Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 23 Sept 2024 · CNR MHCC010130612023
Order Details: Notice of Motion Pdf Text: 1 N.M.No.4614 of 2023 CNR:MHCC01-013061-2023 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL C0URT AT BOMBAY NOTICE OF MOTION NO.4614 OF 2023 IN L.C.SUIT NO.914 OF 2011 Dwarka Hundaldas Sainani .. Plaintiff V/s. Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai & Anr. .. Defendants Appearance:- Adv. B. P. Shukla for plaintiff. Adv. A. K. Nandanwar for MCGM/defendant No.1. Adv. K. R. Parekh for defendant No.2. CORAM : HIS HONOUR ADDL. SESSIONS JUDGE SHRI. R. M. MISHRA CITY CIVIL COURT, GR. BOMBAY (C.R. NO.05). DATE : 23/09/2024. ORDER By this Notice of Motion, the defendant No.2 has prayed for recall of order dt. 13/10/2023 and for permission to cross examine the PW-1 in terms of prayer clause (a) and (b). 2 Perused affidavit and reply. Heard both sides. 3 During the course of arguments, the learned advocate for -- 1 of 5 -- 2 N.M.No.4614 of 2023 the defendant No.2 has submitted that even if no written statement of the defendant No.2 is taken on record, he is not precluded from cross examining the PW-1. He submitted that the junior advocate was present on that day. Moreover, in the affidavit in support of the Notice of Motion, it is contended that the real dispute is between the plaintiff and the defendant No.2. On 08/11/2023, the advocate for the defendant No.2 pointed out the aforesaid facts to the Court by making an application for allowing the defendant No.2 to cross examine the plaintiff. However, the said application was not taken by the Court and it was pointed out that the Notice of Motion will have to be taken, if the defendant No.2 desires to set aside the said order. It is also contended that it is the usual practice that on completion of cross examination by one of the defendants, matter has to be adjourned for the cross examination of other defendants when other defendants are not present. The advocate for the defendant No.2 never expected that the cross examination of PW-1 would be completed on the very same day. Thereafter, on the very same day, evidence closing pursis came to be filed on behalf of the plaintiff. 4 On the other hand, the learned advocate for the plaintiff submitted that this Notice of Motion has been taken out after a lapse of two months and there are no bonafides on the part of the defendant No.2. It is thus, submitted that the Notice of Motion is liable to be dismissed. 5 Considering the submissions of both sides, I have carefully gone through the entire facts and circumstances on record. On perusal of the Roznama dt. 13/10/2023, no doubt, it is mentioned in the said -- 2 of 5 -- 3 N.M.No.4614 of 2023 Roznama that Adv. Priyanka Bhanushali h/f. Adv. Ketan Parekh was present when the matter was called. However, as can be seen from the affidavit of evidence (Ex.10) of PW-1, after the cross examination by defendant No.1 was completed, nobody was present on behalf of the defendant No.2 when the matter was called. In the affidavit of evidence of PW-1, it is also recorded that apart from the absence of the defendant No.2 and his advocate, matter also found proceeded without written statement of the defendant No.2 and Notice of Motion No.1625 of 2018 taken out by the defendant No.2 was also dismissed by an order dt. 29/08/2019. Thus, having regard to these circumstances, in my view, there is no substance in the contention of the defendant No.2 that it is a usual practice to keep the matter for the cross examination of other defendants. So far as the contention that the real dispute is between the plaintiff and the defendant No.2 is concerned, opportunity needs to be granted to cross examine the witness even in the absence of the written statement. In the absence of written statement of the defendant No.2, he can be permitted to cross examine the plaintiff to the extent of issue of law only and not the facts. Thus, by imposing reasonable costs to compensate the plaintiff in view of delay caused by the defendant No.2, Notice of Motion deserves to be allowed. Therefore, following order is passed. ORDER 1 Notice of Motion No. 4614 of 2023 is allowed subject to costs of Rs.1,000/-. 2 The defendant No.2 is directed to pay the costs of Rs.1,000/- to the plaintiff or his advocate or to deposit the same in the Court on or before next date. Accordingly, ‘no cross order’ of PW-1 dt. -- 3 of 5 -- 4 N.M.No.4614 of 2023 13/10/2023 passed against the defendant No.2 is hereby set aside, as prayed subject to payment/deposit of costs, as directed. 3 Notice of Motion stands disposed of. Date:23/09/2024. (R. M. Mishra ) Dictated on :23/09/2024. Judge, City Civil Court, Typed on :23/09/2024. Gr.Mumbai. Signed on :24/09/2024. -- 4 of 5 -- 5 N.M.No.4614 of 2023 “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.” 24/09/2024. 11.25 a.m. (Santosh B. Sawant ) UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge (With Court room No.) HHJ Shri. R. M. Mishra (C.R.No.05) Date of Pronouncement of JUDGMENT/ORDER 23/09/2024. JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P.O.on 24/09/2024. JUDGMENT/ORDER uploaded on 24/09/2024. -- 5 of 5 --
