Final Order 1

Order Details: Copy of Judgment
Pdf Text: ,l-lh- nkok Øekad 3133@2019 --1-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 06-02-2026
MHCC010121282019 nk[ky fnukad % 25-11-2019
uksan.kh fnukad % 28-11-2019
fudky fnukad % 06-02-2026
dkyko/kh % 06&o- 02&e- 11&fn-
uxj fnok.kh U;k;ky;] eqacbZ ;sFkhy U;k;ky; Øekad 09
¼ lqfuy ek- ikVhy] uxj fnok.kh U;k;k/kh’k ½
,l-lh-nkok Øekad 3133@2019
¼U;k;fu.kZ;kpk fnukad % 06@02@2026½ fu’kk.kh & 23
Jh- jktsanz vuar /kqjh]
o;% 59 o”kZs] % O;olk; % uksdjh]
iRrk% ,@307] dkfydk n’kZu] ckcqjko ik:Gsdj
ekxZ] nknj ¼if’pe½] eqacbZ&400 028- -------- oknh
fo:)
egkjk”Vª bekjr o brj cka/kdke dkexkj dY;k.k
eaMGkps lfpr rFkk eq[; dk;Zdkjh vf/kdkjh]
dkexkj vk;qDr dk;kZy;] dkexkj Hkou]
okanzs&dqykZ dkWEiysDl] okanzs ¼iqoZ½] eqacbZ&400
051- ---- izfroknh
odhy Jh- lat; jkat.ks] oknh djhrk
odhy Jh- lfpu dne] izfroknh djhrk
U;k;fu.kZ;
¼ fnukad 06-02-2026 jksth ikjhr ½
izLrqr nkok oknh oknhus izfroknhP;k dk;kZy;kr vkWDVkscj
2018 rs fMlsacj 2018 ;k dkyko/khr dsysY;k dkekP;k esgurkU;kiksVhph
jDde :i;s 69]259@& n-lk-n-'ks- 12 % O;ktklg izfroknhdMwu
olwy gksowu feG.;kdjhrk nk[ky dsyk vkgs-
-- 1 of 12 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 3133@2019 --2-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 06-02-2026
2- oknhps dFku FkksMD;kr [kkyhyizek.ks %&
oknh gk egkjk"Vªª 'kklukP;k lsosrwu fuo`Rr >kY;kuarj fnukad
17-12-2016 jksthP;k 'kklu fu.kZ;kuqlkj lsokfuo`Rr deZpkÚ;kauk
esgurkU;koj dk;kZy;kr dke dj.;kdjhrk cksykfo.;kr vkys o R;kuqlkj
oknhl ik= Bjowu fnukad 18-06-2018 iklwu iq<hy 6 efgU;kdjhrk
njegk :i;s 26]225@& brD;k esgurkU;koj oknhph use.kwd izfroknh
dk;kZy;kr dj.;kr vkyh- oknhus fMlsacj 2018 v[ksji;Zar izfroknh
dk;kZy;kr useysys dke dsys vlwu izfroknhauh oknhl lIVsacj 2018 i;Zar
esgurkU;kph jDde fnyh vlyh rjh vkWDVkscj rs fMlsacj 2018 ;k
dkyko/khrhy esgurkU;kph ,dq.k jDde :i;s 69]259@& oknhl fnyh
ukgh- oknhus R;kckcr osGksosGh rksaMh o ys[kh ekx.kh d:u ns[khy
izfroknh dk;kZy;kus rh jDde oknhl fnyh ukgh- ;kmyV] fnukad
24-12-2018 jksth izfroknh dk;kZy;kdMwu oknhl i= ikBowu fnukad
03-10-2018 jksthps rs i= vlY;kus Hkklowu oknh gk dkekoj ;sow 'kdr
ulY;kus oknhP;k ukos dj.;kr vkysyh lsokdjkj fu;qDrh fnukad
01-10-2018 iklwu laiq"Vkr vk.kY;kps oknhl dGfoys- R;kuarj] oknhus
fnukad 27-03-2019 o 28-05-2019 jksth ofdykekQZr uksVhl ikBowu
izfroknhdMwu lnj jdesph ekx.kh dsyh- ijarq] uksVhl feGqu ns[khy
izfroknh dk;kZy;kus R;kckcr iqrZrk dsyh ukgh- R;keqGs] oknhus fnok.kh
izØh;k lafgrsP;k dye 80 uqlkjph uksVhl fnukad 20-07-2019 jksth
izfroknh dk;kZy;kl ikBowu lnj jdesph ekx.kh djrkuk iqrZrk u dsY;kl
iq<hy dk;ns'khj dkjokbZ dsyh tkbZy vls dGfoys- ijarq] R;kuarj ns[khy
izfroknh dk;kZy;kus lnj jDde oknhl fnyh ukgh- R;keqGs] izfroknh
dk;kZy;kdMwu vkWDVkscj 2018 rs fMlsacj 2018 ;k dkyko/khr dsysY;k
dkekP;k esgurkU;kiksVhph jDde :i;s 69]259@& n-lk-n-'ks- 12 %
O;ktklg olwy gksowu feGkoh v'kh oknhus fouarh dsyh vkgs-
-- 2 of 12 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 3133@2019 --3-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 06-02-2026
3- izfroknh dk;kZy;kus fu'kk.kh 4 oj lgk¸;d ljdkjh
ofdykaekQZr dSfQ;r nsrkuk izfroknh dk;kZy; gs oknhl nkO;krhy jDde
ns.ks ykxr vlY;kps oknhps dFku Li"Vi.ks ukdkjrkuk 'kklu fu.kZ;kuqlkj
oknhl lsokfuo`Rrhuarj lq:okrhyk fnukad 23-10-2017 rs 21-04-2018
;k dkyko/khr lsokfu;qDrh djkjkuqlkj njegk :i;s 26]225@&
esgurkU;koj oknhl fu;qDrh ns.;kr vkyh gksrh- ijarq] lnj dkyko/kh
laiY;kuarj fnukad 18-06-2018 iklwu iq<hy 6 efgU;kdjhrk oknhl
lsokdjkj fu;qDrh ns.;kr vkyh vlyh rjh lIVascj 2018 v[ksjhl oknhus
?kjxqrh vMp.kheqGs lsok nsow 'kdr ulY;kps lkaxhrY;kus fnukad
03-10-2018 jksthP;k i=kuqlkj fnukad 01-10-2018 iklwu oknhph
lsokdjkj fu;qDrh laiq"Vkr vk.kyh vlwu izfroknh dk;kZy;kus oknhl
R;kckcr i=kus dGfoys vkgs- oknhus lIVsacj 2018 v[ksj izfroknh
dk;kZy;kr dke dsY;kus R;kl esgurkU;kph Bjysyh jDde vnk dj.;kr
vkyh vlwu oknhus fnukad 01-10-2018 iklwu iq<hy dkyko/khr izfroknh
dk;kZy;kr dke dsys ulY;kus esgurkU;kiksVh dks.krhgh jDde feG.;kl
oknh ik= ukgh- ;kf'kok;] egkjk"Vª 'kklu@jkT; ljdkj ;kauk nkO;kdkeh
i{kdkj dj.;kr vkys ukgh rlsp egkjk"Vª 'kklukl fnok.kh izØh;k
lafgrsP;k dye 80 uqlkj oknhus nkokiqoZ uksVhl ikBfoysyh ukgh- nkok
nk[ky dj.;kl dks.krsgh dkj.k ?kMys ukgh- ifj.kker% fouarhizek.ks
dks.krhgh nkn feG.;kl oknh ik= ulY;kus nkok [kpkZlg
QsVkG.;kr ;kok v'kh izfroknhrQsZ fouarh dj.;kr vkyh vkgs-
4- oknh rQsZ odhy Jh- lat; jkat.ks rlsp rlsp izfroknh rQsZ
lgk¸;d ljdkjh odhy Jh- lfpu dne ;kapk ;qfDrokn ,sdyk- ojhy
ifjfLFkrhr oknh o izfroknhaps dFku rlsp U;k;ky;kleksjhy iqjkok
o ;qDrhokn fopkjkr Äsrk] ekÖ;k iqokZf/kdkÚ;kauh fu’kk.kh Øekad 05 oj
-- 3 of 12 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 3133@2019 --4-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 06-02-2026
[kkyhy eqn~ns fuf’pr dsys vlwu R;k eqn~n~;kapk dkj.kkalg fu”d”kZ eh
[kkyhyizek.ks ukssanfor vkgs %&
v-Ø- eqn~ns fu”d”kZ
1- fnukad 03-10-2018 jksthP;k i=kuqlkj izfroknh
dk;kZy;kus oknh gk ?kjxqrh dkj.kkLro dkekoj ;sow
'kdr ulY;kus fnukad 01-10-2018 iklwu oknhph
lsok lekIr dsY;kps izfroknh dk;kZy;kus fl) dsys
vkgs dk; \
---gks;---
2- fnok.kh izØh;k lafgrsP;k dye 80 uqlkj izfroknh
dk;kZy;kl uksVhl fnY;kps oknhus fl) dsys vkgs
dk; \
---ukgh---
3- vkWDVkscj] uksOgsacj o fMlsacj 2018 P;k
ixkjkiksVh :i;s 69]259@& n-lk-n-'ks 12%
O;ktnjkus izfroknh dk;kZy;kdMwu olwy gksowu
feG.;kl oknh ik= vkgs dk; \
---ukgh---
4- vkns'k vkf.k gqdqeukek dks.krk\ vaafre
vkns'kkizek.ks
dkj.kfeekalk
eqn~nk Øekad 1 rs 3 %&
5- ojhy frugh eqn~ns ,desdkar xqarys vlY;kus R;kaps fu"d"kZ eh
,df=ri.ks uksanfor vkgs- oknh o izfroknh dk;kZy;kps dFku fopkjkr ?ksrk
egkjk"Vª 'kklukP;k lacaf/kr 'kklu fu.kZ;kuqlkj lsokfuo`Rr vlysY;k
'kkldh;] fue'kkldh; vf/kdkÚ;kaP;k lsok foof{kr dkeklkBh lsokdjkj
in~/krhus ?ksrY;k tkr vlY;kckcr rlsp 'kkldh; lsosrwu fuo`Rr >kysY;k
oknhl izfroknh dk;kZy;kr lq:okrhl fnukad 23-10-2017 rs
-- 4 of 12 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 3133@2019 --5-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 06-02-2026
21-04-2018 ;k dkyko/khr njegk :i;s 26]225@& esgurkU;koj
lsokdjkj in~/krhus :tw d:u ?ksrY;kckcr rlsp fnukad 21-04-2018
uarj R;ke/;s [kaM iMyk o R;kuarj oknhP;k fouarhuqlkj fnukad
23-10-2017 rs 21-04-2018 ;k dkyko/khdjhrk oknhl iqUgk izfroknh
dk;kZy;kr njegk :i;s 26]225@& esgurkU;koj lsokdjkj in~/krhus :tw
d:u ?ksrY;kckcr okn ukgh- ;kf'kok;] izfroknh dk;kZy;kus oknhl
lIVsacj 2018 v[ksji;Zarpk esgurkuk vnk dsY;kckcr ns[khy okn
ukgh- ;k ifjfLFkrhr] oknhP;k dFkukuqlkj R;kus fMlsacj 2018 v[ksji;Zar
izfroknh dk;kZy;kr lsok fnyh vlwu izfroknh dk;kZy;kus 01-10-2018
rs fMlsacj v[ksji;ZarP;k esgurkU;kph jDde R;kl vnk dsyh
ukgh- ;kmyV] izfroknh dk;kZy;kP;k dFkukuqlkj oknhus lsok ns.;kl
vleFkZrk n'kZfoY;kus fnukad 03-10-2018 jksthP;k i=kuqlkj fnukad
01-10-2018 jksth oknhph lsok laiq"Vkr vk.k.;kr vkyh- ifj.kker%
fnukad 01-10-2018 rs fMlsacj 2018 v[ksj oknhus izfroknh dk;kZy;kr
vkiyh lsok fnyh gksrh dk; o lsok fnyh vlY;kl rks njegk :i;s
26]225@& ;k njkus esgurkU;kph jDde izfroknh dk;kZy;kdMwu
feG.;kl ik= vkgs dk; ;klkscrp r'kh jDde feG.;kl oknh ik=
vlrkuk ns[khy izfroknh dk;kZy;kus rh jDde oknhl u fnY;keqGs rh
jDde n-lk-n-'ks 12 % O;ktnjkus olwy gksowu feG.;kl oknh ik= vkgs
dk; gs eqn~ns mifLFkr gksrkr-
6- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] oknhus mijksYysf[kr dkyko/khP;k
esgurkukP;k jdesph ekx.kh izfroknh dk;kZy;kdMs rksaMh rlsp ys[kh
Lo:ikr dsY;kps dFku djrkuk vafrer% fnok.kh izØh;k lafgrsP;k dye
80 uqlkjph uksVhl fnukad 20-07-2019 jksth izfroknh dk;kZy;kl
ikBowu ;s.ks vlysY;k rFkkdFkhr jdesph ekx.kh djrkuk R;kph iqrZrk u
-- 5 of 12 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 3133@2019 --6-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 06-02-2026
dj.;kr vkY;kl dk;ns'khj dkjokbZ dj.;kr ;sbZy vls dGfoY;kps
oknhps dFku vkgs-
7- fu'kk.kh 12 ojhy fnukad 20-07-2019 jksthP;k uksVhlph
LFkGizr ikgrk rh uksVhl egkjk”Vª bekjr o brj cka/kdke dkexkj dY;k.k
eaMGkps lfpr rFkk eq[; dk;Zdkjh vf/kdkjh ;kauk Eg.ktsp izfroknh
dk;kZy;kl fnY;kps Li"V gksrs- izfroknhps dk;kZy; gs egkjk"Vª 'kklukP;k
dkexkj [kkR;kvarxZr ;sr vlwu dkexkj [kkR;kP;k lfpokl oknhus
fnok.kh izØh;k lafgrsP;k dye 80 uqlkjph uksVhl ns.ks xjtsps gksrs- ijarq]
fu'kk.kh 12 ojhy uksVhl egkjk"Vª 'kklukP;k dkexkj [kkR;kP;k lfpokl
fnyh ulY;kus fu'kk.kh 12 ojhy uksVhl oknhus ;ksX;jhR;k fnYkh vkgs vls
Eg.krk ;s.kkj ukgh-
8- ;kf'kok;] fu'kk.kh 4 ojhy dSfQ;re/;s egkjk"Vª 'kklukl
nkO;kdkeh i{kdkj dj.;kr vkys ulY;kps gjdr ?ks.;kr vkyh vlwu]
izLrqr nkok gk QDr egkjk”Vª bekjr o brj cka/kdke dkexkj dY;k.k
eaMGkps lfpr rFkk eq[; dk;Zdkjh vf/kdkjh ;kapsfo:) nk[ky dj.;kr
vkY;kph ckc fopkjkr ?ksrk izLrqr nkok egkjk"Vª 'kklukfo:) nk[ky
djrkuk dkexkj [kkR;kP;k lfpok fo:) nk[ky dj.;kr vkyk vkgs vls
Eg.krk ;s.kkj ukgh- R;keqGs] FksVi.ks dkexkj [kkR;kvarxZr ;s.kkÚ;k egkjk”Vª
bekjr o brj cka/kdke dkexkj dY;k.k eaMG ;kauk nkO;kdkeh i{kdkj
dj.;kr vkY;kph ckc fopkjkr ?ksrk izfroknhrQsZ mifLFkr dj.;kr
vkysyh gjdr fLodkjkgZ vkgs- R;keqGs] fnok.kh izØh;k lafgrsP;k dye
80 uqlkj oknhus ikBfoysyh uksVhl v;ksX; vlwu nkO;kdkeh egkjk"Vª
'kklukl i{kdkj dj.;kr u vkY;kus izLrqr nkok vkgs ;k Lo:ikr
-- 6 of 12 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 3133@2019 --7-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 06-02-2026
pky.;kl vik= vlY;kpk izfroknhrQsZ lgk¸;d ljdkjh
ofdykapk ;qfDrokn fLodkjkgZ vkgs-
9- ;kf'kok;] fnukad 03-102018 jksthP;k i=kuqlkj izfroknh
dk;kZy;kus fnukad 01-10-2018 iklwu oknhpk lsokdjkj laiq"Vkr
vk.kY;kps izfroknh dk;kZy;kps dFku vkgs- nkO;kP;k ifjPNsn 4 e/;s
"The plaintiff states that surprisingly on 24.12.2018 the plaintiff one
letter dated 03.10.2018 from the defendant mentioning that the
plaintiff had disclosed his inability to attend the said service contract
and thereupon the said service contract was ended. The plaintiff
vehemently deny any disclosure." vls uewn dj.;kr vkys vlwu fu'kk.kh
10 ojhy fnukad 27-03-2019 jksthP;k uksVhlP;k LFkGizrhe/;s
"Surprisingly, he get one letter on dated 24.12.2018. The date on the
said letter was on 03.10.2018. The said letter was drawn with
mentioning that my client had disclosed his inability to attend the
service contract and thereupon the service contract was ended." vls
uewn vlwu fu'kk.kh 11 ojhy fnukad 28-05-2019 jksthP;k uksVhlP;k
LFkGizrhe/;s ojhyizek.ks fu'kk.kh 10 ojhy uksVhle/khy etdwj uewn
dj.;kr vkyk vkgs- ;kf'kok; fu'kk.kh 12 ojhy fnukad 20-07-2019
jksthP;k uksVhle/;s ns[khy fu'kk.kh 10 o 11 ojhy uksVhle/khy
mijksYysf[kr etdwj uewn vkgs- ifj.kker% fnukad 03-10-2018 jksthps
i= izfroknh dk;kZy;kdMwu oknhl ikBfo.;kr vkys gksrs o R;k i=kuqlkj
fnukad 01-10-2018 iklwu oknhpk lsokdjkj laiq"Vkr vk.kY;kps izfroknh
dk;kZy;kus oknhl dGfoY;kps Li"V gksrs-
10- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] fnukad 03-10-2018 jksthps i= oknhl
fnukad 24-12-2018 jksth feGkY;kps oknhps dFku vlys rjh fnukad
-- 7 of 12 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 3133@2019 --8-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 06-02-2026
03-10-2018 jksthps lnj i= nkO;kdkeh nk[ky d:u rs vkiY;kyk
fnukad 24-12-2018 jksth izkIr >kY;kps fl) dj.kkjk dks.krkgh iqjkok
oknhus fnyk ukgh- ifj.kker% fnukad 03-10-2018 jksthP;k i=kn~okjs
fnukad 01-10-2018 iklwu oknhpk lsokdjkj izfroknh dk;kZy;kus laiq"Vkr
vk.kY;kps izfroknh dk;kZy;kus fl) dsys vkgs-
11- oknkdjhrk izfroknh dk;kZy;kus fnukad 03-10-2018 jksth
ikBfoysyh uksVhl pqdhph vlY;kps oknhps dFku Lohdkjko;kps >kY;kl
lIVsacj 2018 v[ksji;ZarP;k esgurkU;kph jDde izfroknh dk;kZy;kdMwu
oknhl feGkY;kckcr okn ukgh- R;keqGs] ;qfDroknknjE;ku 01 vkWDVkscj
2018 rs fMlsacj 2018 v[ksj dkyko/khdjhrk oknhus izfroknh
dk;kZy;kdMs esgurkU;kph dsysyh ekx.kh fopkjkr ?ksrk oknhus 01
vkWDVkscj 2018 rs fMlsacj 2018 v[ksj ;k dkyko/khr izfroknh
dk;kZy;kr iqohZizek.ksp vkiys drZO; ikj ikMY;kpk iqjkok oknhdMs vkgs
dk; v'kh ;qfDroknknjE;ku oknhrQsZ ofdykauk fopkj.kk dj.;kr vkyh
vlrk oknhrQsZ ofdykauh lnj dkyko/khr izfroknh dk;kZy;kr oknhus
vkiys drZO; ikj ikMY;kpk iqjkok oknhdMs ulY;kps lkaxhrys-
12- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] tjh nkO;kdkeh oknhP;k ukos vlysyk
lsokdjkj gk fnukad 15-06-2018 iklwu iq<hy 6 efgU;kdjhrk vlY;kps
oknhps dFku vlys rjh oknhus fdeku 01-10-2018 rs fMlascj 2018
v[ksj izfroknh dk;kZy;kr dke dsY;kps@drZO; ikj ikMY;kps tksi;Zar
fl) dj.kkj ukgh rksi;Zar R;kiksVh njegk :i;s 26]225@& izfroknh
dk;kZy;kdMwu esgurkuk feG.;kl oknh ik= vkgs vls Eg.krk ;s.kkj ukgh-
-- 8 of 12 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 3133@2019 --9-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 06-02-2026
13- ojhy dkyko/khr oknhus izfroknh dk;kZy;kr vkiys drZO;
ikj ikMys vlY;kl R;klaca/kh gtsjhiV] i=O;ogkj ;klkj[;k dkxni=kaoj
oknhP;k lg~;k >kY;k vlkO;kr gs visf{kr vlwu izfroknh dk;kZy;kr
oknhus ys[kkf/kdkjh oxZ&2 ;k inkps drZO; ikj ikMY;kpk oknhrQsZ
ofdykapk ;qfDrokn fopkjkr ?ksrk izfroknh dk;kZy;kr gks.kkÚ;k vkfFkZd
O;ogkjklaca/kh th dkxni=s vfLrRokr ;srkr R;koj oknhps 'ksjs fdaok lg~;k
vl.ks visf{kr vlwu fnukad 01-10-2018 rs fMlascj 2018 v[ksj ;k
dkyko/khr njjkstP;k dkeknjE;ku r;kj >kysyh dkxni=s izfroknh
dk;kZy;krwu ekxowu rh oknhl fl) djrk vkyh vlrh ijarq rls ?kMys
ukgh- R;keqGs] fnukad 01-10-2018 rs fMlascj 2018 v[ksj ;k
dkyko/khr izfroknh dk;kZy;kr drZO;koj vlY;kps fl) dj.;kdjhrk
mRd`"V iqjkok ns.;kph la/kh oknhl vlwu ns[khy oknhus R;kckcr dks.krkgh
ys[kh fLodkjgZ o fo'oklkgZ iqjkok fnyk ulY;kus fnukad 01-10-2018 rs
fMlascj 2018 v[ksj ;k dkyko/khr oknhus izfroknh dk;kZy;kr vkiys
drZO; ikj ikMY;kps fl) dj.;kl oknh vi;'kh Bjyk vkgs- ifj.kker%
fnukad 03-10-2018 jksthP;k izfroknh dk;kZy;kdMwu ikBfo.;kr
vkysY;k uksVhlckcrps oknhps dFku ns[khy fLodkjkgZ o fo'oklkgZ ukgh-
14- ;kf'kok;] fnukad 03-10-2018 v'kh rkjh[k uewn vlY;kps
izfroknh dk;kZy;kdMwu ikBfo.;kr vkysys i= fnukad 24-12-2018 jksth
izkIRk >kY;kps oknhps dFku vlwu izfroknh dk;kZy;kus fnukad
03-10-2018 gh lnj i=koj uewn dsysyh rkjh[k pqdhph uewn dsY;kps
rlsp rs i= fnukad 24-12-2018 iqohZ dkgh fnolp vxksnj r;kj
dj.;kr vkY;kps oknhrQsZ ofdykauh ;qfDroknknjE;ku lkaxhrys- fnukad
24-12-2018 jksth oknhl feGkysys i= gs fnukad 03-10-2018 jksth
izfroknh dk;kZy;kr r;kj dj.;kr vkys ulY;kl rs i= useds dsOgk
-- 9 of 12 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 3133@2019 --10-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 06-02-2026
r;kj dj.;kr vkys o R;k dk;kZy;krhy dks.kR;k tkod Øekadkus
dks.kR;k rkj[ksl oknhl ikBfo.;kr vkys ;kckcr] izfroknhP;k
dk;kZy;krhy i=O;ogkjklaca/khph dkxni=s ekxowu R;klaca/kh t:j rks
iqjkok oknhl nsrk vkyk vlrk ijarq] oknhus R;kckcr ns[khy dks.krsgh
iz;Ru dsys ukgh- lcc] fnukad 03-10-2018 v'kh rkjh[k uewn vlysys
i= R;k rkj[ksl r;kj dj.;kr vkysys ukgh gs ns[khy fl) dj.;kl oknh
vi;'kh Bjyk vkgs-
15- rlsp] fnukad 24-12-2018 jksth fnukad 03-10-2018
v'kh rkjh[k uewn vlysys i= oknhl izkIr >kY;kps oknhps dFku
Lohdkjko;kps >kY;kl oknhus fMlsacj 2018 v[ksj esgurkU;kP;k jdesph
ekx.kh dsyh vlwu fnukad 24-12-2018 jksth rs i= izkIr >kY;kuarj
R;kckcr izfroknh dk;kZy;kdMs ykxyhp i=O;ogkj dsY;kps ns[khy rlsp
fMlascj 2018 v[ksj vki.k izfroknh dk;kZy;kr njjkst gtj gksrks o
drZO; ikj ikMr vkgs vls ns[khy oknhus izfroknh dk;kZy;kl dGfoY;kps
oknhps dFku ukgh- R;keqGs] fnukad 24-12-2018 jksth rs i= izkIr
>kY;kuarj oknhus R;k dk;kZy;kr fMlsacj 2018 v[ksj drZO; ikj
ikMY;kps oknhus dFku fLodkjkgZ ukgh fdaok R;kiq"B~;FkZ oknhus iqjkok fnyk
ulY;kus fuOoG nkO;krhy dFku fLodkjkgZ ukgh-
16- ojhy ifjfLFkrhr] izLrqr nkok egkjk"Vª 'kklukfo:) nk[ky
dj.;kr vkyk vkgs vls Eg.krk ;s.kkj ulY;kus rlsp oknhus egkjk"Vª
'kklukP;k dkexkj [kkR;kP;k lfpokl fnok.kh izØh;k lafgrsP;k dye 80
uqlkj uksVhl ikBfoyh ulY;kus lnj nkok vkgs ;k Lo:ikr pky.;kl
vik= vlwu izfroknh dk;kZy;kr ekgs vkWDVkscj 2018 rs fMlsacj 2018
v[ksj drZO; ikj ikMY;kps o i;kZ;kus esgurkU;kph jDde feG.;kl ik=
-- 10 of 12 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 3133@2019 --11-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 06-02-2026
vlY;kpsns[khy fl) dj.;kl oknh vi;'kh BjY;kus fouarhizek.ks izfroknh
dk;kZy;kdMwu nkok jDde n-lk-n-'ks 12 VDds O;ktnkjkus olwy gksowu
feG.;kl oknh ik= ukgh- R;keqGs] eqn~nk Øekad 1 pk fu"d"kZ ^gks;*] eqn~nk
Øekad 2 o 3 ps fu"d"kZ ^ukgh* vls eh uksanfor vkgs-
17- FkksMD;kr] oknh gk izfroknhfo:)ps vkiys dFku fl)
dj.;kl vi;'kh BjYkk vlwu fouarhizek.ks dks.krhgh nkn feG.;kl ik=
ulY;kus lnj nkok QsVkG.;kl ik= vkgs- R;keqGs] eh [kkyhyizek.ks
vkns'k ikjhr djhr vkgs %&
%% vkns’k %%
1- ,l-lh-nkok Øekad 3133@2013 QsVkG.;kr ;sr vkgs-
2- oknhus nkO;kpk [kpZ izfroknhl n~;kok o Lor%Pkk Lor% lkslkok-
fnukad % 06-02-2026
¼ lqfuy ek- ikVhy ½
uxj fnok.kh U;k;k/kh’k] c`gUeqacbZ
U;k;ky; Øekad 9
Jqrys[kukph rkjh[k % 06-02-2026
fyI;arj.kkph rkjh[k % 06-02-2026
Lok{kjhph rkjh[k % 09-02-2026
-- 11 of 12 --
,l-lh- nkok Øekad 3133@2019 --12-- U;k;fu.kZ;] fnukad 06-02-2026
“CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL
SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.”
Upload Date Upload Time Name of the Stenographer
09.02.2026 03:00 p.m. Mrs. Poonam Y. Pawar,
Stenographer (Grade-I)
Name of the Judge (With C.R. No.) H.H.J. SHRI. S. M. PATIL
(COURT ROOM NO.09)
Date of Pronouncement of
JUDGEMENT /ORDER
06.02.2026
JUDGEMENT /ORDER signed by
P.O. on
09.02.2026
JUDGEMENT /ORDER uploaded on 09.02.2026
-- 12 of 12 --