Final Order 1

Order Details: Copy of Judgment
Pdf Text: - 1 - dsl dz- 67@MhOgh@2020
nk[ky rkjh[k % 23@07@2020
fudky rkjh[k % 17@11@2022
dkyko/kh % 02o- 04e- 00fn-
fu-Ø-05
egkuxj naMkf/kdkjh ;kaps U;k;ky;
71 os U;k;ky;] ckanzk] eqacbZ-
¼fiBklu vf/kdkjh fu- v- ljksfl;k ;kaps leksj½
Jherh- #ikyh x.ks'k tk/ko --- vtZnkj
o; & 22 o”ksZ] O;olk; & x`fg.kh
jkg.kkj& dksysojh foyst] pkyhZ] fcikLrk pkG]
dfyuk] lkarkdzq>] eqacbZ-
fo-
1-Jh- x.ks'k oStukFk tk/ko¼irh½
o; & 25 o”ksZ] O;olk; & uksdjh
jkg.kkj& dksysojh foyst] pkyhZ] fcikLrk pkG]
dfyuk] lkarkdzq>] eqacbZ-
2-Jherh- gkSlkckbZ mQZ y{ehckbZ oStukFk tk/ko¼lko= lklq½
o; & 57 o”ksZ] O;olk; & O;kikj
jkg.kkj& dksysojh foyst] pkyhZ] fcikLrk pkG]
dfyuk] lkarkdzq>] eqacbZ-
3-Jh- oStukFk tk/ko¼lkljs½
o; & 59 o”ksZ] O;olk; & 'ksrh
4-Jh- lkfo=hckbZ oStukFk tk/ko¼lklq½
o; & 47 o”ksZ] O;olk; & x`fg.kh
5-Jh- js.kqdk oStukFk tk/ko¼u.kan½
o; & 22 o”ksZ] O;olk; & f'k{k.k
6-Jh- fj”khds'k oStukFk tk/ko¼nhj½
o; & 20 o”ksZ] O;olk; & x`fg.kh
xSjvtZnkj 3 rs 6 jkg.kkj& eq-lqjGokMh]
rk- xaxk[ksM] ft-ijHk.kh] fiu 431 514- --- xSjvtZnkj
-- 1 of 8 --
- 2 - dsl dz- 67@MhOgh@2020
vtZnkj rQsZ odhy Jh- 'kf'kdyk nqcs-
xSjvtZnkj rQsZ odhy Jh- lR;asnz ikaMs-
U;k;fu.kZ;
¼ikfjr fn- 17-11-2022½
1- lnjhy vtZ dkSVqafcd fgalkpkj dk;n;kvUo;s iksVxh laj{k.k
vkns'k o uqdlku HkjikbZ feG.kslkBh nk[ky dj.;kr vkyk vkgs-
2- vtZnkjkps dFku FkksMD;kr vls vkgs dh] fn-16-10-2019 jksth
frpk xSjvtZnkj dz-1 lkscr fookg >kyk- yXukuarj rh xSjvtZnkjkadMs
ukanko;kl xsyh- xSjvtZnkjkauh fryk dkgh fnol pkaxys ukanfoys- ijarq]
dkgh fnolkuarj xSjvtZnkj dz-1 ph okx.kqd cnyyh o R;kyk nqljs yXu
djko;kps gksrs- brj xSjvtZnkjkaph fgp bZPNk gksrh- R;keqGs xSjvtZnkjkauh
fryk f'kohxkG d#u ekjgk.k dj.;kl lqjokr dsyh- xSjvtZnkjkauh ?kVLQksV
n;kok Eg.kqu frpk NG dj.;kl lqjokr dsyh- fn- 20-02-2020 jksth
xSjvtZnkjkauh cGtcjhus ?kVLQksV djkjukE;koj frph lgh ?ksryh o
fryk ?kjkckgsj gdyqu fnys- frP;k vkbZ oMhykauh xSjvtZnkjakuk
le>fo.;kpk iz;Ru d#ugh xSjvtZnkjkauh frpk fLodkj dj.;kl udkj
fnyk- R;keqGs fryk ekgsjh tkos ykxys- frus vusdosGk iksyhlkauk rdzkj
fnyh- frps vls Eg.k.ks vkgs dh] xSjvtZnkj dz-1 us frP;k ikyuiks”k.kkph
dks.krhgh tckcnkjh iq.kZ u dsY;keqGs fryk lnjhy vtZ nk[ky djkok
ykxyk- frps vls Eg.k.ks vkgs dh] fryk mRiUukps lk/ku ukgh- xSjvtZnkj
dz-1 ukekafdr daiuhr uksdjh djrks o R;kyk #-45]000@& izfregk ixkj
vkgs- frus fouarh dsyh dh] xSjvtZnkjkauk :i;s 15]00]000@& uqdlku
HkjikbZ ns.;kps vknsf'kr dj.;kr ;kos- fryk #-25]000@& izfrekg
ikssVxh eatwj dj.;kr ;koh- frus izkFkZuk dsyh dh] frP;k gDdkr laj{k.k
-- 2 of 8 --
- 3 - dsl dz- 67@MhOgh@2020
vkns'k ikfjr dj.;kr ;kos-
2- uksVhl feGkY;kuarj xSjvtZnkj U;k;ky;kleksj gtj >kys- ijarq
ys[kh tckc nk[ky u dsY;keqGs lnjhy vtZ R;kaP;k ys[kh tckckfouk
pkyfo.;kr vkyk-
3- vtZnkjkus frP;k dFkuk i`”BFkZ frph lk{k fnyh o ys[kh
;qDrhokn nk[ky dsyk-
4- vtZnkjkus dsYksY;k iqjkO;ko#u o dsysY;k ;qDrhoknko#u [kkyhy
eqnns mifLFkr >kys R;kojhy mRrj dkj.kfeekalslfgr [kkyhyizek.ks-
v-dz- eqn~ns fu”d”kZ
1. vtZnkjkus fl/n dsys dk; dh]
xSjvtZnkjkauh fryk dkSVqachd
fgalkpkjkph okx.kqd fnyh ? gks;
2. vtZnkj iksVxh o laj{k.k vkns'k
feG.;kl ik= vkgs dk; ? gks;
3. vtZnkj uqDlku HkjikbZ vkns'k
feG.;kl ik= vkgs dk; ? ukgh
4. vkns'k dk; ? vtZ va'kr% eatqj-
dkj.kfeekalk
5- eqnnk dz- 1 rs 4 lkBh%& loZizFke eh ;sFks uewn d#
-- 3 of 8 --
- 4 - dsl dz- 67@MhOgh@2020
bfPNrks dh] gh ckc fufoZokn vkgs dh] vtZnkj gh xSjvtZnkj dz-1 ph
iRuh vkgs- xSjvtZnkjkauh lnjhy ckc ukdkjysyh ukgh- vkrk egRokpk
iz'u vlk vkgs dh] xSjvtZnkjkauh vtZnkjkl fnysY;k =klkeqGs fryk ekgsjh
jkgkos ykxr vkgs dk;-
6- vtZnkjkps vls Eg.k.ks vkgs dh] yXukuarj rh xSjvtZnkjkadMs
ukanko;kl xsyh- xSjvtZnkjkauh fryk dkgh fnol pkaxys ukanfoys- ijarq]
dkgh fnolkuarj xSjvtZnkj dz-1 ph okx.kqd cnyyh o R;kyk nqljs yXu
djko;kps gksrs- brj xSjvtZnkjkaph fgp bZPNk gksrh- R;keqGs xSjvtZnkjkauh
fryk f'kohxkG d#u ekjgk.k dj.;kl lqjokr dsyh- xSjvtZnkjkauh ?kVLQksV
n;kok Eg.kqu frpk NG dj.;kl lqjokr dsyh- fn- 20-02-2020 jksth
xSjvtZnkjkauh cGtcjhus ?kVLQksV djkjukE;koj frph lgh ?ksryh o
fryk ?kjkckgsj gdyqu fnys- frP;k vkbZ oMhykauh xSjvtZnkjakuk
le>fo.;kpk iz;Ru d#ugh xSjvtZnkjkauh frpk fLodkj dj.;kl udkj
fnyk- R;keqGs fryk ekgsjh tkos ykxys- frus vusdosGk iksyhlkauk rdzkj
fnyh- frps vls Eg.k.ks vkgs dh] xSjvtZnkj dz-1 us frP;k ikyuiks”k.kkph
dks.krhgh tckcnkjh iq.kZ u dsY;keqGs fryk lnjhy vtZ nk[ky djkok
ykxyk- vtZnkjkus frP;k dFkuk i`”BFkZ LoRk%ph lk{k fnyh vkgs- frus frP;k
lk{khr Li”Vi.ks dFku dsys vkgs fd] xSjvtZnkjkauh fryk dkgh fnol
pkaxys ukanfoys- ijarq] dkgh fnolkuarj xSjvtZnkj dz-1 ph okx.kqd
cnyyh o R;kyk nqljs yXu djko;kps gksrs- brj xSjvtZnkjkaph fgp bZPNk
gksrh- R;keqGs xSjvtZnkjkauh fryk f'kohxkG d#u ekjgk.k dj.;kl lqjokr
dsyh- xSjvtZnkjkauh ?kVLQksV n;kok Eg.kqu frpk NG dj.;kl lqjokr
dsyh- fn-20-02-2020 jksth xSjvtZnkjkauh cGtcjhus ?kVLQksV
djkjukE;koj frph lgh ?ksryh o fryk ?kjkckgsj gdyqu fnys- frP;k vkbZ
-- 4 of 8 --
- 5 - dsl dz- 67@MhOgh@2020
oMhykauh xSjvtZnkjakuk le>fo.;kpk iz;Ru d#ugh xSjvtZnkjkauh frpk
fLodkj dj.;kl udkj fnyk- xSjvtZnkjkauh fryk myV rikl.kh dsyh
ulY;keqGs frph lk{k vckf/kr vkgs- frus nk[ky dsysY;k dkxni=ko#u
vls fnlrs fd] frus vusdosGk xSjvtZnkjkafo#/n iksyhlkauk rdzkj dsysyh
vkgs- frP;k lk{kho#u Li”V gksrs fd] xSjvtZnkjkauh vtZnkjkoj dkSVqafcd
fgalkpkj dsyk vkgs-
7- egRokps Eg.kts vtZnkj foukdkj.k xSjvtZnkjkaiklqu osxGh jkgr
vlY;kpk dks.krkgh iqjkok U;k;ky;kleksj ukgh- tj vtZnkj foukdkj.k
LoethZus ekgsjh jkgr vlrh rj xSjvtZnkj dz-1 us fryk ukan.;klkBh
ijr ;kos Eg.kwu uksVhl ikBfoyh vlrh fdaok rlk [kVyk nk[ky dsyk
vlrk- iajrq] xSjvtZnkj dz-1 us v'kh dks.krhgh dkjokbZ dsY;kps fnlr
ukgh- ;ko#ulq/nk vls okVrs dh] xSjvtZnkjkauh fnysY;k =klkeqGs vtZnkjkl
ekgsjh jkgkos ykxr vkgs-
8- vtZnkjkps ikyuiks”k.k dj.;kph dk;ns'khj tckcnkjh gh
xSjvtZnkj dz-1 ;kphp vlY;kph ckc fufoZokn vkgs- vkrk jkfgyk
vtZnkj o xSjvtZnkj dz-1 ;kaP;k mRiUukpk iz'u- vtZnkjkps vls Eg.k.ks
vkgs dh] fryk mRiUukps dks.krsgh lk/ku ukgh- vtZnkjkps dFku
xSjvtZnkjkauh ukdkjysys ukgh- vls tjh x`fgr /kjys dh] vtZnkj dkgh
deor vkgs ;kpk vFkZ vlk gksr ukgh dh fryk LFkk;h mRiUu vkgs-
xSjvtZnkj dz-1 us vtZnkjkph ;ksX; rh dkGth u ÄsrY;keqGs fryk dke
djkos ykxr vlY;kph 'kD;rk ukdkjrk ;sr ukgh- vtZnkj deor
vlY;kP;k dkj.kko#u fryk iksVxh ukdkjrk ;s.kkj ukgh-
9- vtZnkjkps vls Eg.k.ks vkgs dh] rh xSjvtZnkj dz-1 ukekafdr
-- 5 of 8 --
- 6 - dsl dz- 67@MhOgh@2020
daiuhr uksdjhyk vlwu R;kyk #-45]000@& izfregk ixkj vkgs- ijarq]
frus ;k eqnn;koj dks.krkgh dkxnksi=h iqjkok nk[ky dsysyk ukgh- QDr
vtZnkjkP;k dFkuko#u xSjvtZnkj dz-1 ps mRiUu #-45]000@&
vly;kpk fu”d”kZ dk<rk ;s.kkj ukgh- ijarq] xSjvtZnkj dz-1 gk 25 o”kkZpk
vkgs- R;kyk dks.krsgh 'kkfjjhd viaxRo ukgh- rks dks.krkgh dke/kank d#u
izfrekg #-15]000@& rs 20]000@& uDdhp dekow 'kdrks- xSjvtZnkj
dz-1 oj R;kps o;kso`/n ikydkaph tckcnkjh vkgs- xSjvtZnkj dz-1 ps
mRiUu ikgrk] vtZnkjkus ekx.kh dsysyh iksVxhph jDde vokLro okVrs-
loZ ckchapk fopkj djrk] vtZnkjkl frP;k ikyuiks”k.kklkBh #-7]000@&
izfrekg feG.ks U;k;ksfpr gksbZy- vtZnkjkus ekx.kh dsysys uqdlku
HkjikbZckcr dks.krkgh lcG iqjkok fnysyk ukgh R;keqGs lnjhy ekx.kh
eatwj djrk ;s.kkj ukgh- vtZnkj iksVxh o laj{k.k vkns'k feG.;kl ik=
vkgs- vtZ va'kr% eatqj gks.;kl ik= vkgs- ifj.kkeh eqnnk dz-1 o 2 ps
mRrj gksdkjkFkhZ o eqn~nk dz-3 ps mRrj udkjkFkhZ ns.;kr ;sr vkgs- eqn~nk
dz-4 ps mRrjklkBh [kkyhy izek.ks vkns'k ikfjr dj.;kr ;sr vkgs-
vkns'k
v- vtZ va'kr% eatwj dj.;kr ;sr vkgs-
c- xSjvtZnkjkauh vtZnkj fo:/n dlY;kgh izdkjs
dkSVqafcd fgalkpkj u dj.;kps vkns'khr
dj.;kr ;srs-
d- xSjvtZnkj dz-1 us vtZnkjkl vtZ nk[ky
dsY;kP;k rkj[ksiklwu frP;k mnjfuokZgklkBh
izfrekg #-7]000@& ¼#- lkr gtkj QDr-½
iksVxh ns.;kps vknsf'kr dj.;kr ;sr vkgs-
M- lnjhy vkns'kkph izr nksUgha i{kkauk foukeqY;
ns.;kr ;koh-
-- 6 of 8 --
- 7 - dsl dz- 67@MhOgh@2020
b- [kpkZckcr dks.krsgh vkns'k ukghr-
¼fu- v- ljksfl;k½
fn- 17-11-2022 egkuxj naMkf/kdkjh]
71 os U;k;ky;] ckanzk] eqacbZ
aan/
-- 7 of 8 --
- 8 - dsl dz- 67@MhOgh@2020
-- 8 of 8 --