Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 1

CNR MHMM12007808202623 Jul 2026
Sewri, MM Court
Mumbai · Maharashtra (MH)
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 1 · 23 Jul 2026 · CNR MHMM120078082026

Order Details: Copy of Order - 1
Pdf Text: - 1 of 5 - (ORDER ON C.C. NO.635/BA/2026)
IN THE COURT OF JUDICIAL MAGISTRATE FIRST CLASS,
46TH COURT, MAZGAON, MUMBAI
BAIL APPLICATION NO.635/BA/2026
C.R.No.405/2026 of MANKHURD POLICE STATION, MUMBAI.
ORDER PASSED ON BAIL APPLICATION
1. This application is filed by accused Shivam Chhedilal Gupta
for grant of bail under Section 480 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha
Sanhita, 2023 in Crime No.405/2026 under Section 123, 223, 274 and
275 of the BNS & for contravention of various provisions of the Food
Safety & Standards Act, 2006 punishable under Section 59 of the Food
Safety & Standards Act, 2006.
2. Perused the application, remand papers and say of I.O. and
the learned APP. Heard the learned APP on behalf of the State and
learned defense counsel for the accused. The learned APP has opposed
to present application on the ground that the offences levelled against
the accused are serious in nature. According to her, the contraband
articles are declared as unsafe food keeping in view the general health
and safety of public at large. It is treated as a most hazardous food
article, the regular consumption whereof is bound to result into death.
Prima facie case is made out as total quantity of 3,32,080	₹ /- of
contraband articles involved in the present crime. The offence under
Section 123 of BNS is exclusively triable by the Hon'ble Court of
Sessions. Therefore, this Court has no jurisdiction to decide the present
application. Lastly, she has submitted that, the investigation is in
progress and if the bail is granted, accused may commit similar offence
in future. Hence, she prayed for rejection of this application. The I.O.
-- 1 of 5 --
- 2 of 5 - (ORDER ON C.C. NO.635/BA/2026)
has resisted the application on the ground that, if the applicant/accused
is released on bail, he may commit similar offence and may tamper with
the prosecution witnesses and may threaten to them. He further resisted
the application and submitted that, other two wanted accused are yet to
be arrested.
3. On the contrary, the learned defence counsel has
vehemently argued that though Section 123 of BNS is triable by the
Hon'ble Court of Sessions, but it is not prima-facie attracted as there is
no attempt of administering or causing to be taken poison or such
alleged substance. He further submitted that Section 223, 274 and 275
of the BNS & for contravention of various provisions of the Food Safety
& Standards Act, 2006 punishable under Section 59 of the Food Safety
& Standards Act, 2006 are also not prima-facie made out against this
accused, therefore, this Court has every jurisdiction to grant bail of
accused. He further submitted that the accused is law abiding person
and resident of Mumbai. He is falsely implicated in this case. The
accused is ready to abide any condition, which will imposed by this
Court.
4. It is submitted by the learned Counsel for the accused that,
the Hon’ble Bombay High Court in
Anand Ramdhani Chaurasiya Vs.
State of Maharashtra (Criminal Writ Petition No.3607 of 2019) and
Ganesh Pandurang Jadhao Vs. State of Maharashtra (Criminal Writ
Petition No.1027 of 2015), has held that, mere transportation/
possession of contraband articles would not attract Section 328 of
Indian Penal Code (Now, Sec.123 of the BNS).
-- 2 of 5 --
- 3 of 5 - (ORDER ON C.C. NO.635/BA/2026)
5. In aforesaid judgments, the Hon'ble Bombay High Court
has negatived the applicability of Section 328 of the IPC for mere
possession or transporting of prohibited food articles like
Pan Masala
and
Gutkha. However, the Hon’ble Apex Court in
State of Maharashtra
Vs. Anand Ramdhani Chaurasiya (SLP No.004101/2020) and
State of
Maharashtra Vs. Ganesh Pandurang Jadhao (SLP No.005861/2020),
has stayed the operation of judgments of the Hon’ble Bombay High
Court in
Anand Chaurasiya and Ganesh Jadhao (cited supra). Hence,
the issue of applicability of Section 328 of the IPC is now under
consideration before the Hon'ble Apex Court.
6. It is the contention of the prosecution that Section 123 of
BNS is triable by the Hon'ble Court of Sessions, therefore, this Court has
no jurisdiction to release to the accused on bail. In this regard, the
Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of
Prahlad Singh Bhati Vs. N.C.T. Delhi
and Another in Appeal (Crl. No.324 of 2001) dated 23.03.2001 has
observed that,
“Even though there is no legal bar for a Magistrate to
consider an application for grant of bail to a person who is arrested for
an offence exclusively triable by Court of Sessions yet it would be
appropriate that in such a case Magistrate directs the accused person to
approach the Court of Sessions for the purpose of getting the relief of
bail”. It is imperative to mention here that, the offence punishable
under Section 123 of BNS is punishable with imprisonment upto ten
years. Therefore, as per the ratio laid down by the Hon’ble Apex Court,
this Court is empowered to release an accused, charged with an offence
punishable under Section 123 of BNS (Corresponding Section 328 of
IPC).
-- 3 of 5 --
- 4 of 5 - (ORDER ON C.C. NO.635/BA/2026)
7. After perusing of remand papers, it appears that the
investigating machinery has already seized contraband articles involved
in the present crime and drawn the samples therefrom. It is significant
to note that the seized contraband articles are in possession of the
Investigating Officer. During investigation, the present accused came to
be arrested being one of the accomplice. The other accused involved in
the offence are released on bail. The remand application shows the
detail address of the accused is available with the investigating
machinery. Hence, there is less possibility of absconding of the accused.
Mere, Section 123 of BNS is triable of Hon'ble Court of Sessions, it is
not the ground to reject the bail of the accused, especially when, the
issue of applicability of Section 123 of BNS for possession /
transportation of contraband articles i.e. Gutkha, Pan Masala and
Scented Tobacco, is pending before the Hon’ble Apex Court. The
custodial interrogation of the applicant/accused is already over. So far
as the fact that the investigation is in progress, necessary conditions can
be imposed while considering the prayer for bail. Hence, this Court is of
the view that there is no special reason to keep the accused behind the
bars. It is to be noted that possibility as to tampering evidence or
inducement or threat to the person acquainted to the fact of the case
can be avoided by imposing conditions upon the accused. Hence, it is
justifiable to release the accused on bail, subject to some stringent
conditions. Accordingly, this Court proceeds to pass following order.
ORDER
1. The Bail Application is allowed.
2. Accused Shivam Chhedilal Gupta be released on bail on executing
P.B. and Surety bond of ₹20,000/- (Rs. Twenty Thousand Only)
-- 4 of 5 --
- 5 of 5 - (ORDER ON C.C. NO.635/BA/2026)
with one surety or on Cash Security of 20	₹ ,000/- (Rs. Twenty
Thousand Only), subject to following stringent conditions :
a. The accused shall not hamper or tamper the material evidence of
the prosecution;
b. The accused shall not pressurize to the informant and prosecution
witnesses;
c. The accused shall make himself available for the purpose of
investigation as and when required by the Investigation Officer;
d. The accused shall not abscond and furnish his address proof-copy of
Ration Card, mobile number and mobile number of his close
relative with name and address of the said relative;
e. The accused shall not indulge himself in similar type of offence.
3. As directed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Zeba Khan V/s. State
of Uttar Pradesh in Criminal Appeal No.825/2026 (Arising out of
SLP Criminal No.12669 of 2025), the Affidavit filed with instant
Bail Application be considered as part and parcel of this bail order.
(P. P. Deshmukh)
Judicial Magistrate F. C.,
Date: 23.07.2026 46th Court, Mazgaon, Mumbai.
RRRT.
14:40
-- 5 of 5 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.