Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 17 Oct 2024 · CNR MHCC040089482022
Order Details: Order Pdf Text: N/M 3111/2022 1 SC Suit No.2494/2015 MHCC040033302022 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT AT BOMBAY BORIVALI DIVISION, DINDOSHI (BRANCH) NOTICE OF MOTION NO. 3111 OF 2022 IN S.C.SUIT NO. 2494 OF 2015 Balbir Kaur ...Plaintiff V/s. M/s Shubh Enterprises and Ors. ...Defendants Shri Vijay Shukla, Advocate for plaintiff. Shri Dhananjay Singh, Advocate for defendant No.5. CORAM: His Honour The 1st Addl.Principal Judge Shri R.N.Rokade (C.R.No.1) DATE : 17th October, 2024. :ORAL ORDER : By this Notice of motion, defendant No.5 is praying for the condonation of delay in filing written statement and for permission to file a written statement on record. -- 1 of 5 -- N/M 3111/2022 2 SC Suit No.2494/2015 2. Shorn of unnecessary details, the material averments in the affidavit filed in support of the Notice of motion are as under: The writ of summons in the present suit is not served upon defendant No.5 till date. Defendant No.5 was not bonafide belief that the time period to file the written statement would commence from the date of the service of the writ of summons. Neither defendant No.5 nor its advocate have waived the service of summons. The service of summons is mandatory under Order 8 Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908. The time limit specified under Order 8 Rule 1 of CPC to file a written statement in ordinary civil suit is directory and not mandatory. If the delay is calculated from the date of appearance of defendant No.5 on 24.11.2015, then there is delay of 1765 days in filing the written statement. There was no deliberate intention or negligence on the part of defendant No.5 for filing the Written Statement. If the delay is not condoned, an irreparable loss would be caused to defendant No.5. On these and amongst other grounds, defendant No.5 has prayed for the condonation of delay in filing written statement. 3. The plaintiff has strongly resisted the notice of motion by filing say on the leaf of the notice of motion. It is contended that defendant No.5 is regularly attending the court. However, defendant No.5 failed to file the written statement purposely. The delay is not properly explained. The notice of motion has not disclosed the said fact. Alternatively, it is submitted that if the delay is condoned, heavy cost may be imposed. -- 2 of 5 -- N/M 3111/2022 3 SC Suit No.2494/2015 4. Heard the Ld.Advocate for defendant No.5 and the Ld.Advocate for the plaintiff. Perused the Notice of motion and the documents placed on record. 5. It is trite that, the liberal and justice oriented approach is required to be taken into consideration while deciding the delay condonation application. At the same time, the liberal approach in considering sufficiency of cause for delay should not be allowed to override the substantial law of limitation. 6. In view of the aforesaid exposition of law, reverting to the facts of the case, the plaintiff has filed the suit for the declaration and specific performance of the Agreement for Sale in respect of the suit flat. The rights of the parties are at stake. If the delay is not condoned, defendant No.5 would be left without much defence and that the situation would certainly lead to a walk over granted to the plaintiff. It is imperative to note that there is no counter version on oath which competes in probability with that of defendant No.5. 7. Having regard to the averments made in the affidavit in support of the Notice of motion, nature of the suit and the reasons put forth by defendant No.5, I am of considered view that this is a fit case to condone the delay, subject to payment of costs of Rs.5,000/- to be paid to the plaintiffs within two weeks, failing which the Notice of motion stands dismissed. With this, I am inclined to pass following order: -- 3 of 5 -- N/M 3111/2022 4 SC Suit No.2494/2015 ORDER 1) Notice of Motion No.3111 of 2022 is hereby allowed. 2) The delay in filing written statement is condoned, subject to payment of cost of Rs.5,000/-(Rupees Five Thousand) to be paid to the plaintiff within two weeks from the date of this order, failing which the Notice of motion shall stand dismissed. 3) After payment of the costs, a Written statement filed alongwith Notice of motion is allowed to be taken on record. 4) Notice of Motion No.3111 of 2022 stands disposed of accordingly. (R.N.Rokade) DT. 17.10.2024 1st Addl.Principal Judge City Civil & Sessions Court Dindoshi, Mumbai. Date of dictation : 17.10.2024 Date of transcription by steno : 18.10.2024 Checked & signed by HHJ on : 18.10.2024 -- 4 of 5 -- N/M 3111/2022 5 SC Suit No.2494/2015 CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER” Date : 19.10.2024 Mrs. S.A.Kapare Time : 11.45 A.M. (Stenographer Grade-I) UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge (with Court Room No.) HH The 1st Additional Principal Judge Shri R.N.Rokade (Court Room No.1) Date of Pronouncement of Jud/Order 17.10.2024 Judgment/Order signed by P.O. on 18.10.2024 Judgment/Order uploaded on 19.10.2024 -- 5 of 5 --
