Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 25 Nov 2025 · CNR MHCC040009592025
Order Details: Order Pdf Text: : 1 : CHS 180/2025 in Suit 1742/2024 ORDER MHCC040009592025 BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT, BORIVALI DIVISION AT DINDOSHI, GOREGAON, MUMBAI CHAMBER SUMMONS NO. 180 OF 2025 IN S. C. SUIT NO. 1742 OF 2024 Mrs. Nitu Sharma widow of Manish Sharma …Plaintiff VERSUS Mr. Joginder Ramlakhan Pankaj & Ors. …Defendants AND The Adani Electricity ...Respondent ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Advocate Shri. Manoj Pandey for the Plaintiff. Advocate Ms. Archana Sharma for the Defendants. Advocate Ms. Mudha Shetty for the Respondent. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ CORAM : SHRI. B. D. PAWAR Judge City Civil Court, Borivali Division, Dindoshi, Mumbai. (Court Room No.04) DATE : 25th November, 2025 -- 1 of 5 -- : 2 : CHS 180/2025 in Suit 1742/2024 ORDER :: O R D E R :: 1. The plaintiff has filed this Chamber Summons under Order-VI Rule17 The Civil Procedure Code for amendment and under Order-I Rule-10(2) of The Civil Procedure Code for addition of respondent as defendant No.4 in the suit. 2. Read the Chamber Summons and say filed by the Advocate for the respondent. Heard Advocate Shri.Manoj Pandey for the plaintiff and Advocate Ms.Mugdha Shetty for the respondent. Advocate Ms.Archana Sharma for defendants submitted that she has no arguments to make on the Chamber Summons. 3. Advocate Shri.Pandey for the plaintiff submitted that the plaintiff is a title holder and in possession of suit property i.e Bungalow No.3/2 known as Sakseria Bungalow described in paragraph No.1 of the plaint. Defendant No.1 is not concerned with the suit property. However, with the help of defendant Nos.2 and 3 he has trespassed into part of the suit property i.e one room admeasuring 10 x 10 feet and attached bathroom admeasuring 9 x 7 feet. 4. Advocate Shri.Pandey submitted that after filing of the suit, plaintiff came to know that defendant No.1 has applied to the respondent for providing electricity connection. The plaintiff rushed to the office of respondent and sought information about it. However, the respondent has not provided the documents to the plaintiff. The respondent has provided electricity connection to defendant No.1. -- 2 of 5 -- : 3 : CHS 180/2025 in Suit 1742/2024 ORDER 5. Advocate Shri.Pandey submitted that subsequent to the filing of suit the respondent has provided electricity connection to defendant No.1. Hence, the plaintiff want to add the respondent as defendant No.4 in the suit and want to make incorporate said incident in the plaint by way of amendment. 6. Advocate Shri.Pandey submitted that the incident of providing electricity connection occurred subsequent to the filing of suit. The amendment is necessary to decide the suit on merit. No prejudice will be caused either to the respondent or to the defendants if proposed amendment is allowed. Hence, by allowing the Chamber Summons, the plaintiff may be permitted to add the respondent as defendant No.4 in the suit and to make amendment as per the schedule. 7. Advocate Ms.Shetty for the respondent submitted that the Chamber Summons is without merit as it goes beyond the pleadings made in the plaint. Therefore, the Chamber Summons may be rejected. 8. I have gone through the plaint. The plaintiff claims to be title holder and in possession of the suit property. She alleges that defendant No.1 has trespassed into portion of the suit property. The plaintiff claimed that defendant No.1 approached the respondent seeking the electricity connection for trespassed portion of the suit property. Alongwith the Chamber Summons, the plaintiff has produced letter of Advocate dated 27.12.2024 raising objection in respect of electricity connection given to defendant No.1. -- 3 of 5 -- : 4 : CHS 180/2025 in Suit 1742/2024 ORDER 9. The alleged incident of giving the electricity connection occurred subsequent to the filing of the suit. The electricity connection is provided by the respondent. Therefore, the respondent became necessary party to the suit and needs to be join in the suit as a defendant. The plaintiff needs to be permitted to make amendment in the suit as per the schedule. The proposed amendment is not going to change the nature of the suit. On the contrary, the proposed amendment is necessary to decide the suit on merit. Hence, I pass the following order :- ORDER 1. Chamber Summons No.180 of 2025 is allowed. 2. Plaintiff is permitted to add the respondent as defendant No.4 in the suit. 3. Plaintiff to make necessary amendment and file copy of amended plaint on record on or before the next date. 4. Parties to bear their own costs. 5. Chamber Summons No.180 of 2025 is disposed off. (B. D. PAWAR) Judge City Civil Court, Date : 25.11.2025 Borivali Div., Dindoshi, Mumbai. Dictated on : 25.11.2025 Transcribed on : 25.11.2025 Checked & Signed by HHJ on : 25.11.2025 -- 4 of 5 -- : 5 : CHS 180/2025 in Suit 1742/2024 ORDER “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.” Ms. Mayuri A. Manjrekar 25.11.2025 at 05:35 P. M. Stenographer (Grade-I) UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge (With Court Room Number) SHRI. B. D. PAWAR Court Room No.04 Date of Pronouncement of JUDGMENT/ ORDER 25.11.2025 JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P.O. on 25.11.2025 JUDGMENT/ORDER uploaded on 25.11.2025 -- 5 of 5 --
