Full Order Text
Order 2 · 24 Dec 2025 · CNR MHCC010133022025
Order Details: Notice of Motion Pdf Text: NM No. 5766 / 2025 Darwin Vs. SBI Order 1 of 15 MHCC010142372025 City Civil and Sessions Court, Mazgaon Greater Mumbai Court Room No. 31 – Commercial Court Notice of Motion No. 5766 / 2025 in Commercial Suit No. 534 / 2025 Darwin Platform Infrastructure Ltd. … Applicant (Original Plaintiff No.2) IN THE MATTER BETWEEN Darwin Platform Force Limited & Ors. … Plaintiffs Vs. State Bank of India … Defendant Appearances : Plaintiffs : Adv. Dhruva Gandhi Adv. Nishta Garhwal Adv. Pranjali Khemnar i/b. Hedgehog & Fox LLP Defendant : Adv. Ashish Mehta Adv. Dhruv Deshpande Adv. Ravi Goenka Adv. Abhayjeet Khairwar CORAM : PRASAD P. KULKARNI COURT ROOM NO.31. IN-CHARGE OF COURT ROOM NO. 14 DATE : 24.12.2025 *************************************************************** -- 1 of 15 -- NM No. 5766 / 2025 Darwin Vs. SBI Order 2 of 15 ORDER (Delivered on this 24th day of December, 2025) 1. This Notice of Motion is preferred by plaintiff no. 2 with various reliefs, which includes restraining defendant from labeling account of plaintiff no. 2 as Non Performing Asset (NPA, for short), Red Flag Account (RFA, for short) and taking any coercive action against plaintiff no. 2 etc. Notice of Motion is supported by an affidavit. Defendant filed reply affidavit on 02.12.2025 and plaintiff filed rejoinder on 08.12.2025. 2. I have heard Learned Advocate Mr. Dhruva Gandhi appearing on behalf of plaintiffs and Learned Advocate Mr. Ashish Mehta on behalf of defendant. 3. This suit pertains to Court Room No. 14. Record reveals that the then Presiding Officer on 03.10.2025 acting on draft Notice of Motion filed by plaintiff no. 2 granted an ex-parte ad-interim injunction restraining defendant from taking any coercive action against plaintiff no. 2. 4. Aggrieved by said order, defendant challenged it in Appeal from Order No. 571/2025 and 572/2025 before Hon’ble Bombay High Court wherein on 18.11.2025 Hon’ble Bombay High Court has directed Trial Court to dispose of both Notice of Motion within a period of three weeks from the date of filing of rejoinder after hearing both the sides by passing a reasoned order. 5. Plaintiff filed rejoinder on 08.12.2025. Charge of Court Room No. 14 is with this Court from 13.11.2025. Both Notice of Motions i.e. -- 2 of 15 -- NM No. 5766 / 2025 Darwin Vs. SBI Order 3 of 15 this one and Notice of Motion No. 5289/2025 in this suit are made time bound by Hon’ble Bombay High Court. In roznama of 08.12.2025, it is recorded that, both Learned Advocates are ready to argue both Notice of Motions before this Court. Crux of Notice of Motion and argument advanced on behalf of plaintiffs would be summarized as under : 6. Plaintiffs contended that cash credit facility was granted in favour of plaintiff no. 2 for the first time on 28.09.2022 for a limit of Rs. 25 Crores. Said facility was sanctioned for a period of 12 months, subject to renewal after every 12 months and repayable on demand. Said facility was renewed vide letter Dt.16.05.2024 and limit was reduced to Rs.19 Crores. In July, 2025, defendant again renewed said cash credit facility. As per plaintiffs, defendant issued email on 01.10.2025 to plaintiffs and “threatened” plaintiff no. 2 to classify his Cash Credit Account as NPA with effect from 02.10.2025. Action of defendant is arbitrary, as defendant in July 2025 itself renewed said cash credit facility. 7. Plaintiff no. 2 very elaborately pleaded about the action taken by Joint Commissioner of State Tax and submits that many a times for no reason GST registration of plaintiff no. 2 was suspended and renewed. Due to action of GST Department, many a times accounts of plaintiff no. 2 in the various banks were freezed and de-freezed. It is contended that plaintiff no. 2 has challenged one of said order of suspension / revocation of GST Registration by way of filing Writ Petition No. 3643/2025 and as per order Dt. 06.05.2025 passed by Hon’ble Bombay High Court an ad-interim order was passed in favour of plaintiffs directing de-freezing of plaintiff no. 2’s Cash Credit -- 3 of 15 -- NM No. 5766 / 2025 Darwin Vs. SBI Order 4 of 15 Accounts with SBI and Bank of Maharashtra. 8. Plaintiff alleged that again Superintendent, Office of the Principal Commissioner, Central GST and Excise issued a Show Cause Notice to plaintiff no. 2 and that was also challenged before Hon’ble Bombay High Court in Writ Petition No. 15448/2025 on 15.05.2025. 9. Plaintiff contended that GST Department, having themselves de-frozen the accounts, are estopped from again resorting to freezing the same accounts in absence of fresh material, reasons, or just cause. It is contended that at the behest of GST authorities, coupled with repeated suspension and revocation of GST Registration (suspension on 03.04.2025 and revocation on 26.05.2025 and fresh suspension on 01.08.2025) has caused severe financial hardship, disruption of business and irreparable hardship to plaintiff’s reputation. 10. As per plaintiffs, there is reasonable apprehension that defendant may declare cash credit account of plaintiffs as NPA and may take coercive action against plaintiffs. It is contended that, in other Commercial Suit 332/2025 filed by plaintiff no. 3, the then Presiding Officer of Court Room No. 14 by order Dt. 14.05.2025 granted ad- interim relief against defendant. So, vindictively defendant is taking action against plaintiffs. 11. Learned Advocate for plaintiffs submit that action proposed to be taken by defendant is arbitrary and high handed, that too, without following due process of law. As per Learned Advocate for plaintiffs, defendant has not issued any formal notice and without such notice, defendant cannot declare account of plaintiff no. 2 as NPA or RFA. -- 4 of 15 -- NM No. 5766 / 2025 Darwin Vs. SBI Order 5 of 15 12. To support his submissions, Learned Advocate for plaintiffs relied on following rulings : a) Bank of Rajasthan Ltd. Vs. VCK Shares and Stock Broking Services Ltd. reported in (2023) 1 Supreme Court Cases 1. b) Keshavlal Khemchand and Sons Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. Vs. Union of India & Ors. reported in (2015) 4 Supreme Court Cases 770. 13. Defendant filed detail reply affidavit wherein Notice of Motion is vehemently objected on a ground that this Court do not have jurisdiction to try and entertain present claim. It is contention of defendant that without filing necessary proceeding before Debt Recovery Tribunal (DRT, for short), plaintiffs have raised this suit and on false submissions made before Presiding Officer of Court Room No. 14 secured ex-parte interim order on 26.09.2025 and 03.10.2025. Defendant contended that these two orders passed by concerned Court were passed without jurisdiction. 14. In fact, more than Rs. 40 Crores are due towards plaintiffs. It is the public money, which defendant is proposed to recover from plaintiffs. Plaintiffs failed to make payment as agreed vide agreement. No notice is required to declare any account as NPA. In fact, plaintiffs are abusing process of law and if such a suit is entertained, then the very purpose of establishing DRT would defeat. 15. Learned Advocate for defendant by pointing out valuation of subject matter in plaint submits that only on the basis of suit of injunction, plaintiffs are attempting to restrain defendant from recovering the dues more than Rs. 40 Crores and such a course of action -- 5 of 15 -- NM No. 5766 / 2025 Darwin Vs. SBI Order 6 of 15 should not be permitted. Learned Advocate for defendant by pointing out details of all four accounts of Darwin group i.e. plaintiff submits that outstanding amount as on 11.12.2025 is more than Rs. 44,91,85,236.97/- 16. As per defendant, all cash credit account of plaintiffs are irregular and despite of various communications made to plaintiffs, they have made no attempt to regularize it. Learned Advocate for defendant submits that even on 26.09.2025 and 03.10.2025 it was portrayed before Presiding Officer of Court Room No. 14 that soon plaintiffs are going to regularize all the accounts and only under said garb, ex-parte interim order was secured. As per defendant, plaintiffs purposely not filed any proceeding in DRT because plaintiffs knows that by filing such a proceeding in DRT, they will constraint to deposit handsome amount in DRT. 17. In order to support his submissions, Learned Advocate for defendant relied on following Judgments, a) Judgment of Hon’ble Delhi High Court in case of Canara Bank Vs. M/s. Karishma Enterprises & Ors. in Writ Petition (C) No. 6494/2016 & CM Appl. 4295/2025 Dt. 06.12.2025. b) Judgment of Hon’ble Apex Court in case of The Authorized Officer, State Bank of India Vs. M/s. Allwyn Alloys Pvt. Ltd. and Ors. in Civil Appeal No. 5248/2018 arising out of SLP (C) No. 32031/2016 Dt. 17.05.2018. Applicability of all rulings cited by both parties will be discussed in reasoning part of this Judgment. 18. Considering rival submissions, following points arise for -- 6 of 15 -- NM No. 5766 / 2025 Darwin Vs. SBI Order 7 of 15 determination and I have recorded my findings for the reasons discussed as under : Sr. Points Findings 1 Whether plaintiff no. 2 made out prima facie case? In the Negative. 2 Whether balance of convenience lies in favour of plaintiff? In the Negative. 3 Whether plaintiff will suffer irreparable loss, if injunction as prayed is refused? In the Negative. 4 What order? As per final order. REASONS As to point nos. 1 to 4 19. Though this Notice of Motion is filed by plaintiff no. 2, but on going through prayer clause it appears that plaintiff no. 2 moved this Notice of Motion wherein reliefs are claimed in respect of all the plaintiffs. More particularly, plaintiff prayed for temporary injunction restraining defendant from declaring account of plaintiff no. 2 or any other account of plaintiffs as NPA. 20. Learned Advocate for plaintiff submits that defendant by an email Dt. 01.10.2025 “ threatened” plaintiff no. 2 that his account will be declared as NPA. He further submits that the proposed action of defendant is not legal. Per contra, Learned Advocate for defendant submits that in spite of frequent correspondence with plaintiffs and despite of warnings, plaintiff no. 2 and other plaintiffs has not regularized their respective accounts. 21. I have gone through the documents filed by plaintiff. I have also gone through correspondence i.e. email sent by defendant to all the -- 7 of 15 -- NM No. 5766 / 2025 Darwin Vs. SBI Order 8 of 15 plaintiffs. Email Exh. P, W and X (appended to plaint) relates with plaintiff nos. 3 and 4 whereas email Dt. 05.07.2025 Exh. C, email Dt. 04.01.2024 Exh. M and email Dt. 10.09.2025 Exh. AA relates with plaintiff no. 2. I have gone through all these emails which very clearly shows that for many a times defendant cautioned plaintiff about their irregular accounts and pointed out various irregularities noticed in the audit report. Defendant called upon plaintiff no. 2 and other plaintiffs to regularize their account by curing the defect. However, it appears plaintiff paid no heed. 22. All these emails are filed on record by plaintiffs. It is not only plaintiff no. 2 who is seeking temporary injunction against defendant but in this Notice of Motion, plaintiff no. 2 is also claiming interim relief in favour of remaining plaintiffs. So in order to decide this Notice of Motion, it is necessary to know exactly what was communicated by defendant to plaintiffs. 23. Exh. C is one of such email of defendant Dt. 05.07.2025 relating to account of plaintiff no. 2. It says that, defendant advised plaintiffs that defendant’s system has flagged early warning signal in cash credit account of plaintiff no. 2. The irregularity as per email is non routing of sales proceeds through consortium/member bank/lenders to the company. Defendant requested plaintiffs to offer justification about early warning signals. 24. Exh. M is another email of defendant Dt. 04.01.2024 and it relates to account of plaintiff no. 3 wherein defendant informed plaintiffs due to non servicing of cash credit interest, account is irregular and requested plaintiffs to regularize the account at earliest. -- 8 of 15 -- NM No. 5766 / 2025 Darwin Vs. SBI Order 9 of 15 On 04.01.2024, defendant vide Exh. P issued email, which pertains to account of plaintiff no. 4 wherein similar issue was raised and it was informed to plaintiff that account mentioned in that email became irregular. 25. On 07.04.2025, defendant again issued email about account of plaintiff no. 3 and informed that said account has been flagged as RFA and said account has became irregular due to non renewal of the account. In this email, defendant apprised plaintiff about SRA Report Dt. 30.09.2024 received at branch on 21.03.2025 with adverse comments. These comments includes that no manufacturing activities observed by SRA auditor during their visit on manufacturing site of plaintiff on 22.02.2025. Further, as per said report, DP is not available against inventories and receivables and showing irregularity of Rs.5.51 Crores. In same email, it is informed to plaintiff that SRA auditor has adversely commented upon the level of sundry creditors and debtors and commented that creditors and receivables are not verifiable in absence of the information as such and genuineness and authenticity is in question. Hence, defendant called upon plaintiff to close the account immediately else it will turn to NPA. 26. On 25.07.2025, again defendant wrote an email to plaintiff. By this email, it was informed to plaintiff that sufficient opportunity was granted in respect of account of plaintiff no. 3 for removing the account from the Red Flag list, but even after lapse of significant period, the position remains unchanged. This email has reference of SRA Report Dt. 25.06.2025. In this email, as much as 11 irregularities relating to accounts of plaintiff were elaborately informed. Based on irregularities on part of plaintiff and non compliance with sanction terms and lack of -- 9 of 15 -- NM No. 5766 / 2025 Darwin Vs. SBI Order 10 of 15 reliable supporting documents, defendant has withdrawn DP from the account which resulted into overdrawn of account by Rs.16.84 Crores as on 10.07.2025. 27. On 10.09.2025, again defendant issued an elaborate email to plaintiff relating to account of plaintiff no. 2 wherein it is categorically informed to plaintiffs that consistent irregularity in accounts will adversely impact the commercial CIBIL score of the company as well as individual CIBIL score of all the stakeholders of the company. It was also informed that such irregularity also tarnish the credit history and creditworthiness of the company, which will restrict the unit from availing any further credit facilities from any financial institution. 28. So, it is very evident that, defendant from time to time informed, alerted and warned plaintiffs that irregularities in accounts should be cured. Defendant had given sufficient time to plaintiffs to comply with the same. Last of such email by defendant was of 10.09.2025. This suit is lodged on 26.09.2025. So, even prior to institution of suit, accounts of plaintiffs were irregular. Whereas plaintiffs have nowhere explained that any reply was sent by plaintiffs to defendant. Even during argument, plaintiffs have not touched this aspect of various irregularities and correspondence made by defendant. 29. Considerable portion of affidavit annexed to this Notice of Motion is devoted to various actions taken by GST Department against plaintiffs. It appears plaintiffs are blaming GST Department for its so called arbitrary action for suspending and reviving GST Registration of plaintiff no. 2. However, in this suit, neither GST Department is party nor there is any relief touching to this aspect. Even for a sake of -- 10 of 15 -- NM No. 5766 / 2025 Darwin Vs. SBI Order 11 of 15 moment it is assumed that action taken by State GST Department was not proper but that doesn’t negate contentions raised by defendant in the above mentioned emails. 30. Likewise, it is hard to believe that only because interim order was passed against defendant in other Commercial Suit No. 332/2025, hence vindictively defendant is acting against plaintiffs. Rather, prima facie it appears that the stand taken by defendant is probable and based on frequent correspondence and inaction of plaintiff. 31. Plaintiff relied on the Judgment in the case of Bank of Rajasthan (Supra) on a point that its a choice of plaintiff to chose a quorum i.e. DRT or Civil Court. Whereas Judgment in Keshavlal (Supra) is relied upon to show that when an asset is to be treated as non performing. It is admitted position that plaintiffs could have raised necessary proceeding before DRT. As rightly argued by Learned Advocate for defendant, it appears plaintiffs avoided to do so with intent to avoid depositing of amount in DRT. It appears by filing declaratory and suit for injunction, which is technically not susceptible of monetary valuation, plaintiffs somehow want to restrain defendant from taking legitimate action against plaintiffs. 32. In case of Canara Bank (Supra), the bank issued repeated reminders and letters calling upon respondent nos. 1 and 2 to regularize the account and despite of opportunities, respondent nos. 1 and 2 failed to regularize it. Therefore, account of respondent nos. 1 and 2 was declared as NPA. In this case as well, ample opportunities were given by defendant to plaintiffs to regularize their accounts. However, there is no positive response from either of the plaintiffs. In Judgment of Canara -- 11 of 15 -- NM No. 5766 / 2025 Darwin Vs. SBI Order 12 of 15 Bank (Supra) itself, in para no. 29 Hon’ble Delhi High Court observed as under : “The legal framework governing this issue is well- established. The Reserve Bank of India’s (“RBI”) prudential norms on Income Recognition, Asset Classification and Provisioning (“IRACP”), which have statutory force under Sections 21 and 35A of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949, provide that an OD or CC account becomes an NPA when the outstanding balance remains continuously in excess of the sanctioned limit or drawing power for more than 90 days. This obligation is mandatory and a bank cannot defer or postpone classification once the statutory period of continuous irregularity has elapsed”. Said ruling is applicable to the facts in hand. 33. So far as Judgment in the case of The Authorized Officer (Supra) is concerned, Hon’ble Apex Court held that, in view of Section 34 of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (SARFAESI Act) jurisdiction of Civil Court is barred and even no injunction can be granted by any Court or authority in respect of any action taken or to be taken in pursuance of any power conferred by or under the Act. Said ruling is applicable to the facts in hand. 34. Injunction is an equitable relief. One who seek equity must come before the Court with clean hands. In that context, I have gone through ad-interim order passed on 03.10.2025. As rightly pointed out by Advocate for defendant, submission was made on behalf of plaintiffs that plaintiffs intends to clear dues by November 2025. Acting on that submission, ad-interim relief was granted against defendant. -- 12 of 15 -- NM No. 5766 / 2025 Darwin Vs. SBI Order 13 of 15 35. However, defendant has placed on record details of Darwin Group of Accounts. This table includes all four accounts of plaintiff nos. 1 to 4 and outstanding amount as on 11.12.2025 of all the four accounts if put together would be Rs.44,91,85,236.97/-. 36. This table very elaborately speaks about date of original sanction, date of last renewal, limit of cash credit facility along with last payment done. As against outstanding amount Rs.18,99,90,229.69/- plus unrealized interest Rs.79,78,887/-, plaintiff no. 2 made payment of Rs.6,66,138/- on 28.11.2025. As against outstanding amount Rs. 16,55,68,249.84/- plus unrealized interest Rs.60,62,934/-, plaintiff no. 3 made payment of Rs.26,00,000/- on 04.09.2025. 37. When it comes to plaintiff no.4, as against outstanding amount Rs.4,62,32,191.78/- plus unrealized interest Rs.11,59,119/-, plaintiff no. 4 made payment of Rs.3,23,182/- on 03.12.2025. So far as plaintiff no. 1 is concerned, outstanding amount as on 11.12.2025 is 4,73,94,565.66/- plus unrealized interest Rs.8,29,418/-. However, last payment was done on 09.12.2025 of Rs.1,59,795/-. 38. When accounts are not regular and despite of requests, warning plaintiffs did not make it regular, then defendant is duty bound to take action as per settled norms of RBI. Defendant is a public undertaking wherein amount of public exchequer is involved. Irregularities on part of plaintiffs are sufficient to disentitle them from any injunction against defendant. Granting injunction against defendant would amount to restraining defendant from taking legitimate action as per law. -- 13 of 15 -- NM No. 5766 / 2025 Darwin Vs. SBI Order 14 of 15 39. Thus, plaintiff failed to make out prima facie case in his / their favour. Likewise, balance of convenience is not in favour of plaintiff. The loss which defendant may suffer by granting injunction would be greater than the loss which plaintiff may suffer by refusing injunction. It is so because by making the accounts regularize, plaintiffs can move on with their business and the accounts. But, defendant cannot be restrained from taking legal action when the accounts are irregular with huge outstanding amount. 40. Therefore, grounds are not satisfactory. Notice of Motion is devoid of merit. Hence, it deserves to be dismissed by vacating ad- interim order passed on 03.10.2025. Hence, I answer point no. 1 to 3 in negative and in answer to point no. 4, following order is passed : ORDER 1. Notice of Motion No. 5766 of 2025 is dismissed. 2. Ad-interim order, if any, stands vacated. 3. No order as to cost. 4. Order is dictated and pronounced in Open Court. 5. Record of Notice of Motion No. 5766/2025 shall form part of Commercial Suit No. 534/2025. Mumbai Dated : 24.12.2025 (Prasad P. Kulkarni) Judge, City Civil & Sessions Court, In charge of Court Room No. 14 Court Room No.31 - Commercial Court, Mazgaon, Greater Mumbai -- 14 of 15 -- NM No. 5766 / 2025 Darwin Vs. SBI Order 15 of 15 CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER” UPLOAD DATE TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER 24.12.2025 5.30 p.m. Prachi Y. Potdar Stenographer - Grade I Name of the Judge HHJ Shri. Prasad. P. Kulkarni (C.R.NO. 31) In charge of C.R. No. 14 Date of Pronouncement of Judgment/Order. 24.12.2025 Judgment/order signed by P.O on 24.12.2025 Judgment/order uploaded on 24.12.2025 -- 15 of 15 --
