Full Order Text
Order 1 · 23 Jul 2026 · CNR MHCC040058712021
Order Details: Order Pdf Text: Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 1 ORDER MHCC040085412021 IN THE CITY CIVIL COURT AT DINDOSHI (BORIVALI DIVISION), GOREGAON, MUMBAI SUMMONS FOR JUDGMENT NO. 88 OF 2021 IN COMMERCIAL SUMMARY SUIT NO. 20 OF 2021 Nidhi Utsav Gupta (Previously Nidhi Jain) Aged :34 years, Occupation: Professional Residing At :- B Wing, 1103 Mahindra Eminent, S. V. Road, Patkar College, Goregaon (W), Mumbai 400 104. Through Power of Attorney Holder Shriram Gupta ... Applicant Versus 1. M/s. Ahuja Properties & Associates Partnership Firm, Registered under the Indian Partnership Act 2. M/s. Ahuja Properties & Developers Partnership Firm, Registered under the Indian Partnership Act 3. M/s. Shree Ahuja Properties and Realtors Pvt. Ltd., A Company registered under the Companies Act, 1956, Partner of Defendant No.1, 4. M/s. Hi- Tech Global infrastructure Pvt. Ltd., A Company registered under the Companies Act, 1956, Partner of Defendant No.1, 5. M/s. Shree Ahuja Properties Pvt. Ltd. A Company registered Under the Companies Act, 1956, Partner of Defendant No. 1, -- 1 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 2 ORDER 6. Bhalchandra Trading Pvt. Ltd. Previously known as M/s. Ahuja Platinum Properties Pvt. Ltd A Company registered under the Companies Act, 1956, Partner of Defendant No. 1, 7. M/s. Shree Ahuja Properties & Developers Pvt. Ltd., A Company registered under the Companies Act, 1956, Partner of Defendant No.1, 8. M/s. Magic Properties Pvt. Ltd. A Company registered under the Companies Act, 1956, Partner of Defendant No. 1, 9. M/s. Keepsade Properties Pvt. Ltd. A Company registered under the Companies Act, 1956, Partner of Defendant No. 1, 10. M/s. Topaim Properties Pvt. Ltd. A Company registered under the Companies Act, 1956, Partner of Defendant No. 1, 11. M/s. Ahuja Housing Projects Pvt. Ltd. A Company registered under the Companies Act, 1956, Partner of Defendant No. 1, 12. Jagdish Bhagwandas Ahuja Aged : Adult, Partner of Defendant Nos. 1 & 2 above, and Director of Defendant Nos. 3, 4, 6, 7, 9, 10 & 11 above, 13. Gautam Jagdish Ahuja Aged : Adult, Partner of Defendant Nos. 1 & 2 above, and Director of Defendant Nos. 3, 5 & 7-10 above, 14. Jia Wei Aged: Adult, Director of Defendant Nos. 5 & 8 above 15. Yifei Wang Aged : Adult, Director of Defendant Nos. 5 & 8 above -- 2 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 3 ORDER 16. Shyamsunder Jaswantrai Hemrajani Aged : Adult, Director of Defendant No. 4 above 17. Ashok Chatumal Gacheria Aged : Adult, Director of Defendant No. 6 above 18. Roshan Ashoklal Jaisinghani Aged : Adult, Director of Defendant No. 11 above All of the above having Office address at A/201, Rajpipla, Opp. Standard Chartered] Bank, Linking Rd., Santacruz (W),] Mumbai – 400054. ... Defendants Appearances :- Ld. Advocate Kunal Kumbhat for the Plaintiff. Ld. Advocate Vedprakash Mishra i/b Advocate Sahil Mahajan for the Defendant Nos. 1, 2, 12 and 14. Ld. Advocate Aryan Deshmukh for defendant nos. 5 and 8. Coram: Her Honour Ad-hoc Judge, Smt. S. N. Sachdeo (C. R. No. 12) Date : 23rd July, 2026 JUDGMENT 1. This is Summons for Judgment in Summary Suit filed by the plaintiff under Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, seeking decree of recovery of Rs. 8,72,815/- together with interest @ 21% per annum, on the balance principle amount Rs. 4,25,000/- from the date of filing of suit till realisation of payment. In response to appearance of defendants, plaintiff has taken out draft summons for Judgment and tendered registered summons for Judgment bearing No. 58 of 2021 as per Order 37 of C.P.C. 2. The defendant nos. 1 to 4, 6, 9 to 13, 16, 17, 18 filed their -- 3 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 4 ORDER leave to defend which is registered as NM No. 403 of 2022 for delay condonation, in their reply to Summons for Judgment. The plaintiff has filed affidavit in rejoinder to the reply of said Notice of Motion reiterated Summons for Judgment. Defendant Nos. 5 and 8 filed affidavit in reply to Summons for Judgment on 28/02/2022. Brief Case of the Plaintiffs is as under:- 3. It is contended that the plaintiff is residing at the address mentioned in the clause title. Defendant No. 1 is Partnership Firm, registered under Partnership Act, 1932 of which the Defendant Nos. 3- 13 are partners. Defendant No. 3 to 11 are companies registered under Companies Act, 1956. Though previously defendant nos. 12 and 13 were Directors of defendant nos. 3-13, presently defendant no. 12 is the Director of defendant nos. 3, 4, 6, 7, 9, 10 and 11, defendant no. 13 is Director of defendant nos. 3, 5 and 7-10, defendant nos. 14 and 15 are Directors of defendant nos. 5 and 8. Defendant No. 6 is Director of defendant no. 4, defendant no. 17 is Director of defendant no. 6 and defendant no. 18 is Director of defendant no. 11. All aforesaid Directors are responsible for day to day affairs of defendant nos. 3 to 11. Defendant No. 2 is Partnership Firm, registered under Partnership Act of which defendant Nos. 12 and 13 are the partners. They are carrying on business of construction development of real estate having office of address mentioned in clause title. 4. Defendant Nos. 12 and 13 represented to the family of plaintiff that the defendants and other entities are part of Ahuja Group. They are having several projects in hand at prime location at Mumbai. -- 4 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 5 ORDER They have already completed several projects. In October, 2011 plaintiff and her family were informed that the defendants were in need of finances for their projects and were willing to pay interest at the rate of 21% p.a. on the amount which would be provided to them. Upon request and assurance of defendant nos. 12 and 13 on behalf of defendant no. 1, the plaintiff agreed to provide short term financial assistance to the tune of Rs. 5,00,000/- to defendant no. 1. It was agreed that bills of exchange and post dated cheques would be issued for the principle amount by the defendant at the time of providing finance and defendant agreed to pay interest at the rate of 21% p.a. on quarterly basis to the plaintiff. Accordingly, at the request of defendant nos. 12 and 13 on behalf of defendant no. 1, plaintiff handed over cheque bearing No. 211507 for an amount of Rs. 5,00,000/- drawn on IndusInd Bank in favour of defendant no. 1 which was honored on presentation. Simultaneously, defendant no. 1 executed Bill of Exchange in favour of the plaintiff which was accepted by defendant no. 2 for amount provided by the plaintiff and also issued post dated cheques towards repayment of principle amount and towards payment of interest. The defendants honored their commitment and kept renewing cheques issued towards principle amount. 5. Till 31/03/2016 defendants made regular payment towards quarterly interest, but subsequent to it, defendants defaulted payment of interest. After lot of pursuation, defendants made part payment of Rs. 75,000/- on 16/09/2016 and issued post dated cheques. -- 5 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 6 ORDER Sr. No. Cheque No. Date Drawn on Amount 1. 430539 02/05/2017 Cosmos Bank Rs. 4,25,000/- 2. 460209 02/05/2017 Cosmos Bank Rs. 23,204/- 3. 418086 01/06/2017 Cosmos Bank Rs. 9,300/- 4. 418384 01/06/2017 Cosmos Bank Rs. 3,825/- 6. Defendant No. 1 also renewed Bill of Exchange for balance principle amount which is Rs. 4,25,000/-, dated 01/09/2016. Just before the date of maturity, defendants requested not to deposit said cheques and sought some time. After waiting for considerable period and when the validity of the cheques was about to expire, the plaintiff presented cheque to our Banker, HDFC Bank on 27/07/2017. However, except cheque bearing No. 418086, rest of the cheques were returned unpaid alongwith written memos with reasons ‘Insufficient Funds’. The plaintiff realized that defendants were no longer interested in returning finance, provided by the plaintiff. Hence, plaintiff presented Bill of Exchange issued by defendant no. 1 and accepted by defendant no. 2 by way of notice dated 30/06/2020 sent by the plaintiff through his Advocate calling upon the defendants to make payment of entire balance principle amount. But, none of said defendants paid amount inspite of receipt of notice. Therefore, the plaintiff has filed suit. 7. Defendant Nos. 1 to 4, 6, 9, 10 to 13, 16 to 18 marked their appearance and tendered registered Notice of Motion bearing No. 403 of 2023, coupled with delay condonation application. Upon condonation of delay, said Notice of Motion is considered, wherein, defendants denied all averments in the plaint contending that the -- 6 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 7 ORDER contents of plaint and Summons for Judgment are inconsistent. The AH Group have no nexus/connection with transactions entered into why the plaintiff with other defendants. No amount whatsoever were paid by the plaintiff to any of AH Group. There is no existing contractual obligation between the plaintiff and any of AH Group defendants. The plaint does not disclose cause of action against AH Group defendants. It is bad for misjoinder of parties, therefore, Summons for Judgment deserves to be dismissed. 8. The plaintiff does not have money lending license and therefore, cannot lend money as per the provisions of Money Lending Act. There is no privity of contract between the plaintiff and said defendants. From the documents, it goes to show that, transaction was entered into by defendant nos. 12 and 13 in their personal capacity and in the capacity of partners of defendant no. 1 and/or defendant no. 2. Likewise, security by way of deposit or otherwise, also ought to be provided by defendant nos. 1, 2, 12 & 13. The plaintiff has willfully suppressed the material facts and made false submission on oath to mislead the Court. 9. Registered address of defendant nos. 5 and 8 is at Ground Floor, Rajpipla, Opp. Standard Chartered Bank, Linking Road, Santacruz (West), Mumbai – 400 054 from August, 2017. Defendant Nos. 14 and 15 are the Directors of defendant nos. 5 and 8 since 01/10/2019. The change of address of defendant nos. 5 and 8 and appointment of defendant nos. 14 and 15, as Directors of defendant nos. 5 and 8 is filed in relevant forms with Registrar of Companies. In early 2018 Foreign -- 7 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 8 ORDER Investor, one Fosum Group approached Ahuja Construction Group to invest in real estate construction and development sector and acquired a stake in certain companies/entities of Ahuja Group. Said Forum Group through Hongkong based company in August, 2019 invested in Ahuja Hive Private Limite and majority share holders in said AHPL controls 12 special purpose vehicles including defendant nos. 5 and 9 which are undertaking various real estate construction and development projects. 10. The defendant nos. 5 and 8 are not under control and management of defendant nos. 12 and 13 and they are not in position to influence or bind any decisions on defendant nos. 5 and 8 by obligation of other defendants. Defendant nos. 1 and 2 are Partnership Firms of Defendant nos. 12 and 13 and they have no concern with AH Group. The plaintiff is tying to fasten liability of AH Group with malafide intent of harassing defendant nos. 14 and 15 who are Foreigners and extracting money from AH Group. The plaintiff never had any dealings with defendant nos. 5 and 8 and in fact defendant nos. 14 and 15 were not even the Directors prior to 2019. 11. It is further also contended that the plaintiff has not made clear whether defendant nos. 5 and 8 are liable in their personal capacity. Default in payment of interest if any, occurred only after 31/03/2016. Defendant nos. 5 and 8 had already retired as Partners of defendant no. 1 with effect from 01/04/2015 i.e. nearly a year before defaults where alleged to have been committed by defendant no. 1. Therefore, no liability can accrue to defendant nos. 5 and 8. Therefore, they are not liable for any defaults committed by APA after their -- 8 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 9 ORDER retirement. Thereby, they are prayed for unconditional leave to defend the suit. 12. Defendant no.5, 8, 14 & 15 in their leave to defend raised the following main defences :- There is no cause of action for filing present suit and summons for judgment against these defendants, as these defendants are not aware of transaction which took place between plaintiff and defendant no.1. There is no direct nexus of these defendants with transaction entered into by plaintiff with other defendants. No amounts were paid by plaintiff to any of these defendants. Plaintiffs document show that the transaction took place between defendant nos.12, 13 & 19 in their personal capacity and as partners of defendant nos.1 and 2 therefore they are liable to pay to the plaintiff and not these defendants. Suit is bad for misjoinder of parties. Defendant nos.14 and 15 are Directors of defendant nos.5 and 8 since 01/10/2019. As these defendants are not concerned with the transaction they are not liable to pay the claim amount of plaintiff and therefore no question arises to pay plaintiff interest @ 21 % p.a. They are impleaded as a party to the suit by plaintiff with malafide intention to extract money. 13. Defendant Nos. 1, 2 and 12 marked their appearance by filing Vakalatnama Exhibit – 11. 14. On behalf of Defendant Nos. 5, 8 and 12 notes of arguments is filed on record respectively. Subsequently, defendant nos. 14 and 15 filed pursis for adopting affidavit in reply dated 28/01/2022 -- 9 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 10 ORDER filed by defendant nos. 5 and 8, as their say to summons for Judgment. Today i.e. 18/07/2026 defendant nos. 1, 2, 12 and 14 have filed pursis to treat written notes of arguments filed by defendant no. 12 for and behalf of all of them. 15. The specific objections tendered by said defendants that there is no privity of contract between the plaintiff and A. H. Group defendants and therefore, they cannot be any admission of claim. On this count, the suit is bad for misjoinder of parties and issue of limitation. To my mind, it amounts to mix question of law which can be considered during trial and for that matter, it is essential to grant opportunity to the defendants to contest the matter. 16. After hearing Advocates of plaintiff and defendants and after going through their written notes of arguments respectively I have gone through the documents and citations relied by them respectively. 17. Considering rival contentions of the plaintiff and the defendants, following points are arise for my determination alongwith my findings for the reasons stated therein. Sr. No. POINTS FINDINGS 1) Whether Summons for Judgment is liable to be allowed or Leave to defend is liable to be allowed, conditionally or unconditionally ? Summons for Judgment Rejected and NM granted conditional leave. 2) What order ? As per final order. -- 10 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 11 ORDER REASONS Point Nos. 1 and 2 are clubbed and answered together :- 18. The learned Advocate for the plaintiff submitted that, the plaintiff has provided an amount of Rs. 8,72,815/- by way of cheque to defendant no. 1 on assurance that defendant nos. 12 and 13 would pay interest at the rate of 21% p.a. on said loan amount on quarterly basis. They agreed for the same and defendant no. 1 executed Bill of Exchange on transfer of amount in favour of plaintiff which is accepted by defendant nos. 12 and 13. 19. The defendant had issued post dated cheques and Bill of Exchange towards payment of interest. Defendants honored their commitment towards payment of interest amount of quarterly interest and thereafter, issued post dated cheques towards repayment of principle amount and towards payment of interest amount. They kept on renewing cheques issued towards principle amount. On 31/03/2016, defendants made regular payment of quarterly interest at the rate of 21% p.a. over principle amount after deduction of capital TDS. 20. After lot of request and pursuation, defendant no. 1 made part payment of Rs. 75000/- on 16/09/2016 and issued post dated cheques for payment of balance principle amount and interest amount due. Sr. No. Cheque No. Date Drawn on Amount 1. 430539 02/05/2017 Cosmos Bank Rs. 4,25,000/- 2. 460209 02/05/2017 Cosmos Bank Rs. 23,204/- 3. 418086 01/06/2017 Cosmos Bank Rs. 9,300/- -- 11 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 12 ORDER 4. 418384 01/06/2017 Cosmos Bank Rs. 3,825/- 21. After making part payment, defendants neglected the request of the plaintiff inspite of repeated reminders. After waiting for considerable time and when the validity of post dated cheques was about to expire, the plaintiff presented cheques for realization with her banker on 27/07/2017 except cheque no. 418086. Rest of the cheques returned unpaid for the reasons “Funds Insufficient”. 22. Thereafter, the plaintiff issued notice by presenting Bill of Exchange on 30/06/2020, calling upon the defendants to make payment of entire balance principle amount alongwith interest. Defendant no. 2 accepted said Bill of Exchange, but failed to make payment of amount. Therefore, the learned counsel for the plaintiff is prayed for recovery of Rs. 8,72,815/- from all defendants, as they are jointly and severally liable with further interest at the rate of 21% p.a. on balance principle amount of Rs. 4,25,000/- from the date of filing of the suit till its actual realization. The plaintiff has placed reliance upon the Judgment of :- i) Mour Marbles Industries Private Limited V/s. Motilal Laxmichand Salecha HUF and Others., 2018(4) Bom.C.R.777. ii) Parekh Aluminex Limited vs. Ashok Commercial Enterprises and another, in 2015(2) ALL.M.R. 679. iii) Tradelink Exim (India) Private Limited V/s. Tulip Land and Developers Private Limited. iv) Maharashtra Money Lending (Regulation) Act, 2014. v) Bharat Barrel and Drum Manufacturing Company V/s. Amin Chand -- 12 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 13 ORDER Pyarelal, (1999) 3 SCC 35. vi) Antwerspse Diamant Bank V/s. M/s. Kamal and Company, (2017) 138 Comp. Case. 866. 23. The learned Advocate for the defendants submitted that the suit is not maintainable as commercial suit, as it does not satisfy conditions of Order 17 of CPC, as it is not based upon any agreement, enactment or guarantee. The plaintiff is carrying the business of money lending, does not possess valid license to carry said business, therefore, claim of the plaintiff is bared by the provisions of Maharashtra Money Lenders Act. Friendly loan does not fall under the purview of Section 2(1)(c) of the Commercial Courts Act. There is no cause of action in filing the suit and SJ against the defendants. The defendants are not Partners of defendant no. 1 in question on account of their retirement. Therefore, they are not liable for making any payment towards claim amount of plaintiff. Thereby, they prayed for dismissal of suit and Summons fo Judgment. 24. Learned advocate for defendant nos.5, 8, 14 and 15 submitted that there is no cause of action for filing present suit and summons for judgment against these defendants. These defendants were not party to the documents annexed to the plaint and there is no nexus with the transactions entered into by plaintiff with other defendants. No amount was paid by plaintiff to these defendants, therefore no contractual obligation exists between plaintiff and these defendants. Transaction was entered into by defendant nos. 1 and 2 in their personal capacity and in the capacity as partner of defendant nos.1 -- 13 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 14 ORDER and 2 therefore they are liable to repay the loan amount to plaintiff. Therefore suit is bad for misjoinder of parties. As these defendants are not partners of defendant no.1 no question arises to make payment of claim of plaintiff and therefore no question arises to pay interest @ 21% p.a. to plaintiff. Plaintiffs suit is misconceived and abuse of process of law. Defendant nos.14 and 15 are foreigners and in order to harass them and extract monies from them they are impleaded as a party defendant to the suit by the plaintiff. These defendants are director of defendant nos.5 and 8 since 01/10/2019 and they are not liable for making any payment towards the claim amount of plaintiff. There is no existing contractual obligation between plaintiff and these defendants therefore it is prayed on behalf of these defendants that summons for judgment may be dismissed with cost. Learned advocate of defendant nos.5, 8 14 & 15 for his submissions relied on following rulings :- 1) Leela Capital & Finance Ltd., vs. Modiluff Ltd. & Others 2003(2) Bom C.R.683. 2) IDBI Trusteeship Services Ltd. vs. Hubtown Ltd. in 2016 DGLS (SC) 1193. 3) Jammu and Kashmir Bank Ltd. vs. Shri Digvijay Cement in 2008 DGLS (Del) 1659. 4) Hemmo Pharma vs. Dawood Shoes Pvt. Ltd. & another, (2003) 3 Bom CR 782. I have carefully gone through all the above cited rulings relied by learned advocate of defendant nos.5, 8, 14 & 15. 25. After going through documents filed on record by the plaintiff as well as defendants and after going through above discussed -- 14 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 15 ORDER citations, before proceeding further I would like to mention that, in order to decide Summons for Judgment, it is important to take into consideration what documents are produced by the plaintiff on record to establish their claim, whether triable issues are raised by defendants in their leave to defend application in order to decide suit summarily by deciding Summons for Judgment in absence of triable issue or if there are triable issues raised by the defendants, then whether those issues required interference of the Court to be dealt with by investigation in trial on the basis of evidence and in that event the suit cannot be disposed off summarily on the basis of Summons for Judgment. 26. The plaintiff has filed on record bank account and Bills of Exchange in order to show that Rs. 8,72,815/- was advanced to defendant no. 1 by way of cheque and Bills of Exchange for this amount were issued by defendant no. 1 in favour of the plaintiff which was accepted by defendant no. 2. Likewise, defendant has also produced on record cheques and memo of dishonor cheques alongwith Bill of Exchange, notice dated 30/06/2020. These documents prima facie show that loan was advanced by the plaintiff to defendants by which they executed Bill of Exchange in favour of the plaintiff and also issued cheques for payment of claim amount. The statement of account shows part payment made by the defendants to the tune of Rs. 9,300/- and Rs. 75,000/- on 16/09/2016. 27. Plaintiff has produced on record statement of plaintiff's bank account cheque bearing No. 211507 showing that Rs.5,00,000/- was advanced to defendant no.1 and for this amount defendant no.1 -- 15 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 16 ORDER which was accepted by defendant no.2. Plaintiff has also produced the cheques and memo of dishonoured cheques, bills of exchange, demand notice dated 30/06/2020 alongwith postal receipts and acknowledgment cards. These documents prima facie show that loan was advanced by plaintiff to defendants for which they had executed bills of exchange in favour of plaintiff and also issued cheques for payment of claim amount, statement of account discloses that part payment of Rs. 75,000/- was also made by defendant no.1. All these documents discloses that loan was advanced for which defendants had made part payment and for balance amount they had issued cheques which were dishonoured, thereafter demand notice was issued calling upon them to make payment of balance amount with interest. In this background, defences taken out by the defendants in their leave to defend in order to decide this summons for judgment needs to be discussed. 28. The objection raised by the defendants in respect of the plaintiff is not having valid license to carry on business of money lending as per the provisions of Money Lenders Act. After going through the statement of account, record of statement of account filed on record by the plaintiff, it reflects part payment made by defendants and post dated cheques issued towards balance claim amount and interest, therefore, it can be very well held that, in view of clause (f) of Section 2(9) of Maharashtra Money Lenders Act, loan does not fall within the purview of act as they are advances made on the basis of negotiable instrument i.e. cheques and bills of exchange. It is loan transaction which clearly falls within Section 2(13j) of the Maharashtra Money -- 16 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 17 ORDER Lenders Act, in view of ratio laid down by Hon’ble Bombay High Court in the case of Mour Marbles Industries Private Limited V/s. Motilal Laxmichand Salecha HUF and Others., 2018(4) Bom.C.R.777. 29. The defendants have failed to produce on record any document to show that there was N number of money lending transactions carried out by the plaintiff in the capacity of money lender in the light of documents produced by the plaintiff. It falsifies the contention of defendants about money lending transaction which goes to show that in order to escape liability of repayment of loan amount to the plaintiff, defendants have raised said objection. Likewise, defendants has also not denied the aspect of part payment towards payment of interest till March, 2016 which can be considered as acceptance of loan amount by them. 30. Defendants have not denied their signatures and stamp, more particularly of defendant no. 1 on bills of exchange and acceptance of liability to pay amount by defendant no. 2. Issuance of cheque is not denied. Therefore, I do not find any substance in said objection. 31. I would like to mention that, Defendant nos. 5 and 8 in their affidavit in reply have come with specific grounds that they have no nexus/connection with the transactions entered into by the plaintiff with other defendants as now they belong to A. H. Group. It will not be out of place to mention here that no specific date in this regard is mentioned by them in their entire affidavit. Therefore, same sounds to -- 17 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 18 ORDER be vague. 32. In chamber summons no.1455/2023 defendant nos. 5, 8, 14 and 15 prayed for deleting the name of defendant nos.14 and 15 and the same prayer is also made by the plaintiff in chamber summons no. 1455/2023 and same is allowed by my learned Predecessor on 08/05/2025. Further I would like to mention that chamber summons no.1455/2023 is partly allowed on the same day i.e. on 08/05/2025 by my learned Predecessor only to the extent of defendant nos. 14 and 15. 33. The material aspect agitated by them is objection in respect of insolvency petition bearing No. 32/2019 to 36/2019 and 38 of 2019 with NM No. 15625/2022 and insolvency petition bearing No. 4 of 2020 to 7 of 2020 and insolvency petition no. 1 of 2021, dated 24/06/2022 filed before Hon’ble High Court. Whether defendant nos. 14 and 15 are liable to pay the dues claimed by the plaintiff being Director of defendant nos. 14 and 15, at this juncture cannot be looked into. Perusal of order of Hon’ble High Court makes it clear that in case of any objection the plaintiff has to approach in regard to insolvency petition before competent authority i.e. official assignee. From said order of Hon’ble High Court, it is clear that the plaintiff in another set of matter has made a statement before Hon’ble High Court to withdraw the claim against defendant nos. 14 and 15 personally, but same is in respect of another suit inter-se between the plaintiff and these defendants and not in the present matter. In such situation from the above discussed chamber summons nos. 298/2022 and 1455/2023 the -- 18 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 19 ORDER plaintiff has been granted permission to delete their names. All the above discussed aspects seems to be triable issues which needs to be appreciated on touch stone of evidence in the light of right and interest between the plaintiff and the defendants and also in the light of change in alleged character of defendant firm and defendant nos. 14 and 15. 34. Learned advocate of defendant no.1 to 4, 6, 9 to 13, 16 to 19 submitted that present suit is not maintainable as a Commercial Summary suit as it does not satisfy conditions of Order XXXVII of CPC, it is not based upon any enactment or guarantee and therefore not covered under Order XXXVII Rule 2 of CPC. There is no cause of action to file the present suit. Plaintiff is guilty of suppressing true and correct facts from this Court. There is neither any agreement between the parties regarding any financial transaction nor there is any agreement between the parties wherein defendants have agreed to pay an amount claimed by plaintiff. Plaintiff is carrying on business of money lending and does not have valid license to carry out the business therefore recovery of claim is barred by provisions of Bombay Money Lenders Act. Friendly loan does not fall under the purview of Section 2(1)(c) of Commercial Court Act, therefore suit cannot be classified as Commercial suit. The alleged cheque were issued as a collateral security at plaintiff's insistence in good faith and were not issued for payment of legally enforceable debt. Plaintiff by depositing those cheques committed breach of defendants trust. Therefore the question of honoring said cheques does not arise. Therefore it is prayed that for these defences trial is required as they have good case on merits and unconditional leave to defend may be granted to them. -- 19 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 20 ORDER 35. To decide this summons for judgment it is important to take into consideration what documents are produced by plaintiff on record to establish their claim and then what triable issues are raised by the defendants in their leave to defend in order to decide whether the suit can be disposed of summarily by deciding summons for judgment in absence of any triable issue or if there are some triable issues raised by the defendants then whether those issues requires interference of Court to be dealt with by investigation in trial on the basis of evidence and in that event the suit cannot be disposed of summarily on the basis of summons for judgment. 36. The defendants raised objection that suit is not maintainable as commercial summary suit as it does not satisfy conditions laid down by Order XXXVII of CPC and as it is a friendly loan it does not fall under the purview of Section 2(1)(c) of Commercial Court Act. Suit is neither based on written contract nor upon any enactment or a guarantee therefore not covered under Order XXXVII of CPC. Bill of Exchange on the basis of which suit is filed is not properly stamped therefore not admissible in evidence. 37. Learned advocate of plaintiff submitted that suit is filed as Commercial Summary suit and transaction took place between financer and developer towards the liability of repayment, bills of exchange and cheques were issued by the defendants, therefore suit is very well maintainable as a Commercial Summary suit and relied on ruling of Hon'ble Apex Court in “Bharat Barrel and Drum Manufacturing Company vs. Aminchand Payrelal, (1999) 3 SCC 35”. I have carefully -- 20 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 21 ORDER gone through the ruling. In the present case admittedly bills of exchange and cheques were issued by the defendants towards repayment of loan amount of plaintiff and the transaction appears to be between the financer and developer therefore falls in the category of commercial transaction as well as in the category of summary suit prescribed under Order XXXVII Rule 2 of CPC. Therefore I do not find any substance in this defence taken out by these defendants and plaintiff's commercial summary suit is very well maintainable under the said category. The issuance of bills of exchange which were payable on demand is not denied by these defendants, bills of exchange bears the stamp and signature of defendant no.1 and acceptance was given by defendant no.2 which is also not denied by these defendants, therefore I do not find any substance in the defence of these defendants that bills of exchange are not properly stamped vide ruling of Hon'ble Bombay High Court in “Antwerspse Diamant Bank vs. M/s. Kamal and Company, (2017) 138 Comp.Case. 866”, wherein it is held that bill of exchange on demand is not liable for any stamp duty. Therefore this defence raised by defendants is not sustainable and plausible and appears to be raised merely to avoid liability. 38. Further contention of these defendants is that cheques were issued by them as a collateral security on plaintiff's insistence and not issued for any payment of legally enforceable debt, however they have failed to disclose for which collateral security those cheques were issued. Not only that the defendants have issued cheque of the above amount in favour of plaintiff for a loan which was advanced by way of -- 21 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 22 ORDER cheques to defendant no.1. As already discussed above these defendants have not denied that the amount has been advanced to defendant no.1 by plaintiff by way of cheques. Therefore it clearly appears that cheques were issued by defendants for repayment of loan which was advanced to them by plaintiff for which bills of exchange were executed by them in favour of plaintiff. Therefore this defence raised by defendants does not hold any water and totally implausible, merely raised to avoid the liability. 39. These set of defendants have not denied the signature and stamp of defendant no.1 on all bills of exchange and acceptance of liability to pay by defendant no.2, they have not denied the issuance of cheque, it is also not denied that the part payment was made by them, the defences raised by them are triable issues and therefore in my considered opinion they are not entitled for any unconditional leave to defend the suit. 40. Learned advocate for plaintiff submitted that the facts of this ruling are different than case in hand and not applicable. I have carefully gone through the above ruling of Hon'ble Bombay High Court and with due respect the facts of the case are different and therefore not applicable to the case in hand. 41. In the present case, the defence of these defendants is that, transaction was entered into by defendant nos.12, 13 & 19 in their personal capacity and as partners of defendant nos.1 and 2, for which these defendants cannot be held liable as they are not partners of -- 22 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 23 ORDER defendant no.1 and defendant nos.12 & 13 are not responsible for day to day affairs of defendant nos.5 & 8. 42. On the contrary learned advocate of plaintiff argued that, there is no specific denial of these defendants in their leave to defend in respect of partnership with defendant no.1 at the time when loan was advanced by plaintiff to defendant no.1. It is the admitted position that in leave to defend of these defendants there is no such specific denial and they have preferred to contend that,” they are not partners of defendant no.1 but they have not specified as to when the defendant no.5 and 8 have ceased to be partners of defendant no.1. As per provisions of Order 8 Rule 3 of CPC denial of defendant should be specific and general denial shall not be sufficient. Absence of specific denial by these defendants as to their partnership with defendant no.1 at the time of loan transaction of present suit shall be taken as admitted as per provisions of Order 8 Rule 5(1) of CPC. Therefore in absence of specific denial by these defendants it has to be concluded as admitted that they were partners of defendant no.1 at the time of loan transaction between plaintiff and defendant no.1 in the present suit. 43. The contention of these defendants that there is no cause of action for filing present suit is without any base because averments in plaint discloses that cause of action arose when the cheques which were issued for repayment of loan got dishonoured and plaintiff issued notice to the defendants by calling upon them to make payment of balance amount alongwith interest. The contention of these defendants that -- 23 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 24 ORDER they are not party to the documents annexed to plaint and have no nexus with transaction as well as plaintiff did not pay any amount to them therefore there is no contractual obligation between plaintiff and these defendants is also not sustainable, in view of above discussion that loan was advanced by plaintiff to defendant no.1 and for repayment defendant no.1 issued postdated cheques and bills of exchange, in bills of exchange the liability to pay was admittedly accepted by defendant no.2 and when there is absence of specific denial by these defendants that at the time when loan was advanced by plaintiff to defendant no.1 regarding their partnership with defendant no.1 which leads to the admission that they were partners of defendant no.1, and therefore they are also liable to pay the dues of plaintiff. In view of it these grounds/defences only points out that in order to get escaped from the liability they have taken out. Therefore I do not find any substance in this defence raised by them. 44. Further they have contended that, it appears from the documents produced by plaintiff on record that loan transaction took place between plaintiff and defendant no.1 based on the representations of defendant nos.12 and 13 and defendant no.2 accepted to pay in bills of exchange issued by defendant no.1 in favour of plaintiff. 45. Vide ruling of Hon'ble Apex Court in “IDBI Trusteeship Services Ltd. vs. Hubtown Ltd. in 2016 DGLS (SC) 1193”, it is held that “if the defendant satisfies the Court that he has a substantial defence, that is a defence that is likely to succeed, the plaintiff is not entitled for leave to summons for Judgment and defendant is entitled to -- 24 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 25 ORDER unconditional leave to defend the suit”. 46. I have carefully gone through this ruling, considering the absence of specific denial of these defendants in respect of their partnership with defendant no.1 at the time of loan transaction which took place between plaintiff and defendant no.1, leaves a scope for doubt about defendants good faith and genuineness of triable issue and therefore in my considered opinion, case of these defendants falls in the category 'C' specified by Hon'ble Apex Court in this ruling. If the doubt is left regarding defendants good faith or genuineness of triable issue, the Court may impose conditions both as to time or mode of trial, as well as payment into Court or furnish security. 47. From the documents produced by plaintiff on record, it clearly appears that defendant no.1 accepted the loan amount and issued cheques, executed bills of exchange, rest of the defendants are partners of defendant no.1 and each partner of firm is jointly and severally liable for the acts of firm. Also considering that mere change in management does not absolve the liability of company towards its creditors, therefore contention of these defendants that defendant nos.14 & 15 are not liable for any payment in personal capacity as per order in Chamber Summons Nos. 298/2022 and 1455/2023 but change in legal character of defendants 1 defendant nos. 5 and 8 needs trial to fix liability for the payment of dues to plaintiff. 48. These defendants have contended that plaintiff is guilty of suppression of material facts and made false submissions, however -- 25 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 26 ORDER which facts are concealed by the plaintiff from this Court is not revealed by these defendants. Therefore this contention appears to be baseless and vague. 49. Learned advocate of these defendants in his oral argument raised the ground of limitation, suit is not filed within limitation therefore barred by law of limitation and placed reliance on the ruling of Hon'ble Bombay High Court in “Hemmo Pharma vs. Dawood Shoes Pvt. Ltd. & another, (2003) 3 Bom CR 782”, I have carefully gone through the ruling of Hon'ble Bombay High Court. In their leave to defend these defendants have not taken out any such defence. The issue of limitation has to be raised at very initial stage as soon as the defendants causes their appearance through their advocate. The stage has passed, lately in the oral argument this issue is raised. As discussed above for repayment of loan the defendants have time and again issued cheques and bills of exchange, part payment of amount admittedly have been made by the defendants to the plaintiff, dishonour of cheques on 27/07/2017 and presentation of bills of exchange on 30/06/2020, thereafter suit was lodged on 20/03/2021, which clearly shows that suit is within limitation. Therefore, I do not find any substance in this ground/defence that suit is not within limitation and this defence again appears to have been raised merely to escape the liability. 50. Learned advocate of these defendants for his submission that, these defendants are entitled for unconditional leave to defend the suit, as onus to show triability of issue is always light and grant of leave -- 26 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 27 ORDER is always to be preferred except in a crystal clear case, placed reliance on the ruling of Hon'ble Delhi High Court in “Jammu and Kashmir Bank Ltd. vs. Shri Digvijay Cement in 2008 DGLS (Del) 1659”. 51. Therefore for the above discussion this Court is of considered opinion that conditional leave to defend the suit can be granted to all the defendants in view of the settled law that the defence of defendants discloses such facts as may be sufficient to entitle them to defend because reply affidavit of defendants show that stage of facts as leads to the interference that during trial of the action they may be liable to establish a defence to plaintiff's claim. So far as the rate of interest and recovery thereof is concerned, plaintiff has sought recovery @ 21% p.a. However rate of interest is a triable issue and the defendants have disputed it in their leave to defend, contending that plaintiff is claiming exorbitant amount of interest which they are not liable to pay. Therefore it can be kept open with rest of the objections raised by defendants in the trial. During the trial the parties can lead evidence and after investigation the issue of rate of interest and recovery thereof will be decided. 52. In the result, conditional leave to defend the suit can be granted to the defendants subject to payment of principal amount Rs.4,25,000/-. Therefore I answer point no.1 accordingly and proceed to pass the following order in respect of point no.2. ORDER 1) The Summons for Judgment No. 88 of 2021 is dismissed. 2) The Defendants are granted conditional leave to defend the suit, -- 27 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 28 ORDER subject to their depositing a sum of Rs.4,25,000/-(Rupees Four Lakhs Twenty Five Thousand Only) jointly and severally in this Court within six weeks from the date of this order. 3) On deposit, the Registry shall invest the said amount in an interest- bearing fixed deposit with a nationalised bank, initially for 12 months, with auto-renewal, to the credit of the present suit, subject to further orders of this Court. 4) Upon compliance, the suit shall be converted into a Regular Civil Suit. The Defendants shall be entitled to file their Written Statement within 30 days from conversion. 5) In default of deposit the Plaintiff shall be entitled to apply for an appropriate order or decree in accordance with law. 6) Accordingly, the Summons for Judgment No. 88 of 2021 stand disposed off. Date : 23.07.2026 (S. N. Sachdeo) Ad-hoc City Civil Judge, City Civil Court, (Borivali Division), Dindoshi, Goregaon, Mumbai Directly Dictated by HHJ on Computer : 23.07.2026 Checked & Signed by HHJ on : 23.07.2026 -- 28 of 29 -- Summons for Judgment No. 88/2021 in Commercial Summary Suit No. 20/2021 29 ORDER CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER” Date : 23/07/2026 Miss. Tejal C. Rane Time : 6.15 P. M. (Stenographer Grade-I) UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge (with Court room no.) HHJ Smt. S. N. Sachdeo (Court Room No. 12) Date of Pronouncement of JUDGMENT/ORDER 23.07.2026 JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P.O. on 23.07.2026 JUDGMENT/ORDER uploaded on 23.07.2026 -- 29 of 29 --
