Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 03 Nov 2025 · CNR MHCC010133992023
Order Details: Other Pdf Text: MHCC010133992023 Presented on 12/12/2023 Registered on 12/12/2023 Decided on 03/11/2025 Duration 01Y: 10M:23D IN THE CITY CIVIL COURT AT MAZGAON, MUMBAI SUMMONS FOR JUDGMENT NO. 275 OF 2023 IN SUMMARY SUIT NO. 598 OF 2022 Lalchand M. Jain (HUF) ] Age 57 years, having address at 2nd floor, ] Room No.22, Old Tambakuwala Building, ] 58, Khadilkar Road, Mumbai – 400 004. ]...Plaintiff Vs. 1. M/s. Satyapur Steel ] 119/121, C. P. Tank Road, Near Madhav Baug, ] Mumbai, Maharashtra 400 004. ] 2. Mr. Shantilal Mishrimal Shah ] age Adult, Partner of M/s. Satyapur Steel, ] 119/121, C. P. Tank Road, Near Madhav Baug, ] Mumbai, Maharashtra 400 004. ] 3. Mr. Bhawarlal Mishrimal Shah ] Age Adult, Partner of M/s. Satyapur Steel, ] 119/121, C. P. Tank Road, Near Madhav Baug, ] Mumbai, Maharashtra 400 004. ] 4. Mr. Harshil Bhavarlal Shah ] Age Adult, Partner of M/s. Satyapur Steel, ] 119/121, C. P. Tank Road, Near Madhav Baug, ] Mumbai, Maharashtra 400 004. ] -- 1 of 7 -- 2 SJ No.275/2023 in Sum Su No.598/2022 5. Mr. Dharmesh Shantilal Shah ] Age Adult, Partner of M/s. Satyapur Steel, ] 119/121, C. P. Tank Road, Near Madhav Baug, ] Mumbai, Maharashtra 400 004. ]...Defendants Appearance :- Ld. Adv. Pankaj Shah for plaintiff. Ld. Adv. K. P. Dubey alongwith Adv. S. R. Maurya for defendants. CORAM : HHJ SHRI SANGRAM SHRIHARI SHINDE C. R. NO.: 81 DATE : 03/11/2025. ORDER ( Dictated and pronounced in open Court) 01] The plaintiff has filed this summons for judgment against defendants on 30/10/2023. Defendants have filed affidavit in reply and additional affidavit in reply to the summons for judgment and resisted it and prayed for unconditional leave to defend the suit. 02] As per plaintiff, he is a Hindu undivided family. Defendant No.1 is a partnership firm and defendants No. 2 to 5 are partners of it. Further, on the request of defendants plaintiff advanced an amount of Rs. 8,00,000/- as a loan on 04/04/2015 to defendant No. 1. Defendants agreed to repay said loan within short period with interest at the rate of 12% p.a. Defendants have paid interest for the financial year 2015 to 2016 for sum of Rs. 95,474/-, after deducting TDS amount of Rs. 9,547/-. Defendants issued confirmation of account statements on 01/04/2016, 01/04/2017, 01/04/2018 and 01/04/2019 along with TDS Form No.16A respectively. Defendants failed to pay interest after 01/04/2016 therefore, plaintiff issued legal notice dated 10/01/2022 which is received by defendants No. 1 and 2. -- 2 of 7 -- 3 SJ No.275/2023 in Sum Su No.598/2022 So far as notice issued to defendants No. 3 to 5 is returned with remark, “Intimation Delivered”. Defendants failed to file reply to the said notice therefore, plaintiff again sent notice dated 01/02/2022 to the defendants and called upon to make the payment of outstanding amount. The said notice is returned with remark, 'Refused'. However, defendants No. 2 sent WhatApp massage to the plaintiff confirming that he will clear the outstanding amount as soon as he receives money from his client. However, defendants sent reply on 09/02/2022 with false contention and denied their liability. Defendants failed to repay the outstanding amount therefore, plaintiff is entitled for sum of Rs. 15,23,669/- including interest at the rate of 12% p.a. Further, it is the contention of plaintiff that the defence of the defendants is that suit is not maintainable under Order XXXVII, Rule 2 of Civil Procedure Code as there is no written contract between the plaintiff and defendants. It is submitted that plaintiff is claiming liquidated amount and it is admitted by the defendants in confirmation of said account. It is defence of defendants that suit is barred by limitation. The defendants have admitted their liability vide confirmation account dated 01/04/2019 and suit is filed on 29/03/2022 therefore, it is within limitation. The plaintiff has failed to raised substantial defence and therefore, Summons for Judgment is liable to be allowed. Hence, Summons for Judgment may be allowed. 03] On the other hand, it is argued on behalf of defendants that suit filed by the plaintiff is not maintainable under Order XXXVII, rule 2 of C.P.C. as defendants have not admitted the claim of plaintiff and there is no written contract between them. Further, there is no cause of action to file the present suit. Plaintiff has filed present suit on the basis forged documents. Further, suit is also barred by limitation as defendants have not signed confirmation of account as alleged by -- 3 of 7 -- 4 SJ No.275/2023 in Sum Su No.598/2022 plaintiff. Defendant No. 2 has not sent WhatsApp massage confirming that he will clear all outstanding dues. Defendants denies all the contentions of the plaintiff. Even, otherwise defendants have made payment to the plaintiff on 07/03/2022 through RTGS and to support said contention has filed additional affidavit along with Exh. A Bank Statement and Certificate issued by the Bank. It is further submitted that defendants have raised triable issues that signatures on the confirmation of account are forged and suit is time barred. This issue needs adjudication and therefore, defendants are entitled for unconditional leave to defend the suit. Therefore, Summons for Judgment may be dismissed. 04] Perused Summons for Judgment, reply, additional reply and record of the case. Heard both parties. On perusing plaint, it appears that plaintiff had advanced an amount of Rs. 8,00,000/- to the defendants on 04/04/2015. As per the plaintiff, defendants have made payment of interest for the financial year 2015-2016 after deducting TDS. Further, it is the contention of plaintiff that defendants have admitted and acknowledged confirmation of accounts on 01/04/2016, 01/04/2017, 01/04/2018 and 01/04/2019. Plaintiff has filed said original confirmation of accounts along with TDS Form No.16A on record vide list Exh. 5/1 to 5/4. Defendants have denied signature on the said confirmation of account and contended that it is a forged document. 05] As per the plaintiff, as defendants failed to repay the said amount, notice dated 10/01/2022 was issued to the defendants and called upon them to make the payment of outstanding amount. It is specific contention of plaintiff that said notice was served on defendant No. 1 and 2 and so far as defendants is concerned it was returned with -- 4 of 7 -- 5 SJ No.275/2023 in Sum Su No.598/2022 remark, 'Intimation Delivered'. It is the contention of the defendants that plaintiff has forged confirmation of account, then at least defendants No.1 and 2 ought to have replied notice dated 10/01/2022. The plaintiff has filed office copy of said notice along with original postal receipts and returned sealed envelopes on record vide List Exh. 5/5 to 5/8. Another notice dated 01/02/2022 was sent to the defendants which is returned with remark, 'Refused'. Plaintiff has filed office copy of said notice and returned sealed envelopes on record vide List Exh. 5/9 and 5/10. 06] Plaintiff has contended that defendant No.2 through WhatsApp massage has agreed to repay the outstanding amount and to support said contention plaintiff has filed photo copy of said WhatsApp Msg on record vide list Exh. 5/11. However, it is not supported by requisite certificate therefore, it cannot be considered in the evidence. 07] It is the contention of plaintiff that defendants replied on 09/02/2022 to the legal notice dated 10/01/2022. Plaintiff has filed said reply on record vide list Exh. 5/12. On perusing said reply, it appears that defendants have raised objection that they are not liable to pay any dues as all the amount is paid to the plaintiff. However, on perusing said reply nowhere defendants have contended that confirmation of account does not bear the signature of the defendants. Even, it is not contended that said confirmation of account are forged by the plaintiff. Therefore, there is no substance in the defendant that confirmation of accounts are forged. However, defendants have filed Exh.A and B along with additional reply to the defendants. On perusing said exhibits, it appears that an amount of Rs. 10,89,380/- is paid to the plaintiff by RTGS on 15/03/2022. It is pertinent to note that on perusing confirmation of account dated 01/04/2019, it appears -- 5 of 7 -- 6 SJ No.275/2023 in Sum Su No.598/2022 that an amount of Rs.10,89,380/- is due against defendants. Thus, apparently it appears that defendants have paid outstanding amount. 08] So far as issue of interest is concerned, it is the contention of the plaintiff that defendants have agreed interest at the rate of 12% p.a. however, there is nothing n record to show that there was any written agreement with respect to the interest. Further, defendants have raised issue of limitation. As per plaintiff, last confirmation dated 01/04/2019 and suit is filed on 29/03/2022. Therefore, I am of the view that suit filed by the plaintiff is within limitation. The only issue i.e. whether confirmation of account forged is triable issue and it requires adjudication. Thus, as discussed above, defendants have made payment of Rs. 10,89,380/- to the plaintiff. Hence, I am of the view that defendants are entitled for unconditional leave to defend the suit. Hence, I proceed to pass following order : ORDER 1) Summons for Judgment No.275/2023 in Summary Suit No. 598/2022 is disposed of as follows: (a) Defendants are granted unconditional Leave to defend the suit and they are at liberty to file written statement on or before next date. 2] Summons for judgment No. 275/2023 is disposed of accordingly. (Sangram S. Shinde) Adhoc Judge, City Civil Court, Mazgaon, Mumbai. C.R.No.81 Date- 03/11/2025 Dictated on : 03/11/2025 Corrected & signed on : 06/11/2025 -- 6 of 7 -- 7 SJ No.275/2023 in Sum Su No.598/2022 “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER” UPLOAD DATE NAME OF STENOGRAPHER 06/11/2025 Mrs. V. V. Malgaonkar Name of the Judge (with Court Room No.) Shri. Sangram S. Shinde C.R. No.81 Date of Pronouncement of JUDGMENT/ ORDER 03/11/2025 JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P. O. on 06/11/2025 JUDGMENT/ORDER uploaded on 06/11/2025 -- 7 of 7 --
