Skip to main content
Court Order

Final Order 1

CNR MHCC01010376202204 Nov 2022
Fort, City Civil Court
Mumbai · Maharashtra (MH)
Back to Case

Full Order Text

Final Order 1 · 04 Nov 2022 · CNR MHCC010103762022

Order Details: Notice of Motion
Pdf Text: CNR NO. :MHCC01-010376-2022 1 Notice of Motion No. 3525/2022
in L.C. Suit No. 2000/2022.
IN THE BOMBAY CITY CIVIL COURT AT BOMBAY.
NOTICE OF MOTION NO. 3525 OF 2022.
IN
L.C. SUIT NO. 2000 OF 2022.
Masiuddin W. Choudhary. ...……………… ….. PLAINTIFF.
V/s.
M.C.G.M. …..…......................................... ….. DEFENDANT.
CORAM : Shri. A.G. Santani.
(Court Room No.11).
DATED : 04th November, 2022.
APPEARANCES :
Mr. B. P. Shukla, Ld. Advocate for the Plaintiff.
Mr. Sunil C. Khandagale, Ld. Advocate for the Defendant/MCGM.
*****
01. The plaintiff has taken out this Notice of Motion (for short
‘the NM’), to restrain the defendant from executing/enforcing the notice
of dtd. 30.08.2022, issued U/s. 354-A of the MMC Act, and the Speaking
Order dtd. 14.09.2022. Perused the NM, his accompanying affidavit, the
reply of defendant and the plaintiff’s reply rejoinder.
02. Considering the record, the point for determination, along -
with my finding and the reasons therefor, are as under :
Sr. No. POINTS FINDINGS
(i). Whether the plaintiff has a prima facie
case in his favour ? …..............................
Common Finding :
Yes, till the
defendant follows
the due process of
law.
(ii). Whether balance of convenience lies in
favour of the plaintiff ? …........................ ...
(iii). Whether the plaintiff would suffer an
-- 1 of 7 --
CNR NO. :MHCC01-010376-2022 2 Notice of Motion No. 3525/2022
in L.C. Suit No. 2000/2022.
irreparable loss, if the interim relief, as
prayed for, is not granted ?......................
(iv). What Order ? …..............….................... …As per final Order.
REASONS FOR THE FINDINGS
AS TO POINT NOS. 1 TO 3 :
03. By filing this suit, the plaintiff contended that he is in use
and possession of the suit premises, consisting of G+2 upper floors,
duly described in para 1 of the plaint. The suit premises is old one and
existed prior to the year of 1961-1962. It was assessed to the Municipal
taxes even before the year 1979. Originally, it was occupied by one Mr.
Harbansh Lal Kapoor. Earlier, as per the permission of dtd. 07.09.1983,
some urgent repairs were carried to it. By virtue of the Sale Deed dtd.
10.01.1997, the plaintiff acquired the suit premises. He has the electric
connection thereat and is running business under the name and style of
‘M/s. Choudhary Engineering Work’. As the suit premises required some
urgent repairs, he carried the same in the form of plastering, painting,
plumbing, etc.. which did not require separate permission. However, on
the false complaints, the defendant issued this notice U/s. 354-A of the
MMC Act. In fact, no such construction was ‘in progress’. He replied this
notice on 01.09.2022 Still, without considering the record, he passed
the Speaking Order on 14.09.2022. However, no such construction was
in progress and therefore, the said notice and the Order are bad in law.
With these facts, he had to file this suit and the NM. Now, at this interim
stage, he relied upon the documents like assessment bills, bearing date
of first assessment as 01.04.1979, the permission of dtd 07.09.1983 for
repairs, bearing a reference of the suit premises with G+2 upper floors,
the copy of his sale deed, wherein the suit premises is described, as area
of 2100 sq. ft., consisting of G+2 upper floors, copies of Electricity bill,
-- 2 of 7 --
CNR NO. :MHCC01-010376-2022 3 Notice of Motion No. 3525/2022
in L.C. Suit No. 2000/2022.
Registration Certificate, the notice, his reply and the Speaking Order. In
reply, the defendant contended on 30.08.2022, in routine inspection, he
observed that the said construction was ‘on-going’. The plaintiff couldn't
justify the structure and hence, this notice came to be issued and after
considering his reply, the Speaking Order was passed. He did not file a
sanctioned plan/permission in respect of the said ‘on-going’ work. There
is no prima-facie case in his favour and therefore, his NM needs to be
dismissed. In support of his contentions, the defendant relied upon the
copies of the Speaking Order, photographs of dtd. 08.09.2022 and also
the requisition for grant of police consistence to demolish, as per the list
of documents at Exhibit 4. That apart, as per the list of documents, filed
vide Exhibit 2, he placed copies of inspection report, the notice, undated
photograph, which is also the part and parcel of the inspection report of
dtd. 30.08.2022, the photograph of dtd. 03.09.2022, etc.. Contrarily, the
plaintiff denied his contentions in view of the reply rejoinder. Moreover,
he filed the list of documents at Exhibit 6, along-with the photographs
of dtd. 13.05.2022 and 30.08.2022, showing that no such construction
was 'in progress'.
04. Heard both the sides. Shri. Shukla, learned advocate for the
plaintiff, submitted that since inception the suit premises is consisting of
G+2 upper floors. It is assessed to the municipal taxes since the year of
1979. In this reference, he invited my attentions on the assessment bill,
letter dtd. 07.09.1983, permitting repairs of the suit premises, Schedule
of property described in the Sale Deed, where it is shown as G+2 upper
floors. He submitted that there is no iota of material to assume that the
said construction was ‘on going’ and hence, this notice U/s. 354-A of the
MMC Act is not justified. In support of this position, he relied upon the
Circular dtd. 29.04.2016, issued by the defendant and on the matters of
-- 3 of 7 --
CNR NO. :MHCC01-010376-2022 4 Notice of Motion No. 3525/2022
in L.C. Suit No. 2000/2022.
Govardhan Ramnaresh Singh V. MCGM, in AO No. 257 of 1999, dtd.
15.04.1999, Muni Suvrat-Swami Jain S.M.P.Sangh V. Arun Nathuram
Gaikwad and Ors., (2006) 8 SCC 590 and also on M/s. Shah and Co. V.
MCGM, in A.O. No. 99 of 2013 along-with C.A. No. 127 of 2013, dtd.
31.01.2013. On his turn, Shri. Khandagale, learned counsel for the
defendant contended that as per the inspection report, it is crystal clear
that the said construction was unauthorized and it was ‘on going’. Being
so, the plaintiff is not entitled for any of the reliefs claimed.
05. Considering the rival stands, here, it is notable that perusal
of record, more precisely the copy of assessment bill, shows that the suit
premises was firstly assessed on 01.04.1979. Further, the fact that since
long, it consisted of G+2 upper floors is fortified as per the permission
dtd. 07.09.1983, for repairs, and the copy of Sale Deed, which is having
a reference to that effect. Now, as compared to this position, the notice
of dtd. 30.08.2022 reveals the unauthorized construction in the form of
'vertical extension' to existing structure, using MS angels, ladi-coba slab
siporex blocks, admeasuirng 5 X 26 X 4 meter. However, that apart, this
notice is silent to assume the exact nature of the so called unauthorized
construction. Here, it is worth to be noted that as, prima-facie, there is
material to infer that the suit premises is consisted of G+2 upper floors,
it was required from the defendant to specify the exact position of this
illegal construction, which is missing from this notice. In this way, it is
vague in itself.
06. Continuing my discussions, at this juncture, it is to be noted
that the notice is issued U/s. 354-A of the MMC Act, which suggests that
as per the defendant the said construction was 'on-going'. True it is that
to substantiate this fact, he filed copy of the inspection report, wherein
-- 4 of 7 --
CNR NO. :MHCC01-010376-2022 5 Notice of Motion No. 3525/2022
in L.C. Suit No. 2000/2022.
at point No. 5, the work status as ‘on going’. However, the inspection
report is lacking the aspect of the panchnama and the photograph, with
the digital details, to conclude that on that day, the said construction
was going on. Surely, the copy of undated photograph, which is referred
to in the inspection report, is falling short to assume this fact. Whereas
the other photographs of dtd. 03.09.2022 and 08.09.2022 corroborates
the plaintiff's case that on that day, there was no 'on-going' construction
activities. Contrarily, as per these photographs, it can safely be gathered
that it was complete. This fact is confirmed even in the photograph dtd.
13.05.2022 i.e. the date much prior to the alleged inspection carried by
the defendant, filed by the plaintiff as per the list Exhibit 6. Moreover,
the plaintiff placed the photograph of dtd. 30.08.2022, at 11.00 a.m., of
the suit premises, which manifests that there was no ‘on going’ work of
construction. This being the position, issuance of this notice U/s. 354-A
of the MMC Act is not justified. In support of this observation, a helpful
reliance may be placed on the Circular and the matters of Govardhan
Ramnaresh Singh, Muni Suvrat-Swami Jain S.M.P.Sangh and M/s. Shah
and Company, Cited Supra, relied by the plaintiff. Needless to say that
Section 354-A of the MMC Act can not be put into operation, when the
construction work is complete, and it has nothing to do with demolition
of the structure.
07. These discussions led me to hold that the defendant could
not substantiate 'on going status' of the alleged construction. He did not
file the photographs, bearing all the digital details as regards date, time
and place of such construction. It is notable that the detailed Guidelines
are laid in the matter of Sopan Maruti Thopte and Another V. Pune
Municipal Corporation, AIR 1996 Bom. 304. This case also deals with
the procedure to be followed by the defendant while proceeding against
-- 5 of 7 --
CNR NO. :MHCC01-010376-2022 6 Notice of Motion No. 3525/2022
in L.C. Suit No. 2000/2022.
the unauthorized structures. However, no such pains are taken by him.
Consequently, I am of the opinion that the defendant failed to follow the
due process of law and hence, till he complies with the same, the notice
structure deserves to be protected. Hence, I answered point Nos. 1 to 3
accordingly and in answer to point No.4, I pass the following Order:
: O R D E R :
(i). Notice of Motion No. 3525/2022 is partly allowed.
(ii). The defendant, its agents, its servants and anybody
else claiming through him are hereby restrained from
proceeding against the notice structure, in pursuance
of the suit notice dtd. 30.08.2022 and Speaking Order
dtd. 14.09.2022, except by following the due process of
law.
(iii). Notice of Motion No. 3525/2022, accordingly, stands
disposed off.
{A.G. Santani}
Mumbai. Ad-hoc Judge,
Dated : 04.11.2022. City Civil Court, Mumbai.
Dictated on : 04.11.2022.
Transcribed on : 05.11.2022.
Checked and Signed on : 07.11.2022.
-- 6 of 7 --
CNR NO. :MHCC01-010376-2022 7 Notice of Motion No. 3525/2022
in L.C. Suit No. 2000/2022.
“CERTIFIED TO BE TRUE AND CORRECT COPY OF THE ORIGINAL
SIGNED JUDGMENT/ORDER”
UPLOAD DATE AND TIME NAME OF STENOGRAPHER
10.11.2022 at 5.50 p.m. Mrs. S.R.Mejari
Name of the Judge (with Court Room no.) HHJ Shri A.G.Santani
(Court Room No.11).
Date of Pronouncement of Judgment/Order 04.11.2022.
Judgment/Order signed by P.O. on 07.11.2022.
Judgment/Order uploaded on 10.11.2022.
-- 7 of 7 --

TrustJury presents public court-record information for legal discovery and reference. Record availability and detail can vary by source and case.