Final Order 2

Order Details: Copy of Judgment
Pdf Text: U;k;fu.kZ; 1 dsl ua-17@Mh-Ogh-@2023
;’kksnk fo- lVokth o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&000833&2023
nk[ky rkjh[k &01@02@2023
uksan rkjh[k &02@02@2023
fudky rkjh[k &15@09@2025
dkyko/kh & o”kZs efgus fnol
02 07 14
fu'kk.kh dz-15
izFke oxZ U;k;naMkf/kdkjh] 12 os U;k;ky;] ckanzk] eqacbZ
;kaps U;k;ky;
¼fiBklhu U;k;k/kh’k % Jh- fxjh’k ,l- ekus½
(J.O.Code-MH2069)
dsl uacj & 17@Mh-Ogh-@2023
¼lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&000833&2023½
U;k;fu.kZ;
;’kksnk lVokth tksxnudj]
o; % 59 o”ksZ] O;olk; % x`fg.kh]
jk- ,@405] pkSFkk etyk] f’koe fl-,p-,l-]
vks-,u-th-lh- fcYMhax leksj] /kkjkoh] eqacbZ- ------- vtZnkj
fo#n~/k
1- lVokth tksxnudj]
o; % 67 o”ksZ] O;olk; % O;olk;]
2- feuk lVokth tksxnudj]
o; % 42 o”ksZ] O;olk; % x`fg.kh]
nks?ks jk- [kksyh dz-6] CykWd dz-2] vkuan uxj]
VªkfU>V dWEi] /kkjkoh] eqacbZ- ------- xSjvtZnkj
-- 1 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 2 dsl ua-17@Mh-Ogh-@2023
;’kksnk fo- lVokth o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&000833&2023
================================================
vtZnkjkrQsZ fof/kK & Jh- fguy la?koh
xSjvtZnkjkrQsZ fof/kK & fujad
================================================
U;k;fu.kZ;
(?kksf”kr fnukad 15 lIVsacj 2025)
vtZnkj fgus xSjvtZnkj ;kapsfo#n~/k dkSVaqfcd fgalkpkjkiklqu
efgykaps laj{k.k vf/kfu;e 2005 ps dye 12 izek.ks izLrqr izdj.k
nk[ky dsys vkgs-
2- vtZnkjkps dFku FkksMD;kr iq<hyizek.ks &
vtZnkj gh xSjvtZnkj dz-1 ph iRuh vkgs- vtZnkj o
xSjvtZnkj dz-1 ;kapk fookg lqekjs pkj n’kdkaiqohZ >kyk- lq#okrhl
lalkj dkghlk lqjGhr vlY;kps Hkklr gksrs- ek= dkykarjkus xSjvtZnkj
dz-1 ;kus vtZnkjkl lrr ‘kkjhfjd] ekufld o Hkkofud =kl ns.;kl
lq#okr dsyh- rks fryk fdjdksG dkj.kkao#u f’kohxkG] ekjgk.k rlsp
tcjnLrhus ySafxd laca/k ykn.ks] v’;k izdkjs NG djhr vls-
3- ;k oSokfgd ukR;krwu lkr eqyh tUekl vkY;k- vtZnkjkus
lalkj fVdfo.;kpk iz;Ru dsyk] ijarw xSjvtZnkj dz-1 ;kus nql&;k
L=h’kh ¼xSjvtZnkj dz-2 lkscr½ fookgln`’k laca/k izLFkkfir d#u fryk ?
kjkr vk.kys- R;keqGs vtZnkjkpk vieku f'kxsyk iksgkspyk- v[ksjhl lu
2007&08 e/;s xSjvtZnkj dz-1 o R;kP;k vkbZus dks.krsgh oS/k dkj.k
ulrkuk vtZnkjkl lkr eqyhalg ?kjkckgsj gkdywu fnys-
-- 2 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 3 dsl ua-17@Mh-Ogh-@2023
;’kksnk fo- lVokth o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&000833&2023
4- R;kuarj vtZnkjkl eqyhalg irhP;k ?kjhp vkJ; ?;kok
ykxyk- lektkrhy lkr eqyhalg ,dVh L=h nqljhdMs dqBs tkbZy] ;k
fHkrheqGs xSjvtZnkj dz-1 us vk{ksi ?ksryk ukgh] i.k R;kus vtZnkj o
eqyhaP;k mnjfuokZgkoj ,d #i;kgh [kpZ dsyk ukgh-
5- vf’kf{kr vlY;kus vtZnkjkl dks.krhgh fLFkj uksdjh
feGkyh ukgh- mnjfuokZgklkBh frus eksyetqjh] HkkaMh ?kkl.ks] eksydjh.k
Eg.kwu dke dj.ks] eqykauk ‘kkGsrwu vk.kwu ns.ks v’kk NksV;keksB;k
dkekaoj voyacwu jkgkos ykxys- eqyhaP;k f’k{k.kklkBh] nSuafnu [kpkZlkBh
frus okjaokj dtZ ?ksrys- rjhlq/nk frus eqyhauk ofMykaiklwu rksMys ukgh]
ek= xSjvtZnkj dz-1 ;kus eqykadMs dks.krsgh izse ok vkiqydh nk[koyh
ukgh- vktP;k ?kMhyk vtZnkjklkscr rhu eqyh jkgrkr- vpZuk irhP;k
e`R;quarj fo/kok >kyh- lkljdMwu gkdy.;kr vkY;kuarj rh vYIko;hu
eqyklg frP;kdMs jkgrs- rh eqacbZP;k Vªsue/;s diMs fodwu eqykyk ikslrs-
fdj.k lkljP;k ?kjxqrh NGkeqGs frP;k lkscr jkgrs- fiz;k lokZr ygku
vfookfgr eqyxh] frP;k lkscr jkgrs- moZfjr pkj eqyh fookfgr vlwu
izlaxh frP;kdMs ;srkr- vtZnkjkps vkjksX; lkrR;kus [kkykor xsys vkgs-
fn?kZdkG mis{kk o ekufld rk.kkeqGs fryk mPp jDrnkc o brj vktkj
>kys vlwu 2017 iklwu oS|dh; [kpZ eksB;k izek.kkr ok<ys vkgsr-
oS|dh; dkxni=s vtkZlkscr tksMysyh vkgsr-
6- ;k myV xSjvtZnkj dz-1 gk vkfFkZdn`”V;k laiUu vkgs- rks
vpZuk ,aVjizk;>sl ;k ukokus gkreksts r;kj dj.;kpk O;olk; djrks-
R;kus Lor%P;k o xSjvtZnkj dz-2 P;k ukokoj vusd LFkkoj ekyeRrk
[kjsnh dsY;k vkgsr- mejxk ;sFks R;kyk eksBs ‘ksr vlwu fidkaP;k
mRiUukrwu rks Hkjiwj jDde dekorks- rks ,sÜo;Ziq.kZ thou txr vkgs- rj
-- 3 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 4 dsl ua-17@Mh-Ogh-@2023
;’kksnk fo- lVokth o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&000833&2023
vtZnkj o frP;k eqyh nkfjnz;kr o vlqjf{krrsr fnol dk<r vkgsr-
7- vtZnkjkus vusd osGk iqUgk lkljh tk.;kpk iz;Ru dsyk]
ek= izR;sd osGh fryk viekfur d#u] ykFkkcqDD;kauh ekjgk.k d#u
gkdy.;kr vkys-
8- vtZnkjkpk [kpkZpk ri’khy %
vtZnkjkP;k nSuafnu mnjfuokZgklkBh o eqyhaP;k laxksiuklkBh
njegk eksBk [kpZ djkok ykxrks- rks [kkyhyizek.ks vkgs %
v- ?kj[kpZ] vUu] oL=] fuokjk % #-20]000@& izfr efguk
c- vtZnkjkpk oS|dh; [kpZ % #-10]000@& izfr efguk
d- eqyhaps brj [kpZ ¼f’k{k.k] nSuafnu vko’;d xjtk] ns[kHkky½ % #-
10]000@& izfr efguk
M- oht [kpZ % #-2]000@& izfr efguk
,dw.k ekfld [kpZ % #-42]000@&
gk loZ [kpZ vtZnkj Lor%P;k d”Vkrwu] NksV;keksB;k dkekaoj o
yksdkadMwu ?ksrysY;k dtkZoj Hkkxors- xSjvtZnkj dz-1 dMwu fryk d/khgh
vkfFkZd enr feGkysyh ukgh-
9- laiq.kZ oSokfgd vk;q”;kr vtZnkjkl lrr ‘kkfjjhd]
ekufld] Hkkofud o vkfFkZd NG lgu djkok ykxyk- frpk
vkRelUeku rqMfo.;kr vkyk] fryk ?kjkrwu gkdy.;kr vkys] lkr
eqyhaps laxksiu iq.kZi.ks frP;k [kkan;koj Vkd.;kr vkys- ;keqGs frps
vkjksX; fc?kMys vlwu vkt rh nkfjnz;] vktkji.k o vlqjf{krrsr
fnol dk<r vkgs- nqljhdMs xSjvtZnkj dz-1 gk laiUu vlwu O;olk;]
-- 4 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 5 dsl ua-17@Mh-Ogh-@2023
;’kksnk fo- lVokth o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&000833&2023
‘ksrh o ekyeRrsrwu eksBs mRiUu feGowu lq[kh thou txr vkgs-
ifj.kkeh vtZnkj fgus gs izdj.k nk[ky d#u [kkyh ueqn dsY;kizek.ks
fofo/k ekx.;k dsY;k vkgsr-
10- xSjvtZnkj gs xSjgtj jkfgY;keqGs fnukad 08-06-2023 P;k
vkns’kkuqlkj lnj izdj.k R;kaP;k fo#/n ,drQkZ pkyfo.;kr vkys vkgs-
11- vtZnkj ;kauh dsysyh oknkrhr dFkus] miyC/k iqjkok]
dkSVqafcd fgalkpkjkiklqu efgykaps laj{k.k vf/kfu;e 2005 e/khy rjrqnh
;ko#u ek>s fopkjkFkZ [kkyhy eqn~ns fu”iUu >kys- eh lnj eq|kaps
dkj.kfeekalslg fu”d”kZ [kkyhyizek.ks uksanfor vkgs &
v-dz- eq|s fu”d”kZ
1- vTkZnkj fgP;koj xSjvtZnkj ;kauh dkSVqafcd
fgalkpkj dsyk vls vtZnkjus 'kkchr dsys
vkgs dk;\
gksdkjkFkhZ
2- vtZnkjkuh dsysY;k ekx.;k eatqj gks.ksl ik=
vkgsr dk\
va’kr% gksdkjkFkhZ
3- vkns'k dk;\ vtZ va’kr% eatqj
dj.;kr ;srks-
dkj.kfeekalk
12- vtZnkj fgus frP;k dFkukaP;k iq”V;FkZ Lor%pk rksaMh iqjkok
fu- dz-11 yk lknj dsyk vkgs- xSjvtZnkj ;kauh rksaMh iqjkok lknj dsyk
ulY;keqGs fnukad 26-06-2024 P;k vkns’kkUo;s R;kapk iqjkok can
-- 5 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 6 dsl ua-17@Mh-Ogh-@2023
;’kksnk fo- lVokth o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&000833&2023
dj.;kr vkyk vkgs-
13- vtZnkj rQsZ fo}ku fof/kKkapk rksaMh ;qfDrokn ,sd.;kr
vkyk- rlsp vtZnkj i{kdkjkekQZr nk[ky dsysyk ys[kh ;qfDrokn
voyksdu dsyk- xSjvtZnkj ;kaP;k ekQZr ;qDrhokn lknj dj.;kr vkyk
ukgh-
eqnn~k dz- 1 dfjrk
14- vtZnkj ;kauh rksaMh iqjkO;ke/;s vtkZe/khy ueqn dkSVqafcd
fgalkpkjkph iqujko`Rrh dsyh vkgs- xSjvtZnkj ;kauh vtZnkj ;kapk
myVrikl ?ksrysyk ukgh- R;keqGs vtZnkj ;kapk rksaMh iqjkok fo’oklkl
ik= Bjyk vkgs- ;kmyV xSjvtZnkj ;kauh vtZnkjkP;k vtkZl ys[kh mRrj
fnys ukgh] rlsp R;kapk rksaMh iqjkok fnyk ukgh- ifj.kkeh vtZnkj ;kauh
xSjvtZnkj ;kaP;k fo#/n dsysys dkSVqafcd fgalkpkjkph dFkus fo’okluh;
okVrkr- lcc] xSjvtZnkj ;kauh vtZnkj fgP;koj dkSVqafcd fgalkpkj dsyk
vkgs gs fl/n gksrs- lcc] eq|k dz-1 pk fu”d”kZ eh gksdkjkFkhZ uksanor
vkgs-
eqnn~k dz-2 dfjrk
15- xSjvtZnkj ;kauh vtZnkj fgP;k fo#/n dkSVqafcd fgalkpkjkps
d`R; d# u;s] v’kh ekx.kh vtZnkj ;kauh dsyh vkgs- xSjvtZnkj o
vtZnkj gs ,dkp ?kjkr ,d= jgkr gksrs gs vtZnkj ;kaP;k rksaMh iqjkO;k
vk/kkjs fl/n >kys vkgs- xSjvtZnkj ;kauh vtZnkjk oj dkSVaqfcd fgalkpkj
dsyk vkgs vls fl/n >kys vkgs- v'kk ifjfLFkrhr dkSVqafcd fgalkp-
kjkiklwu efgykaps laj{k.k vf/kfu;eke/khy dye 18 ¼v½ o ¼c½ uqlkj
xSjvtZnkj ;kauh vtZnkj fgpsoj dks.kR;kgh izdkjpk dkSVaqfcd fgalkpkj
-- 6 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 7 dsl ua-17@Mh-Ogh-@2023
;’kksnk fo- lVokth o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&000833&2023
d# u;s o rls dj.;kl dks.kkykgh lgk¸; fdaok izo`Rr d# u;s] vlk
vkns'k ikjhr dj.ks U;k;ksfpr okVrs-
16- xSjvtZnkj ;kauh vtZnkj fgpk ekufld o ‘kkfjjhd NG d#
u;s] f’kohxkG d# u;s ;k ckcr R;kauh ,d djkj fygwu n;kok v’kh
ekx.kh vtZnkjkus dsyh vkgs- xSjvtZnkjkus vtZnkjkpk dkSVqafcd fgalkpkj
d# u;s vlk vkns’k eatqj gks.ksl ik= vkgs o R;kdjhrk xSjvtZnkjkauh
dks.krkgh djkj fygwu ns.;kph vko’;drk ukgh- R;keqGs vtZnkjkph gh
ekx.kh eatqj gks.;kl ik= ukgh-
17- xSjvtZnkjkus ?kj dz-,@405 ;k ?kjkrwu fryk gdyw u;s]
frps vlysys okLrO;kl gjdr vMFkGk d# u;s] v’kh vtZnkjkus
ekx.kh dsyh vkgs- dkSVqafcd fgalkpkjkiklwu efgykaps laj{k.k vf/kfu;e
e/khy rjrqnhuqlkj v’kh ekx.kh eatqj gks.;kl ik= vkgs-
18- xSjvtZnkjkus oj ueqn ?kj fodw u;s] rlsp xko mejxk]
eqGt ;sFkhy feGdrh fodw u;sr] R;k feGdrhr fr&gkbZr O;Drhpk
gDd fuekZ.k d# u;s v’kh ekx.kh vtZnkjkus dsyh vkgs- ,d=
dqVqackP;k izR;sd lnL;kyk ekyeRrk gLrkarj vf/kfu;e e/khy rjrqnh
uqlkj ,d= dqVqackP;k fdaok ofMyksikftZr feGdrhe/khy R;kpk vfoHkDr
fgLlk R;kyk fodzh dj.;kl dk;ns’khj gDd vkgs- rlsp ,d=
dqVqackP;k lnL;kus v’kk feGdrhe/khy R;kpk fgLlk fodw u;s vlk
eukbZ vkns’k djrk ;sr ukgh- R;keqGs gh ekx.kh eatqj djrk ;s.kkj ukgh-
19- vtZnkj fgus frP;k djhrk #-50]000@& izfr efguk o
nksu eqykaP;k djhrk #-42]000@& izfr efguk feG.;kl fouarh dsyh
-- 7 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 8 dsl ua-17@Mh-Ogh-@2023
;’kksnk fo- lVokth o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&000833&2023
vkgs- rFkkfi] xSjvtZnkj dz-1 ;kps rso<s mRiUu vkgs ;k ckcr dkxnksi=h
iqjkok fnlwu ;sr ukgh- rlsp eqys 18 o”ksZ [kkyh vkgsr vls lq/nk fnlwu
;sr ukgh- R;keqGs brD;k jDdesph ekx.kh eatqj djrk ;s.kkj ukgh-
rFkkfi] xSjvtZnkj dz-1 ;kaps o; ikgrk rks vtZnkj fgyk izfr efguk #-
10]000@& frP;k mnjfuokZgkdjhrk nsow ‘kdrks vls eyk okVrs-
20- vtZnkjkus fryk >kysY;k ekufld o ‘kkfjjhd NGkckcr
xSjvtZnkdMwu #-10]00]000@& uqdlku HkjikbZ ekfxryh vkgs-
xSjvtZnkj ;kps mRiUu ikgrk o vtZnkjkus fryk >kysY;k NGkckcr
iqjkO;kr ekU; gks.ksl ik= oS|dh; dkxni= nk[ky dsys ulY;keqGs]
dsoG frP;k rksaMh iqjkO;k vk/kkjs xSjvtZnkj dz-1 us fryk uqdlku HkjikbZ
#-50]000@& ns.;kph ekx.kh eatqj gks.;kl ik= vkgs-
21- ifj.kkeh eh ;k eqn~n;kpk fu”d”kZ va’kr% gksdkjkFkhZ uksanfor
vkgs-
eqnn~k dz-3 dfjrk
22- eqn~nk dz-1 pk fu”d”kZ gksdkjkFkhZ o eqn~nk dz-2 pk fu”d”kZ
va’kr% gksdkjkFkhZ vlY;keqGs izLrqrpk vtZ va’kr% eatqj gks.;kl ik=
vkgs- lcc] eh [kkyhy vkns'k ikfjr djhr vkgs %
vkns'k
1- vtZ va’kr% eatqj dj.;kr ;srks-
2- xSjvtZnkj ;kauh vtZnkj fgpsoj dkSVqafcd fgalkpkjkps
dks.krsgh d`R; d# u;s-
-- 8 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 9 dsl ua-17@Mh-Ogh-@2023
;’kksnk fo- lVokth o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&000833&2023
3- xSjvtZnkj ;kauh dk;ns’khj izfdz;spk voyac dsY;k
f’kok; ?kj dz- ,@405] pkSFkk etyk] f’koe fl-,p-,l-] vks-,u-th-
lh- fcYMhax leksj] /kkjkoh] eqacbZ e/khy vtZnkj ;kaP;k jfgoklkl]
okLrO;kl gjdr fdaok vMFkGk d# u;s o vtZnkjkl ;k ?kjkrwu
tcjnLrhus ckgsj gdyow u;s-
4- vtZ nk[ky rkjh[k iklwu xSjvtZnkj dz-1 ;kus vtZnkj
fgP;k mnjfuokZgklkBh #-10]000@& izfr efguk fryk n;kosr-
5- xSjvtZnkj dz-1 ;kus vtZnkj ;kauk vkt iklwu ,d
efgU;kP;k vkr #-50]000@& uqdlku HkjikbZ n;koh-
6- vtkZrhy vU; ekx.;k QsVkG.;kr ;srkr-
7- lnj U;k;fu.kZ;kph izr vtZnkj] xSjvtZnkj] lacaf/kr iksyhl
Bk.;kps vf/kdkjh] laj{k.k vf/kdkjh ;kauk fouk'kqYd ns.;kr ;koh-
¼U;k;fu.kZ; [kqY;k U;k;ky;kr Vadfy[khr o ?kksf”kr
dj.;kr vkyk-½
¼fxjh'k lq- ekus½
izFke oxZ U;k;naMkf/kdkjh]
fnukad % 15-09-2025 12 os U;k;ky;] ckanzk] eqacbZ
Jqrys[ku fnukad % 15-09-2025
izfrys[ku fnukad % 15-09-2025
Lok{kjh fnukad % 15-09-2025
-- 9 of 10 --
U;k;fu.kZ; 10 dsl ua-17@Mh-Ogh-@2023
;’kksnk fo- lVokth o brj
lh-,u-vkj-ua- ,e-,p-,e-,e-18&000833&2023
izek.ki=
Ekh izfrKsoj dFku djrks dh] ;k ihMh,Q U;k;fu.kZ;krhy loZ ‘kCn
eqG U;k;fu.kZ;kizek.ks vkgsr-
Yk?kqys[kdkps uko lathouh _f”kds’k ijc
U;k;ky; izFke oxZ U;k;naMkf/kdkjh]
12 os U;k;ky;] ckanzk] eqacbZ-
U;k;fu.kZ; ?kksf”kr dj.;kpk fnukad 15-09-2025
U;k;kfu.kZ;koj Lok{kjh dsY;kph
fnukad
15-09-2025
U;k;fu.kZ; viyksM dsY;kpk fnukad 29-09-2025
-- 10 of 10 --