Full Order Text
Final Order 2 · 31 Jul 2023 · CNR MHCC040069562023
Order Details: Order Pdf Text: 1 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT AT DINDOSHI BORIVALI DIVISION, GOREGAON, MUMBAI ST. NO. 2654 OF 2023 Vali Mohammed Ibrahim Kherani age 55 years, Occ.Business R/o. Open Plot No.12, Shop No.1835, Bharat Nagar, Bandra(E), Mumbai400 051 … Plaintiff V/s 1. Slum Rehabilitation Authority Through its Chief Executive Officer, Administrative Building, Prof. Anant Kanekar Marg, Bandra(E), Mumbai400 051. 2. Tehsildar 1 Slum Rehabilitation Authority, Administrative Building, Prof. Anant Kanekar Marg, Bandra(E), Mumbai400 051. … Defendants Appearance: Ld. Adv. Kanojia for plaintiff. Ld. Adv. Lulia for defendants. CORAM: Her Honour Judge Smt. Neeta S. Anekar (C.R.No.6) DATE : 12th July, 2023 ORDER ON DRAFT NOTICE OF MOTION The plaintiff has taken out this draft Notice of Motion for ad interim injunction restraining the defendants from evicting the plaintiff and demolishing the suit premises. 2. It is the case of the plaintiff that on 30.06.2023 defendant no.1 -- 1 of 5 -- 2 took out action u/s.33/38 of The Maharashtra Slum Areas (Improvement, Clearance And Redevelopment) Act, 1971. The SRA Officer issued notice in the name of 3rd person, who is not concerned with the suit premises. After the notice, the SRA Officer visited the suit structure on 10.07.2023 for demolition, on the ground that plaintiff's name is not reflected in AnnextureII. The plaintiff has informed the SRA Officer that he has already applied for deciding his eligibility of the suit structure and same is pending. But by letter dated 19.05.2023, Tehsildar SRA communicated that eligibility of the plaintiff shall be decided by competent authority i.e. MHADA. The plaintiff has claimed that though MHADA is competent authority, defendant no.1 wants to demolish the suit structure. Therefore, the plaintiff has taken out present Notice of Motion. 3. The request of plaintiff is orally resisted by the defendants contending that the cause of action accrued to the plaintiff as discussed in paragraph no.3 of the plaint is on 09.03.2023. Therefore, as such there is no urgency in the matter. It is further argued that the land belongs to MHADA but the scheme is undertaken by the society through SRA. With a view to the same, the present suit is not maintainable, and this court has no jurisdiction u/s.42 of the Act. 4. It is further argued that plaintiff himself paragraph no.5.3 has claimed that, “the structure was already demolished several years before and the concern slum occupier was already rehabilitated, however, the show cause notice has been issued in the name of that rehabilitated person because the malafide intention is to demolish the structure of this plaintiff. The same is being done at the instance of the -- 2 of 5 -- 3 persons having vested interest to clear that peace of land”. 5. Ld. Advocate for the defendants claimed that neither the society nor developer have made party to the present suit. Though the aforesaid averments in the plaint indirectly refers to them. At the same time when MHADA is the competent authority, the suit is not maintainable. 6. I have heard both the sides. The cause of action as set out by the plaintiff in the plaint is accrued on 09.03.2023. The additional affidavit specifies that on 10.07.2023, defendant no.1 approached for demolition on the ground that name of the plaintiff is not reflected in AnnextureII. 7. With a view to this claim, it can be seen that the letter dated 21.12.2022 placed on record by the plaintiff at Exh20 specifies that the same has been issued by SRA to Mohd. Harun Shaikh. The said letter makes it further clear the application of the plaintiff has been referred, with a view to this dispute for his inclusion of name is AnnextureII. That goes to show that the dispute as regards has already been referred to the concern society. Alongwith this as per own case of the plaintiff in para no.2 the suit premises is situated adjacent to another slum structure bearing Sr.No.16 of AnnextureII, which was already demolished. Therefore, at this stage also, the claim of the plaintiff that the suit premises is protected structure is not well founded. 8. The ld. Advocate for the plaintiff ratio laid down in the Hon'ble Bombay High Court in the case of Qari Mohammed Zakir Hussain & -- 3 of 5 -- 4 others V/s Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai & others (2001 SCC Online Bom 871. On the plaint reading of this ratio it can be seen that the only question for consideration before Hon'ble High Court was whether the trial court was justified in returning the plaint as presented by the appellants on the ground that the same was barred by section 42 of The MaharashtraSlum Areas (Improvement, Clearance and Redevelopment) Act, 1971. On the plaint reading of the facts it can be seen that the said aspect is to be decided on merits. 9. With a view to the same at this stage no any case is made out by the plaintiff to grant any ad interim relief in his favour. Therefore, on considering the own documents of the plaintiff, I am of the view that the defendant should be given opportunity to place on record their reply for consideration of this Notice of Motion on merits. Hence, the order. ORDER 1. Ad interin relief is hereby refused. 2. Defendant to file reply to N/M on next date for its consideration on merits. 3. The plaintiff to register the N/M. Date: 12.07.2023 Mumbai (Smt. Neeta. S. Anekar) Adhoc Civil & Assistant Sessions Judge Borivali Division, Dindoshi, Mumbai Date of dictation : 12/07/2023 Date of transcription : 12/07/2023 Checked & signed by HHJ on : -- 4 of 5 -- 5 CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER” Date : 07/08/2023 Mrs. P. P. Khanvilkar Time : 9:35 a.m. (Stenographer GradeI) UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge (with Court room no.) HHJ Smt. Neeta.S. Anekar, (C.R.No.6) Date of Pronouncement of JUDGMENT/ORDER 12/07/2023 JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P.O. on 13/07/2023 JUDGMENT/ORDER uploaded on 07/08/2023 -- 5 of 5 --
