Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 25 Sept 2025 · CNR MHCC040058832021
Order Details: Copy of Judgment Pdf Text: Comm.Sum.Suit No.28-2021 1 Judgment MHCC040058832021 Presented on : 30.08.2021 Registered on : 30.08.2021 Decided on : 25.09.2025 Duration : 04Ys.00Ms.26Ds Exh-18 BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT, BORIVALI DIVISION AT DINDOSHI,GOREGAON, MUMBAI COMMERCIAL SUMMARY SUIT NO.28 OF 2021 Ankit Agarwal Aged 34 years, Occ.Business Residing at 601, Gokul Heaven, Thakur Complex, Kandivali(E), Mumbai-400101 ] ] ] ] … Plaintiff V/s. 1. M/s.Ahuja Properties & Developers Partnership Firm, registered under the Indian Partnership Act, 2.M/s.Ahuja Properties & Associate Partnership Firm, registered under the Indian Partnership Act, 3.M/s.Shree Ahuja Properties and Realtors Pvt.Ltd. A company registered under the Companies Act,1956, Partner of defendant no.2 4.M/s.Hi Tech Global Infrastructure Pvt.Ltd., a company registered under the Companies Act, 1956, Partner of defendant no.2 ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] -- 1 of 9 -- Comm.Sum.Suit No.28-2021 2 Judgment 5.M/s.Shree Ahuja Properties Pvt.Ltd. Company registered under the Companies Act,1956, Partner of defendant no.2 6. M/s.Ahuja Platinum Properties Pvt.Ltd. Company registered under the Companies Act,1956, Partner of defendant no.2 7.M/s.Shree Ahuja Properties & Developers Pvt.Ltd. A company registered under the Companies Act,1956, Partner of defendant no.2 8.M/s.Magis Properties Pvt.Ltd. Company registered under the Companies Act,1956, Partner of defendant no.2 9.M/s.Keepsade Properties Pvt.Ltd. Company registered under the Companies Act,1956, Partner of defendant no.2 10.M/s.Topaim Properties Pvt.Ltd. Company registered under the Companies Act,1956, Partner of defendant no.2 11.M/s.Ahuja Housing Projects Pvt.Ltd. Company registered under the Companies Act,1956, Partner of defendant no.2 12.Jagdish Bhagwandas Ahuja,age not known Occ.Business Partner of defendant nos.1 and 2 above, and Director of defendants no.3 - 11 above 13.Gautam Jagdish Ahuja age not known Occ.Business Partner of defendant nos.1 and 2 above, and Director of defendants no.3 - 11above ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] -- 2 of 9 -- Comm.Sum.Suit No.28-2021 3 Judgment 14.Jai Wei Age : not known, Occupation : Business Director of defendant nos.5 and 8 (deleted vide order dated 09.02.2024) 15.Yifei Wang Age : not known, Occupation : Business Director of defendant nos.5 and 8 (deleted vide order dated 09.02.2024) 16.Shyamsunder Jaswantrai Hemrajani age not known, Occ.Business Director of defendant no.4 above 17.Ashok Chatumal Gacheria age not known, Occ.Business Director of defendant no.6 above 18.Roshan Ashoklal Jaisinghani age not known Occ.Business Director of defendant no.11 above All of the above having Office address at A/201, Rajpipla, Opp.Standard Chartered Bank, Linking Road, Santacruz(W), Mumbai-400054. ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ] ..Defendant s Plaintiff : Ld. Advocate Kunal Kumbhat Defendants no.1,2 and 12 : Ld. Advocate Shri.Vedprakash Mishra Defendants no.5 and 8 : Ld. Advocate Aryan Deshmukh CORAM : H.H.JUDGE SHILPA S.TODKAR COURT ROOM NO.3 Date : 25th September 2025 -- 3 of 9 -- Comm.Sum.Suit No.28-2021 4 Judgment :: JUDGMENT :: This is suit for recovery of an amount of Rs.43,70,363/- (Rupees Forty Three Lakh Seventy Thousand Three Hundred And Sixty Three Only) from Defendants alongwith further interest @ 21% p.a.on balanced principal amount of Rs.21,00,000/- from the date of filing of suit till realization of entire amount. Brief facts of the suit is as under :- 2. Case of Plaintiff is that defendant No.1 is a Partnership Firm registered under the provision of Indian Partnership Act and defendant Nos.12 and 13 are the partners of defendant No.1. Defendant No.2 is the Partnership Firm wherein defendant Nos.3-13 are the partners. The defendant Nos.3 to 11 are companies registered under the Companies Act, 1956. Although previously defendant Nos.12 and 13 were the Directors of defendant Nos.3-13, presently defendant No.12 is the Director of Defendant No.3, 4, 6, 7, 9, 10 and 11. Defendant No.13 is the director of defendant No.3, 5, 7 to 10. Defendant No.14 and 15 are the directors of defendant No.5 and 8 and defendant No.16 is the director of defendant No.4 and defendant No.17 is the director of defendant No.6 and defendant No.18 is the director of defendant No.11. 3. It is further case of the plaintiff that Defendant Nos.12 and 13 were Directors of Defendant Nos.3 to 13 when the loan was advanced to defendant No.1. Presently defendant No.12 is Director of Defendant Nos.3, 4, 6, 7, 9, 10 & 11. Defendant No.13 is Director of Defendant Nos.3, 5 and 7 to 10. Defendant Nos.14 and 15 are the Directors of Defendant Nos.5 and 8, defendant No.16 is Director of -- 4 of 9 -- Comm.Sum.Suit No.28-2021 5 Judgment defendant No.4, defendant No.17 is Director of Defendant No.6 and Defendant No.18 is Director of Defendant No.11. The Directors are responsible for day to day affairs of defendant Nos.3 to 11. Defendant No.2 is Partnership Firm registered under Partnership Act of which defendant Nos.3-13 are partners. Defendant No.13 is son of defendant No.12. 4. Plaintiff agreed to provide short term financial assistance to the tune of Rs. 25,00,000/- to defendants from time to time on assurance of defendant Nos.12 and 13 to pay interest @ 21% p.a. on the said loan amount on quarterly basis. It was also agreed that defendant No.1 would simultaneously issue bills of exchange for principal amount and post dated cheques for principal and interest amounts. 5. By way of RTGS, the plaintiff advanced 25,00,000/- to defendant No.1 and simultaneously defendant No.1 executed bills of exchange on transfer of each of the amount in favour of plaintiff which was accepted by defendant No.2. In discharge of liability, post dated Cheques were issued by defendant No.1 towards repayment of principal amount and towards payment of interest amount. Defendants honoured their commitment towards payment of quarterly interest, the post dated cheques towards principal amount was renewed and replaced by defendants on maturity time and again. The defendants requested plaintiff just before maturity of said cheques not to deposit the said cheques on maturity and sought sometime. In order to show their bonafides defendant No.1 made meager payment. The plaintiff presented the said cheques for realization and all the said cheques were -- 5 of 9 -- Comm.Sum.Suit No.28-2021 6 Judgment dishonoured and returned unpaid for the reason “funds insufficient”. Despite issuance of notice, the defendants have not made payment towards the demanded amount till date. According to the plaintiff, he is entitled to recover from the defendants jointly and severally an amount of Rs. 21,00,000/- towards principal with interest. 6. After the defendants have entered their appearance, the plaintiff has taken out Summons for Judgment Under Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (For short, CPC). Defendant Nos. 1 to 6, 8, 9 to 11, 13 to 14 have filed their leave to defend. Plaintiff has filed affidavit-in-rejoinder to the reply of defendant Nos.5 and 8. 7. The said Summons for Judgment No.80 of 2021 stands rejected on 05.07.2022 and leave to defend the suit to defendants is granted conditionally on depositing the principle amount of Rs.21,00,000/- in the court within two months from the date of the order. It is further ordered that if the defendants not complied with the conditional order of deposit within the stipulated period, the plaintiff is at liberty to take steps for further orders. 8. Ld. Advocate for the plaintiff submitted that till date the defendants have not complied with the order dated 05.07.2022 passed in Summons for Judgment No.80 of 2021 and therefore plaintiff shall be entitled to judgment forthwith vide O XXXVII of Code of Civil Procedure. -- 6 of 9 -- Comm.Sum.Suit No.28-2021 7 Judgment 9. Accordingly, the report is called from Civil Account Department (PLA Section) regarding the deposit of amount in view of the order passed in Summons for Judgment No.80 of 2021. The Account Department PLA Section filed report contending that after verifying all the records, it appears that defendants have not deposited any amount in this court in Account Department (PLA Section) from 05.07.2022 till today. Hence, it is clear that after passing order on Summons for Judgment No.80 of 2021 dated 05.07.2022, the defendants have not deposited any amount and failed to comply with the said order. 10. In view of O XXXVII Rule 6(b) of the Code of Civil Procedure,1908 if the defendant is permitted to defend as to the whole or any part of the claim, the court or Judge may direct him to give such security and within such time as may be fixed buy the Court or Judge and that, on failure to give such security within the time specified by the Court or Judge or to carry out such other directions as may have been given by the Court or Judge, the plaintiff shall be entitled to Judgment forthwith. 11. Herein, it is to be seen that despite of order dated 05.07.2022 passed in Summons for Judgment No.80 of 2021, the defendants failed to comply with the same. Hence, in view of the pleadings, documents filed on record and the provisions laid down under O XXXVII of Code of Civil Procedure, the plaintiff is entitled for decree. So far as the rate of interest and recovery thereof is concerned, plaintiff has sought recovery @ 21% p.a. The said rate of interest seems to be exorbitant. As the transaction in the suit arisen out of commercial -- 7 of 9 -- Comm.Sum.Suit No.28-2021 8 Judgment transaction, so, in view of Sec.34 of Code of Civil Procedure the plaintiff is entitled for recovery of the amount alongwith further interest @ 9%p.a.on principal amount of Rs.21,00,000/- from 29.03.2016 till realization of the entire amount. 12. In the result I pass following order; ORDER 1. Commercial Summary Suit No.28 of 2021 is partly decreed with costs. 2. Defendants no.1 to 13 and 16 to 18 do jointly and severally to pay to the plaintiff a sum of Rs.21,00,000/-(Rupees Twenty One Lakhs Only) alongwith further interest @ 9% p.a. from 29.03.2016 till realization of the entire amount within three (3) months from the date of this Order. 3. Defendants no.1 to 13 and 16 to 18 do jointly and severally do pay to the Plaintiff Costs of Rs.10,000/-(Rupees Ten Thousand Only) which is quantified under Section 35 of the Code of Civil Procedure,1908 as amended by the Commercial Courts Act,2015. 4 Decree be drawn up accordingly. 5. Court fee, if any, be refunded/recovered as per rules. sd/- (Shilpa S.Todkar) Judge, City Civil Court, Date : 25.09.2025 Borivali Division, Dindoshi, Mumbai Directly dictated on Computer : 25.09.2025 Corrected on : 29.09.2025 Signed on : 29.09.2025 -- 8 of 9 -- Comm.Sum.Suit No.28-2021 9 Judgment “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER” Date : 30.09.2025 Mrs.P.P.Khanvilkar Time : 10.35 a.m. (Stenographer Grade-I) UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge (with Court room no.) HHJ Smt. Shilpa S. Todkar (C.R.No.03) Date of Pronouncement of JUDGMENT/ORDER 25.09.2025 JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P.O. on 29.09.2025 JUDGMENT/ORDER uploaded on 30.09.2025 -- 9 of 9 --
