Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 24 Nov 2023 · CNR MHCC010107262023
Order Details: Chamber summons Pdf Text: 1 C/S. No.1846/23 (LCS No.2517/11) MHCC010107262023 IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT AT GREATER MUMBAI CHAMBER SUMMONS No.1846 OF 2023 IN LONG CAUSE SUIT No.2517/2011 Pravin A. Gohil … Petitioner - Versus - Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai & 2 Ors. ... Defendants Appearance :- Mr. Giriraj with Mrs. Sharma, Advocates for petitioner. Mr. Om Suryavanshi, Advocate for defendants/M.C.G.M. CORAM : S. H. SALUNKHE, AD-HOC JUDGE CITY CIVIL COURT, COURT ROOM NO.4. DATED : 24/11/2023. O R D E R . The plaintiff has taken out this Chamber Summons for amendment in the plaint under Order-VI Rule-17 of The Code of Civil Procedure (in short the C. P. C.). 2] It is stated that the plaintiff has challenged notice under Section 351 of The Mumbai Municipal Corporation Act (in short the M.M.C. Act). It is further stated that the M. C. G. M. has issued a composite notice to 29 persons. Thereafter various notices have filed suits as mentioned in paragraph No.3 of Chamber Summons and -- 1 of 7 -- 2 C/S. No.1846/23 (LCS No.2517/11) challenged same notice. Out of that three suits have been decreed. It is further stated that the said decrees relates to composite notice as in present suit and, therefore, similar order are to be passed on the ground of parity. So also at the stage of final arguments the M.C.G.M. filed purported sanctioned plan and the Hon'ble High Court has permitted the plaintiff to cross-examine the witness of defendant. It is further stated that the proposed amendment is just and necessary for complete and effective adjudication of dispute. On the basis of these contentions, the plaintiff prayed for permission to amend the plaint. 3] The defendants opposed Chamber Summons stating that the proposed amendment is not necessary and relevant for decision of suit. The plaintiffs are trying to prolong trial of suit. On these grounds, defendants prayed for rejection of Chamber Summons. 4] Perused Chamber Summons, affidavit in support thereto, reply, record and proceeding. Heard both sides. 5] It is matter of record that after closing evidence of the parties defendant B. M. C. has produced on record the sanctioned plan. The said order of production and exhibiting sanctioned plan is confirmed by the Hon'ble High Court and the plaintiff was permitted to cross-examine the witness of defendant B.M.C. 6] Admittedly, suit is a part heard. As per the proviso to Order- VI Rule-17 of the C. P. C. when the application for amendment is taken out after commencement of the trial, the party must show that in spite of due diligence, such amendment could not have been sought earlier. Thus, as per the proviso to Order-VI Rule-17 of the C. P. C. unless it is shown that the plaintiff could not have carried out amendment before -- 2 of 7 -- 3 C/S. No.1846/23 (LCS No.2517/11) commencement of trial, the Court cannot permit amendment in the pleadings after commencement of trial. It is contention of the plaintiff that after filing present suit, other suits have been decreed. It is submitted by advocate for the plaintiff that the decree passed in other similar suits is a subsequent event. 7] It is well settled that while dealing with application for amendment in the plaint the Court has to be liberal unless serious injustice or irreparable loss is caused to other side and nature of suit is not likely to be changed as a result of amendment it should normally be allowed. The Hon'ble Apex Court in a recent judgment of the Life Insurance Corporation of India Versus Sanjeev Builders Private Limited & Anr. (Civil Appeal No. 5909 Of 2022) in which the Hon’ble Apex Court summarized law in respect of amendment of the pleadings and held in paragraph No.70 that :- “ (i) Order II Rule 2 CPC operates as a bar against a subsequent suit if the requisite conditions for application thereof are satisfied and the field of amendment of pleadings falls far beyond its purview. The plea of amendment being barred under Order II Rule 2 CPC is, thus, misconceived and hence negatived. (ii) All amendments are to be allowed which are necessary for determining the real question in controversy provided it does not cause injustice or prejudice to the other side. This is mandatory, as is apparent from the use of the word “shall”, in the latter part of Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC. (iii) The prayer for amendment is to be allowed (i) if the amendment is required for effective and proper adjudication of the controversy between the parties, and -- 3 of 7 -- 4 C/S. No.1846/23 (LCS No.2517/11) (ii) to avoid multiplicity of proceedings, provided (a) the amendment does not result in injustice to the other side, (b) by the amendment, the parties seeking amendment does not seek to withdraw any clear admission made by the party which confers a right on the other side and (c) the amendment does not raise a time barred claim, resulting in divesting of the other side of a valuable accrued right (in certain situations). (iv) A prayer for amendment is generally required to be allowed unless (i) by the amendment, a time barred claim is sought to be introduced, in which case the fact that the claim would be time barred becomes a relevant factor for consideration, (ii) the amendment changes the nature of the suit, (iii) the prayer for amendment is malafide, or (iv) by the amendment, the other side loses a valid defence. (v) In dealing with a prayer for amendment of pleadings, the court should avoid a hypertechnical approach, and is ordinarily required to be liberal especially where the opposite party can be compensated by costs. (vi) Where the amendment would enable the court to pin-pointedly consider the dispute and would aid in rendering a more satisfactory decision, the prayer for amendment should be allowed. -- 4 of 7 -- 5 C/S. No.1846/23 (LCS No.2517/11) (vii) Where the amendment merely sought to introduce an additional or a new approach without introducing a time barred cause of action, the amendment is liable to be allowed even after expiry of limitation. (viii) Amendment may be justifiably allowed where it is intended to rectify the absence of material particulars in the plaint. (ix) Delay in applying for amendment alone is not a ground to disallow the prayer. Where the aspect of delay is arguable, the prayer for amendment could be allowed and the issue of limitation framed separately for decision. (x) Where the amendment changes the nature of the suit or the cause of action, so as to set up an entirely new case, foreign to the case set up in the plaint, the amendment must be disallowed. Where, however, the amendment sought is only with respect to the relief in the plaint, and is predicated on facts which are already pleaded in the plaint, ordinarily the amendment is required to be allowed. (xi) Where the amendment is sought before commencement of trial, the court is required to be liberal in its approach. The court is required to bear in mind the fact that the opposite party would have a chance to meet the case set up in amendment. As such, where the amendment does not result in irreparable prejudice to the opposite party, or divest the opposite party of an advantage which it had secured as a result of an admission by the party seeking amendment, the amendment is required to be allowed. Equally, where the amendment is necessary for the court to effectively adjudicate on the main issues in controversy between the parties, the amendment -- 5 of 7 -- 6 C/S. No.1846/23 (LCS No.2517/11) should be allowed. (See Vijay Gupta v. Gagninder Kr. Gandhi & Ors., 2022 SCC OnLine Del 1897)” 8] Hon’ble Apex Court in above referred judgment held that all amendments are to be allowed which are necessary for determining real question in controversy, provided it does not cause injustice and prejudice to other side and this is mandatory as per the provisions of Order-VI Rule-17 of the C. P. C. 9] The plaintiff came with case that the proposed amendment is just and necessary for complete and effective adjudication of dispute. I have gone through the proposed amendment. The plaintiff is seeking permission to incorporate contentions in respect of subsequent document in other similar suit. In my opinion, the proposed amendment is just and necessary for effective adjudication of dispute. Thus, considering contention of the plaintiff and above referred judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court, Chamber Summons deserves to be allowed. No any prejudice would be caused to the other side and there is no likely to change in nature of suit. In the result, I pass following order :- O R D E R 1] Chamber Summons is hereby made absolute in terms of prayer clause (a) subject to payment of cost Rs.3,000/-. 2] Amount of cost be credited to The District Legal Services Authority, Mumbai which would be deposited in this Court. 3] The plaintiff to carry out necessary amendment till the next date and shall serve copy of amended plaint to other side. Date : 24/11/2023. ( S. H. SALUNKHE ) Ad-hoc Judge City Civil Court, Court Room No.4, Gr. Mumbai. -- 6 of 7 -- 7 C/S. No.1846/23 (LCS No.2517/11) “CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED ORDER.” 08/12/2023 03:55 p.m. V. V. Kulkarni NAME OF STENOGRAPHERUPLOAD DATE TIME Name of the Judge (With Court Room No.) H. H. Judge Shri. S. H. Salunkhe, Court Room No. 4. Date of Pronouncement of ORDER 24/11/2023 ORDER Typed on 07/12/2023 ORDER signed by P.O. on 08/12/2023 ORDER uploaded on 08/12/2023 -- 7 of 7 --
