Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 01 Dec 2022 · CNR MHMM160021542020
Order Details: copy of Order Pdf Text: i VIKHROLI, MUMBAI OF 2020 S.C.C. NO. ... Complainant V/s. i) 2) 6A)/l 3) 4) 5) Ti Parsiwadi, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - 400 086. Mr. Gaikar Chandrakant Shrirang Indian Inhabitant, Adult, Aged about 45 years, Occupation : Service, Working as Assistant Teacher In Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - 400 086. R/at Room No.B-505, B-Wing, Gajanand Samrudhi, Bhanushali Nagar, Khadegolavali Gaon, Vithalwadi, Kalyan (W) Abhuday Dnyanvardhani Sanstha Through its President / Secretary, Having office at Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - 400 086. The Headmaster Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi,’Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - 400 086. Shri Mahesh Kisan Karale The Secretary, Abhuday Dnyanvardhani Sanstha Having office at Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - 400 086. Shri Rohidas Govindrao Huie The President, Abhuday Dnyanvardhani Sanstha Having office at Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - 400 086. Smt. Alka Rohidas Huie Member - Trustee, Abhuday Dnyanvardhani Sanst IN THE COURT OF METROPOLITAN MAGISTRATE? Another Address: Peon in Abhyuday Vidyalaya, l?n _ o 1 Cdb-J -- 1 of 12 -- 2 -1- «- 6) 7) 8) 9) 10) 11) ‘•Smt. Mrurial Tushar Huie Member - Trustee, Abhuday Dnyanvardhani Sanstha Having office at Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - 400 086. Smt. Kalpana Ramkrishna Gawande Member - Trustee, Abhuday Dnyanvardhani Sanstha Having office at Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi, Ghatkopar (W), Another Address: Clerk (Primary Section) Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - 400 086. Another Address: Assistant Teacher in Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - 400 086. Shri Rahul Rohidas Huie Member - Trustee, Abhuday Dnyanvardhani Sanstha Having office at Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - 400 086. Smt. Anita Dnyandev Gunjal Member - Trustee, Abhuday Dnyanvardhani Sanstha Having office at Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - 400 086. Shri Tushar Rohidas Huie Member - Trustee, Abhuday Dnyanvardhani Sanstha Having office at Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - 400 086. Shri Harishchandra Kondaji Pingale Member - Trustee, Abhuday Dnyanvardhani Sanstha Having office at Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - .400 086. Another Address: Clerk in Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - 400 086. Having office at Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - 400 086. -- 2 of 12 -- 3 Mumbai - 400 086. 4 13) 14) ... Accused PRIVATE OF EMPLOYEES OF (CONDITIONS SCHOOLS REGULATION ACT, THEREUNDER. MAY IT PLEASE YOUR HONOUR: The Complainant abovenamed begs to submit, as under: The Complainant submits that the Complainant is working 1) i.e. the Accused No.2, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - 400 086, which is run by the Abhuday Dnyanvardhani Sanstha, the Accused No.l, office at Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi, 400 086. Abhyuday Vidyalaya, is Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai hereinafter referred as SERVICE) 1977 AND RULES 1981 FRAMED Another Address: Assistant Teacher in Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - 400 086. Shri Laxman Kondiba Deshmukh The Headmaster, Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - 400 086. The Education Inspector, Brihanmumbai, Northern Zone, Chembur, Mumbai - 400 071. IN THE MATTER OF COMPLAINT U/S.13 OF THE MAHARASHTRA “Said School” for the sake of brevity. The Deputy Director, Mumbai Region, Mumbai, Jawahar Bal Bhavan, Netaji Subhash Marg, Charni Road Mumbai (W) - 400 004. as an Assistant Teacher in Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi -- 3 of 12 -- 4 Abhuday Dnyanvardhani Sanstha is hereinafter referred as 2) The Complainant submits that the Accused No.3 is the President Of the Accused No.l and the Accused No.4 is the Secretary of the Accused No.l. The Complainant further states that the Accused No.5 to 11 are the Members - Trustees of the said Management and the Accused No. 12 is the Headmaster of the Accused No.2. The Complainant further submits that some of the members/trustees are also working in the school, therefore, their another address is shown alongwith their designation in the school. The responsible and in charge of the day-to-day conduct of the business / affairs of the said Trust as well as said School. 3) Appeal being No.7/2018 before the Hon’ble Presiding Officer, School Tribunal, Mumbai Region, Mumbai, thereby challenging Order of Termination dated 23/02/2018 issued by the Accused No.4 being Secretary of the Accused No.l, thereby terminating the services of the Complainant from the post of Assistant Teacher w.e.f. 24/02/2018, on the various grounds & reliefs as more particularly enumerated in the said appeal. The Complainant submits that the said Trust/Management as well as School, have appeared before the Hon’ble Tribunal also filed their Say/Written Statement in the said Appeal. 4) The Complainant submits that after hearing all the parties, the Hon’ble Presiding Officer, School Tribunal, Mumbai, by its Judgment and Order dated 26/02/2019 has been i(Said Trust /Management” for the sake of brevity. preferred an Complainant submits that, thus, all of the Accused are The Complainant submits that the Complainant has -- 4 of 12 -- 5 pleased to quash and set aside the decision of Management of terminating service of the Complainant and pass the following order, the Operative Part of the Order is reproduced herein-below: 1. The present appeal is hereby allowed; 2. The impugned order dated 23/02/2018 of the fresh inquiry directed, is hereby quashed and set aside; 3. In view of the reinstatement of the appellant already effected and withdrawl of impugned order of termination, no express order is needed but the appellant be reinstated notionally with continuity and w.e.f 18/10/2014; 4. Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 shall pay full back wages to the appellant from 18/10/2014 to 31/07/2017 as claimed for within six months of pronouncement of this judgment; 5. Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 shall also pay Rs. 25 thousands each as the compensatory costs to the appellant. Pronounced in open court Sd/- “ORDER termination of the services of the appellant on February 26, 2019 (Maneesh Nanabhau Phatangare) Presiding Officer, School Tribunal, Mumbai.” benefits in ■ service -- 5 of 12 -- 6 The Complainant submits that from the above Judgment 5) and Order dated 26/02/2019, it is very much clear that the Management has to comply with the order within six months from the date of the order i.e. on or before 25/08/2019, however, till date, the Management, has not complied with the same. The Complainant further states that by his letter dated 28/02/2019, the Complainant, by annexing the copy of the Judgment dated 26/02/2019 has requested with the Judgment dated comply Management to 26/02/2019, however, till date, the Management has not complied with the and thus, of the same Management is contemptuous in nature. The Complainant further that though the 6) states Management has filed Writ Petition being No.9966/2019, however, till date, there is no stay operating against the Judgment and Order dated 26/02/2019, therefore, as such, the same is executable in nature. The Complainant further states that except filing of the writ petition, no further visible steps have been taken by the Management and, thus, a smoke screen is being created by filing of writ petition in order to deny and deprive the Complainant of his legitimate right given under the Judgment dated 26/02/2019. The Complainant submits that the Complainant, therefore, 7) by his Advocate’s Notice dated 06/01/2020 has called upon all the Accused to comply with- the Judgment dated 26/02/2019, however, the Management has given evasive, vague and baseless reply and, thus, the Accused are not at Judgment dated all interest in compliance of the 26/02/2019. the act -- 6 of 12 -- 7 8) The Complainant submits that since all the Accused No.3 to 12 are functioning of the said Trust / Management/School and all the Accused are, thus, willfully and deliberately defying & disobeying the orders of the Hon’ble Tribunal and, thus, all contempt of the Court. The Complainant further states that the order of the Hon’ble Tribunal is very clear in sense, however, the Management is not complying with the same. The Complainant submits that since the Accused are not complying the order / direction issued by the Hon’ble Tribunal in its Judgment dated 26/02/2019, therefore, the Complainant is entitled to invoke his remedies as available Schools Maharashtra Employees of Private under the (Conditions of Service) Regulation Act, 1977 and Rules 1981 framed thereunder as well as under the relevant provisions of law thereby seeking compliance of the Judgment dated 26/02/2019. The Complainant submits that Section 13 of the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Regulation Act, 1977, is penal in nature, which provides for imprisonment, in the event the direction / order of the Hon’ble Tribunal is not complied and in the instant issued by the Hon’ble Tribunal in its Judgment dated also liable to be of the Maharashtra prosecuted and punished u/s.13 (Conditions of Service) Schools Employees of Private Regulation Act, 1977 and Rules 1981 framed thereunder and hence, this complaint. -s 26/02/2019, therefore, all the Accused are case, the Accused are not complying the order / direction the Accused have rendered themselves liable for the responsible for the conduct and day-to-day -- 7 of 12 -- 8 The Complainant submits that the Accused are deliberately 9) and willfully defying and disobeying the Judgment of the Hon’ble Tribunal dated 26/02/2019, as aforesaid, and thus all are showing no respect or regard to the orders of the The Complainant submits that since all Hon’ble Tribunal. the Accused are defying and disobeying the Judgment/order of the Hon’ble Tribunal, therefore, all the Accused are liable for punishment of the imprisonment as prescribed in Section (Conditions of Service) Regulation Act, 1977. The Complainant further submits that the Complainant by 10) his Advocate Notice dated 06/01/2020 has also called upon the Accused No. 13 & 14 for ensuring compliance of the Order and Judgment dated 26/02/2019 passed by the Hon’ble Tribunal in Appeal No.7/2018 the Management, however, despite receipt of the Notice, the Accused No. 13 & 14 have neither replied with the notice nor complied with the notice. U) The Complainant submits that since the Accused No. 13 8s 14 School and since the Accused No. 13 8s 14 were also party Respondents in the Appeal, therefore, the Accused No.l 3 8s 14 are duty bound to see the direction of the Hon’ble Tribunal are complied in its true letter and spirit. The Complainant submits that the Accused No.l 3 8s 14 are also vested with the powers to compel the Management to comply under legal obligation to see that the orders / directions of the Hon’ble Tribunal are being executed in its true letter and with the Orders of the Hon’ble Tribunal and further they are are supervising and controlling authorities over the said 13 of the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools -- 8 of 12 -- 9 sprit, however, it seems that the Accused No. 13 &> 14 are least bothered about the same, and thus, the Accused No. 13 & 14 are also defying and disobeying the orders of the Hon’ble Tribunal. The Complainant submits that in order to see that the order of the Hon’ble Tribunal is implemented and executed, the Accused No. 13 & 14 are vested with substantial powers of taking stringent and strong action against the erring Management, including the power to de recognize the school, however, the Accused No. 13 & 14 are not taking any action, on the contrary, the Accused No. 13 & 14 are witnessing the defiance and disobedience of the Judgment dated 26/02/2019 as a mute spectator, therefore, the Accused No. 13 & 14 are also liable to be prosecuted for the contempt of the Hon’ble Tribunal and they are also liable Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Regulation Act, 1977 and Rules 1981 framed thereunder. The Complainant submits that the Judgment was passed by 12) the Hon’ble Tribunal on 26/02/2019 in Appeal No.7/2018 and the period for compliance of the Judgment expired on Petition No.9966/2019, however, till date such, limitation for filing of criminal 13) 25/08/2019 and though the Management has preferred Writ no stay has been 25/08/2019 and again on granted, therefore, as proceedings started after 25/08/2019 and the limitation is being continued and hence, the complaint filed on today is period of six months expired on 06/01/2020 when the Complainant issued notice to all the to be punished u/s.13 of the Maharashtra Employees of well the period of limitation of one year. The cause of action for filing of the complaint arose when the -- 9 of 12 -- 10 Accused and again on when the Accused replied and again on each and every date when the Accused have not obeyed the judgment of the Hon’ble Tribunal and, thus, the cause of action is continuous in nature. 14) The Complainant submits that the Complainant is working Accused No.2, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - 400 086, and office of the Abhuday Dnyanvardhani Sanstha, the Accused No.l, is situated at Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi, Ghatkopar (W), Mumbai - 400 086, the Accused are also from Mumbai and they are members of the said Trust, moreover, the Accused at Ghatkopar and the defiance has been committed by the Accused at Ghatkopar, within the jurisdiction of this Hon’ble Court and, hence, this Hon’ble Court has jurisdiction to try and entertain the present complaint. 15) The Complainant also craves the leave to add the further documents, 16) The Complainant shall examine the following witnesses: a) The Complainant himself. b) Any other and further witness with the leave of the Court. 17) The Complainant, therefore, prays:- PRAYERS a) that this Hon’ble Court be pleased to issue the process against all the Accused for the offences U/S.13 of the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Regulation Act, 1977 and as and when necessary. as Assistant Teacher Abhyuday Vidyalaya, Parsiwadi, the Judgment dated 26/02/2019 was to be complied by the -- 10 of 12 -- 11 Rules 1981 framed thereunder, and punish them according to law; b) Any 'other and further relief be granted in favour of the Complainant for which she is entitled to. That such an order shall be in the interest of justice. SIGNATURE OF THE COMPLAINANT VERIFICATION I, Gaikar Chandrakant Shrirang, Aged about 45 years, the Complainant abovenamed, do hereby state on solemn affirmation that whatever stated hereinabove is true and correct to the best of knowledge and belief. Solemnly affirmed at Vikhroli on 4th day of March, 2020. SIGNATURE7OF COMPLAINANT ADVOCATE FOR COMPLAINANT i O’ rep \ FILED IN THE COURT ON 05^03/2020 -- 11 of 12 -- ctU-ci (2. O ^77«3< yvsQvm ^■WW--S7S1 ' ' Xui U^aAoU-^- Q x ^2-^® <F^(T K' “/ <£-e'^e'n<C( CW5f \7 I , <- s ^pbc^oI b. j 4 (x~>e dwv "Tr® . <0^ vs Yus ^sVtv^Hd _ QTS'Pctf' V > tsW s M J 4a & ■ Gs?^ - V®seftS> -fk4 ' ohJI^ Y^msG a^ •^uP<^q3^- <y(Z' ce^c A J) JYOV~ (WW Vuste# ALc4^®r|. 4u w^a A 4bl|r,H n i V fW_> OVcfhcimkH ^yiploj^7 sy<cj\- j.s^^^y- fji.'m n® <^6p|7j3(^ fs ftlsSg- ) ^'TVU'x'^^ ^Td(VA^LZ^ ) .aiJ'T /V4’4c<® C^pIto’lWJ^ v'0^ cy s' e/ 4(Ys^plc w ^1 a tlO' cmc<A) CMppeA 4 4e RJ- Y<5> A oU rf^e. QcxWpl VtCACy^g^O c) Se^WeA r C '• Cc6 o\£> VS c|ofu piZiyfO T^A Qp)firr^\ QiJ ^0,', ^6 H-eor^ £ IA Sc _ . -ScKcj® I' r^pVod ^-o*, d0'2®^! i ’ \ ( ^-yusAs A ysS« W boot J fete® AX^z, d _ A k ro^ 'h X- QxS fof0-" VGebd J 'pYx'^o^ev (y>' Vy® C0>xp^ 1 & V CdxCCY Z SohMSCC^r’^ cz - —- ikkWf’ w ■ Me 0®\h- WW* I ^sj2i j vk'AI —- - . V-W axY'Y MraccoY 4k ^rpd c^tq\c^_3 J k S *4 4'S€.QsA4 OC.'A ay 1 Yit'S'V gB:te i.M'Y'fc’^SUj 4 a Akk® ■ ' cMwV Wi *0 vS ^-y' ycA5 c LLy-^z - \w vu 9m w4 H 9^9 o -- 12 of 12 --
