Final Order 1

Order Details: Copy of Judgment
Pdf Text: U;k;fu.kZ; --1-- [kVyk Ø- 1782@ihMCY;w@2019
,e,p,e,e18&008099&2019 nk[ky rkjh[k % 14@11@2019-
uksan.kh rkjh[k % 18@11@2019-
fudky rkjh[k % 20@07@2024-
dkyko/kh % 04 o-] 08 e-] 06 fn-
fu'kk.kh Ø- %
egkuxj@izFke oxZ U;k;naMkf/kdkjh ;kaps U;k;ky;
71 os U;k;ky;] ckanzk] eqacbZ-
¼fiBklu vf/kdkjh v- Hkk- tk/ko ;kaps leksj½
izdj.k Ø-1782@ihMCY;w@2019
egkjk”Vª ljdkj]
}kjk &iksyhl vf/kdkjh]
okdksyk iksyhl Bk.ks] eqacbZ- --- rØkjnkj-
fo:/n
1 f’kolans’k vkuanjkt flag-
o; % 28 o”ksZ] O;olk; %& uksdjh-
jkg.kkj& lkarkØq> ¼iw½] eqacbZ-
2 vkuanjkt n’kjFk flag-
o; % 55 o”ksZ] O;olk; %& uksdjh-
jkg.kkj& lkarkØq> ¼iw½] eqacbZ-
3 js[kk vkuanjkt flag-
o; % 50 o”ksZ] O;olk; %& x`fg.kh-
jkg.kkj& lkarkØq> ¼iw½] eqacbZ-
4 lqfiz;k Jhjkt flag-
o; % 26 o”ksZ] O;olk; %& x`fg.kh-
jkg.kkj& lkarkØq> ¼iw½] eqacbZ- --- vkjksih-
ljdkjrQsZ fo/khK % Jh- izlkn tks'kh-
vkjksiharQsZ fo/khK % Jh- vafdr eksVk-
-- 1 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; --2-- [kVyk Ø- 1782@ihMCY;w@2019
U;k;fu.kZ; fn-20@07@2024
1- lnjhy [kVyk vkjksihaP;kfo#/n~ Hkkjrh; naM fo/kkukps
dye 498 ¼v½] 324] 323] 504] 506¼ii½] 406 lg 34
P;k naMuh; vijk/kklkBh pkyfo.;kr vkyk-
2- vfHk;ksx i{kkps FkksMD;kr dFku vls vkgs dh]
fn-24@02@2018 jksth] fQ;kZnh jksfg.kh ghpk vkjksih f’kolans’k
vkuanjkt flag ;kps cjkscj fookg >kY;kuarj rh lkljh ukanr
vlrkuk vkjksihauh fQ;kZnhyk frps oMhykadMwu pkj pkdh xkMh
o ?kj ?ks.;klkBh I-35]00]000@& oMhykadMwu ?ksowu ;s.;kl
lkafxrys- lnj jDde fQ;kZnhus u vk.kY;kus vkjksihauh fQ;kZnhyk
f’kohxkG d:u] gkrkus o dkBhus ekjgk.k d:u] thos Bkj
ekj.;kph /kedh fnyh o fryk ?kjkckgsj dk<ys vkf.k frP;k
L=h/kukpk vigkj dsyk- v’kkizdkjs vkjksihauh laxuerkus fQ;kZnhpk
'kkfjjhd o ekufld NG dsyk- Eg.kwu fQ;kZnhus okdksyk iksyhl
Bk.ksyk rØkj uksanoyh-
3- iksyhlkauh fQ;kZnhus ukasnoysY;k rØkjho:u
vkjksihafo:/n~ vijk/k Ø-283@2018 uksanoyk- l-Ikks-fu- ique
iokj ;kauh lnj xqUákpk rikl dsyk- riklknjE;ku vkjksihauk
vVd dj.;kr vkyh- lk{khnkjkaps c;ku uksano.;kr vkys- rikl
iq.kZ >kY;kuarj riklh vaeynkj l-Ikks-fu- ique iokj ;kauh
vkjksihafo#/n~ nks”kkjksi Ik= nk[ky dj.;kr vkys-
4- loZ vkjksih U;k;ky;kleksj gtj >kys- ek>s iqokZf/kdkjh
;kauh vkjksihP;kfo#/n~ nks”kkjksi ¼fu-Ø-2½ izek.ks fuf'pr dsys-
-- 2 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; --3-- [kVyk Ø- 1782@ihMCY;w@2019
vkjksihauh xqUgk uk dcqy dsyk o laijh{ksph ekx.kh dsyh-
iqjkO;knjE;ku fQ;kZnhuss vkjksihlkscr letksrk >kY;kckcr vtZ
¼fu-Ø-14½] nk[ky dsyk- Hkk-na-fo dye 498 ¼v½] 324 vUo;s
naMuh; vijk/k rMtksMhl ik= ulY;kewGs lnjhy vijk/kklkBh
[kVyk iq<s pkyo.;kr vkyk- vfHk;ksx i{kkrQsZ fQ;kZnhps ofMy
rstcgknqj flax ¼lk-Ø-1½ o fQ;kZnh jksfg.kh ¼lk-Ø-2½ ;kaph lk{k
vuqØes ¼fu-Ø-7½ o ¼fu-Ø-19½ oj uksano.;kr vkyh vkgs-
vkjksihauh dks.krkgh iqjkok fnysyk ukgh-
5- ;k izdj.kkrhy {kfrxzLr fQ;kZnh jksfg.kh ¼lk-Ø-2½
;kauh vfHk;ksx i{kkl lgdk;Z dsysys ukgh- v'kk ifjfLFkrhr brj
lk{khnkj riklwu ns[khy vfHk;ksx i{kkl mi;ksxkps Bj.kkj ukgh-
lnjhy [kVY;ke/;s ¼fu-Ø-15½ ojhy iqflZlizek.ks mHk; i{kke/;s
rMtksM >kY;kewGs vfHk;ksx i{kkpk iqjkok can dj.;kr vkyk-
v'kk ifjfLFkrhr brj lk{khnkj riklwu ns[khy vfHk;ksx i{kkl
mi;ksxkps Bj.kkj ukgh- vkjksihaph QkS-O;-la- dye 313 vUo;s
laifj{kk vuqØes ¼fu-Ø-20½] ¼fu-Ø-21½] ¼fu-Ø-22½ vkf.k
¼fu-Ø-23½ uksano.;kr vkyh- [kksVk vkjksi vkgs] vlk vkjksihapk
cpko vkgs- vfHk;ksx i{kkrQsZ vfHk;ks‰k Jh izlkn tks'kh vkf.k
vkjksiharQsZ fo/khK Jh vafdr eksVk ;kapk ;qf‰okn xzg.k dsyk-
6- vfHk;ksx i{kkus fnysY;k iqjkO;ko#u o nksUgha i{kkauh
dsysY;k ;qf‰oknko#u [kkyhy eqn~ns mifLFkr >kys- R;kojhy
fu”d”kZ dkj.k feekalslghr [kkyhyizek.ks-
-- 3 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; --4-- [kVyk Ø- 1782@ihMCY;w@2019
v-Ø- eqn~ns fu”d”kZ
1- loZ vkjksihauh laxuerkus fn-
24@02@2018 rs fn-
11@07@2018 i;±r] fo’okl
bZekjr] xksGhckj jksM] lkarkØq>
¼iw½] eqacbZ ;sFks vki[kq'khus ,d pkj
pkdh okgu o ?kj ?ks.;klkBh I-
35]00]000@& ph ekx.khph iqrZrk
u dsY;kewGs fQ;kZnh jksfg.kh ghpk
'kkfjjhd o ekufld NG d:u
fryk Øqjrsph okx.kwd fnY;kps
vfHk;ksx i{kkus fl/n~ dsys dk;\ ukgh-
2- loZ vkjksih ;kauh laxuerkus
vki[kq'khuss oj uewn fno'kh] osGh
vkf.k fBdk.kh ;sFks oj uewn fQ;kZnh
;kauk dkBhus ekjgk.k d:u nq[kkir
dssY;kps vfHk;ksx i{kkus fl/n~ dsys
dk;\ ukgh-
3- loZ vkjksih ;kauh laxuerkus
vki[kq'khuss oj uewn fno'kh] osGh
-- 4 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; --5-- [kVyk Ø- 1782@ihMCY;w@2019
vkf.k fBdk.kh ;sFks oj uewn fQ;kZnh
;kauk gkrkus ekjgk.k d:u nq[kkir
dssY;kps vfHk;ksx i{kkus fl/n~ dsys
dk;\ ukgh-
4- loZ vkjksih ;kauh laxuerkus
vki[kq'khuss oj uewn fno'kh] osGh
vkf.k fBdk.kh ;sFks oj uewn fQ;kZnh
;kauk f'kohxkG d:u viekfur dsys
vkf.k lkoZtfud 'kkarrk Hkax
dj.;kl m|q‰ dsY;kps vfHk;ksx
i{kkus fl/n~ dsys dk;\ Ukkgh-
5- loZ vkjksih ;kauh laxuerkus
vki[kq'khuss oj uewn fno'kh] osGh
vkf.k fBdk.kh ;sFks oj uewn fQ;kZnh
;kauk thos ekj.;kph /kedh fnY;kps
vfHk;ksx i{kkus fl/n~ dsys dk;\
Ukkgh-
6- loZ vkjksih ;kauh laxuerkus
vki[kq'khuss oj uewn fno'kh] osGh
vkf.k fBdk.kh ;sFks oj uewn fQ;kZnh
Ukkgh-
-- 5 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; --6-- [kVyk Ø- 1782@ihMCY;w@2019
ps L=h/kukpk vigkj dsY;kps
vfHk;ksx i{kkus fl/n~ dsys dk;\
7- vkns'k dk;\ vkjksihauk funksZ”k eq‰
dj.;kr vkys-
dkj.kfeaeklk
eqn~nk Øekad 1 rs Ø-6 lkBh%&
7- fQ;kZnhps oMhy rstcgknqj flag ¼lk-Ø-1½ gs R;kaP;k
lk{khe/;s vls lkaxrkr dh] fQ;kZnh jksfg.kh R;kaph eqyxh vkgs-
frps yXu fn-24@02@2018 jksth] f'kolans'k vkuanjkt ;kps
lkscr lkarkØq> ;sFks >kys- yXukuarj jksfg.kh ukan.;klkBh
vkjksihadMs xsyh- lkljh frps irh vkf.k lklq & lkljs jkgr gksrs-
vk-Ø-4 gh jksfg.khP;k yXukuarj ukyklksikjk ;sFks jkgk;yk xsyh-
yXukpk [kpZ R;kauh dsyk gksrk- R;kuarj ,d efgU;kuh R;kauk iqUgk
Qksu vkyk vkf.k jksfg.khus lkafxrys dh] f'kolans'k gk fryk R;kps
eko'khdMs iq.ks ;sFks ?ksÅu vkyk vkgs vkf.k rsFks frpk xGk nkcr
vkgs- R;kuarj R;kauh jksfg.khyk iq.ks ;sFkqu dks.krhgh dWc idMqu
ijr ;s] vls lkafxrys- Ik.k f'kolans'k ;kus jksfg.khyk rsFkwu lksMys
ukgh- f'kolans'k gk jksfg.khyk ?ksÅu ijr eqacbZ ;sFks vkyk-
8- iq<s fQ;kZnhps oMhy rstcgknqj flag ¼lk-Ø-1½ gs
R;kaP;k lk{khe/;s vls lkaxrkr dh] R;kuarj ekpZ & ,fizy 2018
ps lqekjkl ldkGh 11-30 ok- R;kauk iqUgk jksfg.khpk Qksu vkyk
vkf.k lkafxrys dh] f'kolans'k ;kus fQusy fiys vlwu rks Eg.krks
dh] frP;keqGs R;kus fQusy fiys vkgs- R;kuarj rs vkf.k R;kaph
-- 6 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; --7-- [kVyk Ø- 1782@ihMCY;w@2019
iRuh vkjksihaP;k ?kjh xsys- R;kosGh vkjksih vkuanjkt ;kus eksVkj
lk;dy fnyh] pkjpkdh dk fnyh ukgh] rlsp ,lh dk fnyk
ukgh] vls fopkjys- rlsp R;kus R;kaps gkrkrhy czslysV ikgwu ek>s
eqykyk R;kis{kk gyds czslysV dk fnys vls fopkjys-
9- iq<s fQ;kZnhps oMhy rstcgknqj flag ¼lk-Ø-1½ gs
R;kaP;k lk{khe/;s vls lkaxrkr dh] R;kuarj fn-09@07@2018
jksth] jksfg.khpk Qksu vkyk vkf.k fryk ?ksÅu xsyk ukghrj rh
vkRegR;k djsu] vls rh Eg.kkyh- rlsp rh Eg.kkyh dh] vkjksih
fryk =kl nsrkr- R;kuarj fn-11@07@2018 jksth] R;kapk eqyxk
jksgu ;kl R;kauh vkjksihaP;k ?kjh jksgh.khyk vk.kk;yk ikBoys-
eqyxh nksu fnolkps diMs ?ksÅu jksgu cjkscj R;kapsdMs vkyh-
R;kuarj R;kaps ukrsokbZd ;kauk R;kauh lnjckc lkafxryh- rs vkf.k
ukrsokbZd vkjksaihuk letkowu lkax.;kl xsys gksrs rjh Ik.k rs ,sdys
ukgh- eqyxh jksfg.kh fgus fQ;kZn fnyh- iksfylkauk pkSd'kh d#u
R;kapk tckc uksanoyk- vkjksih Ø-1 rs Ø-3 ;kauk R;kauh
U;k;ky;kr vksG[kys vkgs vkf.k vkjksih Ø-4 ghyk ikfgY;koj
vksG[kw 'kdrks] vls lkafxrys- vkjksihauh ngstlkBh R;kaps eqyhyk
=kl fnyk gksrk-
10- FkksMD;kr rstcgknqj flag ¼lk-Ø-1½ ;kpk iqjkok vlk
vkgs dh] vkjksihauh fQ;kZnh ghyk yXuke/;s pkjpkdh eksVj xkMh
fnyh ukgh] rlsp gyds czslysV fnys ;ko:u frpk NG dsyk-
cpko i{kkus dsysY;k myV riklke/;s iq<s fQ;kZnhps oMhy
rstcgknqj flag ¼lk-Ø-1½ ;kauh ekU; dsys vkgs dh] vkjksih vkf.k
-- 7 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; --8-- [kVyk Ø- 1782@ihMCY;w@2019
fQ;kZnh ;kapse/;s rMtksM >kyh vkgs] R;k rMtksMhuqlkj R;kaps
eqyhus dsysyh fMOgh dsl Ø-137@2019 gh U;k;ky;krwu
dk<wu ?ksryh gksrh] vkjksih vkf.k fQ;kZnhe/;s vls Bjys gksrs dh]
fMOgh dsl vkf.k izLrwr dsl dk<wu ?ksowu QWfeyh dksVkZe/;s ?
kVLQksVklkBh vtZ nk[ky djk;pk] ák ckch rMtksM fygY;k
gksR;k] R;k rMtksM i=ke/;s nksUgh cktwauh vkivkiY;k laerhus
lák dsY;k gksR;k] rMtksMhuqlkj I-2]50]000@& pk MhMh
fQ;kZnhyk feGkyk gksrk-
11- fQ;kZnh jksfg.kh ¼lk-Ø-2½ gh vfHk;ksx i{kkl lgk¸;
djr ukgh- frus lkafxrys dh] frpk vkf.k vkjksih f’kolans’kpk
fookg fn-24@02@2018 jksth] >kyk- brj vkjksih f’kolans’kps
ukrsokbZd vkgsr- frus vkjksihaP;kfo:/n~ xSjletwrhus iksyhlkr rØkj
dsyh gksrh- fQ;kZnhoj frph lgh vkgs ijarq] R;krhy etdwj fryk
ekfgr ukgh- frus ukdkjys vkgs dh] vkjksihauh frpk ‘kkfjjhd o
ekufld NG d:u Øqjrsph okx.kwd fnyh vkf.k frP;k laiÙkhpk
vigkj dsyk-
12- fQ;kZnh jksfg.kh ¼lk-Ø-1½ iwohZ fnysY;k c;kukizek.ks
lk{k nsr ulY;kewGs ljdkjh odhykauh frph myVrikl.kh Äsryh-
myV riklkr ljdkjh odhykauh lqpoysys izR;sd dFku frus
ukdkjys- frP;k myV rikl.khr v'kh dks.krhgh ckc vkyh ukgh
dh] T;kpk Qk;nk vfHk;ksx i{kkl gksbZy- frph lk{k vfHk;ksx
i{kkl mi;ksxh iM.kkjh ukgh-
13- fQ;kZnh jksfg.kh ¼lk-Ø-2½ gh vfHk;ksx i{kkl
lgk¸; djr ukgh- vfHk;ksx i{kkus brj lk{khnkjkauk gtj dsys
-- 8 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; --9-- [kVyk Ø- 1782@ihMCY;w@2019
ukgh- fQ;kZnh jksfg.kh ¼lk-Ø-2½ egRokph lk{khnkj vlwu ns[khy
vfHk;ksx i{kkyk lgdk;Z djr ukgh- R;kewGs rstcgknqj flag
¼lk-Ø-1½ ;kpk iqjkok gk vkjksihauh xqUgk dsyk vkgs] gs
Bjo.;klkBh mi;ksxkpk Bjr ukgh- f’kok;] nksUgh i{kkae/;s rMtksM
>kY;kps fnlwu ;srs R;kewGs vfHk;ksx i{kkdMs vlk dks.krkgh iqjkok
ukgh dh] loZ vkjksihauh laxuerkus fn-24@02@2018 rs fn-
11@07@2018 i;±r] fo’okl bZekjr] xksGhckj jksM] lkarkØq>
¼iw½] eqacbZ ;sFks vki[kq'khus ,d pkj pkdh okgu o ?kj ?ks.;klkBh
I-35]00]000@& ph ekx.khph iqrZrk u dsY;kewGs fQ;kZnh
jksfg.kh ghpk 'kkfjjhd o ekufld NG d:u fryk Øqjrsph
okx.kwd fnyh] fQ;kZnhyk gkrkus o dkBhus ekjgk.k d:u nq[kkir
dsyh] fQ;kZnhyk f'kohxkG d:u viekfur dsys vkf.k lkoZtfud
'kkarrk Hkax dj.;kl m|q‰ dsys] fQ;kZnhyk thos ekj.;kph /kedh
fnyh vkf.k fQ;kZnh ps L=h/kukpk vigkj dsyk- vkjksih iqjkO;k
vHkkoh funksZ"k eq‰ gks.;kl ik= vkgsr- ifj.kkeh eqn~nk Ø-1 rs Ø-
6 ps mÙkj udkjkFkhZ ns.;kr ;sr vkgsr- eqn~nk Ø-7 P;k mÙkjklkBh
[kkyhyizek.ks vkns'k ikjhr dj.;kr ;sr vkgs-
vkns'k
v- vkjksih Ø-1 f’kolans’k vkuanjkt flag] Ø-2
vkuanjkt n’kjFk flag] Ø-3 js[kk vkuanjkt flag
vkf.k Ø-4 lqfiz;k Jhjkt flag ;kauk QkStnkjh
izfØ;k lafgrsps dye 248 ¼1½ vUo;s Hkkjrh;
naM fo/kkukps dye 498 ¼v½] 324] 323]
-- 9 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; --10-- [kVyk Ø- 1782@ihMCY;w@2019
504] 506 ¼ii½] 406 lg 34 P;k naMuh;
vijk/kkrwu funksZ”k eq‰ dj.;kr ;sr vkgs-
c- vkjksihaPks oS;f‰d o tkreqpydk ca/ki=s
QkStnkjh izfØ;k lafgrsps dye 437&v uqlkj
dk;e Bso.;kr ;srkr-
d- U;k;fu.kZ; [kqY;k U;k;ky;kr ?kksf”kr dj.;kr
vkyk vkgs-
fn-%&20@07@2024-
ljkn-
¼v- Hkk- tk/ko½
egkuxj@izFke oxZ U;k; naMkf/kdkjh]
71os U;k;ky;] ckanzk] eqacbZ-
Jqrys[ku fnukad- %& 02@08@2024-
izfrys[ku fnukad- %& 02@08@2024-
Lok{kjh fnukad- %& 02@08@2024-
ljkn-
-- 10 of 10 --