Final Order 4

Order Details: Copy of Judgment
Pdf Text: U;k;fu.kZ; 1 [kVyk dz-860@ih-MCY;q-@2008
egkjk"Vª ljdkj fo- nkeksnj o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&004836&2018
,e-,p-,e-,e-18&004836&2018 nk[ky fnukad % 07-06-2008
uksan.kh fnukad % 07-06-2008
fudky fnukad % 29-11-2025
dkyko/kh o”kZ efgus fnol
17 05 22
fu’kk.kh dz-30
Hkkx v
izFke oxZ U;k;naMkf/kdkjh] 12 os U;k;ky;] ckanzk] eqacbZ ;kaps
U;k;ky;
¼fiBklhu U;k;k/kh’k % Jh- fxjh’k ,l- ekus½
(J.O.Code-MH2069)
izdj.k dz-860@ih-MCyw-@2008
¼lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&004836&2018½
XkqUgk uksan dz-556@2007] Hkkjrh; naM lafgrps dye 406]
498&v lg 34 vUo;s] ckanzk iksyhl Bk.ks] eqacbZ-
vfHk;ksxi{k % egkjk”Vª ‘kklu ekQZr Bk.ks vaeynkj]
ckanzk iksyhl Bk.ks] eqacbZ-
vfHk;ksxi{kkrQsZ % fo’ks”k ljdkjh vfHk;ksDrk Jherh ‘kkarh
dkseVh-
vkjksih % 1- nkeksnj gfj;k eu’kkjkekuh]
o; % 79 o”ksZ] O;olk; % lsokfuo`Rr]
2- fot;k nkeksnj eu’kkjkekuh]
o; % 76 o”ksZ] O;olk; % x`fg.kh]
nks?ks jkg.kkj % jksgjh /kke] 1194] ‘kkarh
uxj] mYgkluxj] ftYgk & Bk.ks-
vkjksiha rQsZ fof/kK % Jh- ,- ,l- /kks=s
-- 1 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 2 [kVyk dz-860@ih-MCY;q-@2008
egkjk"Vª ljdkj fo- nkeksnj o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&004836&2018
Hkkx c
¼QkStnkjh vknsf’kdkps izdj.k VI e/khy ifjPNsn 44 ¼ii½ vUo;s½
XkqUgk ?kMY;kpk fnukad % lu 2004 rs fnukad 29-
12-2007
rdzkj nk[ky fnukad % 29-12-2007
nks”kkjksii= ikBfoY;kpk fnukad % 07-06-2008
nks”kkjksi fuf’pr dsY;kpk fnukad % 18-04-2018
iqjkok lq: >kY;kpk fnukad % 24-09-2025
U;k;fu.kZ;klkBh izdj.k jk[kwu BsoY;kpk
fnukad
% 08-10-2025
U;k;fu.kZ; fnukad % 29-11-2025
U;k;fu.kZ;krhy f’k{kslanHkkZr vkns’kkpk
fnukad
% fujad
vkjksihaph ekfgrh
vkjksih
dz-
vkjksihaph
ukos
vVd
fnukad
Tkfeukoj
lksMY;k
ph
fnukad
XkqUg;kps
dye
vafre
vkns’k
f’k{kk QkS- iz- la-
ps dye
vUo;s
lek;ksftr
¼set off½
dj.;kckcr
dkyko/kh
1½ nkeksnj
gfj;k
eu’kkjkekuh
02-04-
2008
02-04-
2008
Hkkjrh;
naM
lafgrps
dye
406]
498&
v lg
34
vUo;s
funksZ”k
eqDr
fujad fujad
2½ fot;k
nkeksnj
eu’kkjkekuh
-- 2 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 3 [kVyk dz-860@ih-MCY;q-@2008
egkjk"Vª ljdkj fo- nkeksnj o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&004836&2018
Hkkx d
¼QkStnkjh vknsf’kdkps izdj.k VI e/khy ifjPNsn 44 ¼ii½ vUo;s½
ljdkjhi{kkrQsZ ns.;kr vkysys lkf{knj @ cpkoi{kkps lkf{knkj @
U;k;ky;hu lkf{knkj
v½ ljdkjhi{kkps lkf{knkj &
lk-dz- lkf{knkjkps uko Lo:i fu’kk.kh
1½ efu”kk lnkf’ko uykoMs riklh
vf/kdkjh
24
c½ cpkoi{kkps lkf{knkj
lk-dz- lkf{knkjkps uko Lo:i fu’kk.kh
fujad fujad fujad fujad
d½ U;k;ky;kekQZr lkf{knkj
lk-dz- lkf{knkjkps uko Lo:i fu’kk.kh
fujad fujad fujad fujad
ljdkji{kkrQsZ @ cpkoi{kkrQsZ @ U;k;ky;krQsZ ns.;kr vkys fu’kk.kh
dzekad
v½ ljdkjhi{kkekQZr ns.;kr vkysys fu’kk.kh dzekad
v-dz- o.kZu fu’kk.kh dzekad
fujad fujad fujad
c½ cpkoi{kkrQsZ ns.;kr vkysys fu’kk.kh dzekad
-- 3 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 4 [kVyk dz-860@ih-MCY;q-@2008
egkjk"Vª ljdkj fo- nkeksnj o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&004836&2018
v-dz- o.kZu fu’kk.kh dzekad
fujad fujad fujad
d½ U;k;ky;kekQZr ns.;kr vkysys fu’kk.kh dzekad
v-dz- o.kZu fu’kk.kh dzekad
fujad fujad fujad
M½ egRoiw.kZ eqn~nseky ¼Material object½
v-dz- egRoiw.kZ eqn~nseky ¼Material
object½
o.kZu
fujad fujad fujad
U;k;fu.kZ;
¼?kks"khr fnukad 29 uksOgsacj] 2025½
vkjksihfo#n~/k Hkkjrh; naM lafgrps dye 406] 498&v lg
34 vUo;s xqUgk U;k;izfo”V vkgs-
2½ vfHk;ksx i{kkph gdhdr FkksMD;kr [kkyhyizek.ks %
lu 2004 rs fnukad 29-12-2007 P;k njE;ku 1194]
‘kkarh uxj] jksgjh /kke] MkW- jkW;y nkl njckj] mYgkluxj o lh@41]
vejthou lkslk;Vh] 41 lsaV ekfVZu jksM] ckanzk if’pe] eqacbZ ;sFks
vkjksihauh brj vkjksihalkscr laxuer d#u rdzkjnkjkyk ekgsjgwu jks[k jDde
#-5]00]000@& ?ksowu ;s.;klkBh lrr ekx.kh d#u frpk ekufld o
‘kkfjjhd NG d#u fryk dzqj okx.kwd fnyh- rlsp fryk yXukr feGkysys
-- 4 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 5 [kVyk dz-860@ih-MCY;q-@2008
egkjk"Vª ljdkj fo- nkeksnj o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&004836&2018
frps L=h/ku fryk ijr u djrk frpk vU;k;kus fo’okl?kkr dsyk- R;keqGs
rdzkjnkjkus izLrqrph rØkj nk[ky dsyh-
3½ ckanzk iksyhl Bk.;kps vaeynkj ;kauh lnj rØkjho#u xq-j-dz-
556@2007] Hkkjrh; naM lafgrps dye 406] 498&v lg 34 vUo;s
xqUgk ukasn dsyk o R;kpk rikl e-iks-mi-fu- efu”kk uykoMs ;kaP;kdMs lqiwrZ
dj.;kr vkyk- riklknjE;ku R;kauh lkf{knkjkaps tckc uksanoys] riklkvarh
vkjksihafo:/n U;k;ky;kr nks”kkjksi i= nk[ky dsys-
4½ ek>s fo}ku iwokZf/kdkjh ;kauh vkjksihafo:/n Hkkjrh; naM lafgrk
dye 406] 498&v lg 34 izek.ks nks”kkjksi fuf’pr dsyk vkgss o
nks”kkjksii=krhy etdwj vkjksihauk R;kaP;k Hkk”ksr okpwu o letkowu
lkax.;kr vkyk vkgs- ijarq vkjksihauh vkjksi ukdkjys o izdj.k pkyfo.ksph
fouarh dsyh-
5½ vfHk;ksxi{kkekQZRk iqjkok lknj dj.;kr vkyk- vkjksihafo#/n
xqUgk ‘kkfcr gks.;k brir iqjkok ulY;kus QkStnkjh izfdz;k lafgrk 1973
ps dye 313 vUo;s tckc uksanfo.;kr vkyk ukgh-
6½ vfHk;ksx i{kkrQsZ fo}ku lgk¸;d ljdkjh vfHk;ksDrk Jherh
‘kkarh dkseVh o vkjksiha rQsZ fof/kK Jh- ,- ,l- /kks=s
;kapk ;qfDrokn ,sd.;kr vkyk- miyC/k iqjkok o lknj dj.;kr
vkysyk ;qDrhokn ;ko#u [kkyhy eqn~ns ek>s fopkjkFkZ fu”iUu >kys- lnj
eqn~n;kaps dkj.kfeekalslg fu”d”kZ eh [kkyhyizek.ks ukasnor vkgss %
vuq-
dz-
eqn~ns fu”d”kZ
1½ vfHk;ksx i{kkus vls ‘kkchr dsys vkgs udkjkFkhZ
-- 5 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 6 [kVyk dz-860@ih-MCY;q-@2008
egkjk"Vª ljdkj fo- nkeksnj o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&004836&2018
dk dh] lu 2004 rs fnukad 29-
12-2007 P;k njE;ku 1194] ‘kkarh
uxj] jksgjh /kke] MkW- jkW;y nkl
njckj] mYgkluxj o lh@41]
vejthou lkslk;Vh] 41 lsaV ekfVZu
jksM] ckanzk if’pe] eqacbZ ;sFks vkjksihauh
R;kaP;k o brj vkjksihaP;k leku
mn~ns'kkP;k iqj%lj.kkFkZ rdzkjnkjkpk
fo'okl?kkr d#u frps L=h/ku Lor
%lkBh oki#u R;kpk vigkj dsyk o
R;kauh Hkkjrh; naM lafgrk dye 406
lg dye 34 vUo;s xqUgk dsyk\
2½ vfHk;ksx i{kkus vls ‘kkchr dsys vkgs
dk dh] oj uewn rkjh[k o fBdk.kh
vkjksihauh R;kaP;k o brj vkjksihaP;k
leku mn~ns'kkP;k iqj%lj.kkFkZ
rdzkjnkjkpk ekufld o 'kkfjjhd NG
dsyk] fryk dzwj okx.kwd fnyh o
R;kauh Hkkjrh; naM lafgrk dye
498&v lg dye 34 vUo;s xqUgk
dsyk\
udkjkFkhZ
3½ vkns’k dk;\ vkjksihauk funksZ”k
eqDr dj.;kr ;srs
dkj.kfeekalk
7½ IkzLrqr vkjksihafo#n~/k xqUgk ‘kkchr dj.;kdfjrk vfHk;ksx
i{kkrQsZ lk-dz-1 riklh vf/kdkjh efu”kk lnkf’ko uykoMs ;kapk rksaMh iqjkok
fu'kk.kh dz-24 yk uksanfo.;kr vkyk vkgs- nksu lk{khnkj e;r vlwu
rdzkjnkj o brj lk{khnkj ueqn iRR;koj feGwu ;sr ukghr] vlk iksyhlkapk
vgoky nk[ky vkgs- lnj izdj.k 17 o”kkZagwu vf/kd twus vkgs- ek- mPp
U;k;ky; ;kauh fdzfeuy vWIyhds’ku ua-580@2020 ;k izdj.kh fnukad
-- 6 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 7 [kVyk dz-860@ih-MCY;q-@2008
egkjk"Vª ljdkj fo- nkeksnj o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&004836&2018
27-07-2023 P;k vkns’kkUo;s gs izdj.k ueqn osGsr fudkyh dk<.;kps
funsZ’k fnys vkgsr- R;keqGs lgk¸;d vfHk;ksDrk ;kaP;k rksaMh fuosnukuqlkj
iqjkok can dj.;kr vkyk vkgs- vkjksihauh dks.krkgh iqjkok fnysyk ukgh-
eqn~ns dz- 1 o 2 dfjrk %
8½ Lkk-dz-1 ;kauh iqjkO;ke/;s vls lkafxrys dh] 2007 e/;s R;k
eqacbZrhy ckanzk iksyhl Bk.kse/;s ih-,l-vk;- Eg.kwu dk;Zjr gksR;k] lnj
xqUg;kpk rikl lq#okrhyk nql&;k vf/kdk&;kdMs lksio.;kr vkyk gksrk]
iq<hy rikl R;kaP;kdMs lksio.;kr vkyk gksrk] R;kauk ,Q-vk;-vkj-]
rdzkjnkjkpk tckc vkf.k rdzkjnkjkP;k ikydkapk tckc feGkyk] R;kauk
nk[ko.;kr vkysY;k ,Q-vk;-vkj- oj ,-ih-vk;- jktsanz iky ;kaph
Lok{kjh vkgs] R;kauh ,d= dke dsY;keqGs R;kauk R;kaph Lok{kjh ekfgr vkgs]
R;kauh rdzkjnkjkpk iqjo.kh tckc uksanoyk vkgs] R;kauh lk{khnkj f’kYik
iVsy vkf.k dsru esgrk ;kaps tckc uksanoys vkgsr] rdzkjnkjkP;k lklw o
lkl&;kauk vVdiwoZ tkehu feGkys] rdzkjnkjkpk fnj vkf.k irh Hkkjrkckgsj
vlY;kus R;kaP;kfo#/n ywd vkmV uksVhl tkjh dj.;kr vkyh gksrh]
rdzkjnkjkP;k Eg.k.;kuqlkj vkjksihauh frpk ekufld vkf.k ‘kkfjjhd NG
dsyk vkgs] vkjksihauh frP;k irhP;k vesfjdsrhy [kpkZlkBh #i;s ikp yk[k
gqaMk ekfxryk vkgs] R;kauk izFken’kZuh vkjksikae/;s rF; vk<Gys vkgs]
Eg.kwu R;kauh rdzkjnkjkP;k lklw vkf.k lkl&;kafo#/n nks”kkjksii= nk[ky
dsys vkgs] rdzkjnkjkP;k fnjkyk ywd vkmV uksVhl}kjs foekurGkoj rkC;kr
?ks.;kr vkys] Eg.kwu R;kauh R;kyk vVd dsyh vkgs] R;kauh R;kyk iksyhl
Bk.;ke/;s vk.kys vkgs] R;kuarj R;kauh R;kP;kfo#/n osxGs nks”kkjksii=
nk[ky dsys vkgs-
9½ oj ueqn lk{khnkj gs ?kVusps izR;{kn’khZ lk{khnkj ukghr-
-- 7 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 8 [kVyk dz-860@ih-MCY;q-@2008
egkjk"Vª ljdkj fo- nkeksnj o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&004836&2018
R;keqGs R;kapk iqjkok vkjksihafo#/n xqUgk fl/n gks.;kl ik= ukgh- rdzkjnkj
o izR;{kn’khZ lk{khnkjkaP;k iqjkO;k vHkkoh vkjksihauh xqUgk dsyk gs fl/n gksr
ukgh- ifj.kkeh] eh eqn~ns dz-1 o 2 ps fu”d”kZ udkjkFkhZ uksanfor vkgs-
eqn~nk dz-3 dfjrk %
10½ eqn~ns dz-1 o 2 ps fu”d”kZ udkjkFkhZ vlY;kus vkjksih ;k
xqUg;krqu funksZ”k eqDr gks.;kl ik= vkgsr- lcc] eh [kkyhyizek.ks vkns'k
ikjhr djhr vkgs %
vkns’k
1½ QkStnkjh izfdz;k lafgrk 1973 ps dye 248¼1½ vUo;s
Hkkjrh; naM lafgrk dye 406] 498&v lg 34 ;k
xqUg;krwu vkjksih nkeksnj gfj;k eu’kkjkekuh vkf.k fot;k
nkeksnj eu’kkjkekuh;kl ;kauk funksZ”k eqDr dj.;kr ;srs-
2½ vkjksihaps tkehu jn~n dj.;kr ;srkr-
3½ QkStnkjh izfdz;k lafgrk dye 437¼v½ izek.ks vkjksihauh
izR;sdh :-15]000@& ps oS;fDrd ca/ki= |kosr-
4½ ftYgk naMkf/kdkjh ;kapsdMs U;k;fu.kZ;kph izr
ikBfo.ksr ;koh-
5½ ;k izdj.kh ek- eqacbZ mPp U;k;ky; ;kaP;k vkns’kkizek.ks
iqrZrk dsys ckcr U;k;fyfid ;kauh ek- eqacbZ mPp
U;k;ky; ;kapsdMs iqrZrk vgoky Rojhr ikBokok-
-- 8 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 9 [kVyk dz-860@ih-MCY;q-@2008
egkjk"Vª ljdkj fo- nkeksnj o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&004836&2018
¼U;k;fu.kZ; U;k;ky;kr Jqrys[khr o vf/k&?kksf”kr dj.;kr
vkyk½
¼fxjh'k lq- ekus½
izFke oxZ U;k;naMkf/kdkjh]
fnukad % 29-11-2025 12 os U;k;ky;] ckanzk] eqacbZ-
Jqrys[ku fnukad % 29-11-2025
izfrys[ku fnukad % 29-11-2025
Lok{kjh fnukad % 29-11-2025
-- 9 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 10 [kVyk dz-860@ih-MCY;q-@2008
egkjk"Vª ljdkj fo- nkeksnj o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&004836&2018
izek.ki=
Ekh izfrKsoj dFku djrks dh] ;k ihMh,Q U;k;fu.kZ;krhy loZ ‘kCn
eqG U;k;fu.kZ;kizek.ks vkgsr-
Yk?kqys[kdkps uko lathouh _f”kds’k ijc
U;k;ky; izFke oxZ U;k;naMkf/kdkjh]
12 os U;k;ky;] ckanzk] eqacbZ-
U;k;fu.kZ; ?kksf”kr dj.;kpk fnukad 29-11-2025
U;k;kfu.kZ;koj Lok{kjh dsY;kph
fnukad
29-11-2025
U;k;fu.kZ; viyksM dsY;kpk fnukad 29-11-2025
-- 10 of 10 --