Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 31 Jul 2025 · CNR MHCC040012202025
Order Details: Order Pdf Text: SU. No.3023/2006 in NM.No.484/25 1 Order MHCC040012202025 IN THE COURT OF SESSIONS, AT DINDOSHI (BORIVALI DIVISION), GOREGAON, MUMBAI NOTICE OF MOTION NO.484 OF 2025 (CNR NO.MHCC04-001220-2025) IN CHAMBER SUMMONS NO.141 OF 2019 IN L. C. SUIT NO.3023 OF 2006 (CNR NO.MHCC04-000191-2006) Rizvi Estate and Hotel Pvt. Ltd., ] … Plaintiff Vs. The Municipal Corporation of Gr. Mumbai. ] … Defendant Plaintiff :Ld. Advocate Siddique. Defendant Corporation :Ld. Advocate Swapnil Bharti. CORAM : H.H. ADHOC JUDGE CITY CIVIL COURT & ADDITIONAL SESSIONS JUDGE. SHRI Y. M. H. KHARADI (C.R.NO.14) Date : 31st July, 2025. ORDER The Plaintiff has filed the present Notice of Motion for condonation of delay and set aside the order passed on 18/12/2024 for -- 1 of 5 -- SU. No.3023/2006 in NM.No.484/25 2 Order dismissing the Chamber Summons NO.141 of 2019 for want of prosecution. Brief facts which gives rise to file this Notice of Motion are as under : 2. Plaintiff has filed the suit against the corporation for perpetual injunction in respect of the suit property in which or of status-quo is passed by the Hon’ble High Court. But, in the year 2015, his staff informed him that, RKW Developers Pvt. Ltd., was proposing to develop a SRA project on the said property and had obtained the necessary permission from SRA and Municipal Authority. Hence, plaintiff applied the documents under the RTI Act. 3. Thereafter, he taken out the Chamber Summons No.141 of 2019 and that was adjourned from time to time. But, it was argued before the Predecessor. Afterwards, it was dismissed for want of prosecution. But, as the plaintiff was out of India fo his medical treatment. Hence, he can not instruct his advocate. He contended that, if, the order of dismissal of Chamber Summons is set aside, then no prejudice would be caused to the defendant and for deciding the matter on merits in the interest of justice, it is necessary to restore the Chamber Summons NO.141 of 2019 by condoling the delay. Hence, this Notice of Motion. 4. Defendant corporation resisted the application and contending that, as the plaintiff has not interested to proceed with the Chamber Summons. Hence, this court has rightly dismissed the Chamber Summons. Therefore prayed to reject the Notice of Motion. -- 2 of 5 -- SU. No.3023/2006 in NM.No.484/25 3 Order 5. Perused the application, affidavit and say of Defendant Corporation. Heard both the sides. They submitted as per their contentions. 6. Considering the say of Defendant it is only objected that sufficient opportunity given to the plaintiff. But, in the present Notice of Motion, the reason of delay was given that, due to medical treatment, plaintiff was out of India and that was not denied by the Defendant. Therefore, the reason given for the absence of the plaintiff on 18/12/2024 seems to be justifiable. If, the order of 18/12/2024 is set aside by condoling a delay it would not prejudice to the defendant. On the contrary, it will assist the Court to decide the matter on merit. Hence, considering the prayer in the Notice of Motion and above reasons, to avoid multiplicity in the interest of justice, it is just and reasonable to allow the Notice of Motion and set aside the order dated 18/12/2024 of Chamber Summons No.141/2019 by condoling the delay of 9 days. Hence, Notice of Motion is liable to be allowed. In a result, I proceeded to pass following order: - ORDER 1. Notice of Motion No.484 of 2025 is hereby allowed. 2. The Delay to file Notice of Motion is condone and the order passed on 18/12/2024 in the Chamber Summons NO.141 of 2019 is set aside and the Chamber Summons is hereby restored with the directions that, plaintiff to proceed the Chamber Summons No.141 -- 3 of 5 -- SU. No.3023/2006 in NM.No.484/25 4 Order of 2019 without seeking adjournment. 3. Notice of Motion No. 484 of 2025 stands disposed off accordingly. Date: 31.07.2025 (Y. M. H. Kharadi) Adhoc Judge, City Civil Court & Additional Sessions Judge, Borivali Division, Dindoshi Goregaon, Mumbai. Dictated on : 31.07.2025 Transcribed on : 31.07.2025 Corrected and Signed on : 31.07.2025 -- 4 of 5 -- SU. No.3023/2006 in NM.No.484/25 5 Order “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER” Date : 31.07.2025 Mrs.Madhura M. Palav Time : 05.30 P.M. (Stenographer Grade-I) UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge (with Court room no.) HHJ Shri Y. M. H. Kharadi. (C.R.No.14) Date of Pronouncement of JUDGMENT/ORDER 31.07.2025 JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P.O. on 31.07.2025 JUDGMENT/ORDER uploaded on 31.07.2025 -- 5 of 5 --
