Full Order Text
Order 1 · 09 Jun 2026 · CNR MHCC040083842019
Order Details: Order Pdf Text: NM No.1832/2026 in L. C. Suit No.2678/2019 1 Order MHCC040046032026 BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT, BORIVALI DIVISION AT DINDOSHI, GOREGAON, MUMBAI NOTICE OF MOTION NO.1832 OF 2026 IN L.C. SUIT NO.2678 OF 2019 Srichand Sugnomal Lulla … Plaintiff Vs. 1. Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai. 2. Executive Engineer (B & F) So-called Designated Officer, “H/West” Ward. … Defendants APPEARANCE. For the plaintiff: Advocate Shri Shobhit Shukla. For the defendants/MCGM: Advocate Ms. Rutuja Korde. CORAM : H.H.JUDGE SHRI B. D. PAWAR (C.R.NO.14) Date : 09th JUNE, 2026. ORAL ORDER The plaintiff has taken out this Notice of Motion for setting aside order dated 04.04.2026, whereby Notice of Motion No.3501 of 2019 taken out by him for temporary injunction is dismissed in default and for condonation of delay in taking out this Notice of Motion. 2. Read Notice of Motion and reply filed by advocate for defendants. Heard advocate Shri Shobhit Shukla for the plaintiff and advocate Ms. Rutuja Korde for defendants. -- 1 of 5 -- NM No.1832/2026 in L. C. Suit No.2678/2019 2 Order 3. Advocate Shri Shukla submitted that plaintiff has filed this suit for relief of declaration and injunction. The plaintiff has challenged the notice issued by the defendants as per section 351 of the MMC Act. Vide order dated 26.10.2019, the plaintiff is granted ad-interim relief which is continued from time to time. However, as plaintiff failed to appear, Notice of Motion No.3501 of 2019 is dismissed for want of prosecution. Hence, plaintiff has taken out this Notice of Motion for restoration of earlier Notice of Motion and for condonation of delay in taking out this Notice of Motion. 4. Advocate Shri Shukla submitted that the Secretary of Society assured the plaintiff that necessary application will be moved for regularization of construction. Believing upon the words of Secretary of Society, the plaintiff has not appeared in the suit, when it was called for hearing on Notice of Motion. 5. Advocate Shri Shukla submitted that plaintiff has given sufficient explanation for his non appearance in the Court, when the Notice of Motion was called for hearing. Plaintiff has also given proper explanation for delay caused in taking out this Notice of Motion. Hence, delay in taking out the Notice of Motion may be condoned and by allowing this Notice of Motion, the Notice of Motion No.3501 of 2019 may be restored. 6. Advocate Ms. Korde submitted that in the year 2019, the plaintiff was granted ad-interim relief. Since then, plaintiff is interested only to extend earlier order and not taken steps for hearing on Notice of Motion. -- 2 of 5 -- NM No.1832/2026 in L. C. Suit No.2678/2019 3 Order 7. Advocate Ms. Korde submitted that plaintiff has not given proper explanation for non appearance in the Court, when the Notice of Motion was called for hearing. Plaintiff has also not given proper explanation for delay caused in taking out this Notice of Motion. Hence, Notice of Motion may be rejected. 8. The plaintiff has taken out this Notice of Motion under Order 9 Rule 9 of Civil Procedure Code for restoration of Notice of Motion which was dismissed for want of prosecution. The plaintiff has also sought condonation of delay in taking out this Notice of Motion. Therefore, the burden is on plaintiff to show that on 04.04.2026, due to sufficient reasons he could not remain present in the Court, when the Notice of Motion was called for hearing. 9. I have gone through affidavit in support of Notice of Motion. It is stated in the affidavit that the plaintiff had not contacted his advocate and failed to remain present in the suit due to assurance given by Secretary of the Society for taking steps for regularization of construction. 10. From the contents of affidavit it appears that, the plaintiff has not contacted his advocate. The day on which Notice of Motion was dismissed, both plaintiff as well as his advocate were absent. It is important to note that in the year 2019, plaintiff was granted ad-interim relief. Since then, plaintiff has not cared to ascertain as to whether proposal for regularization is moved by the Secretary of the Society. I am of view that plaintiff failed to show that due to sufficient reasons he could not appear in the suit, when the Notice of Motion was called for -- 3 of 5 -- NM No.1832/2026 in L. C. Suit No.2678/2019 4 Order hearing. Therefore, the plaintiff is not entitled for relief of restoration of Notice of Motion and for condonation of delay. The Notice of Motion is liable to be dismissed. Hence, I pass following order: ORDER 1. Notice of Motion No.1832 of 2026 is rejected. 2. Parties to bear their own costs. Date: 09.06.2026 (B. D. Pawar) Judge, City Civil Court, Borivali Division, Dindoshi. Dictated on Computer : 09.06.2026 Corrected and Signed on : 09.06.2026 -- 4 of 5 -- NM No.1832/2026 in L. C. Suit No.2678/2019 5 Order CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER” Date : 09.06.2026 Mr. Umesh G. Jadhav Time : 05.45 P.M. (Stenographer Grade-I) UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge (with Court room no.) HHJ Shri B.D.PAWAR (C.R.No.14) Date of Pronouncement of JUDGMENT/ORDER 09.06.2026 JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P.O. on 09.06.2026 JUDGMENT/ORDER uploaded on 09.06.2026 -- 5 of 5 --
