu .kZ ;
¼fnukad 25@07@2024 jksth ikfjr½
vkjksih daaz 1 rs 3 Hkkjrh; naM lafgrsps dye 452] 323
vkf.k 427 lg 34 vUo;s e/;s uewn vlysY;k f'k{kkik= xqUg;kP;k
laijh{ksyk lkeksjs tkr vkgsr-
vfHk;ksx i{kkps dFku FkksMD;kr [kkyhyizek.ks %
2- vkjksih vuqjkx ;kyk fQ;kZnh olar xqtjkFkh ;kauh jrudqat dks-
vkW- lkslk;Vhe/khy ¶yWV HkkMs rRrokoj fnyk gksrk- vkjksihus gk ¶yWV
eqnriqoZ [kkyh dsyk- vkjksihyk lnj ¶yWVps HkkMs laca/kkr #i;s
1]00]000@& fMikW>hV fQ;kZnhyk ns.ks ckdh gksrs- ;kckcr vkjksihus
fQ;kZnhyk nksu psd fnys R;kiSdh ,d psd fQ;kZnhus oVoyk- ;k psdps
iSls vkjksih fQ;kZnhyk ekxr gksrk vkf.k ;k laca/kkus R;kus fQ;kZnhlkscr
okn dsyk- fnukad 14@05@2017 jksth nqikjh 12-30 rs 2-00 P;k
njE;ku ojhy loZ vkjksih fQ;kZnhP;k ojhy ¶yWVe/;s vkys o R;kauh
fQ;kZnhyk lnj psdps iSls ekfxrys vkf.k fQ;kZnhus ¶yWVps nkj can dsys
vlrk vkjksihauh R;kP;k ¶yWVP;k nkjkoj ykFkk ek#u nkj rksMys vkf.k
fQ;kZnhP;k csM#ee/khy okrkuqdqy ;a= dk<qu usys- rlsp fQ;kZnhpk vk;
Qksu rksMyk vkf.k QyWVe/khy QksVks QksMys- ifj.kkeh fQ;kZnhus
vkjksihafo#/n ojhy ?kVuslac/kh iksyhl LVs'ku olksZok] eqacbZ ;sFks rdzkj
(Sujitkumar C. Tayde),
JMFC, Andheri, Mumbai.
-- 4 of 9 --
5 C.C.No.428/PW/2018
Exh.09
uksanfoyh- ;k rdzkjhP;k vuq”kaxkus vkjksihafo#n~/k Hkk- na- fo- dye 452]
323 vkf.k 427 lg 34 vUo;s xqUgk dza-151@2017 uksanfo.;kr vkyk-
3- ;k xqUg;kps riklh vf/kdkjh Jh-jksghr fHkls ¼iksyhl&mi&
fujh{kd½ ;kauh lnjP;k xqUg;kP;k riklknjE;ku lk{khnkjakps tckc uksanfoys-
?kVukLFkG iapukek r;kj dsyk- vkjksihauk vVd dsyh- R;kauk lnj
xqUg;kr vkjksihafo#n~/k xqUgkn'kZd iqjkok feGwu vkY;kus vkjksihafo#n~/k
U;k;ky;kr nks”kkjksi i= nk[ky dsys-
4- vkjksihfo#n~/k Hkk-na-fo- dye 452] 323 vkf.k 427 lg
34 vUo;s nks"kkjksi Bsoyk- vkjksihauk lnj nks”kkjksi okpwu o letkowu
lkafxryk- vkjksihauh xqUgk dcqy dsyk ukgh o izdj.k iq<s pkyfo.;kph
ekx.kh dsyh-
5- vkjksihafo#/n xqUgkn'kZd iqjkok vk<Gqu vkY;kus QkStnkjh
izfdz;k lafgrk dye 313 ps vUo;ss vkjksihaps fuosnu uksnafo.;kr
vkys- ;k fuosnukr vkjksihauh R;kauk tk.khoiqoZd xksoY;kpk cpko mifLFkr
dsyk-
6- izzLrqr [kVyk fudkyh dk<.;klkBh [kkyhy eqn~ns ekÖ;k
fopkjkFkZ mifLFkr >kys- R;kojhy fu"d"kZ eh iq<hyizek.ks uksanfor vkgs %
(Sujitkumar C. Tayde),
JMFC, Andheri, Mumbai.
-- 5 of 9 --
6 C.C.No.428/PW/2018
Exh.09
dz- eqn~ns fu”d”kZ
1 vfHk;ksx i{k gs fln~/k djrks dk; dh]
fnukad 14@05@2017 jksth lqekjs 12-
30 rs 14-00 oktrkps lqekjkl QyWV daz-
ch@002] jrudqat dks-vkW- lkslk;Vh] jru
uxj] pkj caxyk] va/ksjh if'pe] eqacbZ]
;sFks loZ vkjksihauh lax.kerkus gsrqiqoZd
LobZPNsus fQ;kZnh olar xksikGnkl xqtjkFkh
;kauk ekj.;kP;k mn~n~s'kkus R;kaP;k ?kjkr
izos'k dsyk vkf.k R;k vuq”kaxkus Hkkjrh;
naM lafgrsP;k dye 452 lg 34
uqlkjPkk xqUgk dsyk\
udkjkFkhZ
2 vfHk;ksx i{k gs fln~/k djrks dk; dh]
ojhy osGh] fno'kh o fBdk.kh loZ
vkjksihauh lax.kerkus gsrqiqoZd LobZPNsus oj
ueqn fQ;kZnhyk gkrkus ekjgk.k d#u
nq[kkir dsyh vkf.k R;k vuq”kaxkus Hkkjrh;
naM lafgrsP;k dye 323 lg 34
uqlkjPkk xqUgk dsyk\
udkjkFkhZ
3 vfHk;ksx i{k gs fln~/k djrks dk; dh]
ojhy osGh] fno'kh o fBdk.kh loZ
vkjksihauh lax.kerkus gsrqiqoZd LobZPNsus oj
ueqn fQ;kZnh ;kP;k ?kjkrhy okrkuqdqy
;a=] vk;Qksu o xq# xksokGdj ;kaP;k
QksVksps uqdlku dsys vkf.k R;k vuq”kaxkus
Hkkjrh; naM lafgrsP;k dye 427 lg
34 uqlkjPkk xqUgk dsyk\
udkjkFkhZ
4 dk; vkns'k \ vafre vkns'kkuqlkj
loZ vkjksihaph funksZ”k
eqDrrk dj.;kr ;sr
vkgs-
(Sujitkumar C. Tayde),
JMFC, Andheri, Mumbai.
-- 6 of 9 --
7 C.C.No.428/PW/2018
Exh.09
dkj.kfeekalk
eqn~ns dz- 1 rs 3 P;k vuq"kaxkus%
7- ojhy loZ iz'u ijLijka'kh fuxMhr vlwu lkekbZd iqjkok
miyC/k vlY;keqGs ;k loZ iz'ukauk ,df=rfjR;k mRrj ns.ks ;ksX; Bjrs-
8- mHk;i{kkpk ;qDrhokn ,sdyk-
9- vkjksihafo#n~/kpk nks”kkjksi fln~/k dj.;klkBh vfHk;ksx i{kk}kjs
[kkyhy lk{khnkjkauk rikl.;kr vkys-
vuqdzeka
d
lk{khnkjkps uko fu'kk.kh dz-
1 lk{knkj & u>he glu dknhj 4
2 rikl vf/kdkjh & jksghr foB~B~y fHkls 5
10- izLrqr izdj.k xsY;k lgk o”kkZiklwu iqjkO;klkBh izyafcr
vkgs- ;k fn?kZ dkyko/khr vfHk;ksx i{kkyk iqjs'kh la/kh nsowulqn~/kk ojhy
lk{khnkjka O;frfjDr dks.kR;kgh lk{khnkjkauk ;k izdj.kkr rikl.;kr vkys
ukgh- v'kk ifjfLFkrhe/;s miyC/k iqjkO;kuqlkj fn?kZdkyhu izyafcr izdj.k
vfoyacfjR;k fudkyh dk<.ks vko';d Bjrs-
11- lk{knkj & u>he glu dknhj ;kus v'kh lk{k fnyh dh
fQ;kZnhus ekfxrY;kizek.ks R;kus lkslk;Vhe/khy lh-lh-Vh-Ogh QqVst vkf.k
isu MªkbZOg fQ;kZnhyk fnys- iajrq ;k lk{knkjkus R;kP;k iksyhl c;kuke/;s
gh ckc ueqn dsyh ukgh- rikl vf/kdkjh jksghr fHkls ;kauh fQ;kZnhus R;kauk
(Sujitkumar C. Tayde),
JMFC, Andheri, Mumbai.
-- 7 of 9 --
8 C.C.No.428/PW/2018
Exh.09
fnysyh flMh tIr dsY;kpk vkf.k ?kVukLFkG iapukek r;kj dsY;kpk iqjkok
uksanfoyk- ijarq lnj lh-lh-Vh-Ogh QqVst] flMh vkf.k isu MªkbZOg
vfHk;ksxi{kkrQsZ ;k izdj.kkr nk[ky d#u R;ke/khy r/; fl/n dj.;kr
vkys ukgh- R;keqGs ;k lk{knkjkapk iqjkok vfHk;ksxi{kkyk nks”kkjksi
'kkfcrhdfjrk mi;ksxh B# 'kdr ukgh-
12- ;k izdj.kkr vfHk;ksxi{kkrQsZ fQ;kZnh fdaok izR;{kn'khZ
lk{knkjkyk rikl.;kr vkys ukgh- rlsp ;k [kVY;kr nk[ky dj.;kr
vkysyk izFke [kcj vgoky vfHk;ksxi{kkrQsZ fl/n dj.;kr vkyk ukgh-
fdacgquk foyackus uksnafo.;kr vkysY;k izFke [kcj vgokykps Li”Vhdj.k
lq/nk nk[ky dj.;kr vkys ukgh- laf{kIri.ks miyC/k iqjkO;kuqlkj rFkkdFkhr
xqUg;ke/;s vkjksihapk lgHkkx gksrk gh ckc fl/n gksr ukgh- ,danjhr
izdj.kkrhy miyC/k lk{khiqjkO;kps foospu dsys vlrk vlk fu”d”kZ fu?krks
dh oj mYysf[kr vkjksihauh Hkkjrh; naM lafgrk dye 452] 323 vkf.k
427 lg 34 vUo;s xqUgk dsyk gh ckc fl/n gksr ukgh- laf{kIri.ks
lcG iqjkO;k vHkkoh loZ vkjksih funkZs”k lqVdk gks.;kl ik= Bjrkr-
ifj.kkeh iz'u dz-1 rs 3 ps fu”d”kZ udkjkFkhZ uksano.;kr ;sr vkgsr- ;k
vuq”kaxkus [kkyhy vkns'k ikfjr dj.;kr ;sr vkgsr-
vkns'k
1 vkjksih daz- 1 vuqjkx v'kksddqekj vLFkkuk] vkjksih daz-2
vihZr lquhydqekj xxZ vkf.k vkjksih dza-3 v'kksd jkecgky
vLFkkuk ;kaph Hkk- n- fo- dye 452] 323 vkf.k 427
lg 34 vUo;s izek.ksP;k naMuh; vijk/kkrwu QkStnkjh
izfdz;k lafgrsP;k dye 248 ¼1½ vUo;s funksZ"k eqDrrk
dj.;kr ;srs-
(Sujitkumar C. Tayde),
JMFC, Andheri, Mumbai.
-- 8 of 9 --
9 C.C.No.428/PW/2018
Exh.09
2 vkjksih daz 1 rs 3 ;kapk oS;fDrd tkreqpydk ca/ki= o
tekurhps ca/ki= jn~n dj.;kar ;kos-
3 vkjksih daz 1 rs 3 QkStnkjh O;ogkj lafgrsP;k dye
437&v vUo;ss izR;sdh jDde #i;s 5]000@& v{kjh #i;s
ikp gtkj QDr pk oS;fDrd tkreqpydk ca/ki= n;kok-
4 [kqY;k U;k;ky;kr U;k;fu.kZ; tkghj-
¼lqftrdqekj pa- rk;Ms½
U;k; naMkf/kdkjh izFke oxZ]
fn- 25@07@2024 va/ksjh] eaqcbZ-
(Sujitkumar C. Tayde),
JMFC, Andheri, Mumbai.
-- 9 of 9 --