Full Order Text
Final Order 4 · 02 May 2026 · CNR MHCC040058762021
Order Details: Copy of Judgment Pdf Text: Commercial Sum Suit No.23/21 1 MHCC040058762021 Received on : 17-09-2021 Registered on : 01-10-2021 Decided on : 02-05-2026 Duration : Y:04 M:07 D:01 Exh.30 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT AT BOMBAY BORIVALI DIVISION, DINDOSHI (BRANCH) COMMERCIAL SUMMARY SUIT NO.23 OF 2021 Saroj Shriram Gupta Aged : 58 years, Occ : -- Residing at B wing, 1103, Mahindra Eminent, S.V.Road, Patkar college, Goregaon (w), Mumbai 400104 Through Power of Attorney holder Shriram Ramrichhapal Gupta ...Plaintiff V E R S U S 1. M/s Ahuja Properties & Associates Partnership Firm, Registered under the Partnership Act. 2. M/s Ahuja Developers Partnership Firm, Registered under the Partnership Act. 3. M/s Shree Ahuja Properties and Realtors Pvt. Ltd., A company registered under the Companies Act, 1956 4. M/s Hi-Tech Global Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd., A company registered under the Companies Act, 1956 -- 1 of 11 -- Commercial Sum Suit No.23/21 2 5. M/s Shree Ahuja Properties Pvt. Ltd. A company registered under the Companies Act, 1956 Partner of Defendant no.1 6. Bhalchandra Trading Pvt. Ltd. Previously known as M/s Ahuja Platinum Properties Pvt. Ltd. A company registered under the Companies Act, 1956 Partner of Defendant no.1 7. M/s Shree Ahuja Properties & Developers Pvt. Ltd., A company registered under the Companies Act, 1956 Partner of Defendant no.1 8. M/s Magic Properties Pvt. Ltd. A company registered under the Companies Act, 1956 Partner of Defendant no.1 9. M/s Keepsade Properties Pvt. Ltd. A company registered under the Companies Act, 1956 Partner of Defendant no.1 10. M/s Topaim Properties Pvt. Ltd. A company registered under the Companies Act, 1956 Partner of Defendant no.1 11. M/s Ahuja Housing Projects Pvt. Ltd. A company registered under the Companies Act, 1956 Partner of Defendant no.1 -- 2 of 11 -- Commercial Sum Suit No.23/21 3 12. Jagdish Bhagwandas Ahuja Partner of Defendant nos. 1 and 2 and director of defendant no. 3,4,6,7,9,10 & 11 above 13. Gautam Jagdish Ahuja Partner of defendant no.1 and 2 and Director of defendant no.3, 5 and 7-10 above 14. Jia Wei and 15. Yefei Wang deleted as per order dated 02.03.2024 16. Shyamsunder Jaswantrai Hemrajani Director of defendant no.6 above 17. Ashok Chatumal Gacheria Director of defendant no.6 above 18. Roshan Ashoklal Jaisinghani Director of defendant no.11 above 19. Vandana Jagdish Ahuja Partner of defendant no.2 above All having office at : A/201, Rajpipla, Opp. Standard Chartered Bank, Linking road, Santacruz (w), Mumbai 400054 ...Defendant. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Appearance:- Ld. Advocate Shri Kunal Kumbhat for the Plaintiff. Ld. Advocate Shri Vedprakash Mishra for defendant no.1, 2, 12 and 19. Ld. Advocate Shri Aryan Deshmukh for defendant no. 5 and 8. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- -- 3 of 11 -- Commercial Sum Suit No.23/21 4 CORAM: A.R. Kamble, Ad-hoc Judge, City Civil & Sessions Court, Borivali Division Dindoshi. (Court No.05) DATE : 2nd May 2026. J U D G M E N T This is a suit for recovery of Rs.56,75,784/- alongwith interest @ 21% p.a. on principal amount of Rs.27,30,000/- from the date of filing of the suit till its realization. 2. Defendant no.1 is a partnership firm registered under Partnership Act of which defendant nos.3 to 13 are the partners. Defendant nos.3 to 11 are Companies registered under Companies Act. Defendant nos.12 and 13 were Directors of Defendant nos.3 to 13 when the loan was advanced to defendant no.1. Presently defendant no.12 is Director of Defendant nos.3, 4, 6, 7, 9, 10 & 11. Defendant no.13 is Director of Defendant nos.3, 5 and 7 to 10. Defendant nos.14 and 15 are the Directors of Defendant no.5 and 8, defendant no.16 is Director of defendant no.4, defendant no.17 is Director of Defendant no.6 and Defendant no.18 is Director of Defendant no.11. All the aforesaid Directors are responsible for day to day affairs of defendant nos.1, 3 to 11. Defendant no.2 is partnership firm registered under Partnership Act of which defendant nos.12, 13 and 19 are partners. Defendant no.19 is wife of defendant no.12 and defendant no.13 is son of defendant no.12. -- 4 of 11 -- Commercial Sum Suit No.23/21 5 3. The Defendant no.12 and 13, informed that they were carrying on business of construction and development of real estate through defendant nos.1 to 11 and there were several ongoing projects in the hands of defendants and other entities forming part of Ahuja Group and therefore they need short term financial assistance for the purpose of their business. 4. Plaintiff agreed to provide short terms financial assistance to the tune of Rs.32,50,000/- for which defendant no.12 and 13 on behalf of all the defendants agreed to pay interest @ 21% p.a. on the said loan amount on quarterly basis. It was also agreed that defendant no.1 would simultaneously issue bills of exchange for principal amount and post dated cheques for principal and interest amounts. 5. By way of cheques the plaintiff advanced Rs.32,50,000/- to defendant no.1 and simultaneously defendant no.1 issued bills of exchange for the said amount in favour of plaintiff which was accepted by defendant no.2. The copy of bank statement showing the above amount provided by plaintiff to defendant no.1 is annexed to the plaint. Post dated cheques issued by defendant no.1 towards quarterly interest were realized on maturity and after gaining confidence of plaintiff, defendant nos.12 and 13 requested to advance additional finances for their business. As per their request plaintiff advanced the amount of Rs.32,50,000/- in favour of defendant no.1 on the request of defendant nos.12 and 13 by way of cheques/RTGS. Simultaneously defendants issued post dated cheques towards repayment of said amount and interest in favour of plaintiff. They had also issued three bills of exchange in favour of plaintiff which were accepted by defendant -- 5 of 11 -- Commercial Sum Suit No.23/21 6 no.2. Then the defendants replaced four bills of exchange by one consolidated bill of exchange for amount of Rs.32,50,000/-. 6. Defendants regularly paid interest @ 21% p.a. to plaintiff after deduction of TDS till 31.03.2016 and defendant no.1 also issued confirmation of account. Copies of bank statement and confirmation account are annexed to plaint. Plaintiff requested defendants to make payment of interest for financial year 2016 -2017, but defendants cited the reason of severe financial crisis. Thereafter defendant no.1 made part payment of Rs.4,87,500/- on 02.5.2017 and 01.06.2017. Copy of bank statement is annexed to plaint. Due to severe financial crunches faced by them they issued post dated cheques for balance principal amount alongwith interest @ 12% p.a. Said cheques were presented by plaintiff but the cheques were dishonoured for the reason “funds insufficient”. Plaintiff intimated defendants about the dishonour of cheques, then they replaced the dishonourd cheques with four post dated cheques towards repayment of balance principal amount alonwith interest. The defendants requested plaintiff not to deposit the post dated cheques immediately on maturity. In the meanwhile, they made meager part payment of Rs.32,500/- . 7. After waiting for considerable period plaintiff presented said cheques for realization and all the cheques were dishonoured and returned unpaid with remark “funds insufficient”. Then plaintiff issued notice u/s. 138 of N.I. Act to the defendants and filed complaint against defendants. Since the defendants did not make payment of dishonoured cheques inspite of receipt -- 6 of 11 -- Commercial Sum Suit No.23/21 7 of notice, plaintiff filed complaint against the defendant nos.1, 3 to 13 u/s. 138 N.I. Act before learned Metropolitan Magistrate which is pending. 8. Plaintiff approached her advocate and demand notice was issued and defendants were called upon to make payment of balance principal amount alongwith interest. Inspite of receipt of notice the defendants have not made payment towards the demanded amount till date. Therefore plaintiff is entitled to recover from the defendants jointly and severally an amount of Rs.56,75,784/- in which Rs.27,30,000/- is balance principal amount. Defendants are also liable to pay to the plaintiff further interest @ 21% p.a. on balance principal amount of Rs.27,30,000/-. 9. From the averments in the pleading, following points arise for determination against which I have recorded the findings with reasons follow thereafter:- Sr. No. Points Findings 1. Does the plaintiff prove that the defendant is in arrears of Rs.56,75,784/- alongwith interest ? Partly in Affirmative 2. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for recovery of Rs.56,75,784/- to the plaintiff ? Partly in Affirmative 3. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for further interest at the rate of 21% per annum as claimed in suit ? Partly in Affirmative 4. What decree and order ? As per final order -- 7 of 11 -- Commercial Sum Suit No.23/21 8 R E A S O N S AS TO POINT NO. 1 TO 3:- 10. All these points are interconnected and therefore their discussion is clubbed. In support of the claim the plaintiff filed original documents vide Exh.24. The plaintiff relied on the following documents:- 1. Certified copy of evidence on behalf of plaintiff before Ld. Magistrate Court 2. Certified copy of List of documents filed before Ld. Magistrate Court 3. Certified copy of power of attorney 4. Certified copy of 7 Bill of exchange 5. Form 26AS 6. Cheques bearing no.430485, 460215, 418166, 418659 7. Dishonour memo of cheques 430485, 460215, 418166, 418659 8. Copy of legal notice 9. Copy of proceedings before Magistrate Court 11. I have heard both sides. The learned advocate relying upon the Hon'ble Authority A.B. and U Communications Pvt Ltd. Vs Jitu Shah, 2009 (6) Bom C.R. 427 argued that the defendant failed to comply the order dt.05.05.2022 in Summons for Judgment No.70 of 2021 wherein it was directed to the defendant to pay an amount of Rs.27,30,000/-. 12. The Hon'ble Authority relied by the plaintiff has held that once the defendants failed to comply with the terms to which they were put, the plaintiff's case will have to be decided on the basis of the plaint and the original documents as per the provisions of Order XXXVII Rule 3(6)(b) of the CPC. As per the order dt. 05.05.2022 in Summons for Judgment No.70 of 2021 the leave to defend was conditionally granted to the defendant on -- 8 of 11 -- Commercial Sum Suit No.23/21 9 payment of Rs.27,30,000/- but the defendant failed to comply the order and therefore in view of Hon'ble Authority and as per the provision of Order XXXVII Rule 3(6)(b) of the CPC, on failure to give security within the time specified by the court or to carry out such other directions as may have been given by the court the plaintiff shall be entitled to judgment forthwith. The defendant failed to comply the directions of the order given in Summons for Judgment no.70 of 2021 and therefore on the basis of pleading and original documents, the plaintiff is entitled to judgment. 13. It appears from documents filed by the plaintiff that in order to discharge his liability to refund the amount, the defendant issued several cheques including the cheques of the amount including principal amount and interest thereon. The amount claimed by the plaintiff is after deducting the part payment of Rs.4,87,500/- and Rs.32,500/-. Thus, the principal amount due is Rs.27,30,000/-. On the said amount the plaintiff is claiming interest from 01.04.2016 to 26.03.2021 at the rate of 21% per annum. However, the plaintiff failed to prove that there was any such agreement or contract to pay the amount at the rate of 21% interest. Therefore, the plaintiff is not entitled for interest prior to filing of the suit. Further, the liability is being arising out of commercial transaction, the plaintiff is entitled for the interest at the rate of 12% P.A. from the date of filing of the suit till the realization of the amount. Hence, following order and decree is passed:- ORDER 1. Commercial Summary Suit No.23 of 2021 is partly decreed with costs. -- 9 of 11 -- Commercial Sum Suit No.23/21 10 2. Defendants do pay to the plaintiff the sum of Rs.27,30,000/- along with interest at the rate of 12% p.a. from the date of filing of the suit till the amount is realized. 3. Decree be drawn up accordingly. (A.R.Kamble) Ad-hoc Judge, City Civil & Sessions Court, Date: 02.05.2026 Borivali Division Dindoshi, Mumbai. Directly typed on computer : 02.05.2026 Checked & Signed by HHJ on : 02.05.2026 -- 10 of 11 -- Commercial Sum Suit No.23/21 11 “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.” 02.05.2026 at 5.45 p.m. Ms. Darshana R.Bhoi UPLOAD DATE AND TIME Name of the Clerk-Typist Name of the Judge (With Court room no.) SHRI. A.R.Kamble (C.R. NO.5) Date of Pronouncement of JUDGMENT/ ORDER 02.05.2026 JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P.O. on 02.05.2026 JUDGMENT/ORDER uploaded on 02.05.2026 -- 11 of 11 --
