Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 28 Jul 2026 · CNR MHCC010113662023
Order Details: Other Pdf Text: MHCC010113662023 Presented on 01/11/2023 Registered on 01/11/2023 Decided on 28/07/2026 Duration 02Y: 08M: 28D IN THE CITY CIVIL COURT AT MAZGAON, MUMBAI SUMMONS FOR JUDGMENT NO. 246 OF 2023 IN SUMMARY SUIT NO. 265 OF 2023 Tilak Dedhia (C.A. of Bhavna Dedhia-daughter) Age: 40 years, Address: 26, Khimji Maharaj Building, Near Shiv-Sena Shakha, M. G. Road, Mulund (W), Mumbai – 400080. ...Plaintiff VERSUS Smt. Jayashreeben Narendrabhai Gala Legal Heir of Shri. Narendrabhai Gala Addresses: 1) 279/280, Shree Divyadarshan C.H.S., S. N. Road, Kandivli - (W), Mumbai – 400067. 2) 4, Bhagat Niwas, Visanji Lalji Road, Near railway Crossing, Kandivli(W), Mumbai – 400067. ...Defendant. Appearance: Adv. Ravindra Kumar i/b. Adv. Prashant Yadav for plaintiff. Defendant and her advocate remained absent. CORAM : SMT. VIDYA G. UPADHYE C. R. NO. : 81 DATE : 28/07/2026 -- 1 of 7 -- 2 SJ 246/2023 in Suit No.265/2023 O R D E R This Summons for Judgment is filed for a claim of a sum of 3,00,000/- together with interest calculated to 1,25,000/- at the rate ₹ ₹ of 15% per annum from 30/06/2019 to 24/08/2022. The plaintiff has filed register copy of Summons for Judgment on 06/02/2024. The defendant, in response, while resisting the claim of the plaintiff has filed her application for leave to defend to the summons for judgment on 06/02/2024 itself. 2] Bereft of unnecessary details, the claim of the plaintiff in the suit as well as Summons for Judgment is that, plaintiff and deceased husband of the defendant, Mr. Narendrabhai Gala were friends and were having cordial relations. Mr. Gala was a producer, director and distributor in Gujrati Film Industry. He was running his business in the name of 'Arya Creations'. The husband of the defendant was in need of financial assistance for his business. Therefore, he had requested to advance loan to the plaintiff. The defendant was also introduced to the plaintiff by her deceased husband as she is engaged in the astrology business and having active participation in business of her husband. The plaintiff therefore advanced a friendly loan of 3,00,000/- to Mr. Gala ₹ from time to time. The husband of defendant had handed over title documents (Sale Agreement and Share Certificate of the society) of his residential flat of Kandivali as a security to the plaintiff towards repayment of a loan. On 21/06/2019, the husband of defendant had acknowledged his liability to pay the outstanding loan amount and had issued a cheque of 20,000/- which was encashed by the plaintiff. ₹ Thereafter, he had avoided to repay the outstanding loan amount on one pretext or the other showing his inability due to financial loss. Thereafter, Mr. Gala passed away on 30/07/2020. The entire -- 2 of 7 -- 3 SJ 246/2023 in Suit No.265/2023 transaction had occurred in front of the defendant. After the death of her husband, the defendant is liable to pay the outstanding loan amount advanced to her husband. As per the statement of account dated 31/12/2019, the total outstanding amount due to be paid along with interest at the rate of 15% per annum is 4,25,000/-. ₹ 3] The defendant in her application for leave to defend has denied the alleged transaction of loan. According to her, there is no cause of action to the suit. The suit is not maintainable in the present form (as a summary suit). The plaintiff has got custody of original Sale Agreement of her residential flat No. A/402, 4th Floor, Shree Divyadarshan Co-operative Housing Society, Kandivali (W), Mumbai – 400047. The plaintiff is therefore, blackmailing her on the basis of title documents to extract money from her. It is pointed by her that the plaintiff has filed one more suit against her for recovery of an amount of 4,11,750/-. The suit is barred by limitation. No document is produced ₹ by the plaintiff in support of his purported claim. She denied the acknowledgment of statement of account by her husband. Lastly, the defendant averred that no amount is due and payable by her or her husband. Accordingly, defendant prayed for rejection of summons for judgment and granting unconditional leave to him to defend the suit. 4] Considering rival contentions of parties following points arise for my determination and I have recorded my findings against them for the reasons stated thereunder: Sr. No. Points Findings 1. Whether Summons for Judgment is required to be made absolute? No 2. Whether there are triable issues to be adjudicated between the parties ? Yes -- 3 of 7 -- 4 SJ 246/2023 in Suit No.265/2023 3. Whether the defendant is entitled for conditional/unconditional leave to defend ? Defendant is entitled for unconditional leave to defend. REASONS As to Point Nos. 1 to 3: 5] In order to buttress his case, the plaintiff has placed reliance on the documents such as, verified copy of Visiting Card of the deceased husband of defendant Mr. Narendrabhai Gala, Copy of Pamphlet of Astrology Class of defendant in Gujrati language (without the true translation of the document), office copy of demand notice dated 20/05/2019, verified copy of statement of accounts of plaintiff's daughter dated 20/06/2019 maintained with Kotak Mahendra Bank, office copy of notice dated 26/05/2022 addressed to the defendant, its postal receipt, printout of Postal Track Report dated 28/06/19, along with Certificate u/s. 65-B, etc. 6] Heard learned advocate for plaintiff. Went through written submission filed by him. Learned advocate for the defendant was absent and did not submit his argument on Summons for Judgment. 7] The plaintiff has reiterated in Summons for Judgment that to secure repayment of loan advanced to Mr. Gala, he had issued an undated cheque of 1,00,000/- drawn on Union Bank of India. Mr. Gala ₹ had also deposited his title documents of his residential flat at Kandivali. Therefore, the defense of the defendant of total denial of loan transaction is a moonshine. According to learned advocate for the plaintiff, the defendant actively participated in phone calls where the transaction was discussed with the plaintiff. The deceased Mr. Gala had also acknowledged his debt in his own handwriting. He had agreed to -- 4 of 7 -- 5 SJ 246/2023 in Suit No.265/2023 pay interest at the rate of 2% per month. He had paid 10,000/- in ₹ cash on 21/06/2019. Lastly, he had delivered an undated cheque of 1,00,000/- on 04/09/2019 towards the security of repayment of loan ₹ which amounts to his undertaking to repay it. Thus, cause of action effectively crystallized on 04/09/2019. The suit is filed on 25/08/2022, which is perfectly within limitation. 8] On going through the documents produced by the plaintiff, it is amply clear that there is no whisper about the date on which the loan was advanced to Mr. Gala in the plaint. Even the particulars of the claim is not signed by the plaintiff or his daughter. There is no documentary proof as such that Mr. Gala had acknowledged his debt and had given undertaking to repay it before expiry of period of limitation for a money recovery suit. The entry in the statement of account of plaintiff's daughter dated 20/06/2019 by which it is reflected that 20,000/- was paid by cash by Mr. Gala is not a sufficient ₹ and cogent evidence to come to the conclusion that such part payment was made towards outstanding loan amount. 9] Admittedly, there was no direct transaction between plaintiff and defendant. The plaintiff has not even filed copy of undated cheque handed over by Mr. Gala to the plaintiff as a security for repayment of loan to show that it was handed over on 4/9/2019. Thus, there is nothing on record prima facie to show that the plaintiff's claim is within the prescribed period of limitation. There is nothing on record to show that the said cheque was issued on 04/09/2019 as an undertaking by Mr. Gala to repay the loan from which date the plaintiff has calculated the period of limitation. Moreover, as disclosed by the defendant, Mr. Gala is survived by his daughter Ami Dipesh Vira who also is his legal representative. She is not made party to the suit. It has -- 5 of 7 -- 6 SJ 246/2023 in Suit No.265/2023 to be tested whether she is necessary party to the suit or not. Therefore, the maintainability of the suit for non-joinder of necessary party is also a core issue involved in this case. Hence, in my humble opinion, there are triable issues which need adjudication on receiving evidence by both parties. There is no document also to show that Mr. Gala had agreed to pay interest at the rate of 2% per month on purported loan advanced to him. As such, the documentary evidence is lacking which demonstrates that the defendant is liable to pay even the principal sum of 2,80,000/-. In the result, I record “ ₹ negative” finding as to Point No.1 and “ affirmative” finding as to Point No.2. The defendant is entitled for unconditional leave to defend as there is much force in the defense taken by her of the suit being barred by limitation. Consequently, I pass following order: ORDER 1) Summons for Judgment No.246/2023 in Suit No. 265 of 2023 is disposed of as follows: (a) Defendant is granted unconditional leave to defend the suit and she is at liberty to file written statement within 30 days from the date of this order. 2) Summons for Judgment No.246/2023 is disposed of accordingly. (Vidya G. Upadhye) Ad-hoc Judge, City Civil Court, Mazgaon, Mumbai. C.R.No.81 Date : 28/07/2026 Dictated on : 28/07/2026 Corrected & signed on: 28/07/2026 -- 6 of 7 -- 7 SJ 246/2023 in Suit No.265/2023 “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER” UPLOAD DATE NAME OF STENOGRAPHER 28/07/2026 Mrs. V. V. Malgaonkar Name of the Judge (with Court Room No.) Smt. Vidya G. Upadhye C.R. No.81 Date of Pronouncement of JUDGMENT/ ORDER 28/07/2026 JUDGMENT/ORDER signed by P. O. on 28/07/2026 JUDGMENT/ORDER uploaded on 28/07/2026 -- 7 of 7 --
