Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 02 Feb 2024 · CNR MHMM120090232023
Order Details: Copy of Order - 1 Pdf Text: 1 of 4 C.C. NO.4602038/MISC/2023 IN THE COURT OF THE METROPOLITAN MAGISTRATE, 46TH COURT, MAZGAON, MUMBAI C.C. NO. 4602038/MISC./2023 C.R. NO. 1855 OF 2023 OF BANDRA POLICE STATION (CNR NO. MHMM120090232023) Bindhbasani Murlidhar Tiwari ...Applicant Vs. 1. The State of Maharashtra (through Bandra P. Station, Mumbai) 2. Dhananjay Vikram Aaghar, Food Safety Officer. … Respondents ORDER BELOW APPLICATION OF REMOVAL OF SEAL This is an application filed by the applicant for removal of seal of the shop premises i.e. Tiwari Pan shop, 121, Hill Road, near Holy Family Hospital, Bandra (W), Mumbai400 050. 02. The facts necessary for deciding the application in short are as follows: It is the contention of the applicant that, he is the owner of sealed shop premises and he being handicap is running business at HPCO Booth, Provision Store & Grocery at the sealed premises. Due to illhealth, his nephew Adarsh Singh was carrying the said business. On 23.11.2023 the respondent along with other staff had visited the premises and seized the alleged contrabanned articles. Thereafter, they sealed the premises. The offence was registered against the accused at Bandra Police Station vide C.R. No. 1855/2023. He is not concerned with the contrabanned articles allegedly found in the sealed premises. Therefore, it is prayed that, the aforesaid premises may be desealed. 03. On receiving the application, say of Ld. APP and the respondent was -- 1 of 4 -- 2 of 4 C.C. NO.4602038/MISC/2023 called. Respondent filed his say and submitted that, the premises is used for the stocking of prohibited food articles. At the time of visit, the FBO /accused was present and found in possession of prohibited food articles various types of Pan Masala, Gutkha and Tobacco worth Rs. 2008/. Respondent submitted various provisions by which said premises is sealed by him. He submitted that, the applicant and accused having knowledge of prohibition, stored various types of Pan Masala, Gutkha and Tobacco for sale. If the premises is desealed and given in possession of applicant, the same may again use for similar purpose. The premises is required as evidence for further investigation. Therefore, he objected for desealing the premises. 04. Perused the application, say filed by the respondent and verified copies of documents submitted by the applicant. Heard the Ld. Counsel for the applicant. It appears that, in view of the Notification FSSA/ Notification/496/7 dtd. 18.07.2023 of the State Government, the product like Gutkha, Scented Tobacco and Pan Masala are banned for transporting, stocking or selling. The FBO in contravention of said Notification found stocking the prohibited articles. Therefore, the offence was registered. The Act defines premises as per definition given in Section 3 (zi) of the Act which includes shop, stall, hotel etc. At the time of search, the FBO was present in the said shop. 05. Rule 2.1.3 (4) of the Food Safety and Standard Rules, 2011 authorises the FSO to seal the premises for the purpose of investigation after taking a sample of such adulterant or food for analysis. However, to invoke these powers, the FSO has to record his reasons in writing. He has to come to a conclusion that, it is not possible to comply with section 38 (1) (c) of the Act or proviso to Section 38 (1) of the Act. The Rules also -- 2 of 4 -- 3 of 4 C.C. NO.4602038/MISC/2023 prescribe nonavailability of the FBO as one of the reasons to seal the premises. In the present matter, the reply filed by FSO does not show that, the FSO has passed any order in writing before sealing the premises. Moreover, the object of sealing the premises is restricted for the purpose of investigation. Considering the fact that various types of Pan Masala, Gutkha and Tobacco is seized in this matter, the Investigating Officer and FSO are supposed to dispose the contrabanned articles as per law. The premises was sealed on 23.11.2023. More than two months have elapsed from sealing of the premises. Hence, sufficient time has been granted to the machinery for investigation. 06. The prohibited food articles already seized by the FSO. The samples of the same have been already taken. In the present case, there is nothing on record to suggest noncompliance of Sec. 38 (1) (c) of the Act or proviso to section 38 (1). Moreover, the FBO was available to the FSO at the time of visit. Thus, the compliance of Section 38 (1) (c) of the Act could have been done easily. Thus, there is no reason to seal the premises. If the applicant shows his interest over the premises, he is entitled for relief claimed. 07. The applicant has filed on record copy of FIR, copy of Shop License, copy of Disability Certificate of applicant, electricity bill, verified copies of Aadhar Card and PAN Card and Affidavit cum NOC of the accused Adarsh Kumar Munna Singh. The Shop License issued by BMC and electricity bill produced on record are in the name of the applicant. At the time of sealing of the premises, FBO/accused Adarsh Kumar Munna Singh was in possession of the premises. The applicant has also filed on record Affidavit cum No Objection of FBO Adarsh Kumar Munna Singh to deseal the premises in favour of the applicant. Therefore, considering that, the applicant is the owner of the sealed premises, the prohibited food articles -- 3 of 4 -- 4 of 4 C.C. NO.4602038/MISC/2023 have been seized and the sufficient time has been given for investigation, the premises can be desealed by imposing certain conditions which will suffice the purpose for which the application is opposed by the respondent. Hence, I pass following order; O R D E R 1. The application is allowed. 2. The Food Safety Officer is directed to remove the seal from the shop premises Tiwari Pan shop, 121, Hill Road, near Holy Family Hospital, Bandra (W), Mumbai400 050 sealed in C.R. No. 1855 of 2023 registered at Bandra Police Station. 3. Applicant/owner Bindhbasani Murlidhar Tiwari and FBO/accused Adarsh Kumar Munna Singh directed to execute indemnity bond of Rs. 5,00,000/( Rs. Five Lakhs Only) before the Food Safety Officer and give undertaking that they shall not use or let the premises for storing the prohibited food articles and not indulge themselves in similar kind of offence in the future. 4. The Food Safety Officer is directed to prepare detailed panchnama of the premises while removing the seal and obtain colour photographs at the cost of the applicant. Sd/ (D. S. Patale) Metropolitan Magistrate, Dated : 02.02.2024 46th Court, Mazgaon, Mumbai. SVP -- 4 of 4 --
