Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 11 Dec 2025 · CNR MHCC040079982025
Order Details: Order Pdf Text: 1 Com. Sum. Suit No. 42 of 2021 … Order on Review Application No. 5 of 2025 MHCC040079982025 Presented on : 09.09.2025 Registered on : 11.09.2025 Decided on : 11.12.2025 Duration : 3 Ms. 2Ds BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT, BORIVALI DIVISION AT DINDOSHI,GOREGAON, MUMBAI REVIEW APPLICATION NO. 5 OF 2025 IN SUMMONS FOR JUDGMENT NO. 141 OF 2022 IN COMMERCIAL SUMMARY SUIT NO. 42 OF 2021 1. Jayant Bhavanji Soni (Since deceased) Sole Proprietor, Joy Builders, Through Legal Heirs. 1-A) Malti Jayant Soni, (Wife of deceased Defendant No. 1) 1-B) Snehal Jatin Dharmasi, (Daughter of deceased Defendant No.1) 1-C) Jagruti Ketan Nagda, (Daughter of deceased Defendant No. 1) 2. Bhavin Jayant Soni, (Son of deceased Defendant No.1) Mandate Holder, Joy Builders All having office at Ashiana Building, N. S. Road No.1, Near Bhaidas Hall, J. V. P. D. Scheme, Ville Parle (West), Mumbai – 400 056. ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] … Applicants (Original defendants) -- 1 of 12 -- 2 Com. Sum. Suit No. 42 of 2021 … Order on Review Application No. 5 of 2025 Vs. Rohit Ramesh Modi Age 37 Years, Occupation : Doctor, Residing at 404, Chandra Sagar, Plot No. 223, Film City Road, Gokuldhan, Goregaon (East), Mumbai – 400 063. ] ] ] ] ] … Respondent (Original Plaintiff) Appearance : Applicant : Ld. Advocate Narula Respondent : Advocate Kunal Kumbhat CORAM: H.H.JUDGE SHILPA S.TODKAR COURT ROOM NO.3 Date : 11th December 2025. ORDER BELOW EXHIBIT – 1 . The Applicants are the original defendants in the present suit. The plaintiff filed the present suit against the defendants for recovery of the alleged loan of Rs. 20,00,000/- alongwith interest @ 18% p.a. on the said principal amount of Rs. 20,00,000/-. 2. The respondents/original plaintiff claimed to have advanced the said loan of Rs. 20,00,000/- on 16th January 2018 in cash, to the Applicants/original defendants. The present Applicants/original defendants upon being served with the summons entered their appearance. Thereupon the Applicants were served with Summons For Judgment No. 141 of 2022 taken out by the respondent/plaintiff seeking judgment against defendants for the amount claimed therein. -- 2 of 12 -- 3 Com. Sum. Suit No. 42 of 2021 … Order on Review Application No. 5 of 2025 3. The Applicants resisted the Summons for Judgment by filing their affidavit in reply dated 11.11.2022 and applied for leave to defend the above suit by inter-alia demonstrating several issues involved in the suit. Applicants pointed out in their reply that the purported loan of Rs. 20,00,000/- was never advanced by the plaintiff to the defendants and the Promissory Note was executed without consideration in the circumstance set out in detail in para 5(a) to 5(d) of the said reply. 4. The Summons For Judgment was heard and was decided by order dated 10th January 2025. In the said order in para No. 17 and Para No. 21, it is observed and the court came to the conclusion that restrictions is on the defendant to not accept more than 20,000/- in cash. Therefore, the objection raised by the defendant was not accepted. 5. The present court consider the provisions of the Income Tax Act relating to the cash transactions but unfortunately lost sight of penal provisions of Income Tax Act in the event of such cash transaction is entered into. 6. Applicants have come across a judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of The Correspondence RBANMS Educational vs B. Gunashekar reported in 2025 SCC Online SC-793 in which the Hon'ble Court has issued the following directions in later part of the clause-18.1: (A) Whenever, a suit is filed with a claim that Rs. 2,00,000/- and above is paid by cash towards any transaction, the courts must intimate the same to the jurisdictional Income Tax Department to verify the -- 3 of 12 -- 4 Com. Sum. Suit No. 42 of 2021 … Order on Review Application No. 5 of 2025 transaction and the violation of Section 269ST of the Income Tax Act, if any, (B) Whenever, any such information is received either from the court or otherwise, the Jurisdictional Income Tax authority shall take appropriate steps by following the due process in law, (C) Whenever, a sum of Rs. 2,00,000/- and above is claimed to be paid by cash towards consideration for conveyance of any immovable property in a document presented for registration, the jurisdictional Sub-Registrar shall intimate the same to the jurisdictional Income Tax Authority who shall follow the due process in law before taking any action, (D) Whenever, it comes to the knowledge of any Income Tax Authority that a sum of Rs. 2,00,000/- or above has been paid by way of consideration in any transaction relating to any immovable property from any other source or during the course of search or assessment proceedings, the failure of the registering authority shall be brought to the knowledge of the Chief Secretary of the State/UT for initiating appropriate disciplinary action against such officer who failed to initiate the transactions.” 7. In para 20 (v) and para-21, the Hon’ble Supreme Court further directed as under: - “20(v) The directions given by us in paragraph 18.1 of this judgment shall be intimated by the Registrars of the High Courts, the Chief Secretaries of the States/Union Territories and the Principal Chief Commissioner of Income Tax Department to the District Judiciary, the -- 4 of 12 -- 5 Com. Sum. Suit No. 42 of 2021 … Order on Review Application No. 5 of 2025 officials of the registration department and the jurisdictional officers under the Income Tax Department respectively, so as to facilitate the conduct of periodical audit.” “21. The Registrar (Judicial) is directed to circulate a copy of this Judgment to the Registrar General of all the High Courts, the Chief Secretaries of all the States / Union Territories, and the Principal Chief Commissioner of Income Tax Department, enabling them to communicate the directions issued by this Court for strict compliance. 8) In view of the above, this court be report the present transaction purportedly involving the alleged loan of Rs.20,00,000/- advanced by the plaintiff so as to enquire about the source of such huge amount of cash with the Respondent. The Applicants-Defendants have already clarified and set out in detail the circumstances under which the Promissory Note was executed by the Applicants without consideration. 9. In the circumstances, the Applicants are seeking review of the order dated 10.01.2025 passed by this court in Summons For Judgment No. 141 of 2022 on the grounds as stated in the present Review Petition and to modify or set aside the same and hear the aforesaid matter once again on merits. 10. According to Applicants, there is a error apparent on the record is as such as this court while brushing aside the objection taken by Defendants-Applicants under Section 269-SS of Income Tax Act stating that the restriction on cash advanced was in fact on the taker and not on the person who makes and advance, lost sight of inter-alia -- 5 of 12 -- 6 Com. Sum. Suit No. 42 of 2021 … Order on Review Application No. 5 of 2025 Section- 68, 69, 69A and 69C of Income Tax Act which forbids any person from dealing with unaccounted cash without disclosing its source. 11. The Applicants further contended that the grounds set out so that there are errors apparent on the face of the record and therefore, this is a fit case for this court to exercise its inherent power of review and recall the order dated 10.01.2025 passed in Summons For Judgment No. 141 of 2022. 12. There is sufficient reason to review the said order dated 10.01.2022 and to modify the same and to set aside the same in the interest of justice. The said order fails to take into consideration the admitted facts and circumstances as stated in the Petition and accordingly the order is liable to be reviewed and modified/set aside. There is error apparent on the face of the order and the correct position of law most necessarily be prevailed and upheld to serve the ends of justice. Lastly the Applicants prayed to review the said order dated 10.01.2025 passed in Summons for Judgment No. 141/2022. Hence, this review petition. 13. Advocate for respondents submitted that he has proceeded with the review petition on the basis of denial. 14. Heard Ld. Advocate for the Applicants/defendants and Ld. Advocate for the respondent/plaintiff. 15. Perused the petition, documents filed by the -- 6 of 12 -- 7 Com. Sum. Suit No. 42 of 2021 … Order on Review Application No. 5 of 2025 Applicants/defendants and documents filed by the respondent/plaintiff. 16. Ld. Advocate for the Applicants has placed reliance upon the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in the case The Correspondence RBANMS Educational vs B. Gunashekar reported in 2025 SCC Online SC-793 in which the Hon'ble Court has issued the following directions in later part of the clause-18.1: (A) Whenever, a suit is filed with a claim that Rs. 2,00,000/- and above is paid by cash towards any transaction, the courts must intimate the same to the jurisdictional Income Tax Department to verify the transaction and the violation of Section 269ST of the Income Tax Act, if any, (B) Whenever, any such information is received either from the court or otherwise, the Jurisdictional Income Tax authority shall take appropriate steps by following the due process in law, (C) Whenever, a sum of Rs. 2,00,000/- and above is claimed to be paid by cash towards consideration for conveyance of any immovable property in a document presented for registration, the jurisdictional Sub-Registrar shall intimate the same to the jurisdictional Income Tax Authority who shall follow the due process in law before taking any action, (D) Whenever, it comes to the knowledge of any Income Tax Authority that a sum of Rs. 2,00,000/- or above has been paid by way of consideration in any transaction relating to any immovable property from any other source or during the course of search or assessment proceedings, the failure of the registering authority shall be brought to -- 7 of 12 -- 8 Com. Sum. Suit No. 42 of 2021 … Order on Review Application No. 5 of 2025 the knowledge of the Chief Secretary of the State/UT for initiating appropriate disciplinary action against such officer who failed to initiate the transactions.” 17. In para 20 (v) and para-21, the Hon’ble Supreme Court further directed as under: - “20(v) The directions given by us in paragraph 18.1 of this judgment shall be intimated by the Registrars of the High Courts, the Chief Secretaries of the States/Union Territories and the Principal Chief Commissioner of Income Tax Department to the District Judiciary, the officials of the registration department and the jurisdictional officers under the Income Tax Department respectively, so as to facilitate the conduct of periodical audit.” “21. The Registrar (Judicial) is directed to circulate a copy of this Judgment to the Registrar General of all the High Courts, the Chief Secretaries of all the States / Union Territories, and the Principal Chief Commissioner of Income Tax Department, enabling them to communicate the directions issued by this Court for strict compliance. 18) Ld. Advocate for the Applicants/defendants has submitted in his arguments that in view of the above, this court be report the present transaction purportedly involving the alleged loan of Rs.20,00,000/- advanced by the plaintiff so as to enquire about the source of such huge amount of cash with the Respondent. The Applicants-Defendants have already clarified and set out in detail the -- 8 of 12 -- 9 Com. Sum. Suit No. 42 of 2021 … Order on Review Application No. 5 of 2025 circumstances under which the Promissory Note was executed by the Applicants without consideration. 19. According to Applicants, there are errors apparent on the face of the record of the order dated 10.01.2025 passed in Summons for Judgment No. 141/2022. According to the Applicants, in their reply dated 11.11.2022 filed to Summons for Judgment, in the said reply it is specifically denied having received any amount in cash much less the said alleged amount of Rs. 20,00,000/-, the said transaction is required to be intimated to the Income Tax Department. But the respondent/plaintiff has not intimated the said transaction to the Income Tax Department, in view of the order passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the above matter. 20. Ld. Advocate for the applicants further submitted in his arguments that in view of the said order of Hon’ble Supreme Court it is necessary to report the present transaction purportedly involving the alleged loan of Rs. 20,00,000/- advanced by the plaintiff in cash, so as to inquire about the source of such huge amount of cash with the respondent. The Applicants/defendants have already clarified and set out in detail the circumstances under which the promissory note was executed by the Applicants without consideration. 21. Per contra Ld. Advocate for the respondent/plaintiff submitted in his arguments that they have already reported the present transactions to the Income Tax Department. In the order dated 10.01.2025 passed in Summons for Judgment No. 141/2022, this court rightly observed in paragraph 21 of the order that, the restrictions are -- 9 of 12 -- 10 Com. Sum. Suit No. 42 of 2021 … Order on Review Application No. 5 of 2025 on the person who takes amount in cash and not on the person who advances money in cash. Restrictions are on the defendant and not on the plaintiff. 22. Here it is necessary to perused the order dated 10.01.2025 passed in Summons For Judgment No.141/2022 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 42 of 2021. In paragraph No. 21 of the said orders reads as thus. “ 21. The next ground taken by the Defendant is in regard to Section 269-SS of Income Tax Act. This defence has also not taken by Defendant in leave to defend. According to the Plaintiff and in plaint it is pleaded that the loan has been advanced in cash, that time Ld. Advocate for the Defendant has taken this defence. But upon perusal of the case law reported in 2022 LiveLaw 483 as well as judgment delivered in Criminal Appeal 764 of 2009. It has been held that, no person can accept loan or deposit sum of Rs.20,000/- or more otherwise than by an account payee cheque or account payee bank draft. It has been held in para 25 that “no person shall accept” has been mentioned. Provision does not show that person cannot advance more than Rs.20,000/- in cash to another. Restriction on cash advanced was in fact on the taker and not on the person who makes an advance. Therefore, in view of the said case law the restrictions is on the person who takes amount in cash and not on the person who advances more than Rs.20,000/- in cash. Restrictions is on the Defendant and not on the Plaintiff. Therefore, this objection is also not acceptable.” 23. Moreover, Ld. Advocate for the respondent/plaintiff has placed on record the Income Tax Return of present respondent/plaintiff -- 10 of 12 -- 11 Com. Sum. Suit No. 42 of 2021 … Order on Review Application No. 5 of 2025 for Annual year 2024-2025. On perusal the said Income Tax Return, it appears that in Balance Sheet as on 31st March 2024, in particulars column an amount of Rs. 20,00,000/- shown against Joy Builders i.e. present Applicants/defendants. So, in view of the above decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, the respondent/plaintiff has already complied with the said directions issued in the above judgment. 24. So, considering the over all record, there are no errors apparent on the face of the record while passing order dated 10.01.2025 passed in Summons for Judgment No. 141 of 2022. So, the Applicants are not entitled to recall the order dated 10.01.2025 passed in Summons for Judgment No. 141 of 2022. 25. In the result I pass following order. :- ORDER 1) Review Application No. 5 of 2025 stands dismissed and accordingly disposed of. (Shilpa S.Todkar) Judge, City Civil Court, Date : 11.12.2025 Borivali Division, Dindoshi, Mumbai. Dictated on : 11.12.2025 Transcribed on : 22.12.2025 Corrected and Signed on : 24.12.2025 -- 11 of 12 -- 12 Com. Sum. Suit No. 42 of 2021 … Order on Review Application No. 5 of 2025 “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER” Date : 24.12.2025 Mrs. Shruti. M. Raut Time : 05.55 p.m. (Stenographer Grade-III) UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge (with Court room no.) HHJ Smt. Shilpa S. Todkar (C.R.No.03) Date of Pronouncement of JUDGMENT/ORDER 11.12.2025 JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P.O. on 24.12.2025 JUDGMENT/ORDER uploaded on 24.12.2025 -- 12 of 12 --
