Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 13 Feb 2026 · CNR MHCC010120952025
Order Details: Other Pdf Text: MHCC010120952025 Presented on 02/09/2025 Registered on 10/09/2025 Decided on 13/02/2026 Duration 00Y: 05M: 11D IN THE CITY CIVIL COURT AT MAZGAON, MUMBAI SUMMONS FOR JUDGMENT NO. 196 OF 2025 IN SUMMARY SUIT NO. 753 OF 2022 Mr. Shahaban Ali Soharab Ali Shaikh ] Age 52 years, Occ:Business, residing ] at Room No. 6, Milan Star Building, ] B-1/6, S.M.D. Road, Opp. Fire Brigade, ] Antop Hill, Wadala, Mumbai-400 037. ]...Plaintiff VERSUS ] Mr. Riyaz Ahamed Zahoor Ahamed Ansari ] Age 55 years, Occ:Business, residing at ] Hill no. 4, Azad Nagar, Glass Factory, Near ] Akbar Lala Compound Ghatkopar (W), ] Mumbai-400 086. ]...Defendant Appearance :- Ld. Adv Chatradhari Nishad h/f. Jagdish Singh for plaintiff. Ld. Adv. Prakash Wagh for defendant. CORAM : HHJ SHRI SANGRAM SHRIHARI SHINDE C. R. NO.: 81 DATE : 13/02/2026 ORDER ( Dictated and pronounced in open Court) 01] The plaintiff has filed this summons for judgment against defendants on 15/07/2025. Defendant has filed affidavit in reply to the -- 1 of 7 -- 2 SJ No.196/25 In Sum Su No.753/2022 summons for judgment and resisted it and prayed for unconditional leave to defend the suit. Brief facts of plaintiff’s case may be summarized as under :- 02] As per the plaintiff, he has cordial relationship with defendant. On 01/02/2018, defendant requested the plaintiff to arrange an amount of Rs.3,00,000/- as friendly loan for his domestic purpose with Undertaking to return the said amount on 10/08/2018. Accordingly, on 15/02/2018, plaintiff paid an amount of Rs. 3,00,000/- in cash in presence of two witnesses namely Mr.Abdul Kalam Sayyed and Mr. Mohd. Irfan Shah, who are common friends. On 27/06/2018 defendant executed Undertaking in presence of two witnesses. Thereafter, on 10/08/2018 plaintiff requested defendant to repay the said amount however, plaintiff sought 6 to 10 months time. Further, even after said period, defendant failed to make the payment. When plaintiff requested the defendant to repay the said amount, defendant told that, he does not have money and he will repay whenever he will receive the money. Further, the defendant stated that he can file case against him. Therefore, plaintiff filed complaint against defendant on 17/06/2019 at Pydhonie Police Station, Mumbai. Thereafter, the concerned police station called both parties and defendant was made to understand the consequences. Thereafter, defendant made part payment of Rs.20,000/- in cash to the plaintiff on 25/07/2019 and Rs. 20,000/- on 30/11/2019 and obtained receipts. Further, the defendant assured to make the balance payment of Rs. 2,60,000/- on or before 30/03/2020. Further, due to national lock- down due to pandemic of Covid-19, defendant failed to pay the outstanding amount. Therefore, plaintiff issued legal demand notice dated 04/06/2022 to the defendant and called upon him to make the payment of Rs.3,27,600/- including interest at the rate of 12% p.a. The -- 2 of 7 -- 3 SJ No.196/25 In Sum Su No.753/2022 said notice was returned with remark, “Insufficient Address”. The cause of action has arose within the jurisdiction of this court and the plaintiff has filed suit within limitation. The defendant has admitted his liability. Therefore, defendant is not entitled for leave to defend the suit. Hence, Summons for Judgment may be allowed. 03] On the other hand, it is submitted on behalf of the defendant that plaintiff has filed suit for recovery of an amount of Rs. 2,60,000/- with interest. Further, it is the contention of the plaintiff that he has advanced an amount of Rs.3,00,000/- in cash on 15/02/2018 and defendant has executed Undertaking on 27/06/2018. It is submitted that the alleged loan is dated 15/02/2018 and Undertaking is dated 27/06/2018. The plaintiff has not explained why Undertaking was executed at belated stage. It is further submitted that defendant is illiterate person and do not understand English language. The alleged Undertaking is with respect to the amount of Rs. 3,00,000/- given to BMC officer at Parel, BMC office to provide room premises at Govandi. It is further submitted that the plaintiff has asked him to signed on the said Undertaking as a witness therefore, he has signed the said Undertaking. It is further submitted that plaintiff has contended that the defendant paid an amount of Rs. 20,000/- each on 25/07/2019 and 30/11/2019 however, there is no receipt to that effect. Further, the alleged Undertaking dated 27/06/2018 and therefore, plaintiff ought to have filed suit within three years i.e. on or before 26/06/2021. However, suit is filed on 11/06/2022, therefore, suit is not within limitation. The plaintiff is taking undue advantage of lock-down period to file the present suit. The defendant has not received any demand notice as contended by the plaintiff. The defendant has raised substantial defence that suit is not within limitation and alleged Undertaking is not with respect to the alleged -- 3 of 7 -- 4 SJ No.196/25 In Sum Su No.753/2022 loan. Therefore, these issues need to be adjudicated. Hence, defendant is entitled for unconditional leave to defend the suit. Therefore, Summons for Judgment may be dismissed. 04] Perused Summons for Judgment, reply and record of the case. Heard both parties. On perusing plaint, it appears that plaintiff has contended that he has advanced an amount of Rs. 3,00,000/- in cash to the defendant as a friendly loan on 15/02/2018 in presence of two witnesses namely Mr. Abdul Kalam Sayyed and Mr. Mohd Irfan Shah. It is also contention of the plaintiff that defendant executed Undertaking in presence of witnesses on 27/06/2018 and admitted that he has received an amount of Rs. 3,00,000/-. The plaintiff has filed original Undertaking on record vide List Exh.11/1. On perusing said Undertaking, it appears that defendant has admitted that he has received an amount of Rs. 3,00,000/- as a friendly loan and agreed to repay the same. However, there is no clause of rate of interest to be charged on default of repayment of loan. It is the contention of the defendant that he had signed said Undertaking at the instance of the plaintiff with respect to an amount of Rs. 3,00,000/- to be given to one BMC officer at Parel, BMC office. It is pertinent to note that though defendant has taken the said defence however, he has neither mentioned the date nor mentioned the name of the concerned BMC office to whom alleged amount of Rs. 3,00,000/- was paid. 05] It is further contention of the plaintiff that defendant made part payment of Rs.20,000/- each on 25/07/2019 and 30/11/2019 and obtained receipts. However, plaintiff has not filed office copies of the said amount on record to substantiate the said contention. Further, it is the contention of the plaintiff that as defendant failed to repay the amount of Rs. 2,60,000/- therefore, he -- 4 of 7 -- 5 SJ No.196/25 In Sum Su No.753/2022 had filed complaint at Pydhonie Police Station on 17/06/2019 against the defendant. The plaintiff has filed certified copy of said complaint on record vide List Exh.11/2. Though, the plaintiff has filed complaint against defendant police station, this itself will not lead to inference that the defendant has admitted the liability. Further, plaintiff had issued demand notice dated 04/06/2022 by RPAD to the defendant and called upon him to make the payment of outstanding amount with interest. The plaintiff has filed office copy of said notice and returned sealed envelop on record vide List Exh.11/3 and 11/4. It is the contention of the plaintiff that notice sent to the defendant was returned with remark, “Insufficient Address”. On perusing said document, it substantiate the contention of the plaintiff. 06] The defendant has raised defence that he has not executed Undertaking dated 27/06/2018. However, except bare contention, there is nothing on record to substantiate the contention of the defendant. Therefore, I am of the view that plaintiff has demonstrated that the defendant has admitted that he has received an amount of Rs. 3,00,000/- vide said Undertaking. However, the plaintiff has not filed any document on record to substantiate his contention that the defendant made part payment of Rs. 20,000/- each on 15/02/2018 and 25/07/2019. The defendant has denied of alleged part payment. Therefore, the plaintiff ought to have filed some documentary evidence to substantiate his contention. 07] Further, plaintiff has raised issue of limitation. As per the plaintiff himself an amount of Rs.3,00,000/- was given on 15/02/2018 and Undertaking was executed on 27/06/2018. Therefore, the plaintiff ought to have filed suit within three years from 27/06/2018 i.e. on or before 26/06/2021. The plaintiff has filed suit on -- 5 of 7 -- 6 SJ No.196/25 In Sum Su No.753/2022 11/07/2022. As per the plaintiff, defendant has made last part payment on 30/11/2019 and therefore, suit filed on 11/07/2022 is within limitation. As discussed above, the plaintiff has not filed any material on record to show that defendant has made last payment on 30/11/2019. Therefore, I am of the view that there is substance in the contention of the defendant that issue of limitation arises in the present suit. Thus, the defendant has raised substantial defence and triable issue i.e. limitation. These issues need to be adjudicated. Therefore, the defendant is entitled for unconditional leave to defend the suit. Hence, I proceed to pass the following order. ORDER 1] Summons for judgment No. 196 of 2025 is disposed of as follows:- (a) Defendant is granted unconditional Leave to defend the suit and at liberty to file written statement on or before next date. 2] Summons for judgment No.196 of 2025 is disposed of accordingly. (Sangram S. Shinde) Adhoc Judge, City Civil Court, Mazgaon, Mumbai. C.R.No.81 Date-13/02/2026 Dictated on : 13/02/2026 Corrected & signed on : 16/02/2026 -- 6 of 7 -- 7 SJ No.196/25 In Sum Su No.753/2022 “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER” UPLOAD DATE NAME OF STENOGRAPHER 18/02/2026 Mrs. V. V. Malgaonkar Name of the Judge (with Court Room No.) Shri. Sangram S. Shinde C.R. No.81 Date of Pronouncement of JUDGMENT/ ORDER 13/02/2026 JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P. O. on 16/02/2026 JUDGMENT/ORDER uploaded on 18/02/2026 -- 7 of 7 --
