Full Order Text
Interim Order 4 · 07 May 2026 · CNR MHMM140027432022
Order Details: Order below Ex-1 Pdf Text: 1 IN THE COURT OF JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE, FIRST CLASS 40TH COURT, GIRGAON, MUMBAI. C. C. No. 26/SW/2022 -: ORDER BELOW EXH. 1 :- 1. Present complaint is filed for the offence punishable U/Sec.465, 467, 468, 471, 420, 34 & 120(B) of IPC. Initially there was prayer for investigation U/Sec.156(3) of CrPC. That prayer was rejected and liberty was given to the complainant to proceed as per Sec.200 of CrPC. Accordingly her verification was recorded. Thereafter, matter was sent to police station for inquiry. Police have filed negative report. It is submitted that dispute is of civil nature. Thereafter, complainant has given her evidence for issuance of process. 2. There are two complainants. They are real sisters of each others. Accused No.1 is their real brother. Accused No.2 is their cousin brother. Accused No.3 is cousin brother of their father. Accused No.4 is Medical Practitioner. Accused No.1 was always dependent on his father. He started to cut off his relations with family after his marriage. Mr. Ramesh Shah was passed away on 16.05.2018. Complainant came to know that will executed by Mr. Ramesh Shah is in possession of accused No.2. Accused No.2 asked declaration from complainants stating that they shall not challenged the will. Accused No.2 deliberately delayed reading of the will. He asked the complainant and accused No.1 to come to Ahmedabad on 25.08.2018 for reading of the will. Accused No.2 informed the complainant that will was sent by Mr. Ramesh Shah in April 2018. It was handed over through his one office boy. Mr. Ramesh Shah had informed the complainant that notarized will has been made and kept in mother’s cupboard along with mother’s will. As per alleged will, two flats and shops were given to accused No.1. Movable properties were distributed between the complainants. Nomination has been -- 1 of 3 -- 2 made in respect of flat No.101 in the name of complainants. Complainants are also entitled to their share in respect of flat No.91. 3. Complainant further alleged that signature on alleged will has not matched with signature of her father. Signatures on the will are forged. Accused No.2 has filed testamentary Petition 2901/2018 for probate of the will. Amount of Rs.13 Lacs was transferred from joint account of complainant to the account of Goodwill Travels. Complainant has obtained handwriting expert report. She has also approached various police authorities. But no cognizance was taken. 4. There is allegation of forgery in will of Mr. Ramesh Shah. Complainant has verified herself on oath. She has filed on record document examination report. She has examined expert witness Akash Machado. She has also examined two witnesses namely Kulbhushan Behal and Damayanti Pandey. Mr.Kulbhushan Behal deposed about his various discussions with deceased Ramesh Shah. Witness Damayanti Pandey is relative of Shah family. She has stated about relationship between the parties. 5. There is some civil litigation pending between the parties. Complainant was asked to file affidavit in respect of that litigation. She has filed that affidavit. There is one partition suit between the parties filed by the complainant. Accused No.1 has filed declaratory suit. Both that suits are pending before Hon’ble City Civil Court. One testamentary suit is pending at pre-admission stage. Advocate for the complainant relied upon case law of Iqbal Singh Marwah Vs Meenakshi Marwah 2005 SCC Online SC 531 of Hon'ble Supreme Court. He argued that there is no necessity of permission of the Court if forgery is committed before institution of the case in Court. It is well settled principal. Therefore, there is no bar to take cognizance of present complaint. There is no need to complaint by Officer of the Court. -- 2 of 3 -- 3 6. There is specific allegation of forgery and cheating against the accused. There is expert report in the favour of the complainant. She has also examined two more witnesses to support her case. Considering evidence given by the complainant, there is prima facie case against the accused No.1 only. He is beneficiary of the alleged forged will. There is no prima facie material against other accused. Hence I proceed to pass following order :- ORDER 1. Issue process against the accused No.1 only for the offence punishable U/Sec.420, 465, 467, 468, 471 of IPC. Issue summons accordingly. 2. Complaint is dismissed against other accused. Mumbai. ( S. R. Nimse ) Date :- 07.05.2026 Judicial Magistrate, First Class 40th Court, Girgaon, Mumbai. ask -- 3 of 3 --
