Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 04 Jan 2025 · CNR MHMM150081772024
Pdf Text: 1 IN THE COURT OF JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE FIRST CLASS (62nd COURT), DADAR, MUMBAI. Appl. No. 6201931/Misc./2024 Surbhi Agrawal V/s. The State of Maharashtra and 08 Others ORDER BELOW EXH. 01 1] The applicant moved present application under Section 497 and 503 of Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita 2023 and requested to return the amount lying with the accounts mentioned in the application by de- freezing those accounts. 2] Read the application and say. Investigating officer in his reply has given the details of 14 bank accounts which are put on hold/lien and requested to pass necessary order with respect to the amount claimed by the applicant. Whereas Ld. APP requested to pass appropriate order. 3] On perusal of application it transpires that on the inducement of the accused the applicant had transferred the amount of Rs. 10,34,124/- in four different accounts i.e an amount of 4,40,124/- was transferred through RTGS in account No. 43332176911 Current account maintained with State Bank of India Payyanuk ADB, secondly an amount of Rs. 5,00,000/- was transferred through RTGS in account No. 16760100041780 Saving account maintained with Federal Bank Mohali Branch, an amount of Rs. 51,000/- was transferred through UPI payment to UPI ID 8802025265@ptys and Rs. 43,000/- was transferred through UPI payment to UPI ID 99741219508-2@ybl. -- 1 of 6 -- 2 4] Reply of investigating officer shows when the applicant filed online complaint about online fraud committed with her on Cyber helpline No. 1930. Thereafter, with the help of Nodal officer Cyber helpline an amount of Rs. 4,20,467/- has been put of hold/lien in around 14 accounts. Details thereof are as follows Sr. No. Bank Name Bank A/c Amount 1 Indian Overseas Bank 264501000004677 51000/- 2 HDFC 50200085608022 68087/- 3 Unity Small 051320991000412 9981/- 4 Bank of India 445810110011003 233/- 5 State Bank of India 43301350513 203973/- 6 Kotak Mahindra Bank 8445524631 2662/- 7 Equitas Bank 200002668139 216/- 8 State Bank of India 00000036532745760 546/- 9 Canara Bank 5542101001431 24802 10 State Bank of India 00000032109302752 4135/- 11 HDFC Bank 00600310018256 33019/- 12 Bank of Maharashtra 60501834203 12527/- 13 UCO Bank 34910210000700 8700/- 14 UCO Bank 24930110031926 586/- Total 4,20,467/- 5] This itself shows that these are not the accounts in which the -- 2 of 6 -- 3 amount was transferred by the applicant. Only after the complaint is filed by the applicant, above accounts were put on debit freeze. Admittedly it is done through system generated message, these accounts were put on debit freeze. 6] Here since the applicant has claimed the amount from 14 different accounts she will have to prove her better right to get interim order in her favour in respect of the amount lying in those accounts. It can be established by producing the documents to show that the amount lying in those accounts is credited to those accounts once it was debited from the account of the applicant. However, the applicant has not produced any document to show the amount lying in those account was actually debited from her account. Another option which could have been opted for to establish her claim, the banks in which accounts were put on hold could have explained from where the amount was credited in those accounts, whether it was transferred from the account of the applicant. Therefore, applicant made application for seeking permission for amendment and to add the banks as respondents which were mentioned by I.O in his reply dated 08/11/2024. Permission was granted for the same. But, later on the applicant has filed pursis on 19/12/2024 and stated therein that, these are not necessary parties, these account holders are accused and the investigating agency which is an independent agency has concluded after investigation that the amount belongs to the applicant. Therefore, she was not willing to make those Banks as party to present proceeding. 7] Thereafter, this Court has passed an order on Exh. 01 and observed that, as the applicant has sought interim custody of amount but Court has to see prima facie see whether that amount transferred from the account of applicant. Therefore, it is necessary to verify whether such amount lying -- 3 of 6 -- 4 the bank account as per police report is transferred from the account of the applicant. Still Ld. Adv. for the applicant insisted to pass final order as applicant do not want to add those Banks as party. 8] Here it is important to note that it is not the case that after thorough investigation the investigating officer has come to conclusion that amount lying in those Banks belong to the applicant. It is system generated message by which those Bank officials were directed to put these accounts on hold or lien. It was admittedly an ex-parte order. It is not seizure of any other commodity as in other cases, it is an amount which was put on hold. We come across many cases in which several lien orders are passed by different police stations and Bank officials are directed to put the account on lien. In several cases different Courts pass order with respect to same amount at interim stage. Here though the order is passed in the nature of interim custody still there should be prima facie material to show that the amount at present lying with the account belongs to the applicant. But here it has not been happened. 9] No doubt an unfortunate incident had occurred with the applicant however without ascertaining above aspect it will not be just to pass blanket order, without ascertaining whether the amount is there or not, whether any other Court has passed order in respect of same amount, if any other police station asked to put the amount on hold. If later on any rightful claimant claims the amount it would not be easy for him to get the amount once order in respect thereof is passed. So at this initial stage only as a caution it is necessary to ascertain if the amount lying in those account credited to those account after it was debited from the account of the applicant. -- 4 of 6 -- 5 10] Considering the facts and documents on record, it seems, the applicant has reported the fact of cheating with her and on that basis crime was registered mean time those fourteen accounts were put on hold with the help of Cyber Helpline 1930. In such situation it would be just to direct the I.O to ascertain, if the amount lying in those accounts belongs to the applicant and thereafter issue letter to concerned banks to defreeze the accounts and amount be transferred to the account of the applicant. Hence, following order; ORDER 1) The application is allowed as follows. 2) The investigating officer is directed to ascertain if the amount lying in fourteen Banks belongs to the applicant and thereafter issue letter to the concerned banks to defreeze the available amount stated as per those banks and it be transferred in the account of applicant till the conclusion of the trial on executing indemnity bond of same amount available with the banks. 3) The concerned banks are directed to transfer frozen amount lying with respondent banks and transferred in the account of the applicant on furnishing details of her account through the Investigating Officer. 4) The applicant shall deposit an amount stated by respondents banks as well as stated by investigating officer in the Court as and when required. I.O also informed to the Court to submit report after handing -- 5 of 6 -- 6 over the amount to the applicant. 5) The Investigating Officer is directed to produce the indemnity bond and panchanama if any in the court, if charge-sheet filed. (Suhas Vijaya P. Bhosale) Judicial Magistrate First Class Dt: 04/01/2025 62nd Court, Dadar, Mumbai. Grs/- -- 6 of 6 --
