Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 07 Jun 2023 · CNR MHCC040007982019
Order Details: Copy of Judgment Pdf Text: Judgment 1 S.C. Suit No.889/2019 MHCC040007982019 Presented on : 25012019 Registered on : 29032019 Decided on : 07062023 Duration : 04 yrs, 02 ms, 09 ds Exhibit16 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT AT BOMBAY BORIVALI DIVISION, DINDOSHI (BRANCH) S.C. SUIT NO. 889 OF 2019 1. Conrad D'Souza Aged 42 years, Indian Christian Inhabitant Occupation:Service residing at 407, Malad Parivar Coop. Housing Society Ltd., Kandivali(West), Mumbai 400 067. 2. Diana D'Souza alias Diana Mascrarenhas Aged 40 years, Indian Christian Inhabitant, Occupation:Service residing at 10, Luciana, Sunder Lane, Orlem, Malad(West), Mumbai 400 064. … Plaintiffs V/s. 1. Teresa D'Souza aged 74 years, Indian Christian Inhabitant, residing at -- 1 of 6 -- Judgment 2 S.C. Suit No.889/2019 Flat No.13 La Charmian Coop. Housing Society Ltd., Tank Road, Orlem, Malad(West), Mumbai 400 064. 2. La Charmian Coop. Housing Society Ltd., Tank Road, Orlem, Malad(West), Mumbai 400 064. 3. M/s JDN Developers 503, Sadguru Kripa, Junction of Jakaria Road, Malad(West),Mumbai 400 064. … Defendants Appearances Shri Joseph Kelwani, Advocate for plaintiffs. None for Defendants. Coram : His Honour 1st Addl.Principal Judge Shri V.V.Patil (C.R.No.1) Date : 7th June, 2023. :ORAL JUDGMENT : 1. The plaintiffs have filed suit for perpetual injunction restraining defendant No.1 from selling, creating third party interest or parting with possession of Flat No.13, La Charmian Coop. Housing Society Ltd., Tank Road, Orlem, Malad(West), Mumbai 400 064 (hereinafter referred as 'suit premises'). They also prayed to direct defendant No.3 to execute registered agreement for sale in respect of the permanent alternate accommodation in lieu of the suit premises and to hand over the benefits, emoluments accruing to the suit premises to the extent of 2/3 rd share. -- 2 of 6 -- Judgment 3 S.C. Suit No.889/2019 2. According to the plaintiffs, defendant No.1 is their mother, defendant No.2 is the Cooperative Housing Society and defendant No.3 is the developer of defendant No.2 society. The father of the plaintiffs was the original owner of the suit premises. He died on 19.8.1999. The plaintiffs and defendant No.1 are his legal heirs. According to the plaintiffs, as per Section 33(A) of the Indian Succession Act, the plaintiffs and defendant No.1 are having 1/3rd share each in the suit premises. 3. They contended that defendant No.1 had filed Suit No.5509/2003 in the City Civil Court, Mumbai against them for perpetual injunction, however later on she withdrew the suit. They contended that defendant No.1 in collusion with defendant No.2 got transferred her name in the share certificate of defendant No.2 in respect of the suit premises. 4. The plaintiffs contended that defendant No.2, society is redeveloping the area/building wherein the suit premises situated. They appointed defendant No.3 as its developer. When the plaintiffs came to know about redevelopment of defendant No.2 society, on 20.4.2018 they filed application with defendant No.3 and informed him that they have collectively 2/3rd share in the suit premises. They alleged that defendant Nos.2 and 3 ingnoring the rights and interest of the plaintiffs in the suit premises, are intending to hand over right and interest in the suit premises to defendant No.1 only. When they came to know that their legal rights in the suit premises are being infringed, they by issuing notice to the defendants on 4.9.2018 claimed their right and interest in the suit -- 3 of 6 -- Judgment 4 S.C. Suit No.889/2019 premises, however defendant Nos.1 to 3 have not responded to the notice issued by the plaintiffs and therefore, they constrained to file the suit. 5. Defendant Nos.1 to 3 though served with Writ of summons (Exh.2), failed to appear and to contest the suit. My Ld.Predecessor by passing order directed to proceed the suit of plaintiffs exparte. 6. The plaintiffs in support of their plea, have produced on record evidence by way of affidavit of plaintiff No.1. He reiterated the contents of plaint in his evidence by way of affidavit. Apart from oral evidence, the plaintiffs have produced on record, death certificate of their father(Exh.10), Birth certificate of plaintiff Nos.1 and 2(Exh.11), Baptism certificate of plaintiff No.2(Exh.12) and copy of order passed in SC Suit No.5509/2003 dated 21.11.2003(Exh.13). On the date of hearing, the plaintiffs have produced on record the extract of register maintained in the Department of Registration and Stamps. 7. Heard Ld.Counsel for the plaintiffs. I have gone through the plaint contents, oral evidence of plaintiff No.1, which has gone unchallenged as well as the documents produced on record by the plaintiffs in support of their claim. 8. It is an undisputed fact that plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 are the children of defendant No.1, as such they are having right and interest in the property left by their father as contemplated under Section 33(A) of the Indian Succession Act. -- 4 of 6 -- Judgment 5 S.C. Suit No.889/2019 9. Now it is to be ascertained, whether the suit premises was owned and possessed by the father of plaintiff Nos.1 and 2 and husband of defendant No.1. The extract of register maintained in the Department of Registration and Stamps goes to show that at present, the suit premises is standing in the name of defendant No.1. The perusal of order in S.C.Suit No.5509/2003 goes to show that defendant No.1 had filed suit against the plaintiffs for perpetual injunction wherein she had contended that the suit premises was owned by her husband and after his demise the same inherited by her. The Ld.Judge who passed order in the notice of motion of defendant No.1 in S.C.Suit No.5509/2003 has observed that, the plaintiffs and defendant No.1 are having 1/3rd share each in the suit premises. It appears that when defendant No.1 realised that in the suit filed by her against her sons, she will not get any relief, she withdrew that suit. It appears that behind the back of plaintiffs, who are not residing in the suit premises, she got entered her name in the share certificate. The documents produced on record by the plaintiffs are sufficient to arrive at a conclusion that the suit premises was owned and possessed by their father. After demise of their father, the plaintiffs as well as defendant No.1 being his legal heirs are entitled for 1/3rd share each therein. The record shows that defendant Nos.2 and 3 are denying the right and interest of the plaintiffs in the suit premises. In my opinion, as the plaintiffs are legally entitled for 1/3rd share each in the suit premises, they are entitled for the decree as prayed. Hence, the order: ORDER 1) S.C. Suit No.889 of 2019 is decreed in terms of prayer clauses -- 5 of 6 -- Judgment 6 S.C. Suit No.889/2019 (a), (b), (c ) and (d). 2) No order as to costs. 3) Decree be drawn up accordingly. ( V.V.Patil ) 7.6.2023 1st Addl.Principal Judge City Civil & Sessions Court Dindoshi, Mumbai. Date of dictation : 7.6.2023 Date of transcription : 7.6.2023 Signed on : 7.6.2023 Sent to Dept.on : “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.” Mrs.S.A.Kapare 7.6.2023 at 2.05 p.m. STENOGRAPHER(GradeI) UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge (With Court Room No.) H.H.1st A.P.J. Shri V.V.Patil Court Room No.1 Date of pronouncement of Judgment/ Order 7.6.2023 Judgment/Order signed by P.O. on 7.6.2023 Judgment/Order uploaded on 7.6.2023 -- 6 of 6 --
