Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 29 Sept 2025 · CNR MHCC010116032025
Order Details: Chamber summons Pdf Text: 1 MHCC010116032025 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT AT MUMBAI CHAMBER SUMMONS NO.2043 OF 2025 (CNR NO.MHCC01-011603-2025) IN L.C. SUIT NO.1817 OF 2025 Mr. Mazhar Khan ….Applicant. In the matter between : Mr. Syed Faisal Pervez ….Plaintiff. V/s. The Assistant Municipal Commissioner, G/North Ward Office, Near Plaza Cinema, Dadar, Mumbai 400 008. ....Defendant. Appearance : Adv. Devashish Godbole for applicant. Adv. A.S. Pande for plaintiff. Adv. Amar Patil for defendant / BMC. CORAM : HIS HONOUR JUDGE SHRI. R.V. BHAKTA (COURT ROOM NO.06) DATE : 29th September, 2025. ORAL ORDER This Chamber Summons taken by the applicant to add him as a party of the Suit. -- 1 of 5 -- 2 2. The applicant averred that, the plaintiff has filed this Suit challenging the notice issued by the BMC dated 24.03.2025 u/Ss.351, 352, 352-A and 354-A of MMC Act. According to the applicant that, the suit property is a chawl. The applicant is residing on the upper floor of the suit property and the plaintiff is residing on the ground floor. The plaintiff has illegally constructed masonry wall. Due to the said wall the common chamber is blocked. Therefore, it is very difficult to clean the common chamber. Consequently, it causes nuisance. Not only this due to the above illegal structure the common area is also covered by the plaintiff. Not only this the said illegal structure is also causes damage and affect the stability of the chawl. According to him that, he is not stranger and his personal interest is involved in the said Suit as it is affecting his legal rights. Therefore, he is a necessary party of this Suit. In support of this, he has relied on the case law in a case of, Aijaz @ Azaz Mohammed Shaikh V/s. Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay & Anr., 2012 (2) ALL MR 171 in which it has held that, "if a person is vitally interested in the subject matter of the suit who is a necessary party of the suit." 3. The plaintiff has challenged the Chamber Summons by filing of his say in which he has denied most of the averments of the Chamber Summons. It is his contention that, it is a well settled law that the plaintiff is a dominus litis of his case. Therefore, the applicant can not be added as a party of this Suit against his wish. Hence, prayed to dismiss the Chamber Summons. In support of this, he has relied on judgment given by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in a case of, Ramesh Hirachand Kundanmal V/s. Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay and Ors., 1992 SCR 21 in which it has held that, “ if the respondent has no interest in the subject matter of the suit and if his legal rights will -- 2 of 5 -- 3 not affect then he is not a necessary party”. 4. I have gone through the Chamber Summons, say and heard both the parties. 5. It is pertinent to note here that, the applicant has taken this Chamber Summons to add him as a party of this Suit. According to the applicant that, he is residing on the upper floor of the plaintiff's room. The plaintiff has made illegal structure of masonry wall. Due to the said wall the common chamber is blocked, rather it is difficult to clean the said chamber. Therefore, it causes nuisance. It is the further case of the applicant that, by way of such illegal structure the common area is affected and it also affects the structural stability of the chawl. 6. In my view, it is admitted fact on record that the applicant is residing on the upper floor of the suit property. The alleged construction definitely affects the legal rights of the applicant as he is not stranger. Therefore, the personal right of the applicant is involved in the present Suit and by virtue of the said structure his legal rights are infringed. In my view, whether the structure made by the plaintiff is legal or illegal it is a matter of evidence which has to be decided as per the merits of Suit. In these circumstances, in order to decide the real controversy between the parties if the applicant is added as a party of this Suit then it will not cause any harm to the either side, rather it will serve the ends of justice. Hence, following order : ORDER 1. The Chamber Summons No.2043 of 2025 is allowed and disposed of, accordingly. 2. The applicant is directed to carry out necessary amendment -- 3 of 5 -- 4 within limitation. 3. Cost in main cause. (R.V. BHAKTA) Judge, City Civil Court, Date: 29.09.2025 Gr. Bombay. Dictated on : 29.09.2025 Signed on : -- 4 of 5 -- 5 CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER.” 29/09/2025 05.05 p.m. N.S. Bakre UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge (With Court Room Number) HHJ SHRI. R.V. BHAKTA (C.R.NO.06) Date of pronouncement of Judgment/ Order 29.09.2025 Judgment/Order signed by P.O. on 29.09.2025 Judgment/Order uploaded on 29.09.2025 -- 5 of 5 --
