Full Order Text
Interim Order 3 · 18 Dec 2025 · CNR MHCC040058802021
Order Details: Order Pdf Text: CHS 1362/2024 : 1 : ORDER MHCC040094642024 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT AT DINDOSHI BORIVALI DIVISION, GOREGAON, MUMBAI CHAMBER SUMMONS NO. 1362 OF 2024 IN COMMERCIAL SUMMARY SUIT NO.26 OF 2021 Shree Ahuja Properties Private Limited & Anr. IN THE MATTER BETWEEN: ..Applicants Ketan Dhirajlal Barai ) ..Plaintiff Versus M/s Ahuja Properties & Associates & Ors. ) ..Defendants --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Appearance:- Learned Advocate Shri Kunal Kumbhat for the plaintiff. Learned Advocate Shri Aryan Deshmukh for the defendant No.5 and 8. Learned Advocate Shri Vedprakash Mishra for defendant No.1, 2, 12 and 19. --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- CORAM : A.R.Kamble Ad-hoc Judge, City Civil & Sessions Court, Borivali Division Dindoshi. (COURT NO.05) Date : 18th December, 2025 :: O R D E R :: 1. The defendant no.5 and 8 has preferred this chamber summons -- 1 of 11 -- CHS 1362/2024 : 2 : ORDER under Order VII Rule 11 r/w Section 151 of CPC for rejection of plaint for non compliance with mandatory provision of Section 12A, Commercial Courts Act, 2015 and for not disclosing cause of action against defendant no.5 and 8. 2. It is contended that the defendant no.5 and 8 who were the partners of defendant no.1 have retired with effect from 01.04.2015 by deed of retirement cum reconstitution. 3. The plaintiff has instituted the suit without complying mandatory provision of Section 12A of Commercial Courts Act, 2015. The cheques were issued by the defendant no.1 to the plaintiff which came to be dishonoured. The defendant no.5 and 8 were neither involved in any transaction with the plaintiff nor was the plaintiff aware about defendant no.5 and 8's existence as partners at the time when the transaction took place or defaults occurred. The suit is filed on the basis of default occurred after 31.03.2016, the defendant no.5 and 8 had already retired as partners of Ahuja Properties with effect from 01.04.2015 i.e. almost a year before the defaults occurred. They have no liability towards the defaults. 4. The defendant 5 and 8 are not necessary or proper parties for determination and adjudication of the matter. The averments in the plaint against these defendants are vague, generic and non definite and failed to make any purpose to cause of action against them. It is further contention of these defendants that retiring partners are liable to third parties after their retirement until a public notice of retirement is given, such retiring partners would not be liable to third parties if the third -- 2 of 11 -- CHS 1362/2024 : 3 : ORDER party was not aware of the existence of partner at the time of the transaction or the default. The plaintiff has not made averment that he was aware of the existence of defendant no.5 and 8 as partners of defendant no.1 at the time of defaults committed or loans were advanced. The plaintiff was dealing with defendant no.12 and 13 throughout the transactions, therefore there is no liability towards defendant no.5 and 8. There is no allegations against defendant no.5 and 8 and there is no statement in the plaint disclosing cause of action against them. Therefore, it is submitted to reject the plaint against the defendant no.5 and 8. 5. The chamber summons is opposed by filing say contending that the said chamber summons is filed delayed after the order is passed on summons for judgment and matter is fixed for passing of decree. The same contentions were raised by the defendants in leave to defend application and was considered even by the Hon'ble High Court by order dated 07.11.2023 in Civil Writ Petition No.8715 of 2022 except on the issue of non compliance of Section 12A of Commercial Courts Act, 2015. 6. It is further contention of the plaintiff that these defendants have introduced new facts which is not permissible. The plaintiff had already filed application seeking waiver of pre-mediation. The said application was allowed by reasoned order which is not challenged by these defendants. Therefore, the issue of non compliance of Section 12A of Commercial Courts Act, 2015 cannot be raised without challenging the order granting leave to register the suit after waiver of pre-mediation. As contended by the plaintiff the provision of Section 12A of the Act is -- 3 of 11 -- CHS 1362/2024 : 4 : ORDER made mandatory only after 22.08.2022 whereas the present suit is filed taking leave to waive the pre-insitution mediation prior to 01.10.2021. Hence, the bar of Section 12A could not apply. Therefore, it is submitted to dismiss the chamber summons with heavy cost. 7. Both the parties are heard at length. The main crux of the argument advanced by the learned advocate for the defendant no.5 and 8 is that mandatory pre-institution mediation is not done by the plaintiff. There is no cause of action to the plaintiff to file suit against these defendants. Since prior to the transactions with plaintiff and defendant no.1, 12 and 13, the defendant no.5 and 8 have retired and the plaintiff was not aware of whether they were partners of defendant no.1. Therefore, there is no cause of action against these defendants. The learned advocate relied on copy of deed of retirement cum reconstitution dated 01.04.2015. 8. In support of his contention the learned advocate for the defendant no.5 and 8 relied upon Hon'ble Authority ' Patil Automation Private Limited and Ors Vs Rakheja Engineers Private Limited', (2022) 10 SCC 1 and argued that in cases where no urgent interim relied is sought, requirement of pre-institution mediation has not been complied with. Any suit instituted violating mandate of Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act must be visited with rejection of plaint under Order VII Rule 11 of CPC. In view of the Hon'ble Authority, the declaration of law shall be effective from 20.08.2022. The learned advocate further relied upon Hon'ble Authority ' Deepak Raheja Vs Ganga Taro Vazirani', (2021) 1 HCC (Bom) 685 and argued that in view of facts of the cited case the mechanism and structure for pre-institution -- 4 of 11 -- CHS 1362/2024 : 5 : ORDER mediation was available as on 06.07.2019 when the suit was filed in the cited case, that time Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act was in operation. The structure and modalities were available to the plaintiff to exhaust the process of pre-institution mediation but the plaintiff in the present case has not complied the mandatory provision of Section 12A and therefore according to the submission of the learned advocate the plaint is to be rejected. The Main Mediation Monitoring Committee of Hon'ble Bombay High Court implemented mediation scheme from 11.02.2019. 9. The learned advocate for the defendant further relied on Hon'ble Authority ' Yamini Manohar Vs T.K.D. Keerthi', (2024) 5 SCC 815 and argued that the plaintiff has no any absolute choice and right to bypass mandatory provision of Section 12A by making prayer of urgent relief. According to the learned advocate the plaintiff had no reason to waive process of pre-institution mediation since the relief sought for were not urgent in nature. 10. The learned advocate relying upon the Hon'ble Authority ' Glorious Plastics Ltd. Vs Laghate Enterprises and Ors', 1992 SCC OnLine Bom 373 argued that retired partner who had not given notice of retirement sought to be held liable by plaintiffs for liabilities of the firm incurred subsequent to his retirement. Plaintiffs while dealing with firm not aware about the said person being a partner of the firm. Failure to give public notice would not make the retired partner liable to person who had no knowledge of such person being a partner. It is submission of the learned advocate prior to the transactions between plaintiff and defendant no.1, the defendants 5 and 8 were already retired from the -- 5 of 11 -- CHS 1362/2024 : 6 : ORDER defendant no.1 firm and therefore there is no cause of action to file suit against them. 11. In reply to argument advanced by the learned advocate for the defendant, the learned advocate for the plaintiff at the very outset argued that the plaintiffs has waived pre-institution mediation and the suit was instituted. The leave to register the suit is not challenged by the defendant and therefore the suit is maintainable and does not come within the ambit of Order VII Rule 11. By order dated 15.09.2021 the court has granted permission to waive the procedure laid down under Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act. The learned advocate also relied upon the Hon'ble Authority Deepak Raheja (supra) and argued that even for non compliance of Section 12A the plaint cannot be rejected and parties are to be sent for mediation. He further argued that the plaintiff applied for mediation. Notices were issued but there was no response from the defendants. Therefore, by application the plaintiff was permitted to waive the procedure of Section 12A of the Act. 12. The learned advocate for plaintiff argued that none of the grounds raised by the defendant comes within the ambit of Order VII Rule 11 of CPC. The present defendants are the partners of defendant no.1 Ahuja Properties. The grounds in the said chamber summons are not to be considered as the chamber summons under Order VII Rule 11 is to be decided on the basis of pleadings in the plaint. These defendants are liable to pay to the plaintiff being partners of Ahuja Properties and therefore there is cause of action to file suit against them. Therefore, it is submitted to reject the chamber summons. 13. As relied by the learned advocate for the defendants the Hon'ble -- 6 of 11 -- CHS 1362/2024 : 7 : ORDER Authority Deepak Raheja (supra) in the cited case the respondent does not seek any urgent interim relief and has not approached the legal services authority to exhaust the remedy under Section 12A of the Commercial Court Act. In view of the Hon'ble authority Patil Automation (supra) any suit instituted violating mandate of Section 12A be rejected under Order VII Rule 1 CPC. Compliance of Section 12A of the Act is mandatory. Pre-litigation mediation is necessary, unless the suit contemplates urgent interim relief. The Hon'ble Authority Yamini Manohar (supra) has held in para 10 that “ We are of the opinion that when a plaint is filed under the CC Act, with a prayer for an urgent interim relief, the commercial court should examine the nature and the subject-matter of the suit, the cause of action, and the prayer for interim relief. The prayer for urgent interim relief should not be a disguise or mask to wriggle out of and get over Section 12-A of the CC Act. The facts and circumstances of the case have to be considered holistically from the standpoint of the plaintiff. Non-grant of interim relief at the ad interim stage, when the plaint is taken up for registration/admission and examination, will not justify dismissal of the commercial suit under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code; at times, interim relief is granted after issuance of notice. Nor can the suit be dismissed under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code, because the interim relief, post the arguments, is denied on merits and on examination of the three principles, namely: (i) prima facie case, (ii) irreparable harm and injury, and (iii) balance of convenience. The fact that the court issued notice and/or granted interim stay may indicate that the court is inclined to entertain the plaint.” 14. On perusal of record it appears that the plaintiff had filed an -- 7 of 11 -- CHS 1362/2024 : 8 : ORDER application for waiving the procedure of pre mediation and this court after hearing the plaintiff granted permission to waive the procedure laid down under Section 12A of the Act observing that various reminders were sent to the defendant but the defendant did not appear. It appears from the roznama dated 15.09.2021 that the plaintiff had exhausted pre institution mediation but the defendant did not appeared. Therefore, by application the plaintiff sought permission to waive the procedure laid down under Section 12A of the Act. The defendant had to challenge the said order dated 15.09.2021 but instead defendants by this chamber summons which is filed on 06.11.2024 at belated stage seeking rejection of plaint under Order VII Rule 11. Since the procedure under Section 12A of the Act is waived by the order of this Court, the Hon'ble Authorities cited by the learned advocate for the defendant are not helpful to the submission of learned advocate that there is non compliance of mandatory provision of Section 12A. 15. The defendants seeking rejection of plaint under Order VII Rule 11(a). According to the learned advocate the defendant no.5 and 8 have no concern with the transaction of plaintiff with defendant no.1, 12 and 13. The defendant no.5 and 8 had already retired as partners of Ahuja Properties with effect from 01.04.2015 and the default of transaction was occurred on 31.03.2016 and therefore there is no cause of action to file suit against the defendants no.5 and 8. The learned advocate relied upon Hon'ble Authority Glorious Plastics Ltd.(supra) and submits that failure to give public notice would not make the retired partner liable to persons who had no knowledge of such person being a partner. According to the plaintiff, the present defendants were the partners of defendant no.1 and therefore they are liable to pay. In view of -- 8 of 11 -- CHS 1362/2024 : 9 : ORDER provisions of Partnership Act, 1932, the Hon'ble Authority has held that retired partner who had not given notice of retirement sought to be held liable by plaintiffs for liabilities of the firm incurred subsequent to his retirement. Plaintiffs while dealing with firm not aware about the said person being a partner of the firm. Failure to give public notice would not make the retired partner liable to person who had no knowledge of such person being a partner. 16. On perusal of plaint, it appears that as per the nomenclature of the suit, the defendant no.5 and 8 are shown as partners of defendant no.1 i.e. Ahuja properties and associates. It is not in dispute that defendant no.1 is a partnership firm. The defendant no.1 firm has issued the cheques to the plaintiff towards the interest and principal amount to the plaintiff as the plaintiff had advanced loan to the defendant. There is specific averments and prayer for recovery of amount jointly and severally from the defendants including the defendant no.5 and 8 being partners of defendant no.1 liable to pay to the plaintiff and thus there is cause of action against the present defendant no.5 and 8 to file the suit. According to the defendants, these defendant no.5 and 8 were retired with effect from 01.04.2015 whereas the default of payment occurred on 31.03.2016. It is to be noted that on the day of filing of suit the plaintiff had no knowledge whether these defendant have been retired from the partnership firm on 01.04.2015 since there is no public notice as required under the Act. In view of the Hon'ble Authority, failure to give public notice would not make the retired partner liable to persons who had no knowledge of such person being a partner. Here in the present case the plaintiff had specific knowledge that the defendant no.5 and 8 are the partners of defendant -- 9 of 11 -- CHS 1362/2024 : 10 : ORDER no.1 and there is no public notice to the knowledge of the plaintiff in respect of retirement of these defendants from the partnership firm/defendant no.1 Ahuja Properties and Associates and therefore there is cause of action to the plaintiff to file the suit against the defendants. Hence, the submission of the learned advocate that for want of cause of action, plaint be rejected would not come within the ambit of Order VII Rule 11(a) of te CPC. Hence, following order: ORDER 1. Chamber Summons No. 1362 of 2024 is hereby rejected. 2. Chamber Summons No. 1362 of 2024 is disposed of accordingly. (A.R.Kamble) Ad-hoc Judge, City Civil & Sessions Court, Date: 18.12.2025 Borivali Division Dindoshi, Mumbai. Directly typed on computer : 18.12.2025 Checked & Signed by HHJ on : 18.12.2025 -- 10 of 11 -- CHS 1362/2024 : 11 : ORDER CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.” 18.12.2025 at 05:41 p.m. Mrs Revati Kadam UPLOAD DATE AND TIME Name of the Stenographer Name of the Judge (With Court room no.) SHRI. A. R. Kamble (Court No.5) Date of Pronouncement of JUDGMENT/ ORDER 18.12.2025 JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P.O. on 18.12.2025 JUDGMENT/ORDER uploaded on 18.12.2025 -- 11 of 11 --
