Full Order Text
Final Order 1 · 08 Nov 2023 · CNR MHCC010107002023
Order Details: Copy of Judgment Pdf Text: ... 1 ... MHCC010107002023 Presented on : 13-10-2023 Registered on : 20-10-2023 Decided on : 08/11/2023 Duration : 00 00 27 Years Months Days IN THE COURT OF CITY CIVIL FOR GREATER BOMBAY AT BOMBAY MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO. 129 OF 2023 (CNR NO. MHCC010107002023) Mr. Anant Yashwant Dandekar Age : 60 years, Occ :- Retired Residing at Flat No. B-98/4, Government Colony, Bandra (East) Mumbai 400 051. …. Appellant Versus 1. Competent Authority 404, Fourth Floor, New D.D Building, Old Custom House, S.B.S Road, Fort Mumbai 400 001. 2. Executive Engineer Public Work Department, North Bombay Division, New Administrative Building, Near Bhavan’s College, Andheri (West) Mumbai 400 058. 3. The State of Maharashtra Through the Government Pleader Office, Bombay City Civil, Mumbai …. Respondents CORAM : HIS HONOUR THE PRINCIPAL JUDGE, SHRI A.SUBRAMANIAM C.R.NO.. : 19 DATE : 08th DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2023 Appearances :- Mr. Prashant Sarwankar, Learned Counsel for the appellant. Mr. M. B. Jadhav, Learned Counsel for the Respondents. -- 1 of 5 -- ... 2 ... ORAL JUDGMENT 1. By the present appeal, the appellant is challenging the order passed by the learned Competent Authority dated 28.08.2023 in Eviction Case No.25974 of 2023 by which appellant has been directed to vacate the premises and pay compensation of Rs.9,14,775/-. 2. The case of the appellant is that he was in employment and he has retired. The appellant has not been given statutory dues of retirement and hence is unable to pay or get accommodation and hence unable to vacate the premises. These factors are not considered by the learned Competent Authority. Covid period is also included for compensation which is exempted. 3. Heard learned Counsel for the respondents. He vehemently submitted that the concerned employee has exceeded his time and considering the same submitted that the order of the learned Competent Authority is just and correct. No exemption can be granted as the benefit of the G.R. has not been availed by the concerned employee. 4. Heard learned Counsel for the appellant as well as respondents. 5. Perused the record and proceedings, the impugned order, the appeal memo and considered the submissions, following points arise for my consideration and I answer the same as under for the reasons stated hereinafter; Sr. Nos POINTS FINDINGS 1 Whether the appellant said to be unauthorized occupant? :: In the affirmative 2 Whether the impugned order requires any interference? :: Partly in the negative -- 2 of 5 -- ... 3 ... 3 What order? :: As per final order REASONS As to point No.1: 6. On consideration of the facts of the case, pending the present appeal, the appellant tendered undertaking and has also vacated the premises. The affidavits are also filed and this fact is not disputed. It is admitted that the appellant has over stayed the limit and hence this aspect has to be considered to be unauthorized occupancy by the appellant. Hence, I Answer the point no.1 in affirmative. As to Point No.2: 7. Considering the above facts of vacation, there is no requirement of interference in the order of eviction. On perusal of the impugned order, the Competent Authority has without any finding or reasoning fixed the rate at of Rs.150/- per square feet which has considered to be excessive and exorbitant. In view of the same, I hold that the fair amount would be at Rs.10/- per square feet. It is further required to be considered that the appellant is entitled for the benefit under the gazette of occupation of COVID period as per G.R.No.’kkfuok&1520@iz-d- 113@20@23&v dated 22.04.2022 of Maharashtra government. Hence, I pass the following order. O R D E R 1. Misc. Appeal No.129 of 2023 is partly allowed. 2. The order of eviction passed by the Learned Competent Authority in Eviction Proceedings No.25974 of 2023 dated 28.08.2023 is hereby confirmed. 3. The order of payment of compensation is modified to the extent that the compensation will be payable at the rate of Rs.10/- per -- 3 of 5 -- ... 4 ... square feet per month from 01.03.2022 till 31.05.2024 in case the appellant vacates on or before 31.05.2024. 4. If the appellant fails to honour the undertaking given to this Court, the compensation be recovered as per impugned order. 5. Appellant is entitled for the benefit under the gazette of occupation of Covid period as per G.R.No.’kkfuok&1520@iz-d-113@20@23&v dated 22.04.2022 of Maharashtra government. 6. No order as to cost. 7. Inform the concerned Learned Competent Authority. 8. Record and Proceedings be sent back to respondents. DATE : 08.11.2023 (A.SUBRAMANIAM) PRINCIPAL JUDGE CITY CIVIL COURT, MUMBAI. (JO CODE MH01711). Dictated on : 08.11.2023. Transcribed on : 08.11.2023. Signed on : 08.11.2023. -- 4 of 5 -- ... 5 ... "CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER" DATE : 08.11.2023, AT 05.35 P.M. Mr. Mohit M. Patange STENOGRAPHER (GRADE-III) UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER Name of the Judge (with Court no.) : SHRI A.SUBRAMANIAM. C.R.NO.19. Date of pronouncement of judgment/order : 08.11.2023 Judgment/order signed by the P.O. on : 08.11.2023 Judgment/order uploaded on : 08.11.2023 -- 5 of 5 --
