Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 07 Dec 2022 · CNR MHMM120125882022
Order Details: Copy of Order - 1 Pdf Text: 1 of 3 C.C. NO.4602369/MISC/2022 IN THE COURT OF THE METROPOLITAN MAGISTRATE, 46TH COURT, MAZGAON, MUMBAI C.C. NO. 4602369/MISC/2022 CNR NO. MHMM120125882022 C.R. NO.969/2022 OF CHARKOP POLICE STATION Shahjad Saeed Ahmed Ansari … Applicant Vs. The State of Maharashtra. (Through – Charkop Police Station) … Respondent ORDER BELOW APPLICATION OF RETURN OF PROPERTY This is an application filed for return of motor vehicle Honda Activa Scooter bearing registration No.MH47BA5616 and cash amount of Rs.16,300/ seized in CR. No. 969/2022 of Charkop Police Station. However, the applicant has not pressed his claim in respect of cash amount of Rs.16,300/ at the time of argument by filing pursis on record. 02. It is the contention of the applicant that, his brother Mohd. Arshad Saeed Ansari is the registered owner of the seized vehicle. The respondent had seized said vehicle for alleged transportation of contrabanned articles. The vehicle is lying with the respondent. If the vehicle is remain there in the custody of the respondent it may get damage. He is ready to abide by all the terms and conditions imposed by the court while releasing the custody of the vehicle in his favour. Therefore, this application. 03. On receiving of the application, say of the respondent and Ld. APP. was called. Respondent has resisted the application on the grounds that, if the vehicle is returned to the applicant, the same may be used for transporting contrabanned articles. The other accused involved in the offence are yet to be arrested and it is yet to be ascertained from where the applicant has brought the contrabanned articles. Ld. APP. has filed say and objected the application on the grounds that, the said vehicle is used to transport bannedfood articles, if the vehicle is released the possibility of sale, alter and, transfer of the vehicle and repetition of the -- 1 of 3 -- 2 of 3 C.C. NO.4602369/MISC/2022 offence can not be ruled out. 04. Perused the application supported with the affidavit of the applicant and verified copies of the documents submitted by the applicant. Heard the Ld. Counsel for the applicant and Ld. APP. It appears that, in view of the Notification No.5242022/7 dated 15.07.2022 issued by the FDA, the food products Gutkha, Scented Tobacco and Pan Masala are banned for transporting, stocking or selling. The prohibited food article found transporting through the vehicle driven by the applicant, which contravenes the said notification, therefore the offence is registered and therefore, he is Food Business Operator (hereinafter referred to as ‘the FBO’). The Act defines premises as per definition given in Section 3 (zi) of the FSS Act, 2006 which includes vehicles, stall, hotel etc. 05. Perused the documents filed on record. The applicant has filed on record his affidavit in support of the application, Photocopy of Remand Report, Photocopy Insurance Cover Note of the vehicle, Photocopy of Registration Certificate of vehicle, Affidavit cum NOC of Mohd. Arshad Saeed Ansari and Verified copy of his Aadhar Card and of registered owner. RC Book of the vehicle produced on record by the applicant shows Mohd. Arshad Saeed Ansari is the registered owner of the vehicle. The applicant has filed on record No Objection of Mohd. Arshad Saeed Ansari to hand over custody of the vehicle in his favour. Therefore, the registered owner of the vehicle has given NOC to hand over custody of the vehicle to applicant, he is entitled to get custody of the seized vehicle. So, it will not just and proper to detain the vehicle for the grounds cited by the prosecution. So also, the stringent conditions can be imposed for objections raised by the prosecution which will suffice the purpose. The vehicle is seized in the above offence for alleged transportation of prohibited food articles. The articles are already seized and the sufficient time has also been given to investigating agency since seizure of the vehicle. The Hon’ble Apex Court in Sunderbhai Ambalal Desai Vs. State of Gujrat (2002) 10 SCC 283 has given -- 2 of 3 -- 3 of 3 C.C. NO.4602369/MISC/2022 the directions to decide the applications in respect of return of property during pendency of trial. If the seized vehicle is not returned to the applicant, it may get damaged. Therefore, considering all these circumstances, it is just and proper to release custody of the vehicle in favour of applicant on certain conditions. Hence, the following order. O R D E R 1. The application is partly allowed. 2. The custody of seized vehicle Honda Activa Scooter bearing registration No.MH47BA5616 seized in CR. No. 969/2022 of Charkop Police Station be handed over to applicant Shahjad Saeed Ahmed Ansari. 3. The applicant/FBO Shahjad Saeed Ahmed Ansari and Registered owner Mohd. Arshad Saeed Ansari are directed to execute indemnity bond of Rs.80,000/ (Rupees Eighty Thousand Only) before the concerned police station that to produce the vehicle as and when required by the Court during the trial. 4. The applicant/FBO and Registered Owner of the vehicle shall not use and/or let the vehicle for transporting banned food articles and not to indulge themselves in similar kind of offence in the future. 5. The Charkop Police Station is directed to prepare panchnama by taking photographs of the property. 6. The Charkop Police Station is also directed to file entire documents along with chargesheet. 7. The applicant and registered owner are further directed not to sold out said vehicle nor change its nature/appearance and produce the same whenever called. 8. The proceeding is closed. ( D. S. Patale ) Metropolitan Magistrate, Dated : 07.12.2022 46th Court, Mazgaon at Sewree, Mumbai. RRRT. -- 3 of 3 --
