Final Order 1

Order Details: Copy of Judgment
Pdf Text: U;k;fu.kZ; 1 [kVyk dz-3431@ih-,l-@2017
egkjk"Vª ljdkj fo- lqQh;ku ‘kdhy vgen ik’kk
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&002804&2017
,e-,p-,e-,e-18&002804&2017 nk[ky fnukad % 15@11@2017
uksan.kh fnukad % 15@11@2017
fudky fnukad % 13@02@2026
dkyko/kh 8 o”kZ 2 efgus 29 fnol
fu’kk.kh dz-2 layXu
Hkkx v
izFke oxZ U;k;naMkf/kdkjh] 32 os U;k;ky;] ckanzk] eqacbZ
;kaps U;k;ky;
¼fiBklhu U;k;k/kh’k % Jherh Lojk ,l- ikj[kh½
(J.O.Code-MH2041 )
izdj.k dz-3431@ih-,l-@2017
¼lh,uvkj dz-,e,p,e,e&18&002804&2017½
XkqUgk uksan dz-266@2016] Hkkjrh; naM lafgrps dye 279] 336] 427
vkf.k eksVj okgu dk;nk dye 184 vUo;s] [ksjokMh iksyhl Bk.ks] eqacbZ-
vfHk;ksxi{k % egkjk”Vª ‘kklu ekQZr Bk.ks vaeynkj] [ksjokMh
iksyhl Bk.ks] eqacbZ-
vfHk;ksxi{kkrQsZ % ljdkjh vfHk;ksDrk Jh- fd’kksj ‘kkarkjke
ikVhy
vkjksih % lqQh;ku ‘kdhy vgen ik’kk]
o; % 27 o”ksZ] O;olk; % ukgh] jkg.kkj % ukjk;.k
uxj] lkbZ lsok lkslk;Vh] :e ua-6] ?kkVdksij
if’pe] eqacbZ
vkjksih rQsZ fof/kK % Jh- vkj-ds-xkSre
Hkkx c
-- 1 of 9 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 2 [kVyk dz-3431@ih-,l-@2017
egkjk"Vª ljdkj fo- lqQh;ku ‘kdhy vgen ik’kk
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&002804&2017
¼QkStnkjh vknsf’kdkps izdj.k VI e/khy ifjPNsn 44 ¼ii½ vUo;s½
XkqUgk ?kMY;kpk fnukad % fn-12-10-2016
rdzkj nk[ky fnukad % 13-10-2016
nks”kkjksii= ikBfoY;kpk fnukad % 15-11-2017
nks”kkjksi fuf’pr dsY;kpk fnukad % 15-11-2017
iqjkok lq: >kY;kpk fnukad % 13-02-2023
U;k;fu.kZ;klkBh izdj.k jk[kwu BsoY;kpk fnukad % &&
U;k;fu.kZ; fnukad % 13-02-2026
U;k;fu.kZ;krhy f’k{kslanHkkZr vkns’kkpk fnukad % fujad
vkjksihph ekfgrh
vkjksih
dz-
vkjksihps
uko
vVd
fnukad
Tkfeukoj
lksMY;kph
fnukad
XkqUg;kps
dye
vafre
vkns’k
f’k{kk QkS- iz- la- ps
dye
vUo;s
lek;ksftr
¼set off½
dj.;kckcr
dkyko/kh
1½ lqQh;ku
‘kdhy
vgen
ik’kk
13-10-
2016
13-10-
2016
Hkkjrh; naM
lafgrps
dye
279]
336] 427
vkf.k eksVj
okgu
dk;nk
dye
184
vUo;s
funksZ”k
eqDr
fujad fujad
Hkkx d
-- 2 of 9 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 3 [kVyk dz-3431@ih-,l-@2017
egkjk"Vª ljdkj fo- lqQh;ku ‘kdhy vgen ik’kk
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&002804&2017
¼QkStnkjh vknsf’kdkps izdj.k VI e/khy ifjPNsn 44 ¼ii½ vUo;s½
ljdkjhi{kkrQsZ ns.;kr vkysys lk{khnkj @ cpkoi{kkps lk{khnkj @ U;k;ky;hu
lk{khnkj
v½ ljdkjhi{kkps lk{khnkj &
lk-dz- lk{khnkjkps uko Lo:i fu’kk.kh
1½ i`Foh lat; vxjoky [kcj ns.kkj 2 layXu
2½ XkkSjo lur ‘ksokGs iap 2 layXu
3½ lqfer lfr’k dne riklh vf/kdkjh 2 layXu
c½ cpkoi{kkps lkf{knkj
lk-dz- lk{khnkjkps uko Lo:i fu’kk.kh
fujad fujad fujad fujad
d½ U;k;ky;kekQZr lk{khnkj
lk-dz- lk{khnkjkps uko Lo:i fu’kk.kh
fujad fujad fujad fujad
ljdkji{kkrQsZ @ cpkoi{kkrQsZ @ U;k;ky;krQsZ ns.;kr vkys fu’kk.kh dzekad
v½ ljdkjhi{kkekQZr ns.;kr vkysys fu’kk.kh dzekad
v-dz- o.kZu fu’kk.kh dzekad
1½ Nkfiy izFke [kcj 3
2½ ?kVukLFkG iapukek 4
c½ cpkoi{kkrQsZ ns.;kr vkysys fu’kk.kh dzekad
-- 3 of 9 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 4 [kVyk dz-3431@ih-,l-@2017
egkjk"Vª ljdkj fo- lqQh;ku ‘kdhy vgen ik’kk
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&002804&2017
v-dz- o.kZu fu’kk.kh dzekad
fujad fujad fujad
d½ U;k;ky;kekQZr ns.;kr vkysys fu’kk.kh dzekad
v-dz- o.kZu fu’kk.kh dzekad
fujad fujad fujad
M½ egRoiw.kZ eqn~nseky ¼Material object½
v-dz- egRoiw.kZ eqn~nseky ¼Material
object½
o.kZu
1½ fujad fujad
U;k;fu.kZ;
¼?kks"khr fnukad 13-02-2026 ½
vkjksih fo#n~/k Hkkjrh; naM lafgrps dye 279] 336] 427 vkf.k
eksVj okgu dk;nk dye 184 vUo;s xqUgk U;k;izfo”V vkgs-
2½ vfHk;ksx i{kkph gdhdr FkksMD;kr [kkyhyizek.ks %
fnukad 12-10-2016 jksth jk=h 9-30 oktrk nf{k.k okghuhoj]
if’pe nzqrxrh egkekxZ] ckanzk iqoZ] eqacbZ ;k fBdk.kh vkjksihus R;kph eksVjlk;dy
dzekad ,e,p 03 ,Mh 3252 gh g;hxbZus] fu”dkGthi.kkus] Hkj/kko osxkus o
okgrqdhP;k fo:n~/k fn’ksus pkyowu [kcj ns.kkj ;kaP;k eksVj dkj dzekad ,e,p 02 lh
Ogh 848 yk /kMd nsmu lnj dkjps uqdlku dsys- R;keqGs [kcj ns.kkj i`Foh lat;
vxjoky ;kauh izLrqrph rØkj nk[ky dsyh-
-- 4 of 9 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 5 [kVyk dz-3431@ih-,l-@2017
egkjk"Vª ljdkj fo- lqQh;ku ‘kdhy vgen ik’kk
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&002804&2017
3½ [ksjokMh iksyhl Bk.;kps vaeynkj ;kauh lnj rØkjho#u xq-j-dz-
266@2016] Hkkjrh; naM lafgrps dye 279] 336] 427 vkf.k eksVj okgu dk;nk
dye 184 vUo;s xqUgk ukasn dsyk o R;kpk rikl iks-m-fu- Jh- lqfer lfr”k dne
;kaP;kdMs lqiwrZ dj.;kr vkyk- riklknjE;ku R;kauh vkjksihyk vVd dsyh- nksu
iapkale{k ?kVukLFkGh tkmu fu’kk.kh dzekad 4 ojhy ?kVukLFkGkpk iapukek dsyk-
lk{khnkjkaps tckc uksanoys- riklkvarh vkjksihfo:/n U;k;ky;kr Hkkjrh; naM lafgrsps
dye 279] 336] 427 vkf.k eksVj okgu dk;nk dye 184 vUo;s nks”kkjksi i=
nk[ky dsys-
4½ izLrqr dkeh ek>s fo}ku iwokZf/kdkjh ;kauh vkjksih fo:/n Hkkjrh; naM
lafgrk dye 279] 336] 427 vkf.k eksVj okgu dk;nk dye 184 vUo;s nks”kkjksi
fuf’pr dsys vkgs o nks”kkjksii=krhy etdwj vkjksihyk R;kP;k Hkk”ksr okpwu o
letkowu lkax.;kr vkyk vkgs- ijarq vkjksihus vkjksi ukdkjys o izdj.k pkyfo.ksph
fouarh dsyh-
5½ vfHk;ksxi{kkekQZRk rhu lk{khnkjkapk iqjkok lknj dj.;kr vkyk-
6½ vkjksihps QkStnkjh izfdz;k lafgrk 1973 ps dye 313 vUo;s tckc
uksano.;kr vkyk- vkjksihus lk{khnkjkauh fnysyk iqjkok [kksVk vlY;kps lkaxwu R;kyk
[kksV;k dsle/;s xksoY;kpk cpko ?ksryk- R;kus R;kP;k cpkokdjhrk dks.kkykgh
riklys ukgh-
7½ vfHk;ksx i{kkrQsZ fo}ku lgk¸;d ljdkjh vfHk;ksDrk Jh- fd’kksj
‘kkarkjke ikVhy o vkjksih rQsZ fof/kK Jh- vkj-ds-xkSre ;kapk ;qfDrokn ,sd.;kr
vkyk- R;kauh R;kaP;k ikfo=;kuqlkj ;qDrhokn dsyk-
-- 5 of 9 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 6 [kVyk dz-3431@ih-,l-@2017
egkjk"Vª ljdkj fo- lqQh;ku ‘kdhy vgen ik’kk
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&002804&2017
8½ miyC/k iqjkok o lknj dj.;kr vkysyk ;qDrhokn ;ko#u [kkyhy eqn~ns
ek>s fopkjkFkZ fu”iUu >kys- lnj eqn~n;kaps dkj.kfeekalslg fu”d”kZ eh [kkyhyizek.ks
ukasnor vkgss %&
vuq- dz- eqn~ns fu”d”kZ
1½ vfHk;ksxi{kkus vls ‘kkchr dsys vkgs dk dh] fnukad
12-10-2016 jksth jk=h 9-30 oktsP;k lqekjkl]
if’pe nzqrxrh egkekxZ] nf{k.k okghuh] ckanzk jsYos czht
p<rkuk] ckanzk iqoZ] eqacbZ ;sFks vkjksihus R;kP;k rkC;krhy
eksVjlk;dy dzekad ,e,p 03 ,Mh 3252 gh
fu”dkGthi.ks] gbZxbZus o ekuoh thokyk /kksdk fuekZ.k
gksbZy v’kk in~/krhr pkyoyh o [kcj ns.kkj ;kP;k eksVj
dkj dzekad ,e ,p 02 lh Ogh 848 yk /kMd fnyh o
R;kus Hkkjrh; naM lafgrk dye 279 vUo;s xqUgk
dsyk \
udkjkFkhZ
2½ vfHk;ksxi{kkus vls ‘kkchr dsys vkgs dk dh] oj ueqn
rkjh[k] osGh o fBdk.kh] vkjksihus R;kP;k rkC;krhy
eksVjlk;dy dzekad ,e,p 03 ,Mh 3252 gh
fu”dkGthi.ks] gbZxbZus o ekuoh thokyk /kksdk fuekZ.k
gksbZy v’kk in~/krhr pkyowu brjkaP;k ftokyk fdaok
oS;fDrd lqj{ksyk /kksdk fuekZ.k dsyk o R;kus Hkkjrh; naM
lafgrk dye 336 vUo;s xqUgk dsyk\
udkjkFkhZ
3½ vfHk;ksx i{kkus vls ‘kkchr dsys vkgs dk dh] oj uewn
rkjh[k] osGh o fBdk.kh vkjksihus R;kP;k rkC;krhy
eksVjlk;dy dzekad ,e,p 03 ,Mh 3252 gh
fu”dkGthi.ks] gbZxbZus o ekuoh thokyk /kksdk fuekZ.k
gksbZy v’kk in~/krhr pkyowu [kcj ns.kkj ;kP;k eksVj dkj
dzekad ,e ,p 02 lh Ogh 848 yk /kMd fnyh o R;kaP;k
xkMhps uqdlku dsys o o R;kus Hkkjrh; naM lafgrk dye
427 vUo;s xqUgk dsyk\
udkjkFkhZ
-- 6 of 9 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 7 [kVyk dz-3431@ih-,l-@2017
egkjk"Vª ljdkj fo- lqQh;ku ‘kdhy vgen ik’kk
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&002804&2017
4½ vfHk;ksx i{kkus vls ‘kkchr dsys vkgs dk dh] oj uewn
rkjh[k] osGh o fBdk.kh vkjksihus jLR;kP;k fo:n~/k
fn’ksus /kksdknk;di.ks okgu pkyowu eksVj okgu dk;nk
dye 184 vUo;s xqUgk dsyk\
udkjkFkhZ
5½ vkns’k dk;\ vkjksihyk funksZ”k
eqDr
dj.;kr ;srs
dkj.kfeekalk
9½ IkzLrqr vkjksihfo#n~/k xqUgk ‘kkchr dj.;kdfjrk vfHk;ksx i{kkrQsZ
lk{khnkj dz-1 [kcj ns.kkj i`Foh lat; vxjoky ;kapk rksaMh iqjkok fu’kk.kh dzekad 2
layXu uksanfo.;kr vkyk- lk{khnkj dzekad 2 xkSjo lur ‘ksokGs ;kapk rksaMh iqjkok
fu’kk.kh dzekad 2 layXu uksanfo.;kr vkyk- lk{khnkj dzekad 3 lqfer lfr’k dne
;kapk rksaMh iqjkok fu’kk.kh dzekad 2 layXu uksanfo.;kr vkyk-
eqn~ns dz-1 rs 4 dfjrk %
10½ Lkk{khnkj dz-1 [kcj ns.kkj i`Foh lat; vxjoky ;kauh iqjkO;ke/;s
fu’kk.kh dzekad 3 ph fQ;kZn ‘kkchr dsysyh vkgs- R;kauh R;kaP;k ljriklkr vkjksihP;k
xkMhpk rif’ky vkf.k uksan.kh dzekad lkafxryk vkgs- R;kauh vkjksihyk U;k;ky;kle{k
vksG[kysys vkgs- R;kauh R;kaP;k myVriklkr ^gs Eg.k.ks [kjs vkgs dh] ?kVusP;k osGh
rsFks cjhp xnhZ teyh- gs Eg.k.ks [kjs vkgs dh] jk=hP;k osGh gk;os o:u xkM;k osxkus
tkrkr-* v’kk dcqY;k fnY;k vkgsr-
11½ lk{khnkj dzekad 2 xkSjo lur ‘ksokGs ;kus R;kP;k myVriklkr
dks.krhgh egRRokph dcqyh fnyh ukgh-
-- 7 of 9 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 8 [kVyk dz-3431@ih-,l-@2017
egkjk"Vª ljdkj fo- lqQh;ku ‘kdhy vgen ik’kk
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&002804&2017
12½ lk{khnkj dzekad 3 lqfer lfr”k dne gs riklh vf/kdkjh vlwu R;kauh
ljriklkr dsysY;k riklkph ekghrh fnysyh vkgs- R;kaP;k myVriklkr dks.krhgh
egRRokph dcqyh vkjksihus ?ksrysyh ukgh-
13½ lnjP;k lcG iqjkO;kpk lkjklkj fopkj djrk] izR;{kkr vi?kkr
>kY;kps ikghysyk ,dgh lk{khnkj fQ;kZnh i{kkus riklysyk ukgh- oknkdjhrk ckbZd
dzekad ,e ,p 03 ,Mh 3252 gh vi?kkrkr lgHkkxh gksrh vls ekU; dsys rjhgh
lnjps okgu ?kVusP;k osGh vkjksihp pkyor gksrk vls n’kZo.kkjk dks.krkgh iqjkok
vfHkys[kkoj vkysyk ukgh- lnj okgukpk uksan.khd`r ekyd dks.k gksrk ;kckcrpk
dks.krkgh iqjkok vfHkys[kkoj vkysyk ukgh- ?kVukLFkGkoj lhlhVhOgh dWesjk miyC/k
vkgsr dh ukgh vkf.k vlrhy rj R;kaps QqVst ?ksrysys ukghr- R;keqGs ?kMysyh ?kVuk
fdrhgh nqZnSoh vlyh rjhgh lnjP;k vi?kkrk’kh vkjksihpk dkgh laca/k vkgs vlk
dks.krkgh FksV] Bksl] lcG vkf.k fo’oklkgZ iqjkok vfHkys[kkoj vkysyk ukgh-
14½ fQ;kZnh i{k vkjksihpk xqUg;k’kh vlysYkk dks.krkgh laca/k ‘kkchr d:
‘kdysys ukgh- R;keqGs vkjksihyk R;kpk Qk;nk feG.ks gk R;kpk U;k¸; gDd vkgs-
lcc iqjkO;k vHkkoh eh frUgh eqn~n;kaps mRrj fln~/k ukgh vls nsrs-
15½ vkjksihus fu’kk.kh dzekad 5 P;k vtkZP;k vkns’kkuqlkj QkStnkjh izdh;k
laghrk uqlkj 437 & v ph iqrZrk dsysyh vkgs- R;kuqlkj [kkyhyizek.ks vkns'k ikjhr
dj.;kr ;srks-
vkns’k
1½ QkStnkjh izfdz;k lafgrk 1973 ps dye 255¼1½ vUo;s Hkkjrh;
naM lafgrk dye 279] 336] 427 vkf.k eksVj okgu dk;nk
dye 184 ;k xqUg;krwu vkjksih lqQh;ku ‘kdhy vgen
ik’kk ;kl funksZ”k eqDr dj.;kr ;srs-
-- 8 of 9 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 9 [kVyk dz-3431@ih-,l-@2017
egkjk"Vª ljdkj fo- lqQh;ku ‘kdhy vgen ik’kk
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&002804&2017
2½ vkjksihps tkehu jn~n dj.;kr ;srkr-
3½ QkStnkjh izfdz;k lafgrk dye 437¼v½ izek.ks vkjksihus :-
15]000@& pk tkehu nsmu iqrZrk dsyh vkgs-
¼U;k;fu.kZ; U;k;ky;kr Jqrys[khr o vf/k&?kksf”kr dj.;kr vkyk½
Lojk ,l- ikj[kh½
izFke oxZ U;k;naMkf/kdkjh]
fnukad % 13-02-2026 32 os U;k;ky;] ckanzk] eqacbZ-
Jqrys[ku fnukad % 13-02-2026
izfrys[ku fnukad % 13-02-2026
Lok{kjh fnukad % 13-02-2026
izek.ki=
Ekh izfrKsoj dFku djrks dh] ;k ihMh,Q U;k;fu.kZ;krhy loZ ‘kCn eqG
U;k;fu.kZ;kizek.ks vkgsr-
Yk?kqys[kdkps uko f’kry losZ’k yqMcs
U;k;ky; izFke oxZ U;k;naMkf/kdkjh]
32 os U;k;ky;] ckanzk] eqacbZ-
U;k;fu.kZ; ?kksf”kr dj.;kpk fnukad 13-02-2026
U;k;kfu.kZ;koj Lok{kjh dsY;kph fnukad 13-02-2026
U;k;fu.kZ; viyksM dsY;kpk fnukad 13-02-2026
-- 9 of 9 --