Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 12 Feb 2026 · CNR MHCC040023052025
Order Details: Order Pdf Text: N/M No.915/2025 in SU-1879/2024 1 Order MHCC040023052025 IN THE CITY CIVIL COURT FOR GR.MUMBAI AT DINDOSHI BORIVALI DIVISION, MUMBAI NOTICE OF MOTION NO.915/2025 IN S. C. SUIT NO.1879/2024 M. D. Shetty and Associates. ... Plaintiff. Vs. STC Employees Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. ... Defendant. Adv. Manoj Prajapati, for Plaintiff. Adv. Abhijit Mahadik, for Defendant. CORAM : K. R. Deshpande Ad-hoc City Civil Judge, (C.R. No.16) Date : 12th February, 2026 O R D E R Defendant has taken out this notice of motion for rejection of plaint under Order 7, Rule 11 of CPC. 2. Perused affidavit in support of notice of motion and affidavit in reply filed by plaintiff. 3. Heard the learned counsels for both the sides. -- 1 of 5 -- N/M No.915/2025 in SU-1879/2024 2 Order 4. Perused the record. 5. By this notice of motion defendant prayed for rejection of plaint under Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC on the ground that, suit is barred by law under Section 163 of Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act as per approved bylaws of the society object is to do the business and this resolution is challenged by the plaintiff. Therefore, this is affair of the society and this court has no jurisdiction because the plaintiff is nominal member. It is further contended that, as per the bye laws society decided to retain ownership of shop by accepting the deposit from nominal member. Therefore, the suit is not maintainable. 6. The plaintiff filed reply and strongly opposed the notice of motion on the ground that, the defendant by suppressing their fault filed this mischievous notice of motion. It is contended that defendant failed to oblige their obligations and taking advantage of their own fault filed this false notice of motion. The plaint cannot be rejected on the say of defendant under Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC. It is denied that, the object of the society is to borrow the money because it is Co-operative Housing Society there cannot be object of business of such society and therefore prayed for rejection. 7. The learned counsel for defendant submitted that, the plaintiff is nominal member. He was given license governed by rules, bye laws of the society. The suit property belongs to the society. Suit is filed for declaration of ownership as well as adverse possession. The suit property was given on license and therefore this court has no jurisdiction, he can approach under Section 91 of the Co-operative Societies Act. The plaintiff paid deposit amount and hence prayed for -- 2 of 5 -- N/M No.915/2025 in SU-1879/2024 3 Order rejection of plaint. 8. As against this, the learned counsel for plaintiff submitted that, the defendant wanted to sell the suit property and assured to execute agreement. The plaintiff is in possession of suit property since last 33 years. The society wanted capital gain without paying income tax and therefore prayed for rejection. 9. I have considered submissions of both the parties and find that, the plaintiff instituted this suit and prayed for declaration of ownership, permanent injunction and alternately prayed for declaration on the basis of adverse possession. It is well settled position of law that, the plaintiff can take defences of ownership as well as adverse possession. At appropriate time plaintiff has to waive either of defence. In view of this settled position I find that, it is the Civil Court which can consider defence of adverse possession. It is also settled position of law that, under Order 7, Rule 11 of CPC the pleadings of plaint and the documents produced by the plaintiff that too forming the part of pleadings only can be considered under Order 7 Rule 11 of CPC. Of course there is prayer of declaration of resolution dated 30.07.1988 as null and void. However, as far as declaration of ownership and adverse possession issues definitely false within the jurisdiction of this court. 10. Since the defendant relying on their policies, object and tried to get ousted the plaintiff from this court. However, the plaintiff has denied the alleged object of the defendant. Prima facie it is Co- operative Housing Society and therefore whether business can be object of Housing Society this aspect is doubtful. Apart from it, the plaintiff has produced several documents to show that, the defendant agreed to -- 3 of 5 -- N/M No.915/2025 in SU-1879/2024 4 Order execute agreement for sale in favour of the plaintiff by obtaining legal opinion and also issue was considered to sell outrage to the plaintiff. Whether this deposit amount was really towards deposit or consideration this aspect also needs to be looked into. I find that, under Order 7, Rule 11 of CPC these aspects cannot be considered. Prima facie I find that the plaint cannot be rejected entirely and therefore this court has very well jurisdiction to entertain the suit. 11. The defendant relied on case laws reported in Naru B. Shetkar Vs. Vishram Jaya Shetkar and Ors., O. N. Bhatnagar Vs. Smt. Rukibai Narsindas & Ors. and Puran Singh Sahni Vs. Sundari Bhagwandas Kripalani and Ors. I have gone through these case laws and facts and circumstances of present case. In these cases it was held that, the documents produced by plaintiff would be part of the plaint as it naturally forms part of the pleadings in the plaint and court can take into consideration the documents. In another case it was held that, the touching of the business of the society the dispute lies to Co-operative Court under Section 91. In another case it was found that, there was intention of the agreement to give lease or license and therefore licensee acquired status of tenant. In another case reported in Liverpool and London S. P. and I Asson. Ltd. Vs. M. V. Sea Success I and Ors., it was held that documents produced by plaintiff forming part of plaint needs to be considered. After considering all these case laws, facts and circumstances of the present case, I find that these case laws do not extent any help to the defendant. I therefore do not find any substance in the notice of motion. Hence, the following order: ORDER 1. Notice of Motion No.915 of 2025 is rejected. 2. Cost in cause. -- 4 of 5 -- N/M No.915/2025 in SU-1879/2024 5 Order 3. Notice of Motion No.915 of 2025 is disposed of accordingly. 12/02/2026 (K. R. Deshpande) Ad-hoc City Civil Judge City Civil Court, Dindoshi, Mumbai. Dictation given directly on Computer on: 12/02/2026 Checked & Signed by HHJ on : 12/02/2026 “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.” UPLOADED ON 12.02.2026 AT 05.55 PM Mrs. J. S. Gawai NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge (with Court Room No.) HHJ Shri. K. R. Deshpande, C.R. No.16. Date of Pronouncement of Judgment/Order. 12/02/2026 Judgment/Order signed by P.O. on 12/02/2026 Judgment/Order uploaded on 12/02/2026 -- 5 of 5 --
